Film: My Darling Clementine

A 1946 Western directed by John Ford. It is one of many, many film depictions of Wyatt Earp, and the first to be explicitly structured around the shootout at the OK Corral. Henry Fonda stars as Earp, with Victor Mature as Doc Holliday and Cathy Downs as the (historically unattested) title character.

The film opens with ex-lawman Earp working a cattle drive with his brothers. But when his cattle are rustled and his youngest brother killed, he accepts the marshalship of Tombstone in order to investigate and legally avenge these crimes. This sets in motion a ripple of escalating tensions that finally leads him to confront the Clanton family at the OK Corral. Viewers familiar with the film Tombstone or with non-fiction accounts will recognize few particulars of the story, as the facts have been liberally rearranged.

Has nothing to do with the song — which does, however, serve as theme music.

This film provides examples of:

  • The Alcoholic: Holliday.
  • Artistic License History: The film diverges frequently from the known facts, particularly concerning the main characters' love lives and the timing and circumstances of various deaths. In particular, the plot is kicked off by the murder of the youngest Earp brother, James. In reality, James was the eldest, was uninvolved in the feud, and long outlived both Virgil and Morgan. (The 1957 film Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, though not a remake of Clementine, used James in a similar way.)
  • The Bartender: Notable for this memorable exchange:
    Wyatt: Mac, you ever been in love?
    Mac: No, I've been a bartender all my life.
  • Betty and Veronica: Clementine and Chihuahua — except their rivalry is only in Clementine's head. Holliday has definitely chosen Chihuahua.
  • California Doubling: As expected in a John Ford Western, the southern Arizona location is represented by Monument Valley, Utah.
  • Chekhov's Gun: James's pendant ends up revealing who killed him.
  • Classically Trained Extra: Granville Thorndyke, possibly. His reputation is that of a Shakespearean actor, and he never tires of quoting the Bard — but the play he is supposed to be appearing in is a trashy crime drama set in New York City.
  • Cruel Mercy: Invoked and then subverted. After the O.K. Corral gunfight, Wyatt Earp tells Old Man Clanton (who earlier killed Earp's brother James, and whose own sons have just been killed in the fight) that he's not going to kill him: "I hope you'll live a hundred years, so you'll feel just a little of what my pa's gonna feel." Then he tells him to get on his horse and get out of town. However, as Clanton is departing, he suddenly turns to shoot Wyatt, and Morgan Earp shoots and kills him.
  • Curse of the Ancients: The Deacon's favorite expression seems to be "dad-blast it."
  • Drink Order: Of course this is a Western, so everybody drinks whiskey. There's also a scene in which Holliday uses celebratory champagne as the pretense for a display of power: when first meeting Wyatt, he orders "A glass of champagne for the marshal." Wyatt asks for whiskey instead, but Holliday insists on champagne, and the barman complies.
  • Drowning My Sorrows: Holliday, after Clementine comes back into his life.
  • Faux Affably Evil: Old Man Clanton's friendly and inviting towards Wyatt the first few times they meet. Wyatt doesn't buy it for a second.
  • Hangover Sensitivity: Holliday follows a rough night of Drowning His Sorrows with a surprisingly semi-comic scene in which he complains about all the noise.
  • Historical Domain Characters: The Earps, the Clantons and Doc Holliday.
  • Hope Spot: Holliday musters all his skill to perform emergency surgery on Chihuahua. She endures it bravely and he goes off considerably heartened. The next time we see Holliday, he announces Chihuahua's off-screen death.
  • Important Haircut: Played with. Wyatt Earp goes from scruffily bearded to neatly mustachioed shortly before he becomes the marshal of Tombstone, but there's no direct connection between these events. However, we don't clearly see his shaven face until he decides to accept the marshalship. Also of note, Earp's first heroic act occurs just before he is shaved: he literally already has lather on his face.
  • Incurable Cough of Death: Zig-zagged. Holliday doesn't die of tuberculosis in this version, but he does die because of his cough: it distracts him during the climactic gunfight.
  • Literal Ass Kicking: Earp does this to the drunken Indian at the beginning of the film.
  • Narrative Filigree: All over the place. The revenge plot only takes center stage in the first few and last few scenes; the scenes in between include an obligatory musical number, a visiting actor who must be coaxed into the theater, and a church dedication that turns into a dance.
  • Nice Hat: Wyatt has a big soft-crowned felt hat that he always makes sure to dent just so — and he isn't the only one. On the female side, Chihuahua dons an impressively enormous sombrero for one musical number.
  • Only Known by Their Nickname: Holliday. When Clementine comes to town, she keeps referring to him as "Dr. John Holliday" — which leaves people momentarily confused until they realize that, oh, she must mean Doc Holliday.
  • Open Heart Dentistry: A bit of a meta-example: in real life, Doc Holliday was a dentist. In the film, however, he is a surgeon. This is explicitly established early on in order to justify having him perform surgery later in the story.
  • Rage Against the Reflection: Holliday, whilst Drowning His Sorrows. It even has a double meaning; the reflection is in the glass over his framed medical degree.
  • Real Song Theme Tune: As noted in the summary.
  • Retirony: James Earp looks forward to quitting the trail and going home to marry his sweetheart, and even shows off the expensive necklace he plans to give her. He is murdered that night.
  • Satellite Character: The title character, Clementine Carter, exists for two reasons: to drop hints about Holliday's backstory and motivations, and to engage in a Token Romance with Earp. Subtly subverted at the end, when she decides to stay on as the new schoolmarm. By this point she is the only major character remaining in Tombstone: the rest have either died or left.
  • Secondary Character Title: Clementine is not part of the shoot-out.
  • Schoolmarm: Clementine, at the end of the story.
  • The Sheriff: Wyatt Earp, naturally.
  • Shout-Out to Shakespeare: A long section in the middle concerns Granville Thorndyke, a ham-actor with a reputation as a Shakespearean: he skips out of his scheduled appearance in a modern play in favor of drunkenly quoting Hamlet in the local saloon. Midway through the "To be or not to be" soliloquy, he loses his place and asks for a cue. Holliday continues the soliloquy, imbuing it with a pathos drawn from his own death wish.
  • Showdown at High Noon: Averted, as per history. (Which is not to say that the rest of the fight is historically accurate.)
  • Signature Item Clue: James Earp shows off a distinctive cross necklace shortly before being murdered; much later, Chihuahua is seen wearing it, making Wyatt think Holliday was responsible for James's death. (She was actually trysting with one of the Clantons.)
  • A Tankard of Moose Urine: In the extended pre-release version, Wyatt compares the champagne to "fermented vinegar."
  • That Man Is Dead: Holliday, when Clementine tries to bring up his (decent and respectable) past. It's more explicit in the pre-release version.