troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
Headscratchers: Fahrenheit 451
  • I'm just going to quote Stephen Bond's pointing out that the premise of the book is implausible and how the "Book People" come across as shallow idiots who learn books by rote instead of engaging with the text, and wonder if anybody else thought anything similar.
    • Well, as nothing in the book defies the laws of physics (other than implying some people have super-memory, and the transforming helicopters/cars and fireproof-houses are just the typical predicted advances in technology in stories set in the future, and pretty tame, at that), nothing about the premise is "impossible." Learning books by rote is not stated to be a substitute for "engaging with the text" but the only way to hang onto your books when the government burns all physical copies (before anyone invokes Tech Marches On, using e-books would be even more foolish, since they require electrical power that is scarce when you're on the run from society, and accessing them can be easily tracked); reciting is used as the only available substitute (under the circumstances) for reading, and memorizing as a weapon to protect valuable texts from the fire so people can continue to engage with them just as people once did in the days of the Oral Tradition. Is it tragic that people have to resort to this method to read? Yes. But what's the alternative? And what's shallow about bookworm rebel survivalists? Bond's completely right that the film was poor — as usual. I find it ridiculous, however, that he got the impression that a society that hates books also cannot read. People read words all the time in the book! The tv programs come with scripts for audience participation! The Firemen get written reports of houses to burn! Bond should have read Faber's conversation with Montag; it's not the act of reading written strokes of ink or type that represent sounds and form words that is disappearing, it's the activity of reading, and any bookworm could have told him there's a difference. It's books the government destroys, not the written word.
EvolutionHeadscratchers/LiteratureThe Faultin Our Stars

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
3093
40