The Jem'Hadar are considered expendable, and cannot understand why the Federation dismisses the idea of expensibility. The Jem'Hadar consider Sisko cowardly for not executing Worf for disobedience. However, the Jem'Hadar are lucky to make it to 20- they're combat ready soon after birth- replacing one is simple. There's no fanfare in creating Jem'Hadar, they are merely cloned. However, other solids take years to reach any kind of expertise. Even if they shared Jem'Hadar outlook, it would still be impractical to execute someone over a mistake- that's 30 years of training, down the drain rather than 1, perhaps 70 to 100 years of contribution ended by their death, rather than 10 to 20.
In the episode in question Sisko questions a Jem'Hadar unit leader's devotion to his men, given his willingness to kill one for a breach of discipline, and the offended leader replies he had served with this second for three years. Long enough in any context, but when you take relative lifespan into account Jem'Hadar serving together for three years is like humans serving together for a decade - much more meaningful.
This difference in time investment also likely explains why they bother to clone and transfer memories to Vorta instead of just cloning tons of them like the Jem'Hadar - the Vorta likely take longer to train. You get your diplomat Vorta all oiled up for negotiations, your doctor Vorta all trained for medicine and research, or whatever other training they require depending on their purpose, and the cloning and memory transfer allows you to skip that step in the next incarnation.
In "Sacrifice of Angels", when Sisko is about to Engage the Dominion Fleet in the wormhole, the Prophets give him a vision to stop him. Sisko's life is referred to as "The Game", which seems to imply that The Prophets consider him somewhat akin to a distraction, until you remember that Sisko initially explained linear time as being like a game of baseball
Word of God says that although the Federation was not aware of the existence of the Dominion until after the discovery of the Worm Hole, the Dominion was aware of the Federation and the rest of the Alpha Quadrant civilizations long beforehand, and were planning how to handle them when they inevitably reached the Gamma Quadrant in two hundred years. The Federation's discovery of the Worm Hole forced the Founders to put their contingency plans into action ahead of schedule, throwing them off their game. This turns into Fridge Horror when one considers that they still came damn close to winning the war with the Alpha Quadrant powers. Had they fought the war on their own terms and time table, it seems questionable if the Founders would have lost the war.
They probably would have avoided the war altogether; their attempts to trick the Alpha Quadrant powers into destroying each other were only barely averted as it was, and that was because the hastily thrown together infiltration meant there were threads to spot.
In an early episode, Garak is criticizing Shakespeare's Julius Caesar for being entirely too predictable and unrealistic, much to the annoyance of Bashir:
Garak: "I knew Brutus was going to kill Caesar in the first act! But Caesar didn't figure it out until the knife was in his back."
Bashir: "But that's what makes it a tragedy. Caesar couldn't conceive that his best friend would plot to kill him."
Garak: "'Tragedy' is not the word I'd use. 'Farce' would be more appropriate. Supposedly, this man is supposed to be a leader of a great empire, a brilliant military tactician and yet he can't see what's going on under his own nose!"
In the next episode Garak's old mentor Enabrin Tain had no idea that his Dragon Colonel Lovok was a Changeling spy until it was much too late.
Garak himself didn't realize the person trying to kill him was Tain until Tain told him.
He pretty much acknowledges Shakespeare had it right when he recites a line from him later and tells Tain this was something he picked up from Bashir.
In the following episode, a replacement for the runabout that was destroyed is dropped off at the station. It's name? USS Rubicon.
Then, many episodes later, Gul Dukat's daughter, Ziyal, helps free La Résistance, who then disable the station's weapons array which allows Sisko to retake the station. Her betrayal of her father had been a long time coming and Dukat had been warned repeatedly in the episodes before then, but he refused to believe it until it was far too late and the damage had already been done. It should be noted that Garak and Dukat are sworn enemies.
In that context it doubles as a Not So Different moment: Despite both being paranoid ultra-survivors, Garak and Dukat were both blindsided because the betrayal came from someone they loved. Which was exactly the case with Caesar, except that Garak didn't have the empathy or experience (of being betrayed by a loved one) to see it from Caesar's perspective.
The second half of the two-parter "The Maquis" puts Sisko in the position of having to rescue Gul Dukat from the Maquis who've captured him so that he can avert a second war between the Federation and the Cardassian Empire. When Legate Parn from the Cardassian Central Command arrives to discuss the situation with Sisko, he makes the rather surprising claim that Gul Dukat is the ringleader of several high-ranking officers who've been conspiring to smuggle weapons to the Cardassian colonists in order to take on the Federation's colonists and their newly formed Maquis cells. As such, they don't want Dukat back and frankly won't be shedding any tears if the Maquis execute him for them. While neither Sisko nor Kira believes a word Parn says, Kira afterward insists that she agrees with Parn that they ought to leave Dukat to die, since he's long overdue for his comeuppance for all the Bajorans he massacred. Sisko, however, insists on rescuing him anyway, as he needs Dukat's help in exposing the Cardassians' double-dealing.
What neither of them ever stops to consider is how incredibly convenient it is that Cardassia has decided to cut Gul Dukat loose and lay all the blame on him, especially since they know Kira and her fellow Bajorans and practically everyone else for that matter never liked him anyway and would be just as glad to see him dead. Had Sisko not overruled her, Kira would have been playing right into the Cardassian Empire's hands by allowing Dukat, who's the only individual in a position to expose the Central Command's treachery, to be the patsy for it instead. This is where Sisko's Federation discipline shines through most brightly, as he and Kira and everyone else have to swallow hard and put their personal feelings aside in order to get their jobs done.
"In The Pale Moonlight" yields one more level of ingenuity to Garak and Sisko's scheme to bring the Romulans into the war against the Dominion. Sisko started off wanting to get the Romulans to see that taking on the Dominion was in their own best interest, as the Dominion was sure to conquer them next once the Klingons and Federation were overthrown. In the end, not only did he and Garak successfully bring them into the war, but they got the Romulans to perceive that the Dominion surely would target them for takeover sooner or later. Moreover, once the Romulans attacked the Dominion, they were committed to the war: even if they did find out about the deception later, they wouldn't exactly be in any position to apologize and ask the Dominion if they could get their non-aggression pact reinstated, would they?
The Founders appear to be callous and uncaring towards the Vorta, uncaring if they die and killing them for their failures, but considering what we hear from the Weyoun that defects to Odo and some comments by the female Founder and I realized that the Founders view assuming a new form to grant them new insight so by killing a Vorta they're actually helping that Vorta gain a new perspective that may aid it where the previous version failed. After all, why continue to clone servants you have no personal investment in who keep failing you unless you really do care and don't view death as that big a deal?
The only evidence we have about their attitude toward the Vorta in the first place is the Female Changeling's comments when either Weyoun was disrespecting Odo or the war was going very badly. That and their attitude toward solids in general, in which comments they never make it a point to exclude Vorta and Jem'Hadar, except that the Female Changeling interestingly referred to Weyoun specifically as the only solid she's ever trusted. But of course, trust is not the same as respect or caring. But in any case, their habit of cloning the Vorta, and giving the new ones the memories of the old, could be due to any combination of concern for their development and for their services to the Dominion.
In some ways, what we know about the Founders' relationship with the Vorta actually serves as an example of how the Dominion is basically the opposite of the Federation. Whereas the Federation has certain standards of moral development other species and civilizations have to meet before they can be allowed to join, it never imposes these on any of its members by force. With the Vorta, however, we get to see how the Dominion insists on shaping and manipulating all of its members to serve its purposes. From Weyoun 6 (the defector), we learn that the Vorta being genetically manipulated to be the Dominion's managerial species is actually the Dominion's reward to them for having hidden and protected one of the Founders from enemies long ago. In other words, the Dominion's idea of kindness to a species is the direct opposite of the Federation's Prime Directive; do the Dominion a favor, and the Founders will perfect your species by any means available, including genetic manipulation.
In Dramatis Personae, the crew gets affected by a telepathic Hate Plague that turns them into a bunch of paranoiacs. Odo isn't affected because his brain is distributed, rather than centralized. Dax is affected, but instead of being paranoid, she acts stoned, telling rambling stories and forgetting things. Why was it different for her? Because a joined Trill, between the host and symbionts, has two brains! That probably threw the effects off kilter.
I took it be that they were playing the roles of some previous power struggle, and Dax just got saddled with someone completely oblivious. After all, Sisko didn't become aggressive either, he just got Attention Deficit... Ooh, Shiny!.
An alternate explanation is that Odo was unaffected because Paranoia is a default state of mind for him. He's suspicious of everyone already.
Dax actually seemed to me a bit like a stereotypical grandma: sweet as sugar, but tells long, irrelevant stories and forgets and repeats herself in conversation... which makes sense, because Dax the symbiote is a couple hundred years old.
The Loves of Quark. He claims to hold traditional Ferengi values of gender and stuff, but none of the women he has fallen in love matches the ideal of a Ferengi Female. Dax; Grilka, the Klingon woman; Natima Lang, the Cardassian dissident; and Pel, Quark's only Ferengi love interest; are all strong, independent women. Similar to his mother, one might say
Quark and Rom also demonstrate that in one way or another, they've each inherited the opposite traits from their parents: Quark inherited his father's values and mother's business sense, while Rom inherited his mother's values and father's business sense. That's why Quark is generally the more financially successful of the two, while Rom ultimately proves to be more politically successful; Quark has mastered the Ferengi tradition which has worked well for them for centuries, while Rom with his quirky point of view has a rare talent for social and political innovation.
In "Trials and Tribble-ations," the Defiant crew is taken back in time to Kirk's time period. Odo, Worf, O'Brien, and Bashir witness Scotty starting a brawl with a Klingon captain after the captain insults the Enterprise. Worf and O'Brien immediately start fighting the Klingons. Why? They also served on the Enterprise.
In "For the Cause" Eddington compares the Federation to the Borg to Sisko's face (okay via communicator but still...). Cue "For the Uniform": Eddington has been playing with Sisko, taunting him. The man compared the Federation and the Treaty with Cardassia to the alien menace that didn't even let Sisko give his wife a proper funeral. The Sisko is pissed.
Speaking of Eddington, some people were surprised at how Sisko threw himself into the chase. They shouldn't have been, since in "The Die Is Cast," the first time Eddington betrays Sisko (this time for an admiral), Sisko sets up why he throws himself into the hunt for Eddington then and there.
Sisko: I make it a policy to never question the word of anyone who wears that uniform. Don't make me change that policy.
In the episode where Worf kills Gowron, the Klingons are meeting in a conference room on the station. Then they grab bat'leths off of the wall, which are probably not a standard feature of Federation decor. Conclusion? The Klingons have specifically equipped their war room with bat'leths just in case there's a Klingon Promotion situation. That is kind of hilarious.
It should also be noted that Gowron came to power because Worf killed his rival Duras in the TNG episode "Reunion". So Worf was directly responsible for Gowron's rise and fall.
And on that note, why does Worf immediately abdicate the Chancellorship in favor of Martok? Aside from the respect he obviously has for his blood brother, he may also remember what happened back in "The Sword of Kahless." To wit: he and Kor discover the legendary bat'leth wielded by Kahless himself, and the idea of using the sword to claim leadership of the Klingon Empire drives Worf and Kor to try to kill each other. Having felt the temptation of power and being driven to attempted murder because of it, Worf may have decided that he's not truly worthy of leading the Empire, or simply didn't trust himself with the position, so he yields to someone whom he considers incorruptible.
In "Distant Voices" Bashir claims to be hearing voices in the distance, to the confusion of Garak, who guesses that humans may have more acute hearing than Cardassians. Years later, it turns out that Bashir is genetically enhanced, including superior hearing. The reveal that the episode takes place in Bashir's mind provides an early hint of his nature via his own subconscious.
There's another hint in "Our Man Bashir" when Julian shoots Garak in the neck. He implies that he was really trying to kill Garak and that his aim was off - giving Garak the confidence that Julian has the willpower to make the hard call for survival if it is necessary - but knowing that his hand-eye coordination is insanely enhanced due to being an Augment, it turns out he was bluffing the entire time.
Besides the Improbable Aiming Skills, there are a bunch of subtle things. Julian knocks a huge assassin off his feet during a fight, shoots a guy with a champagne cork, can pass as an expert geologist, which all things found in Bond parodies. I give full credit to SF Debris here for this observation: How much of this is part of the program and how much is just Bashir being himself?
Julian Bashir's best friend back home is a holoprogrammer named Felix. James Bond's (only?) friend is also named Felix (Leiter).
Felix is also the genius holoprogrammer who created the self-aware Vic Fontaine AI. So it begs the question whether Bashir asked him to create a Bond program that would put the test to even Bashir's augmented abilities. Worth noting, Data trying to create a similarly challenging holodeck program is what lead to the creation of the TNG incarnation of Professor Moriarty.
Odo has a strained relationship with Dr. Mora, the man who...well, not raised him, so much as experiment on him until Odo was so fed up that he struck out on his own. In the episode The Begotten, Odo gets a chance to resolve some of his issues with Mora, as he learns that some of what the doctor did was in Odo's best interest; and they even start to bond over trying to do the same for an infant Changeling. It's in these moments, when the two are standing close to each other that we start to notice some interesting things about the two: Mora and Odo share a similar height, build, face-shape, hair color, eye color, and even sport exactly the same hair style. Odo quite obviously modeled his appearance on that of Dr. Mora.
In the first season episode with Lwaxana Troi, Odo tells her that he modeled his appearance on Dr Mora.
In the pilot, it's obvious that Sisko is still very badly affected by his wife's death, years after she's died. The wound is still very fresh, and very raw, as his conversation with Picard and his experience with the Prophets attests, more so than it might be for some. It's stated in Star Trek, from time to time (though the degree to which it's applied tends to vary on the show in question), that in the future, humans don't grieve when their loved ones die. This would imply that, among humans, not showing excessive grief (excessive being a relative term) at the death of a loved one is the norm in social behavior, which would also imply that showing "excessive" grief isn't considered normal, or socially acceptable. Perhaps that's why Sisko still has such a hard time with Jennifer's death years later, despite the fact that he has access to counseling and seems to otherwise have moved on with his life—he really doesn't have a healthy outlet for his grief.
In "Statistical Probabilities" the crew make a big deal over the reason that Augments aren't allowed to work freely in society in a productive manner is because it would be unfair to everyone else and parents would feel pressured to upgrade their children so they could compete. Odo even cites this as the reason why the law against DNA-resequencing was put in place in the first place. However a quick look at the issue makes it obvious that with a harsh penalty for the parents if they do perform genetic upgrades on the child, and the child being a labelled genetic augment - and hence being made an intellectual outcast by nature and not allowed to compete in straight-up competitions - would be enough to deter that sort of behaviour. No, the real reason why the law is in place is to prevent new superhuman supervillains like Kahn trying to take over. However, by having people concerned with the philosophical debate of whether it is fair or not to allow genetic augments to be productive members of society, no one is discussing the real threat of Augments - and the real reason why they aren't allowed positions of power or authority - and so anyone who is thinking of genetically engineering their child would be encouraged to think about making their child more intelligent so they can have an advantage over other children and get jobs and positions in society that are competitively vied over, rather than engineering their child to become the next Kahn.
Sisko is the only Trek captain across the entire franchise to punch Q's lights out. Q avoids DS9 from that point on. As of that episode, we don't know that Sisko is the progeny of one of the Prophets; he's just a Starfleet captain—a badass by any reasonable measure but not to the level of physically assaulting an omnipotent being and getting away with it. His status as Emissary derives from the Prophets communicating with him, but doesn't confer any special powers beyond political and religious clout amongst the Bajorans. At least, not yet. Perhaps Q knew of Sisko's true relationship to the Prophets—who certainly would be in the same league as Q, or close to it—before Sisko himself did?
I always took it as more of Sisko not playing the games Q likes to play and therefore being no fun.
In "Soldiers of the Empire", the writers and JG Hertzler do a good job of tracking Martok's process of getting his groove back. Listen to the ways he concludes his orders to the Rotarran's helmsman. The first time, he gives a desultory "mak'cha", which probably means "Forward", "Advance", or something else suitably martial. The second time, when he's at the nadir of his Heroic B.S.O.D., he uses the neutral (and English) "Engage". The third time, after he beats Worf and goes forth to kick ass, he uses an enthusiastic "mak'cha!", and looks ready to throw down again. Very subtle, and very good.
In "The Emperor's New Cloak," a mirror Vic Fontaine appears, and he's actually human instead of a hologram. In the prime universe, it could be that there's a human singer named Vic Fontaine, and Felix used his likeness for the holoprogram.
It's also possible, considering the Continuity Snarl in that episode (Klingons in the Mirror Universe had perfectly good cloaking devices in earlier episodes) that Vic was based on an actual Vic Fontaine from back in the 1930s, and that he was brought forward through time by some of the Terran rebellion's temporal manipulations in their efforts to cripple the Klingon & Cardassian Alliance.
Another possibility is that the mirror Vic was not human at all, but an android. We don't clearly see any blood when he's shot, just smoke rising from the wound. Perhaps mirror Felix is a cyberneticist instead of a holoprogrammer.
Or perhaps Mirror Vic is a clone or an Augment of some kind.
Homefront: in the scene where Odo discovers a changeling posing as admiral Leyton, the scene starts with Odo landing on a rock in the form of a seagull and shapeshifting into his humanoid form. Commander Benteen comments that while not being able to mimic a humanoid (a Bajoran, Dr. Mora to be exact), Odo made a convincing seagull, to which Odo replies "I'm not sure the gulls would agree" and this is where a minor fridge logic sets in: this underlines that Odo is bad at shape-shifting! He can not convince the seagulls that he is one of them any more than he can convince us (humanoids) that he is one of us.
"Who Mourns For Morn?" brings out a minor, but clever example in explaining Morn's apparent One-Hour Work Week. As Mark Allen Sheperd, who played Morn, pointed out in an interview, "No wonder I sit all day at Quark's and do nothing. I'm rich!"
"Take Me Out To the Holosuite": It rather underlines Solok's racism that he comes from a 100% Vulcan ship and team. Despite all his taunts about "humans", Sisko's team is actually minority human. There's 5 humans - The Siskos, Yates, Bashir and O'Brien, but 7 nonhumans - Trill ("Did I forget to wear my spots today?"), 2 Bajorans, 3 Ferengi and a Klingon, 2 of whom are "first in Starfleet" for their respective races.
There's also the Irony that Solok's very-not-diverse team uses the IDIC (Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations) as their logo. Ten Vulcan males and one Vulcan female? Yeah reallydiverse there.
And yet Solok's team makes logical sense: on average males are physically stronger than females of equal level of fitness, it only makes sense that most of his team, drawn from a ship with an all-Vulcan crew, would contain mostly males, among the volunteers they're (physically) the best.
Hey, remember when the Female Changeling told Weyoun that returning Odo to his people was more important to her than the entire Alpha Quadrant? She was being completely earnest. Sure, she would have rather manipulated him back while still conquering the place, but what happens in the end? She gives up on conquering the Alpha Quadrant and submits to their justice in exchange for Odo returning to the Link.
Merriam-Webster's Dictionary defines profit as "the advantage or benefit that is gained from doing something; a valuable return." Nog and Rom are the first Ferengi we see who understand that profit is more than latinum: it's also the respect of your peers, and friends who'll watch your back. Quark, meanwhile, is busting his lobes scheming and swindling, trying to live up to traditional Ferengi values and earn the respect of his fellow Ferengi businessmen, most of whom have nothing but contempt for a "loser" like Quark. Rom and Nog are smarter than Quark.
Quark even gets taught an object lesson in profit as understood by Rom and Nog at the end of "Body Parts" when the Ferengi Commerce Authority takes away everything he owns...and the other members of the station crew rebuild his bar with donated fixtures and equipment.
This is also demonstrated in Nog's Chain of Deals episodes ("In the Cards" and "Treachery, Faith, and the Great River"). He doesn't outright say it, but he clearly considers things like happiness, entertainment, and morale as a type of "profit" that can be valued and bartered like any other. Which also ties into how he becomes the first Federation Ferengi; in a post-scarcity world like most of the Federation, you can't make a profit selling material goods unless they're luxuries or illegal, but it is possible to carve out a niche as a dealer in ephemera, which requires a keen understanding of how people put value on intangible feelings and opportunities.
Interestingly, Nog probably learned about this kind of "enlightened capitalism" from Jake. Their first attempt at financial enterprise started with getting their hands on a case of Yamok sauce and making a series of trades until they had a piece of Bajoran land. Nog was getting frustrated that they kept bartering instead of making a sale, but Jake assured him that that everything has value to somebody - it's just a matter of figuring out who. By the end, they had both a tidy profit and a string of satisfied customers.
On one occasion, in the episode "In The Cards," Kai Winn and Weyoun meet and interact. Weyoun comments about how he believes that he feels they are so much alike. Winn proceeds to touch his earlobe (the Bajoran way of sensing one's pagh, or spirit), then says that they are nothing alike. She's right, but not in the way that you think - he's a true believer in the Founders, his Gods. Winn, however, turns her back on the Prophets come the final season, siding with the Pai-Wraiths. He is a true believer, and she is a heretic.
Gul Dukat is an arrogant, selfish, self-righteous man who places his personal ambitions above Cardassia, and by doing so causes both Cardassia’s and his own destruction. Enabran Tain is an arrogant, selfish, self-righteous man who places his personal ambitions above Cardassia- and by doing so, causes the destruction of the Obsidian Order, which paves the way for Dukat’s own schemes. It’s interesting how Garak’s most hated enemy and Garak’s beloved mentor resemble each other so much, isn’t it?
In "Valiant," Red Squad is quickly shown as talented but inexperienced when they waste four torpedoes on a Dominion attack ship that was already exploding. Later in the episode they decide to take on the prototype Dominion battleship by using a special torpedo that will attack a specific weakness of the design, but when they fire it the Dominion ship shrugs it off. There are three explanations for this: the Red Team either failed to properly put together the torpedo, the weakness wasn't actually a weakness (possibly because the design called for shielding it to work, and the designers, being experienced, did just that), or the battleship's shields were still up and blocked the attack. Whatever happened, they failed because they were inexperienced, and anyone with some experience could have told them it was a bad idea... As Jake did (Nog was too busy gushing on the supposed elite cadets to think about it).
There's a fairly strong hint early on that their technical skills are subpar. This entire time they haven't been able to get warp drive online despite Nog being able to jury rig a fix within a few hours. They may be honor graduates but Red Squad is no where near knowledgable enough to identify a structural weakness like that or exploit one if the oppurtunity presented itself.
And speaking of how cocky they are, their belief that they could pull off a stupid impossible stunt is Starfleet's fault, and not just because of whatever "best of the best" pep talks these kids probably got. It's because the last timethey pulled off a crazy stunt, they had at least one Insane Admiral covering for them. No wonder it went to their heads.
Lieutenant Primmin is assigned to DS9 in Season 1 to be in charge of the Starfleet Security detachment, giving Starfleet someone who will answer directly to them and going above Odo's head since they don't entirely trust him. However, he disappears after "Move Along Home." Why? Because Starfleet realized he was immensely stupid. His reaction to none of the senior staff showing up in Ops the next day was to laugh it off, thinking they were all hungover without even bothering to check the computer. When Sisko filed his report on the incident, along with Odo's lengthy report on Primmin's actions, Starfleet decided to take him off and shipped him to another distant sector where he could do less damage.
Captain Sisko, at the end of the last episode of Deep Space Nine, left his treasured baseball in his old office at the station. He never leaves the station permanently unless he takes his baseball with him. Oh yeah. He'll be back someday. ;)
"In the Hands of the Prophets" was always Anvilicious. What made it anvilicious most of all was that the religious zealot (Winn) almost immediately jumped to terrorism to solve the problem. This became brilliant when I realized something: it's really just the hammer and nail problem. For 50 years, the Bajorans had been solving all of their problems with terrorism; that's all entire generations of them knew. And it worked; the Cardassians left. So peace breaks out, and how do they propose to fix a relatively minor dispute? Terrorism. It also explains why the coup attempt seems to come at the end of the season seemed to come off so well. - Korval
You don't really need the apocrypha of Deep Space Nine to know that Mila is Garak's mother; if anything, their first interactions on-screen confirm it. Considering Tain never acknowledged Garak as his own son until he was dying, it's the only explanation for why Garak grew up in Tain's house... technically, Garak could just be a child of another household servant, but Mila is the only one he has ever displayed fondness for.
If Garak was publicly known to be an illegitimate child what would his status be? He was already in the situation of being publicly unacknowledged by his father and, if Mila was his mother (and even Odo implies he suspects it with the "I can believe there's one [person who would regard Garak with affection]" which obviously alludes to the idea that the only person who could ever love some people would be their mother), then he'd be publicly unacknowledged by his mother as well. That's very close to making him an orphan (two parents who can't publicly acknowledge him). Now watch the episode "Cardassians" where we learn orphans have no status in Cardassian society (the implication being they're actually treated better in Bajoran orphanages than they ever would be on Cardassia). Look at Garak's reaction when he spots the Cardassian orphans watching him. He looks like he's just been punched in the stomach and then he all but flees the place, even his attitude towards the Bajoran in charge of the centre has changed. He's utterly shaken. When Bashir later stops the runabout to confront him, Garak automatically thinks the plight of the orphans is haunting Bashir. As it turns out, that's not on Bashir's mind at all... but it must have been on Garak's still for him to jump to that conclusion. Given his parentage and the secrets surrounding it, it's a miracle he wasn't an abandoned child with the according "orphan" status. With hindsight there's an almost "there but for the grace of God..." sense to this. At the very least, the subject of the orphans did seem to hit a nerve for him.
In the episode, "The Assignment" it would seem strange that the prophets would not have expected the Pah Wraith's return and surprise attack - them being timeless, able to see anywhen at once, would have surely seen it coming from the beginning of time and taken precautions against it. But of course because the attack failed, it's possible they never did or never will find out about it - if they were looking out of the wormhole it would just look like DS9 zapping a shuttlecraft with something - so it's possible they simply don't know about the attempt.
Alternatively, not being stuck in linear time, the ones living in the wormhole were entirely aware of how the episode would end, and didn't feel any intervention was necessary.
Looking back it is interesting how many little references there are to Bashir being genetically engineered that, whilst probably unintentional, do add to the series somewhat. One example is as early as season 2 episode 11 Rivals where he casually reveals to O'Brien that he once faced a Vulcan in a Racquetball final - and won. Keep in mind Vulcans are at least three times as strong and fast as a human and suddenly that excuse that he more or less had a lucky shot suddenly seems ever so slightly suspect.
Also, in the Mirror Universe, he dresses and acts more like Khan than Bashir. There were a few mirror episodes before the one that revealed he was genetically modified.
The Monac IV shipyards were in quite a strange location, so close to a star. It seemed dangerous, given the chance of a solar eruption... And then I realized: cloaked ships are unshielded, and thus unable to come close enough to the shipyards placed near the star and blow them up, while solar flares, on the other hand, could be seen forming, and the slipways could be moved out of their path. Until O'Brien figured out how to cause artificial solar flares, that position was the best defence against both Klingon and Romulan raiders.
And this begs the question: how many shipyards and other facilities got destroyed by Romulan raiders appearing from nowhere and firing plasma torpedoes (that, in spite of the name, are more like Wave Motion Guns), on the day the Romulans entered the war?
Of all the infiltrators in 'Apocalypse Rising' Sisko takes the role by far the best, not really surprising considering his mentor was Curzon Dax, who was greatly respected as an Ambassador to the Klingons.
A bit of meta: in one episode, a Bajoran musician has a holo-recording of himself playing a "traditional" Bajoran folk tune. It's just the Deep Space Nine theme music recycled for the scene. Then it hit me. The theme would be a traditional "Bajoran" piece. Sisko is the emissary and he became a part of their spiritual life, so of course his leitmotif would be a traditional Bajoran song!
In "The Way of the Warrior," General Martok insists on himself, Sisko, and Kira proving they aren't changelings by cutting themselves and seeing whether their shed blood reverts back to changeling-stuff - a soon-to-be-standard blood testing. Sisko's father famously points out the biggest flaw in this test later in the series, but the first hint of it is actually in the very same episode, only a couple scenes afterward: Odo shows that he's learned to mimic drinking by making a cup and liquid attached to his hand, "drinking" the liquid, and even refilling the cup if he wants. It's not the exact same situation as faking the blood test, but it strongly suggests that a changeling could store foreign liquid in their bodies and discharge it at will.
Likewise, we later learn that by this point in time, Martok has ALREADY been replaced by a Changeling, and the one introducing the concept of blood screenings to the Federation is indeed a Changeling himself.
And that's not even getting into the fact that the Klingons are known for blood letting being involved in various rituals and ceremonies, the number of which you're involved with tend to go up the further up in the hierarchy you are, and for the Martok Changeling to have survived unnoticed for over a year means that they had to have already HAD a way around this security measure.
Further, something that would have successfully found out Changlings: Telepaths. The very first planet that the Dominion took out was Betazed. Presumably Vulcan's might have worked in a pinch (ha).
At the end of Inquisition, the crew discuss how Section 31 has stayed under the radar for the last two centuries, unlike the Tal Shiar or the Obsidian Order. But there's the difference: Those two want their people to know about them, so that they'll stay in line like good, loyal and frightened Romulans / Cardassians, while Section 31 doesn't.
In The Wire, Bashir and Garak discuss a genre of Cardassian literature known as the Repetitive Epic. Your characters live selfless lives, in service to the state, grow old, and die, "and then the next generation comes along and does it all over again!" Is Doctor Bashir describing The Never Ending Sacrifice, or Star Trek? Each installment has largely the same premise, a group of bold intellectual explorers trekking across the unknown, seeking out new life and new civilizations, and each new installment changes the formula slightly by switching the character archetypes and roles around, allowing the producers to effectively pitch the exact same process, but getting a different result with each cycle thanks to the progressive changes. Out of all of the series and the reboot films, DS9 is the one that strays the farthest off the path, and only then because instead of exploring the unknown, our heroes are parked at an interstellar crossroads and dealing with the ever-shifting politics of the setting.
"Past Tense" - Little wonder both Dax and Bashir were able to play their roles so well in the heavily class-stratified Earth. Bashir is a de facto exile, having to live a lie and stay quiet about what he really is all the time. And why was Jadzia Dax able to play the part of an upper-class human? Think about what we learn about Trill society being just as nastily stratified along the lines of Joined and Unjoined. As a Joined, she is already an upper-crust member of her society, and Sanctuary District Earth is unfortunately Not So Different from the Trill homeworld.
Social change among Ferengi seems to happen much faster than any time in human history (where a big part of major changes is usually waiting for the previous generation to die). At first, this seems contrived. Then you realize: Ferengi aren't humans, and value their bottom line much more than their old traditions. Once they realized women's rights was profitable, and didn't really have a rational objection, they changed their views. Could also double as Fridge Horror when you realize that Ferengi are fundamentally more open to rational persuasion than humans.
At first, the Ferengi seem a little weird, compared to actual capitalists. For instance, among Ferengi, a contract is sacred, even though real capitalists would happily toss out a contract if breaking it were profitable. The Ferengi are tied to a bunch of old traditions, like making women go naked and not handle money, even when actual capitalists would have long ago realized there's profit to be made in bucking those. Ferengi would never do business with a blacklisted Ferengi, even though there would be plenty of profit in dealing with someone nobody else would sell to. It makes sense, though, when you realize that the Ferengi government is also made up of profit-hungry businessmen. Who benefits from contracts being nigh unbreakable? The Nagus — he'd be able to buy out anybody whose contract he didn't like (or throw them in jail on phony charges), but nobody could break one with him. Who benefits from society staying stagnant and rigidly following old taboos? Rich Ferengi (like the Nagus et al.) who own large, stable businesses that profit off the status quo, and whose market share would be threatened by disruptive innovation. Who profits from strict adherence to blacklists? The people who have the power to set those blacklists — the Nagus and the rest of the government. All the weird Ferengi traditions and taboos are due to the Ferengi government making themselves profitable at the expense of everyone else.
Remember the element from Whispers about Keiko suspecting that the replicant isn't really O'Brien because it drinks coffee in the afternoon, which he doesn't, only for the real O'Brien to order coffee in the afternoon at the end of the episode and reveal that he does? This troper just realized that this is a refere to the TNG episode Datalore, where Wesley suspects Lore isn't Data because he uses contractions, which Data doesn't, only for Data to use a contraction at the end of the episode.
During "Sacrifice of Angels", Dukat and Weyoun talk about what they would do once the Federation is conquered, and agree that a rebellion will start on Earth. Weyoun's solution would be to wipe out the entire population. Dukat tells him he "can't", because "true victory is to make your enemy realize they were wrong to oppose you in the first place". Weyoun gives him a look that clearly says "this guy's insane". From the episode "Statistic Probabilities", we know Weyoun's right: a rebellion is predicted to start on Earth and eventually overthrow the Dominion. It seems like the scene wants to invoke Fridge Horror, but it doesn't. While Dukat's Fatal Flaw is his desire to make others realize how great he is, even though he isn't; the Dominion's flaw is its believe that they can solve any problem just by stomping on it until it goes away. In the very same epidose, the Female Changeling has a similar problem: Odo just won't return with her to the Great Link because he still has feelings for Kira, so her solution is simple: kill Kira and problem solved. Of course, merely telling her plan to Odo causes him to leave her and go help Kira, resulting in the Dominion loss of DS9 and eventually the war. If the Dominion conquered the Federation and if they wiped out the entire population of Earth, it would still not be enough to subjugate the Federation, other planets would rebel instead. Both Dukat's and the Dominions outlook are wrong, and the Federation would prevail eventually anyway, even if it lost 900 trillion lives and the whole of Earth.
The entire series, from beginning to end, is about the conflict between Sisko and Dukat. First, both characters make their debut in the first episode, where Dukat was the former commander of the station and Sisko is the incoming commander. Both of them hold similar ranks throughout the series: Sisko starts out as a commander who is promoted to captain, while Dukat (even when he is running Cardassia), retains the rank of Gul (stated in the TNG episode "The Wounded" to be equivalent to Captain) through the entire series (with a brief stint as Legate). Both Dukat and Sisko are family men who are devoted to their children, and we see Jake and (to a lesser extent) Ziyal on screen. Now, the differences that divide the two: Sisko serves the Federation, a free, peaceful society while Dukat serves the oppressive, warlike Cardassian regime. Whereas Sisko sees his task as overseeing the reconstruction of Bajor in the hope that they will take their place as an equal member of the Federation, Dukat, in "Indiscretion" and "Waltz", deluded himself into thinking that he would improve the lot of the Bajorans, but refused to respect them as equals and became their greatest oppressor. It should be noted that, of the ten million people who died in the fifty-year Occupation (cf. "Cardassians"), half of them did so during the ten years Dukat was in charge (cf. "Waltz"). The opposition becomes even more clear when Dukat leads Cardassia into the Dominion, which has been noted on this page, and confirmed by Word of God, to be the anti-Federation. Additionally, Sisko becomes the Emissary of Bajor, a role he endures reluctantly, at least until "Accession" when the Prophets teach him a lesson, showing how even a well-meaning alternative could prove disastrous to Bajor. Gul Dukat, on the other hand, evinces messianic delusions throughout the series, particularly in his conversations with Kira in "Indiscretion" and with Sisko in "Waltz". After the latter episode, Dukat joins the Pah Wraths, eventually becoming their Emissary to reinforce his position as Sisko's equal and opposite counterpart. In a conversation in "Ties of Blood and Water", Dukat indicates that, despite being the ruler of Cardassia, he has retained the title Gul rather than a pretentious title such as Emissary. Here, we see that he is the inverse of Sisko: whereas Dukat has a modest title, he pursues absolute power, sees himself in messianic terms, and craves adoration; Sisko, meanwhile, despite his exalted title, has the comparatively modest ambition of the admiralty, sees himself only as a very good Starfleet officer, and is uncomfortable with the reverence and adoration the Bajorans give him. Another example of their differences is found in the Season 4 episode "To the Death", when Weyoun offers Sisko a chance to be absolute ruler of the Federation, answerable to no one. Sisko, of course, declines, but this is a foreshadowing of the offer that Dukat will accept, to become the absolute ruler of Cardassia under the Dominion. The episode "Covenant" brings the point home. In this episode, Dukat has taken over Empok Nor, a Cardassian space station in Dominion space which is almost the twin of Deep Space Nine (Formerly Terok Nor). Here, parodying Sisko's role as commander of [DS9] and Emissary, he has set himself up as the Emissary of the Cult of the Pagh Wraiths, surrounded by devoted Bajorans, including one of Kira's former teachers. As leader of the cult, he has even arrogated to himself the power to determine whether couples are allowed to have sex and have children, in a parody of Sisko's duty as Emissary (seen in "Accession" and "Call to Arms"), which includes blessing marriages and performing wedding ceremonies. The end of the episode, in which Dukat is prepared to sacrifice the cultists to save himself, prefigures and inverts the end of the series, in which Sisko sacrifices himself to save Bajor from the Pah Wraiths.
Looking at the above, it becomes clear exactly why Dukat hates the Bajorans. At first glance, an obvious reason reveals itself: revenge. As the head of the failed Occupation, it is evident in "Cardassians" and "The Maquis Part 2" that Dukat is being scapegoated for the failure of the Occupation, jeopardizing his career. Moreover, in "Sacrifice of Angels" and "Waltz", we see that Dukat craved not just the Bajorans' cooperation, but their adoration. The fact that they hated him instead is yet a further cause for resentment. However, when we look at the fact that Sisko is viewed the way Dukat sought to be viewed, we see yet another reason for Dukat's hatred: jealousy. Dukat saw himself in messianic terms, as a father figure to the Bajorans, and expected their adoration, incurring their fear and hatred instead. The very things that were denied Dukat were handed to Sisko in his role as Emissary. Dukat's snarking to Sisko about the pretentiousness of his title in "Ties of Blood and Water" has yet another dimension, then, as he is secretly jealous of the adoration Sisko receives.
In "To the Death," Weyoun mentions that he's an expert both in telling lies and in spotting them. We see that this is true throughout the show. On rewatch of this show after watching the Daredevil Neftlix series, I think I've figured out how, other than facial expressions. In "In the Cards," Jake tells Weyoun the truth, which Weyoun disbelieves, then tells him a really ridiculous story. Rather than believing the second story, as the rules of fiction usually demand, he suddenly believes the first story. Why? In "Favor the Bold" it's established that the Vorta have excellent hearing. He probably heard Jake's heartbeat change while telling the second story and knew what it sounded like when he lied, and realized he wasn't a good enough liar to have pulled off the first story without a change in heart rate if it wasn't true.
I was initially quite baffled by the court in House of Quark. It seemed downright bizarre that the Council running the entire Klingon Empire had no means of assessing the validity of Quark's accusation of financial crimes, and no one on call who could (the whole situation came down to his word against D'Ghor). Then I talked with a friend who understood Klingon society better than me, and nearly burst out laughing when I realized that Grilka actually got screwed over precisely because she was of such a high caste: If the same crime had been committed to (or by) a member of a lower caste, they would have gone to a lower court, and an accountant could have been called to assess the case. However, anyone even capable of sitting through Quark's lecture (let alone following it) would be too dishonorable to associate with the High Council, and thus there was no way to resolve the question of D'Ghor's guilt without a duel.
After Li Nalis is returned to Bajor he is given the religious/military title of Navarch, with the title meaning he answered directly to the Prophets. His technical commander is Benjamin Sisko, the Emissary, and the one who actively speaks to the Prophets.
Keiko and Sisko's ethnicities in "Cardassians" and "Waltz" respectively. In "Cardassians," Miles O'Brien casually remarks about Cardassians, "Any compassion was bred out of those people a long time ago," to which Keiko angrily replies "That was a very ugly statement!" "I just said—" "I don't have to hear it twice!" Keiko is Japanese. Miles was talking about Cardassians the same way Americans were talking about her country during WWII, demonizing an entire population for the actions of their government. In "Waltz," Sisko shakes with rage while trying to remain diplomatic as Dukat tries to justify Cardassia's occupation of Bajor, ranting about how "inferior" the Bajorans were, and how "grateful" they should have been for the Cardassians' "help." This troper spent the entire scene thinking Sisko was simply channeling the reaction of any sane audience member, and only later remembered "Oh my god, Ben's African American! And he just listened to that."
In Far Beyong The Stars, where each character from the series has a corresponding character from 1950s America, it is Quark (The Ferengi and therefore ultimate capitalist)'s counterpart that gets mightily offended at the accusation of being a communist.
In Who Mourns For Morn in season 6, Quark's ability to just shatter the golden bricks in his bare hands seems pretty inexplicable — until one remembers that, when they were introduced in TNG'sThe Last Outpost, the Ferengi were characterized as Pint Sized Powerhouses, with Ferengi warriors being capable of taking on Worf and winning. Furthermore, in another [DS9] episode, one Ferengi singlehandedly throws Sisko several meters in a fit of pique. So, why are they characterized as cowards? Because of Deliberate Values Dissonance! As a Proud Merchant Race, who also happen to know that most beings of comparable strength tend to have the advantage in size and reach, the vast majority of Ferengi don't bother to train in combat because they have no interest in it, and their culture regards fighting as an act of failure. They're strong, they just don't have any reason to show it off or the training to put it to effective use.
Furthermore, this explains how Quark manages to survive his off-screen sex with Grilka in Looking For Par'Mach In All The Wrong Places and, it's implied, actually managed to pleasure her in the bargain — her certainly doesn't act like the Destructo-Nookie was unsatisfying, after all. Quark's actually strong enough to make a very spirited attempt at keeping up with a Klingon female in the throes of passion; it's just not something that comes up normally since he's a Non-Action Guy.
Why did the Founders keep Martok and Bashir alive after replacing them? Wouldn't it make more sense to kill them so that they can't escape and expose the Changelings who replaced them? I suppose I could see why they'd keep Martok around (if his replacement is exposed, he makes a valuable prisoner in case of an exchange), but Bashir isn't important enough to the Federation even for that, and his replacement's assignment was to blow up the solar system he was in.
Not only prisoner exchange but information as well.
It's worse. The Dominion is infamous for genetic manipulation, giving their Jem'hadar cloaking abilities, creating Vorta with telekinetic powers, and altering their own people on molecular levels (Odo being turned solid). So why did they keep Julian? He's an augment. He's significantly smarter and has better hand-eye coordination than most humans, and as the show repeatedly gets across, compared to other augments from centuries ago, he's underpowered. Of course the Founders would recognize and try to capitalize on that.
Also, if the Federation ever created blood tests that could compare genetic material, they would need supplies of blood from the original to cover it up.
Has anyone given thought to Dax's average life? In "You Are Cordially Invited", Sisko states that the symbiote is 356. That was in early season 6, meaning Dax was AT MOST 357 when Jadzia died. This means that it went through 8 lifetimes in that time, making the life expectancy of a Dax host less than 45 years.
A couple of points to be made:
The host lives at least 20 years before being joined to the symbiote; that wouldn't count towards the age of the symbiote (who during that time would still be living in a previous host)
Torias and Joran were joined for less than a year each before dying and having Dax taken away respectively
Recalculating for 6 hosts* Ignoring Jadzias early death this gives an approximate lifespan of 59 years or 79 years if we assumed they all were joined at 20.
In Trials and Tribble-ations Sisko accidentally brought the Tribbles into his time. Remember that these creatures bred fast enough and ate enough that the Klingon Empire was forced to order the entire population wiped out. Either Sisko just started a new Alpha Quadrant-wide ecological disaster or they killed every Tribble on the station. Either way it's a grim realization for a light hearted episode.
It's not quite that bad. McCoy in the original episode figured out that the only reason that the tribbles were breeding so rapidly is because they had unlimited access to food via the food slots and everyone feeding their new pet tribble. All they need to do is find a way to control how much food the tribbles get, and the breeding can be kept under control.
McCoy noted it had to be the smallest morsel, and that doesn't do anything about the very large population already in existence without any controls and obviously eating more than morsels. If a single Tribble found its way to the Bajoran wilderness Bajor would have to implement widespread destruction just to keep the population under control.
Bob Barker reminding you to help control the tribble population. Have your tribbles spayed or neutered.
That's only a problem in an artificial environment with no predators. Much like mice, locusts, and other creatures that can ecological terrors, there's a food chain keep their populations in check. In fact the tribbles appear to have evolved to reproduce quickly because they're absolutely defenseless. No teeth, claws, spikes, or armor. They can't run, jump, fly or burrow. Any carnivore would eat them up like popcorn. If they were released into an area with something that could keep the population in check, the tribbles wouldn't be nearly as big a hazard.
McCoy actually pointed this out in the episode. He stated that the tribbles came from a planet with a predator filled environment that kept them in check. And that the tribbles reproduced the way they did because out-breeding the carnivores was the only way they could survive.
It's also a problem in any natural environment that doesn't have the right predators, either. Look at the classic actual analogue of Australia: notionally carrying plenty of predators, but you wouldn't know it from the rabbit problem. Even if they were kept in check on their original homeworld by predation (a logical notion, and one backed up by the Extended Universe), introducing any predators vicious or simply active enough to keep something as...prolific as tribbles in check to Bajor would just cause new problems, like cats across the world (a significant contributor to the endangered status of many birds and the extinction of many others in once-isolated ecosystems like islands) or mongeese (mongooses?) on Pacific islands. If native Bajoran predators don't recognize them as edible, don't get some important nutrient from eating them instead of their usual prey, do get some toxic byproduct due to the two species being from ecosystems that evolved separately on completely different worlds, or simply can't kill them fast enough...
On a possibly related note, was it ever established what the station's vole infestation ate?
The Klingon have already exterminated the species once. Just call them, they know what to do.
Fortunately, the creatures are contained on the Defiant and DS9, so it shouldn't be too hard to mass-transporter them into containment, the way it was handled in the original episode. One of the novels also offhandedly mentioned that tribbles can be sterilized (and Odo insists on verifying that one has been before he lets it on the station).
In "Duet" Maritza seems to be doing a fairly typical Evil Is Hammy act, playing the Card-Carrying Villain in order to make his perfidy too obvious to be ignored. The horror comes when you realize that he's pretending to be someone he actually KNEW, and who was (albeit distantly) his commanding officer. And that behavior would not only not be frowned on for a Cardassian officer, it would be encouraged. So there's a good possibility that the real Gul Darheel was exactly as horrible as Maritza portrayed him.
Is that a surprise? One would expect Guls who ran camps like that to be horrible.
Sisko's parentage. We learn that his "mom" was not his actual biological mother; instead, Joseph Sisko was first married to a woman named Sarah who had been possessed by a Prophet solely to give birth to Ben. Once Ben was one year old, the prophet left and Sarah immediately went to Australia, because the entirety of the romance and marriage was the Prophet's doing. Think about this for a moment—Sarah was raped. It's not Joseph's fault because apparently the Prophet was good enough at acting to convince him that there was an actual romance happening, and a likely case of Blue and Orange Morality (non-corporeal beings probably don't have a concept of physical rape) but it's still really fucking creepy. And of course they never address the creepy implications in the show; instead they bring back the Prophet, using Sarah's appearance, as a mother figure. It's made worse by the fact that poor Sarah was killed in some accident later on..
In "The Alternate", Odo, Mora Pol, Jadzia Dax, and Weld Ram discover a monolith on the planet L-S VI, nearly identical to the monolith seen on the Changeling Founder's homeworld in "The Search". This suggests that L-S VI may have been an abandoned Changeling colony. While exploring L-S VI, Odo is exposed to a volcanic gas that later induces his psychosis and transformation into a monstrous form. What if L-S VI was abandoned after volcanic gasses triggered a mass psychotic rampage among the Changeling inhabitants?
When Laas departs from Deep Space Nine, he embarks on a mission to find other Changelings sent out as infants like himself. Thus, it's conceivable that Laas and the Changelings he tracks down could someday form a second Great Link. Given Laas' utter contempt for non-Changeling races, he would likely form a circle with like-minded Changelings rather than Changelings who happily integrated into their adopted cultures. Over centuries, the bigotry of Laas and like-minded Changelings could blossom into outright aggression toward solids. In the distant future, one can see Laas' second Great Link forming the basis of another Dominion.
Laas and two other Changelings actually create the New Link in Star Trek Online and ally themselves with Jem'Hadar that are still in the Alpha Quadrant.
Vic Fontaine's treatment by his creator Felix. We know that Vic was designed to be a self-aware hologram. But in "Bada Bing, Bada Bang," it's discovered that Felix installed a "jack in the box" in the holoprogram, putting Vic in serious danger, and causing him to get beat up by other holograms, purely for the amusement of humans playing the holoprogram. Vic even exclaims, "How could Felix do this to me?" It's another hologram-abuse case for The Doctor.
In a larger sense, the creation of a sentient program designed entirely for entertainment is very troubling issue, which is really never addressed in the series. The ethical ramifications of dealing with sentient androids is a recurring issue in TNG, and dealing with The Doctor's sentience is a significant part of Voyager's series arc. But Vic Fontaine, who's evidently fully conscious and self-aware is just taken in stride. Apparently the Federation, at some point, went from agonizing over the god-like power of creating intelligent life to casually granting holograms sentience so they can be better lounge singers!
It is possible that being a lounge singer really is Vic's highest ambition (stranger things have happened); alternatively, maybe he isn't really self-aware, Felix was just very clever in writing his responses.
The Romulans. Think about it: their warships can invisible to sensors and the naked eye with ease, their fleet is powerful enough it turned the tide against the Dominion, at least some of their ships have friggin' Wave Motion Guns... And they have a rather tyrannical government and an expansionist agenda. Have you ever wondered why Kirk was terrified of getting a second war against the Romulans and the Federation and the Klingon went beyond their bad blood so easily? Here's the answer.
Had Darvin's revenge in "Trials and Tribble-ations" succeeded, he would have doomed the Klingon Empire. A devastating war with the Federation would have ensued, and all would have been lost for Qo'noS when Praxis blew up.
And this is set not long after the Organians promised to end both sides if they went to war.
The Founders always intended to exterminate the Cardassians once they didn't need them. The female Changeling's order at the end of the series seems like she's just really frustrated and pissed off about losing (and the Cardassians rebelling), but remember what she told Garak earlier when he asked if there were any survivors from the Tal Shiar/Obsidian Order attack on the Founders' homeworld?
Female Changeling: They're dead. You're dead. Cardassia is dead. Your people died the instant they decided to attack us.
Remember not only that this is the same Changeling, but that they share all their thoughts within the Link; she's not just talking out of her gelatinous hindparts here. The Founders didn't just take advantage of Cardassia's weakness; they created that weakness and tricked them into joining the Dominion with the full intention of enslaving and then exterminating them. All in revenge for a preemptive strike most Cardassians didn't know was happening. By extension, this probably means the Founders were going to wipe out the Romulans as well as soon as they beat the Federation.
This is also quite the plot point for "In The Pale Moonlight" if you think about it. Note that when Sisko first comes to Garak asking him to help him get his hands on proof that the Dominion is planning a sneak attack on the Romulans, Garak doesn't question the existence of any such war plans, only the feasibility of obtaining them. That's because he knows those plans exist, thanks to what the female changeling told him. This surely made his (first) backup plan to feed a forgery of those records to Vreenak that much easier to justify to Sisko as well: "fake but accurate" could never have been a more applicable description, even if their forgery was only an imprecise approximation of what took place at the actual meeting.
The Klingons love doing the blood test for Changelings. Yet General Martok's Changeling replacement remains undetected for months. How? Joe Sisko gave us a possible answer in "Homefront." A Changeling kills a person and absorbs all their blood, and lets some of it eek out when they're cut or have blood drawn. So ... it seems extremely likely some poor bastard got killed by Changeling!Martok for his blood.
There is a lot of moral debate over Section 31's plan for Changeling genocide - but here's another thing to think about. Would it even have worked? We know that the Dominion was functioning very well with minimal interference from the Founders, and some of the Female Changeling's decisions are actively detrimental to their cause (antagonizing the Cardassians by giving away their territory, ordering the elimination of the Cardassian populace during a crucial moment). And here's where the Fridge Horror sets in - when the Cardassians and Romulans attempted a preemptive strike, everyone hurried to stop them because they knew they'd be dealing with angry Jem'Hadar flooding through the wormhole if they succeeded. We also know that Weyoun already wanted to take out Earth's population because they were most likely to lead a rebellion. Now imagine what Weyoun would have done if he survived the war but the Founders didn't, and the Vorta scientists figured out the virus came from Earth? All of that considered, it's very lucky the virus didn't work faster than it did.
Ezri Dax gets a lot of heat for being meek, confused, and ineffectual until the Expanded Universe. However, look at it this way; she never completed Host training. Either she washed out or dropped out, possibly after realizing how sick the whole setup was, and probably took Starfleet as a way to get off the Trill worlds, which are nastily repressive. She must have been relieved to leave it behind...until her ship took on an injured Symbiont and she had all of 15 minutes to make the decision to save it at the cost of her identity. So an untrained Host, a renegade Symbiont with about nine lives' worth of experiences (I'm counting Verad), and remember what happened the last time before that Dax had an "unauthorized" Host? Ten to one, the Trill homeworld would have quietly breathed a sigh of relief if she had let Dax die, so I'm betting they were of no help at all. It's a small miracle and a testament to Ezri Tegan that she's even halfway sane.
The implication (at least for me) seemed to be that Ezri Tigan had no desire to be joined prior to happening to be the only Trill on board the Destiny at the time Dax took a turn for the worst and needed to be joined to a host or die. The Trill government has made their society believe that only a small percentage of its population is capable of being joined, it's entirely possible that she'd never even wanted to be joined but agreed to joining with Dax to save the symbiont's life.
I believe there is an expanded universe novel that explicitly STATES that she didn't want to be joined at all (let alone to a symbiote with that much life experience) and hadn't done ANY host training what so ever. Even worse, she didn't want to be joined even when the Dax Symbiote HAD to be joined to a host. She only agreed because she felt she had no choice between Trill cultural values and peer pressure from the crew of the Destiny.
You don't need the EU to tell you this. Ezri herself said so just a few minutes after she introduced herself to Sisko. And regarding her barely maintaining her sanity, imagine what would've happened if Joran had decided to take over. (And in "Field of Fire", he almost does.)
In the episode "Defiant", William (actually Thomas)Riker is commanding the newly stolen Defiant into Cardassian space, he activates the Defiant's cloak in order that they are not detected by the patrolling Cardassian Warships. Interestingly, when the cloak is activated, one of his Maquis crewman cuts main power and enters a sort of silent running subcommand which is visibly similar to when Commander Sisco and company disastrously attempt to evade the Jem'Hadar earlier in the series (antiproton beams, etc), They find that running silent helps to some degree. At any rate, we can assume that Sisco and his crew, being great Starfleet officers, made very accurate reports about the incident- but for any number of reasons up to and including that a Romulan Cloaking Device would be top secret and by extension the Defiant's ability to cloak- those reports would be difficult to access, and probably not readily available to rank and file members of starfleet. This may extend even to Thomas, assuming the main computer cannot tell the difference between a goatee and a beard. Also to underscore the gravity of the reports, it is later revealed in the same episode (to Sisco's surprise) that the obsidian order knew about the cloak already. We can begin to construct a conspiracy suggesting the Maquis have intimate knowledge of the Defiant's capabilities. This blooms wonderfully into Fridge Brilliance as it begins to flesh out the very real threat of systemic infiltration by a number of interested entities into high levels of the Starfleet intelligence infrastructure, which more or less morphs right back into Fridge Horror.
The effect Jadzia Dax's death would've had on her stepson Alexander. The show focused heavily on Worf grieving his wife, but nothing about the teenage boy who, having seen his own mother (Ke'leyr) murdered when he was a child, finally got a fun, bubbly stepmother (Jadzia), and then she dies the exact same way his first mother did, murdered out of the blue in cold blood. He could use some help from Counselor Dax...which would've made for a pretty interesting relationship.
The Bajorans. No matter how much the Prophets visited Bajor for how long, and no matter how much their population dwindled due to the Occupation, there's just no way an entire species belongs to the same religion, or its counter-cultures (the religion of the Pah Wraiths and Ro's atheism came about in response to the Prophet religion). There have to be other belief systems and cultures on Bajor, however small...and they're all living under a theocracy run by the Prophet worshipers. Maybe not Fridge Horror per se, but at least "Fride-Not-As-Great-As-It-Seems." Consider how many Bajorans we see in Starfleet, the Maquis, or random colonies who don't wear the earring or mention Prophets. Put two and two together. Many off-world Bajorans are likely Bajorans who either belong to minority religions, or who practice different denominations of the main one, and left Bajor due to some amount of religious persecution.
Before anyone says it, yes, Starfleet bans jewelry on the job; but we don't see Wesley Crusher's Bajoran classmate or any of the Bajorans on Voyager wearing earrings off-work either.
Obviously that doens't mean they don't follow the religion of the Prophets, not every religious person will flaunt their religion. But the lack of earrings and Prophet mentions cff Bajor certainly opens the door to a lot of other possibilities.
And even for those who do wear the earring or exclaim "thank the Prophets!", Jewish humans may exclaim "Jesus Christ!" when shocked, and minority cultures usually take on some of the fashion and customs of the dominant one. Memory Alpha also states that the Bajoran earring is as much a symbol of Bajoran planetary pride and defiance against Cardassians as it is a religious symbol. (Think of when the U.S. inserted "Under God" into the Pledge during the 1950s to distinguish it from the Communists.)
Long story short, evidence and common sense suggests that some amount of Bajorans we see do not follow the beliefs that Kai Winn preaches, and that to some extent or another, that sucks for them.
In the episode "Children of Time" the colony's Odo alters the Defiant's computer to prevent the ship from going back in time. And four episodes later the Dominion War begins. Had the other Odo not done what he did nobody would've put up the minefield to stop the Dominion from sending convoys through the wormhole, or gotten the Prophets to eliminate the giant Dominion fleet in "Sacrifice of Angels" or any of the other things DS9 officers did to win the war. He may have caused Gaia to never exist but in so doing he inadvertently saved the Alpha Quadrant.
In "The Visitor", the Klingons have been "making angry noises" but don't appear to have attacked and the Bajorans and Cardassians have entered into a defence pact. The Dominion war didn't happen, the pah-wraiths stayed locked in the fire caves, Jadzia is alive and her and Julian are together and have had children. It would have been better for everyone else if Ben Sisko had stayed lost in subspace.
The Defiant came into play because the producers realized that after introducing The Dominion in season two, it made no sense that the only defense Deep Space Nine would have was itself and three runabouts, even before the first open conflict at the ending of season two.
This was also the point when Starfleet began to quietly upgrade DS9 into a station that could fend off a Klingon fleet of more than fifty ships in Way of the Warrior. This from a station that was overwhelmed by just three Cardassian warships in the pilot.
Another example: Worf was reassigned to the station after the destruction of the Enterprise-D in Star Trek: Generations. This meant that the writers needed to come up with a reason — any reason — to have Worf present on the Enterprise-E for his subsequent appearances in the Next Gen movie franchise. Star Trek: First Contact gives a reasonable explanation. Star Trek: Insurrection blatantly Hand Waves his presence at the beginning of the movie: he begins to explain what he's doing there before Riker starts talking over him. Finally, in Star Trek: Nemesis — which is set after the Deep Space Nine finale, in which Worf resigns from Starfleet and becomes the Federation Ambassador to the Klingon Empire — Worf is on the Enterprise-E, in Starfleet, as a member of its crew, with no explanation at allnote There actually was an explanation given, but it was cut from the final film.
Perhaps Insurrection takes place between episodes of Deep Space Nine during Worf's brief vacation from the station in an attempt to be very far away from Keiko O'Brien during her pregnancy (which didn't last long anyway, but Worf wouldn't know that until he got back).
The pregnancy was two years past by that point - Insurrection occurred in Season 7, Kirayoshi O'Brien was born in Season 5.
Dialogue also establishes that the movie took place after the end of the Dominion War; which ended in the final episode of DS9.
Actually, Insurrection HAS to be set during the series - at the end, Worf is no longer on the station or the Defiant. Common fanon puts the events of Insurrection as occurring during the episode 'It's Only A Paper Moon,' which explicitly takes place over several weeks.
There was also the obligatory trial episode, where a crew member had to represent Dax because they had no lawyers. At all. To reiterate the scenario, this is a government that's being operated according to Bajoran law, but is enforced by Starfleet personnel, and is dealing with fallout from what was done under the Cardassian government. Why. The. Hell. do they not have any legal experts? They should need an entire team of them!
There's a difference between solicitors dealing with trials and those used for the disputes between nations. Actually having trained trial defence solicitors wasn't a high priority since DS9 doesn't seem to have been equipped for that in mind.
The primary mission of Deep Space Nine, at least in the earliest seasons, was to help out war-torn Bajor with Federation personnel and supplies. This would present a pretty significant legal and diplomatic challenges. There should be a number Federation lawyers and diplomats either based on DS9 or Bajor itself; we just never see them.
It's never actually established if the Trills joined the Federation or are just merely allies. Due to this, one can infer that there are numerous legal issues over dealing with a Trill citizen, working for the Federation, on a Bajoran space-station. Regardless, it is however established that the Klaestrons have a treaty with the Federation that permitted extradition, but had no such treaty with the Bajoran government. Considering that the Federation was trying to maintain diplomatic relations with both parties, it's likely why they didn't attempt to use their lawyers and let the Bajorans take over the case.
Bajor also had a fledgling government and very idealized self-image at that point; it's entirely possible the pre-occupation society didn't have lawyers as such, and the provisional government wanted to mimic that (which would explain why their judge is 100 years old). It's also possible the provisional government had a very crude constitution with an ill-defined judicial branch and Sisko was deliberately exploiting the situation.
Further questions are raised by how a minor fringe planet managed to get the Federation to agree by treaty with the extraordinary rendition of its own citizens without even informing Federation authorities of the matter. This is far from the only time in the series we see the Federation Diplomatic Corps to be established as utterly incompetent (the treaty with the Cardassians is a stinker of equal odor), but it's one of the worst.
They constantly test for changelings with a blood test. They keep doing it and believing the results even after they find out the man who came up with the test was a changeling infiltrator, and even Sisko's father figured out how a changeling could get around it. And even though the blood tests have never actually exposed a changeling—the only two people "exposed" as changelings were both victims of false positives.
That's par for the course in some modern militaries: If it doesn't work, keep doing it until it does. Maybe humans haven't changed as much as they claim.
There's more to it than that. The idea for the blood test came in the third-season ender, "The Adversary." In the fourth-season opener, "The Way of the Warrior," General Martok uses the blood test to prove he really is who he says he is. A year later, in the fifth-season opener "Apocalypse Rising," it's revealed that a changeling replaced Martok. Midway through the season, "In Purgatory's Shadow" has the real Martok in a Dominion POW camp, where he says that he'd been kidnapped two years earlier, midway through Season 3. Meaning that, until then, the Martok we'd seen had always been a changeling. And as Bashir pointed out in "Apocalypse Rising," any changeling impersonating a Klingon would have to be able to bleed on cue. Put it all together, and you realize that there was a changeling posing as Martok and bleeding when necessary before Starfleet's use of blood tests had even been conceived. The truth is, the blood tests were never a viable way to expose changelings.
Speaking of the blood test, Sisko gets framed for a changeling at one point by this test, and later asks the admiral who framed him whether he's going to tell him how he did that. The admiral asks whether it really matters, Sisko admits that no, it doesn't really, and they never speak of it again. How did they do it, then? Simple: that device they were supposedly using to draw his blood was actually a miniature holo-generator programmed to produce a convincing hologram showing blood being drawn in a tube turning into changeling goo. The admiral never actually drew so much as a drop of Sisko's blood. Star Trek: Voyager demonstrated on several occasions that the Federation's holo-technology was getting quite sophisticated, and the Federation's actual blood test was demonstrated to be completely painless, so the only way to discover that the sample was fake was to be expecting such treachery and looking for such a simple holographic trick, which in the paranoid environment the admiral was deliberately fostering, no one was.
Another possibility? The part that draws the blood, and the part that shows he blood isn't steamless. He drew Sisko's blood into that part...at which point it shot off a sample of Changeling blood, which hey had on file from a variey of ways, either one of hose Changelings who they saw and fled...or Odo.
Where was the Defiant when the Klingon fleet attacked in "The Way of the Warrior"? Really, the ship was probably staying under the cover of the station's shields so that they didn't get caught in a 50-on-1 curb-stomp, but it was like they were never there ...
The Defiant had been severely damaged rescuing the Cardassians minutes earlier. It is reasonable to assume that Sisko kept it docked to prevent its destruction.
Why didn't the Cardassians blow up Terok Nor before withdrawing from Bajor?
Try reading the Star Trek: Millennium trilogy. Not exactly canon, but a) it's excellent and b) explains a lot.
At the time it was in orbit of Bajor, if it exploded pieces of it might have hit the planet caused damage or killed people. The last thing Cardassia needed was more reason for the Federation to be pissed at them.
Given the usual reliability of Cardassian technology, I always assumed they tried and the self destruct failed. They do have a scrapped fusion reactor or two, perhaps they were supposed to explode instead of just shut down improperly..
They also left in a rush. One of the plot-points they depended on in early seasons is that the Cardassians didn't even have a chance to completely wipe the computers— O'Brien manages to retrieve all the engineering records from it, he tells Bashir that he could pull the medical records if he let a program run for a couple of weeks, and in one episode he pulls enough image data from a communication recording to identify the man making the recording. (The image they pulled was just a blurry mess, but it was good enough to match with a database of known faces.)
Of course this also brings up another problem— why didn't the Federation ever replace the computer system? The Cardassians are known to be magnificent bastards, and early in the series they find the replicators were sabotaged by Bajorans... who knows what kind of backdoors or boobytraps are in the thing?
That actually came up in the episode "Civil Defence", where O'Brien and Sisko accidentally trip an anti-insurgency program that was buried in the computer. In their defense, they were trying to wipe Cardassian files out of the computer at the time...it just didn't work out too well.
And then we find out that the head of Starfleet security on the station was busy installing his own backdoors and booby traps into the computer.
In addition, in "The Forsaken", O'Brien tells Sisko that it will take approximately three years to carry out the necessary upgrade.
O'Brien refers to the process as 'a root canal'.
Given how quickly and how often the Cardassians tried to reoccupy the station, they seemed to view their departure as a temporary one. Before the wormhole was discovered, Bajor had nothing to offer anyone. The Cardassians likely assumed that Bajor would descend into civil war, the Federation would leave after realizing nothing could be done to stop the fighting, and the Cardassians would come back to 'restore order.'
Why are the deities worshiped by the Bajorans called the "Prophets?" A prophet is an individual who communicates with a deity. Sisko's role as the Emissary is literally that of a prophet. Saying that the Bajorans worship the Prophets is like saying that Muslims worship Muhammad, or that the leader of their country is an ambassador.
Maybe they hold that there is a higher level of divinity that the Prophets have one foot in and link the material universe to it, perhaps with its own deity that Shall Not Be Named or something similar. It's not like the series ever really goes into detail.
Maybe because one of the main bases for their faith is the Orbs—through an orb experience, you generally see the past or the future, right? Meaning that the beings who give those experiences, through the orbs, are like prophets.
This troper always took the term more in its original linguistic sense of "someone who tells what will happen," as opposed to being the mouthpiece for the supernatural. In other words, in Bajoran religion, the primary (emphasized) characteristic of their Gods is that they communicate the future (or sometimes the past, or what is otherwise outside the realm of mortal knowledge) - this is notably what the orbs do for example. Translation Convention also possibly applies, since "Prophet" may be the closest English translation of the native Bajoran term, but may not be saddled with the same kinds of implications.
It may not even be a translation issue, Prophet may very well be a Bajoran word that just happens to also mean something in english.
Probably for the same reason the hourglass-shaped devices are called "orbs".
This is given a handwave in season 1 or 2. Sisko notes to Jake that the Prophets basically exist outside of time and do not perceive past, present, and future the way humans and Bajorans and so forth do. The line goes something like, "That could be considered prophetic."
In "Through the Looking Glass", we meet the Mirror Universe version of Bashir. Given that the technology to make human Augments almost certainly doesn't exist, shouldn't Mirror!Bashir still be severely developmentally disabled?
Given the heightened aggression and irrationality presented by many Humans in the Mirror Universe, it actually makes a lot of sense that the Augments won the Eugenics War or it was never banned, thus making their descendants all Augments.
None of them seem quite so bright as to be Augments. Look at how mirror Bashier acts: he's an aggressive idiot who is constantly unable to grasp the full scope of both his actions and any of the major events around him. A more likely story is that Mirror!Bashir is a bit low on the brainpower, considering that he's portrayed mostly as Dumb Muscle. By all indications, it seems he wasn't so much "disabled" as just rather slow. The Julian Bashir from regular continuity was lagging badly behind the other children before his parents got him enhanced, but that doesn't necessarily mean he would never have grown and developed sufficiently to take care of himself eventually; just that he probably would have had a more menial adulthood. Mirror!Bashir is probably a pretty accurate picture of how Bashir would be without those enhancements (and with a much rougher upbringing).
It's Star Trek, so yeah there's plenty to be found. One notable example includes the episode featuring Worf's brother and its resolution. It basically has both of them completely forget how they handled a very similar situation before (their family standing in disgrace) and ends with Worf arguably crossing the Moral Event Horizon for a really bad solution to a problem that ends up solving itself within a season when the dishonor is lifted (again).
That's not really the best example, since they dealt with it before by pretending they weren't related (not really an option anymore since everyone knows they are) and technically their family honour wasn't restored, Martok made Worf an honorary member of his own family (although he might have extended the offer to Kurn if Worf had asked nicely).
I think the main thrust of the point stands. They had been in dishonor before and gotten out of it. Also, if Worf was able to join another house, then surely Kurn would have had a much easier time of it. After all, it wasn't Kurn's fault.
Klingon laws and traditions don't care about "fault". A Klingon has to bear the dishonor of his family members also, not just his own. If Worf does something dishonorable, then it affects Kurn just as much. Even if he didn't do the act himself, he would be "the brother of a traitor". Just as Duras was "the son of a traitor".
The main point of the episode is Kurn is showing all the symptoms of clinical depression after having had his entire life taken from him, twice attempting suicide by proxy and then putting a gun to his head and coming very close to pulling the trigger before Worf takes it off him. Worf's solution is basically to have Kurn join another house but it would be interesting to know Kurn's reaction if Worf had actually suggested it to him rather than resorting to a memory wipe and subterfuge. Was he in the right frame of mind to have gone along with it willingly or would he have still seen death as the only release?
Then you have O'Brien working as an intelligence officer (again) infiltrating the Orion Syndicate, and the station keeps lampshading his genius engineering skills by giving hiccups every 5 seconds or so. And he had a wife and two kids. Was Starfleet Intelligence really desperate enough to send someone that important to a suicide mission like that?
It's important to note that the Klingons were engaged in war with the Cardassians at the time. O'Brien's presence could be a Call-Back to a fairly forgettable TNG episode, where O'Brien has some backstory revealed that he and his old captain (who is the focal point of that episode) spent a lot of time fighting Cardassians back in a war between the two powers that occurred before the start of TNG.
In "Emissary," Sisko says that his father "was a gourmet chef," seemingly referring to him in the past tense and inferring his father is no longer alive. While we meet Joseph Sisko years later, it's possible that Joseph was a gourmet chef before moving home to New Orleans and opening a creole restaurant.
Who says creole can't be gourmet? Perhaps his father entered another line of work for a while, such as a restaurant management job with no actual cooking duties? Or maybe his first restaurant went under (not an unlikely occurrence, given the nature of the business). Or maybe the elder Sisko decided to retire, but got bored and opened a new restaurant by the time we finally meet him in person?
In the Federation, all chefs are gourmet chefs, since any cook who wasn't brilliant would get put out of a job by the replicator!
The Die is Cast: The device being used to torture Odo is sitting on a desk right in front of him, seemingly unprotected. Garak leaves him alone with it for hours. Why doesn't Odo just break the device?
Odo is more acquainted with Cardassian technology than the rest of the crew, and has dealt with Cardassians longer than everyone else and thus understands their methods. He may have recognized Garak's apparent neglect of the device as Schmuck Bait—the device may have been set to do something truly nasty to him if he touched it.
Garak never actually leaves the room, he's there the whole time. Odo's used to using his shapeshifting abilities, while Garak has likely had Obsidian Order training for combat, and he can call on the Romulan guards if Odo were to attack him. So Odo doesn't really have much opportunity to go for the device.
"In The Pale Moonlight" has Sisko talking about the casualty list he had to post each Friday and how it motivated him to roll with Garak's shady scheme to get the Romulans into the war even as he began to have serious doubts that he was doing the right thing. For all the emphasis on how every name on that casualty list was a loved one, friend, or associate to somebody, however, neither he nor anyone else agonizes much over the four Romulan bodyguards who also got killed by Garak's scheme. Sorry, dudes, but you're Red Shirts.
The entire point of that episode was that Sisko had reached the point where he was willing to sacrifice a handful of lives (against his principles) to save billions more. And he is quite clearly agonized over the entire plot.
Not just Sisko, but Garak doesn't care either. Watch as he lists the price of Sisko's victory to him near the end: see any glaring omissions in that list? That's right: he mentions only two lives, not the six lives it actually cost.
Another point from earlier in the episode: that optolythic data rod ended up costing Sisko 85 liters of biomimetic gel which, as Bashir pointed out, is dangerous stuff that can be used for highly illegal genetic experiments and biogenic weapons (the weapons of mass destruction of the future). Sisko didn't think to ask, but isn't that one more loose end Garak needed to tie up? It couldn't be a good idea to let some loose cannon with an unknown agenda be roaming freely around the Alpha Quadrant with enough material to build a bio-nuke. If Garak couldn't trust his source not to misuse that phlebotinum, he must surely have had to arrange to make a "tragic casualty of war" out of whoever sold him that data rod as well.
There was no agent, and no informant/supplier who needed the Biomemetic Gel. Garak made the bomb himself to destroy the shuttle himself to frame the Romulans, and might have used the doom gel to fake the crystal, if he didn't have one of his own to use. Remember, Garak played Sisko like a fiddle, up to and including using the "good men died to get this" by telling Sisko that all of his contacts died in hours, then later telling Sisko to use the same excuse on the Romulan Rep he tried to trick. Ergo, Garak had been planning for something like this all along, and had as much needed in place as he could get.
"Rules of Engagement": Worf blows up a Klingon transport when it decloaks in front of him. At his extradition hearing, how come nobody thinks to question why a civilian transport has a cloaking device, or how completely incompetent the judge is for not shutting the trial down in the first five minutes?
They are in the middle of a war. The Klingons are likely attacking Cardassian civilian ships, so they expect the Cardassians to retaliate in the same manner. The cloak is the best protection they can offer.
Or how about why an unarmed transport would decloak right in the middle of a battle, right in front of an enemy warship ready to shoot at anything that twitches? This particular bit was mentioned only briefly, and outside the hearing. If I were Sisko, I would've put this front-and-center and argued that the transport's destruction was actually the fault of a very stupid (and possibly suicidal) captain.
Sisko did question this. He sent Odo to find out if the captain was a glory hound or death seeker. The information came back negative. It's also mentioned several times that the battle occurred very near to a set of shipping lanes. Odo even says it would only take a very small navigational error to end up there. Add in that shields don't function while cloaked. If they were caught cloaked in the middle of a firefight, decloaking and raising shields is a smart maneuver.
Shipping lanes aside, the freighter should've still seen the battle and immediately changed course to avoid it.
Did Klingons even have cloaking technology at that point? Evidently so, I just don't remember when that was established. They would probably say they cloaked to "avoid pirates", which is very flimsy but that point might have been outside the trial's scope.
The Klingons obtained cloaking technology from the Romulans in the 23rd century, in a trade. The Romulans had cloak but not very powerful ships, the Klingons had much more powerful ships but no cloak. So they traded a bunch of D-7 class attack cruisers for cloaking tech. The Romulans used those for awhile and eventually used their tech to upgrade their own ships. And the Klingons got cloaking tech out of the deal.
"The Muse": How does Tavnian law regarding the disposition of Lwaxana's baby by a Tavnian supersede Federation law? In other words, why couldn't Lwaxana just file for an injunction in a Federation court? She is, after all, not just a Federation citizen, but a senior Federation ambassador.
The Federation in general is HIGHLY respectful of the laws of other worlds, both member planets and non-member planets. Member planets have to agree to the Federation charter (which disallows things like class systems, racial profiling and requires things like democratically elected governments). But these are *loose* requirements, not strict rules. Even member planets are free to make their own rules as long as they don't contradict something in the Federation charter. Also, even if a planet DOES violate the Federation charter, the worst case scenario is they won't be allowed to be a member of the Federation, they won't meddle in their affairs.
Several reasons. 1 - Lwaxana and the man were married on the Tavnian homeworld in a Tavnian ceremony. Tavnian custom dictates that the son would be his to raise. Lwaxana would have implicitly agreed to that when she married him. 2 - They are not in Federation territory, they're in Bajoran territory. The federation can't do much about it.
Something worth considering at the end of the series: Elim Garak is very nearly the only Cardassian left with the qualifications to govern Cardassia. All his colleagues in the Obsidian Order were assassinated or wiped out in Tain's attack on the Dominion, Gul Dukat has gone to Bajoran Hell in the Fire Caves, the Dominion purged the last of the Cardassian High Command from its ranks (and took Damar's successor out to be shot even as he protested that he was still loyal), and Damar didn't make it through the final raid on the Dominion's Alpha Quadrant headquarters. That pretty much leaves Elim Garak in the same position as Vladimir Putin after the collapse of the Soviet Union... if his colleagues in the KGB, Politburo, and Duma had all been wiped out. Of course, considering what a wreck Cardassia was by the end, being put in charge by the survivors would be quite a mixed blessing for him, at best. No wonder he spends a whole scene griping to Julian Bashir about how badly ruined Cardassia is.
However, in the relaunch novels, we see that Garak had changed for the better since the Dominion War. He preached the merits of democracy and openness, as opposed to the remnants of the military preaching for xenophobia and nationalism. He cleans up, becomes Cardassia's ambassador to the United Federation of Planets, and eventually is elected the Castellan of the Cardassian Union. Even Picard was impressed by how much he had changed.
Garak also convinces the remaining members of the Obsidian Order to help the Union against those wanting return to the old militaristic ways, reforming the Order as he himself has been.
We don't even have to get to the relaunch novels to see Garak's change of heart; in "Tacking into the Wind" and "What You Leave Behind", he recognizes the need to build a new Cardassia that is quite different from the old one.
In "Explorers", how did Dr. Elizabeth Lense mistake Bashir for an Andorian for years without realising her mistake? Does "Julian Bashir" sound at all like an Andorian name? Did she never bother to look up his file? And unless she arrived late to her own graduation and missed him giving the first speech as the Salutatorian, she would have noticed the man giving the speech was human! Granted, she might not have particularly cared who he was, but a woman who's supposed to be as intelligent as Julian is, making such an elementary mistake? It strains credulity!
Julian was talking to an Andorian when he was pointed out to her at a party. She may have assumed it was just a strange name for an Andorian. And she missed his speech because she was preparing for hers. She flat out says it in the episode.
I think I've figured out why saying why the S31 virus is unjustified gets me accused of spreading "anti-S31 propaganda" and Word of God seems to say that changeling genocide = okay, yet Borg genocide = wrong. The only times we see a Changeling who's not a Founder are Laas, who's a total jackass, and the baby changeling, who dies. And the writers even decide that in spite of his important relationships with the other characters, witnessing the Occupation, and his proud declaration early on that he's not the kind of person who steps on ants, the only thing that stopped Odo from joining a bunch of genocidal fascists who make the Occupational authorities look like treehuggers is Kira. So the Changelings are Always Lawful Evil and we're not meant to feel that bad about preemptive genocide because they'll end up deserving it (unless they fall in love with a Solid). But doesn't that... not gel with Trek's usual position on "enemy" races? Romulans, Cardassians, Klingons, even Borg all get a chance to prove that they're more complex than that, but the Changelings don't. Seems out of line of Star Trek's usual.
The Changelings are a study of what happens when you don't treat new races with openness and respect. From what Laaz and the female Changeling say at different points, Changelings are commonly discriminated against by humanoids. Effectively they founded the Dominion to protect themselves, they just went way WAY overboard with the whole idea. Think of them like a beaten child, of course they're going to lash out, and they'll develop severe defense mechanisms to protect themselves.
A couple of points:
The Great Link, even if the Founders/Changelings promote it as the perfect melding of thought and form, and infinitely better than any Solid form of intercourse (sexual or otherwise), it's still shown to be unreliable or capable of manipulation—tricking Odo as to who the Klingon infiltrator was, the Female Changeling trying to take his attention off of Kira and all the other Solids, and so on. This was Laas' first time linking, and he probably interpreted Kira's intense presence in Odo's mind as being his only reason for not being a Founder. Odo's own self-doubt probably assumed this to be true.
The whole genocide question has been muddy for ages, but one can look at it like this: the Borg, for all their incredible resources and terrifying collective presence, have only made a handful of excursions into the Alpha Quadrant spaced out over a decade or more. Scary as hell, but there's hadn't been a real opportunity for sustained conflict with the Borg until Voyager, and that was on the other side of the galaxy. Thanks to the wormhole, the Dominion was practically right next door, and there were 4 years of tension and cold war leading up to open conflict. There was more time and opportunity to enact such a plan, compared to the Borg incursions. Heck, if you think about it, it's because of the Borg as a implacable threat to the Federation that the Council would be willing to go along with such an extreme measure against the Dominion, even if they didn't directly initiate it. It's not a justification, just something to think about—Section 31 would've committed genocide against the Borg if they had the chance, and the Council would've been too glad to go along with it. The Dominion plague is more a case of aiding and abetting.
What is more, the Borg could be viewed as trillions of innocent people being compelled by an alien cybernetic intelligence to do things against their individual will. Since multiple Borg drones have been reformed (Hugh, Picard, 7 of 9) the idea of genocide against the Borg might be seen as killing a slave army which could still (in theory) be cured and freed from bondage. The Changelings are a collective intelligence when in the Great Link, and could be seen as one massive hostile life form (Odo being just the lingering doubts in the back of a single giant mind). Killing a "race" that is uniformly bent on the subjugation of all life in the universe (and has themselves used biological weapons to suppress races, "the Quickening") might be seen in the same way as "curing" the Borg of the malign intelligence that drives the drones to conquest.
Mirror Leeta ("The Emperor's New Cloak"). In the mirror universe the Terrans are to the Bajorans what the Cardassians are in the prime universe and the Cardassians saved their asses, so what the hell is Leeta doing working for the Terrans?
The Terran Empire seems to have been overthrown by the Klingon-Cardassian Alliance at least a few decades before the DS9 crossover, possibly more than seventy years prior, and if Intendant Kira is any indication Alliance Bajor seems to be a fairly oppressive place (it's just that the oppressors are Bajoran too). It's possible that by this time memories of Terran atrocities are fading, and that some Bajoran losers of internecine struggles might decide to join up with the Terrans against common foes (some might decide that freedom thing the Terrans are talking about sounds good too, although this is the Mirror Universe).
Not to mention that the Mirror Universe is rather known for self-serving backstabbing. Perhaps Mirror Leeta just thinks she has more to gain from being on what looks like the winning side.
"Valiant" has the Red Squad cadets on a training cruise close to the Cardassian border with only a few commissioned officers who are all conveniently killed in the opening of the Dominion War. Why would Starfleet have a ship full of cadets be near a potential warzone but also have the ship be a Defiant-class who is among the very few dedicated warships in the Starfleet armada and of vital importance for the coming war effort instead of a training vessel.
Because the cadets are training for an upcoming war. The time for "peaceful exploration" is over.
Shadow Play, the third mention of the Dominion, involved a colony where everyone and everything in it was a hologram, except the old man who founded it. The holograms had to be shut down to repair the generator, otherwise it was going to fail anyway (and possibly be unrepairable). When it was shut down, literally everything but the old man and his clothes disappeared. Why didn't his clothes disappear? Holographic clothing is perfectly usable; the only reason they shouldn't have disappeared was that he happened to keep a personal replicator and only used clothes created by it. However, the logistics of maintaining that would likely be beyond him considering the isolation of the colony.
Has anyone thought for a second what the life expectancy is for a being that is 300-400 years old and has had nine hosts? Because it isn't very high.