Fanfic Recs: The Baby-Sitters Club

Proof that the remaining 10% is worth dying for here.

These are recommendations made by Tropers for The Baby-Sitters Club fanfics, all of which have to be signed to stay on the page. Feel free to add a fanfic of your own to the list, but remember to use the template found here.

You can also add to the current recommendations if you want. Refrain from posting Conversation in the Main Page though; that goes in the discussion page.

Authors and Web Sites

None Yet.

General Fics

Stories focused on the family and the friendly relationships of the cast. Plot-focused stories or light day-in-the-life stories. Pretty much anything that isn't focused on romance.

When Forever Wasn't Enough by melcia
  • Recommended by Jane Poirot
  • Synopsis: After a single event that tears the club apart, each girl goes down their separate paths dealing with their own individual issues until one of the girls who was the catalyst for the friends tearing apart commits suicide, bringing the girls together in tragedy.
  • Comments: Incredibly heartwrenching toward the end, but well worth the effort. The author has a firm grasp on the characters and rounds them out well, shaping some of them into different people than in the original series but in a believable way. The author also handles each issue the girls deal with in a touching and realistic manner (such as Abby realizing she may be gay and have a crush on Kristy, a suspicion long held by many fans), never getting preachy and narrating from each point-of-view in a manner that makes you truly want to believe them. The event that was the catalyst for the girls falling apart is handled well without treating it as a trivial subject matter. And then there is the suicide of the club member...again, it is very heartwrenching especially because of the other girls' reactions. They each have different reactions to her suicide, which is dealt with realistically. Overall, an emotional, well-thought out fanfic.
    • This troper agrees with the above comment, but would like to add that it took awhile to get used to how jaded the characters acted, and that the fic is 100+ chapters- and worth every bit of it.
    • This troper agrees as well. Heartbreaking is the right word.
    • Sadly, it's been taken down.
  • Add Review
  • Amsterdam! Amsterdam! by Celica60
    • Recommended by Jane Poirot
    • Synopsis: Done in the style of a BSC Super Special, the BSC is whisked off to Amsterdam after Shannon's family inherits a dutch mansion, where they each have individual encounters with the city.
    • Comments: If When Forever Wasn't Enough gets a prize for best drama, then this deserves the prize for best comedy. Hilariously written, the humour sharp as ever (especially the sexual humour which never gets over-the-top), this fanfic highlights the various traits of the BSC that get flanderized by various ghost writers and gives them even more flanderization, resulting in something that is truly hilarious to read. However, they are not mere cariactures of themselves in this fanfic; they are also genuinely rounded out and developed by the story's end, also managing to rake in a few genuinely dramatic moments (such as what happens to Stacey). Overall, a wonderfully well-written comedy.
  • Add Review
  • Caludia Keeshi Middel Skol Mamma by Celica60
    • Recommended by Fiftynumber, Twilight Shimmer
    • Synopsis: After ten years in the eighth grade, will Claudia finally graduate?
    • Comments: A hilarious read in which Claudia's dumbtitude has reached its logical conclusion.
  • Add Review