Fridge / Kaeloo

Fridge Horror
  • Smileyland doesn't have police officers, doctors or firefighters.
  • In "Let's Play Baby-Sitting", Kaeloo agrees to seduce Mr. Cat in order to produce a baby for Stumpy to take care of. Now consider the anatomical differences between cats and frogs. Thankfully, it never got to that stage thanks to an emotional outburst on Kaeloo's side before anything could happen. However, if they'd gone through with the plan, it would not have ended well. There's also the fact that neither cats nor frogs produce one baby at a time...
  • So far, we've only seen seven inhabitants of Smileyland and have been given insight into the past of three of them, and one is the "guardian" of the place. What happened to everyone else?
  • The scene at the end of "Let's Play House" just seems like a naughty little joke, but the implications of the entire scene, from Mr. Cat rubbing his groin against Kaeloo's to the honking sound effect that played once the lights went out were rather unfortunate. In other words an attempt at rape had just been shown on-screen. Granted, the fact that she can transform into a hulking monster and beat the stuffing out of him lessens the impact, but it is more the idea that Mr. Cat might not be above raping his friend which is truly frightening.
    • This happens again in "Let's Play Baby-Sitting". She slips out between his legs and then beats him up for it.
  • In Epsiode 77, Olaf is nowhere to be seen when the planet explodes. And he was confirmed to be in Smileyland during the episode...
  • Episode 65 ends with Kaeloo, Stumpy and Quack Quack chasing Mr. Cat around with his own weapons, pretending that they are him and he is Quack Quack. It's funny until Mr. Cat yells "I'M NOT INDESTRUCTIBLE!"
  • Yoghurts are shown to be sentient in Smileyland. Quack-Quack eats them by the crate.
  • The Carnivore Confusion Mr. Cat must have as a result of constantly being around a duck, a squirrel, two rabbits, a penguin and a frog. It's lampshaded in a few episodes, too.
  • Kaeloo's psychological profile in general. At times, to prevent herself from transforming into Bad Kaeloo out of rage, she forces herself into a wired-open grin. She also puts a lot of emphasis on being 'cute', 'sweet' and 'nice'. The fact that she was so overjoyed to die via being crushed by a meteorite in Let's Play the Quest for the Wholly Gruel indicates she may even be suicidal. Add to that her readiness to leave Smileyland in "Let's Play Courtroom Drama" when she decided her other personality was a serious threat to her friends and it quickly becomes clear that Bad Kaeloo is holding her hostage in her own body.
  • The main four treat everything like a game. Olaf, who has proven to be quite dangerous, does not.
  • In Episode 75, Mr. Cat reacts very negatively to Quack Quack leaving. In the absence of someone to torture, he almost kills Stumpy with a chainsaw. What's going to happen when Mr. Cat leaves Smileyland?
  • Mr. Cat can just claim to be a "professional [insert occupation here]", etc. and everyone just believes what he says. This includes professions such as, for example, a doctor.
  • The expository comics show Stumpy holding a chainsaw and Mr. Cat playing with weapons and explosives - as babies.
    • Stumpy has been shown on the show several times to be a victim of Parental Neglect, so his mother probably didn't know or didn't care. Mr. Cat, on the other hand... given his backstory in "Let's Play Baby-Sitting", it's even possible that he was an unwanted kitten. Let that sink in.
    • This is shown again in a flashback in episode 110, where little Stumpy is shown, before going to bed, using a taser instead of a stuffed animal. He then bites the taser, which gives him an electric shock.
  • Mr. Cat's psychopathic behavior is even scarier when Episode 34 reveals that he is less than 13 years old.
  • In Episode 106, Mr. Cat offers to sell Stumpy a bazooka. Kaeloo diverts the conversation, but what would have happened if a dangerous weapon like that wound up in the hands of someone like Stumpy, who is not only lethally stupid but also established to be insane?
  • In "Let's Play Air Pockets", before the plane takes off, Mr. Cat says that the plane will take off after he has had some champagne to celebrate the CEO's retirement. Mr. Cat is the pilot. And champagne is alcoholic. He may have been drunk-driving a plane.

Fridge Brilliance
  • Kaeloo denies being a boy or a girl, but is clearly female. Then you remember that for some species of frog, gender isn't exactly a fixed attribute, and that hermaphrodites aren't a rare occurrence among amphibians.
  • Why didn't the spaceship work in Episode 77? If it was the same one from "Let's Play Astronauts", it runs on imagination, and the gang clearly weren't imagining anything at the moment.
  • In "Let's Play Time Travel", the episode starts with Stumpy as Prince Charming, riding on his "horse" Quack Quack, to kiss Sleeping Beauty. Suddenly, Mr. Cat shows up out of nowhere and shoots Stumpy with a bazooka and says that Sleeping Beauty is "his". This may seem like Mr. Cat being a jerk, but Kaeloo's lines later in the episode make it seem like she was also part of the game. Since she was the only one not present during this scene, we can conclude that the Sleeping Beauty in the game was Kaeloo - who Mr. Cat has a crush on.
  • Stumpy frequently says he can't read or write. So how come he's such a big fan of comic books? The pictures help him understand.
    • This may also be the reason he hates books without pictures.
  • In Episode 128, Pretty believes that Stumpy is faking his injuries. She was one of the background dancers in Mr. Cat's presentation to Stumpy on how to manipulate people into donating money, and therefore probably knew what he was doing.

Fridge Logic