open/close all folders
William Sherlock Scott Holmes
"Who cares about decent? The game, Mrs Hudson, is on!"
The hero of the story (of course), Sherlock Holmes is rude, impulsive, selfish, sees little need to observe social niceties he doesn't understand anyway, and is altogether insufferable. He's also one of the smartest men on the planet, who solves impossible crimes often without leaving his flat. The series starts with him receiving a new flatmate in the form of John Watson, who keeps him grounded.
- Adorkable: When John arrives at 221B while Sherlock's parents are there, Sherlock's attempts to get them out and his attempt at casualness afterwards are hilariously awkward.
- Taken up to Eleven in "The Sign of Three", both as John's best man, and the de facto wedding planner.
- Addiction Displacement: He outright admits he solves crimes as an alternative to getting high in "His Last Vow".
- Allergic to Routine: Sherlock has a need for intellectual stimulation that strongly brings to mind a drug addict's desire for the stimulant of their choice, and repeatedly goes to dangerous lengths in order to avoid becoming bored - a trait he shares with his arch-nemesis, Moriarty. However, possibly as a means to complement Sherlock, this particular version of John Watson is heavily hinted to be an adrenaline addict and a thrill-seeker.
- All of the Other Reindeer: In addition to being hated by pretty much the entire police force sans Lestrade, in "The Blind Banker", it is revealed that all his classmates hated him back in school (specifically university) too.
- Ambiguous Disorder:
- Sherlock's behavior alternates from episode to episode between classic Asperger Syndrome (difficulty understanding others' emotions, abnormally intense interests, idiosyncratic language) and classic sociopathy (disinhibition, lack of empathy, manipulation of others). John puts forth the former as a diagnosis, Sherlock insists it's the latter. There's a moral dimension to which way one interprets the ambiguity, as an autistic individual is more likely to be able to learn acceptable social interaction than a sociopath.
Lestrade: I suppose he likes having the same faces back together. It appeals to his... his...
John: [snarkily] Asperger's?
- The sociopathic tendencies predominate in A Study in Pink (taking inappropriate pleasure in horrific but novel crimes), The Great Game (pursuing his goals without concern for the impact they will have on others), and The Hounds of Baskerville (shamelessly manipulating everyone around him, including John).
- Sherlock behaves more like a high-functioning autistic in A Scandal in Belgravia (when he seems genuinely confused by Irene's complex feelings for him) and The Sign of Three (when he can't understand why everyone has started crying in the middle of his best man speech).
- Anti-Hero: Sherlock solves crime for fun and not justice, to the point he tells John that heroes don't exist and even if they did he wouldn't be one.
Lestrade: Sherlock Holmes is a great man, and I think one day, if we're all very very lucky, he might even be a good one.
- Annoying Younger Sibling: Plays this role to Mycroft throughout The Empty Hearse.
- Badass: Make no mistake. Sherlock is a very good fighter, in no small part due to his intelligence. He even tries to take on the freakishly huge assassin The Golem during 'The Great Game'.
- Badass Baritone: Benedict Cumberbatch's deep voice suits the character perfectly.
- Badass Bookworm: In The Sign of Three, Molly mentions that Sherlock is a graduate chemist.
- Badass Longcoat: Sherlock sports a tailored, woolen one that costs £1,350.
- Berserk Button:
- The normally calm Sherlock doesn't take anyone hurting or insulting Mrs Hudson well. He throws the CIA agent in Scandal out a second-story window apparently several times for handling her roughly.
- Don't mess with John, either. In The Empty Hearse Sherlock throws himself into a fire, and pulls John out with his bare hands. In His Last Vow, Sherlock murders Magnussen when he realizes that it's the only way to save Mary (and by extension, John) from the information Magnussen was using to blackmail her. He seems fully prepared to go to his death as a consequence of doing so.
- Big Brother Worship: If Mycroft's appearances in the mind palace are anything to go by, Sherlock definitely looks up to Mycroft intellectually, although the way Mental Mycroft belittles his brother indicates that this coexists with a great deal of resentment.
- Break the Haughty:
- Brilliant but Lazy: Zig Zagged Trope. If he thinks it's worth his while he'll run several blocks, break into private property, or lie and cheat to get information. If he doesn't, his level of laziness has to be seen to be believed:
- In "A Study in Pink", won't lift his hand about three inches to grab the phone John offers him, forcing John to actually place it in his palm.
- In "The Great Game", while fiddling with instruments, Sherlock asks Watson to hand him his phone, which is in his jacket. The one Sherlock's wearing.
- In "A Scandal in Belgravia", gets John to Skype him a view of a crime scene because he doesn't want to get out of bed. Then can't be bothered to get dressed when summoned by the Queen.
- Brutal Honesty: Sherlock's M.O. Used for both comedy and drama: one time he might humorously extort someone with sensitive information, while another John might chew him out for being rude and tactless.
- Bunny-Ears Lawyer: Treated as one by Mycroft and Lestrade.
- Byronic Hero: Embodies all of the major traits of this trope.
- Can't Hold His Liquor: As shown at John's stag night.
- Catch Phrase:
- "Not Good?"
- "The game is on!"
- Celibate Hero/Celibate Eccentric Genius: Sherlock considers himself married to his work, though that doesn't stop an intense - but brief - relationship from blossoming between him and Irene Adler in A Scandal in Belgravia, the exact romantic/sexual nature of which is not discussed; and then there's the Ho Yay between him and John Watson that certain fans claim to see all over the place (and which is occasionally referenced in-universe to John's annoyance).
: It's the choice of a monk, not the choice of an asexual. If he was asexual, there would be no tension in that, no fun in that – it's someone who abstains who's interesting. There's no guarantee that he'll stay that way in the end – maybe he marries. Mrs Hudson. I don't know! (The Guardian, Jan 20th, 2012)
- Moffat posits in the same interview that Sherlock dismisses the charms of women because he finds them a distraction, and that he would not be living with a man if he fancied men (because it would also be a distraction).
- Cumberbatch weighed in on the matter to the blog Zap2It:
Benedict Cumberbatch: For me, Sherlock's not gay. He's not straight, necessarily. He has a sexual appetite, but it's entirely swallowed by his work. He doesn't have time for it.
- Magnussen's "file" reveals that he has a porn preference. It's apparently normal (though he was deep undercover by that point, so it is entirely plausible he completely fabricated said porn preference simply so Magnussen could find it.)
- Clueless Chick Magnet: Molly Hooper, Irene Adler, Kitty Reilly and Janine all seem to think so.
- Cloud Cuckoolander: Owing to his not always paying attention to the world. In spite of his intelligence, he doesn't know who the Prime Minister is and even forgets that England has a queen instead of a king- something he used to know.
- Despite being able to deduce an entire person's life with one look at them, he thought the morning tea that Mrs. Hudson would bring up for him "just sort of happened".
- Consummate Liar: Demonstrates several times that he is a rather convincing actor, pretending to be various roles as the situation requires. At one point he's so convincing he even fools the audience for a bit, crying and breaking down before laughing his arse off that John fell for it.
- Crazy-Prepared: Had 13 possible plans to escape Moriarty on the rooftop. Faking his death was one of them, although it's implied that it was a last-ditch option.
- Creepy Good: Owing to his sociopathic behaviour, even after it gets toned down significantly.
- Deadpan Snarker / Tall, Dark and Snarky: Being a self proclaimed high functioning sociopath may make you seem like a massive jerkass, but Sherlock shows how brilliant his wit is.
- Defrosting Ice Prince/Character Development: Starts treating his friends better over the course of Series 2. Even more so in Series 3.
- Distracted by the Sexy: Irene Adler has this effect on him, to the extent he noticeably stumbles over his words at one point and unwittingly foils a highly top secret and clandestine government plan, all in an effort to impress her.
- However, it also gets averted when he pretends to reciprocate her advances by holding her hand and staring deeply into her eyes, only to later reveal that he was taking her pulse and checking if her pupils were dilated (to deduct if she was genuinly interested in him).
- During "The Sign of Three", whilst working out a case in his head, he's briefly gets distracted by the mental image of (a very naked) Irene Adler, when musing about the very few people aware of John's Embarrassing Middle Name.
- Ditzy Genius: Invoked. Sherlock only keeps important information in his "mental hard drive," which does not include tact, common sense or heliocentrism. He even deletes stuff he used to know, such as there being a queen of England as opposed to a king.
- Driven to Suicide: Appears to jump off a building to his death at the end of Series 2. Subverted soon after, when it turns out he faked his death instead.
- Eerie Pale-Skinned Brunette: Eerie owing to his sociopathic nature, even after it gets toned down a lot.
- Embarrassing Middle Name: Inverted. Turns out his first name is actually William. Granted, it's a lot less catchy and unusual than "Sherlock".
- Epic Hail: Sherlock's solution to getting the police to arrive quickly is to casually fire a gun into the air!
- Everyone Has Standards: Even Sherlock seems disgusted at the man who admits to murdering his girlfriend in Belarus, taking obvious pleasure in the fact he will likely get a death sentence.
- Faking the Dead: Faked his own death at the conclusion of "The Reichenbach Fall" to save his friends.
- Fatal Flaw: His obsessive curiosity and constant need to not be bored leads him to irrational or cruel behavior that damages his relationships with his friends and sometimes even leads him to put his own life in danger.
- His pride and tendency to underestimate his foes also gets him into trouble.
- Forgets to Eat: Cumberbatch purposefully lost weight to highlight this. From the unaired pilot:
John: Aren't you going to eat?
Sherlock: What day is it?
Sherlock: I'm okay for a bit.
- Freudian Excuse: It's implied he had a very unhappy childhood:
- Attempts by his parents to socialize him and Mycroft with other children to make friends failed, miserably. Both Mycroft and Sherlock scoff at the idea years later.
- In Series 3, spending most of his development years with Mycroft is implied to have left a negative effect on his personality.
- Until he met other children he always assumed he was an "idiot" due to only having Mycroft as a companion.
- His mother by his own admission "has a lot to answer for" in regards to how her children turned out.
- The death of his dog Redbeard hit him hard.
- Friend to All Children: In "The Reichenbach Fall", he's very concerned about finding the kidnapped children and is very disturbed when they react in fear at seeing him. In "The Sign of Three", he befriends Archie through Brutal Honesty - and a shared interest in bizarre murders.
: You really do have to wear the outfit. Archie
: What for? Sherlock
: Grown-ups like that sort of thing. Archie
: Why? Sherlock
: I don’t know. I’ll ask one.
- Friendless Background: It's strongly implied that John was Sherlock's first real friend. In A Study in Pink, both Donovan and Mycroft point out that Sherlock isn't the kind of person who make friends.
- Genius Bruiser: While a more skilled combatant such as John can handle him, it's clear that this guy would demolish the average person in a physical fight.
- Glad He's on Our Side: His sociopathy, his despising being bored, and his being Not So Different from Moriarty are frequently brought up, as well as how awful of a prospect it would be if he stopped helping the police and ended up committing crimes for thrills himself.
- The writers speculate in one episode commentary that Sherlock stays on the side of the law as a self-imposed challenge: doing what Moriarty does would be too simple to stay interesting.
- Good Is Not Nice: As he tells Moriarty in "The Reichenbach Fall", "I may be on the side of the angels, but don't think for one second that I am one of them."
- Grammar Nazi: Deliberately corrects the grammar of a prisoner in Minsk at the start of "The Great Game" to make the man confess to murdering his girlfriend.
- Gray Eyes: Benedict Cumberbatch's glasz eyes can appear icy blue, grey or even slightly green depending on how a scene is lit. This is especially noticeable during his phone call with Mycroft in The Sign of Three, as he paces through several different lighting angles.
- Guile Hero: Most of his fights are won through pure observation and intelligence.
- Heartbroken Badass: During John's wedding in Sign of Three when he begins to realize how the marriage will affect their relationship. It upsets him enough that he can't handle staying around for the reception.
- Heroes Love Dogs: As a child he had a beloved pet dog named Redbeard who had to be put down. It's still a touchy subject for Sherlock well into adulthood.
- Heroic BSOD:
- Appears to be struck by one twice in "A Scandal in Belgravia". Firstly, he drifts trance-like into Baker Street after the revelation Irene Adler is, in fact, alive. Later, he seems stunned into inaction for a while once he realises that he has fallen for the oldest trick in the book.
- Freaks out in "The Hounds of Baskerville", when he experiences fear and doubt for likely the first time in his life.
- Played with in "The Sign of Three" where, after being asked to be John's best man, he stared at John for what is implied to be at least five minutes
- Between the revelation of the Appledore vaults and the arrival of the choppers in "His Last Vow," Sherlock is practically catatonic.
- Hypocritical Humour: During series three, episode three. He comes back to 221B and realizes that Mycroft is inside because the door knocker is straight, and says that he's OCD and straightens it without even realizing it. He then makes it crooked. Watson asks why he did that, and Sherlock's response is a genuine "Did what?"
- I Want My Beloved to Be Happy:
- Sherlock seems quite melancholy that Molly has moved on from her crush on him to get engaged, but he wants her to be happy. Not that her engagement works out, anyway.
- In Series 3 with John. By the time of "Sign of Three" Sherlock is well aware that things will be different with him and John since John now has a wife and unborn child to care for, but this doesn't stop Sherlock from doing whatever he can to protect the couple and their happiness. This culminates in him even willing to go off and die to protect John.
- Iconic Outfit:
- The deerstalker gets this treatment in-universe, to his exasperation.
Sherlock: Why is it always the hat photograph?
- Not to mention his popped-collared Badass Longcoat and Scarf of Asskicking, which are iconic in-universe and out — to the point that when Lestrade asks him not to be as... Sherlock... as he usually is, he just un-pops his collar.
- I Love You Because I Can't Control You: Implied with Irene Adler in "A Scandal in Belgravia". He shares but one meeting with her where his Sherlock Scan is rendered completely moot on hernote , and it ends with her drugging, violently whipping him and leaving him a slurring, passed out mess on the floor, topping it off by telling him to remember her as "the woman who beat you". When learning she's dead a little while later, he goes into a Heroic BSOD, as commented by John (he "plays sad music, doesn't eat, barely talks"). Although, as it's Sherlock we're talking about, it probably accounts more to a strong fascination than downright love. By the end of the episode however, his dialogue strongly implies that he did develop some kind of feelings for her, also showcased by how, despite her having worked for Moriarty and played a cruel trick on him, he still proceeds to save her life from executioners in Pakistan. Benedict Cumberbatch even hinted that Sherlock and Irene had a "very loving time" there.
- Inferiority Superiority Complex:
- Despite his apparent disdain for "normal people", Sherlock constantly feels the need to prove his brilliance to others.
Sherlock: That's the frailty of genius, John. It needs an audience.
- In-Series Nickname:
- Called "Hatman" by the press, due to wearing a deerstalker to hide his face.
- "The Reichenbach Hero" for his most famous case to date.
- "Sir Boast-A-Lot", which Moriarty alludes to while telling a fairytale. According to Irene, he also calls him "the virgin".
- "Shag-A-Lot Holmes" by a paper who got a falsified scoop from the woman Sherlock was temporarily engaged to.
- Insufferable Genius: He really can't help himself, not even after getting tossed out of a courtroom where he's the star witness and into a prison cell for showing off.
- Intelligence Equals Isolation: Zig-Zagged. It's hard to say what came first, Sherlock's incapacity of social interaction, or his aversion of it. Although Mycroft seems to have encouraged distance to others, his friendship with John proves that he is neither above nor averse to relationships with other people as long as it does not hinder his work.
- It's All About Me: It's entirely likely that Sherlock didn't know the earth revolves around the sun because he thinks that it actually revolves around him.
- Jerk with a Heart of Gold:
- Sincerely apologizes to Molly after offending her in "Scandal"; John is visibly shocked.
- Fantasizes about all the ways he could kill the CIA operative and then throws him out a second story window multiple times after the man harms Mrs. Hudson later in "Scandal".
- Fakes his own death to protect Watson, Mrs. Hudson and Lestrade in "The Reichenbach Fall". Note that he does this by jumping off of a building, likely using the same deductions he used to throw the CIA operative repeatedly out a window with non-lethal results on a larger scale. But he still fakes his death to save those he cares about by jumping off of a building, which still has the somewhat expected results of just nearly killing him instead.
- Acknowledges this himself in his best man speech at John's wedding, calling himself an "arsehole" but saying that John makes him better. As "The Last Vow" shows, he'll get himself exiled on a suicide mission for his sake.
- Knight Templar Big Brother: When it comes to John and Mary's happiness. Unbeknownst to either of them, after deducing that one of her former boyfriends invited to the wedding was still madly in love with her, he took matters into his own hands. He confronted him with the evidence, announced that he'll be downgraded to casual acquaintance and only allowed three visits per year (with John's supervision) and that he will be monitoring him closely. To say nothing of His Last Vow, in which he murders a man in cold blood so that John's wife will be safe.
- Lack of Empathy: Subverted ONLY when it comes to his friends.
- Limited Wardrobe: Black suit, grey coat, dark shirt, blue scarf, black leather shoes. And now, a word from the fashion coordinator.
- Mad Scientist: He keeps a human head in the refrigerator and human eyeballs in the microwave, both of which are being used in "experiments". Enough said.
- Especially when he's bored or irritated.
- Admits it during a conversation with a boy in John's wedding.
Sherlock: Grown-ups like that sort of thing.
Sherlock: I don't know. I'll ask one.
- Also from John's wedding:
Sherlock: You'll be great parents. You've had lots of practice with me.
- In His Last Vow, after John has found him in a drug den.
Sherlock: I'm undercover.
John: No, you're not.
Sherlock: Well, I'm not NOW!
- When Mary shoots him, he temporally regresses into a child inside his mind palace, when looking for a way to maximize his survival chances.
- A Man Is Not a Virgin:
- Manipulative Bastard:
- Tricks victim's distraught family members into giving him information, lies his way into locked apartments, and so on.
- A particularly egregious example is on his return in the third series. In the Underground below parliament he leads John to believe that he can't stop the bomb, he hasn't called the police, and they will surely die He begs for forgiveness, complete with quavering voice and tears. And having received John's forgiveness as he reconciles himself to their deaths Sherlock laughs and turns it into a Did You Actually Believe? moment. .
- Another brutal example comes from "His Last Vow," when he seduces and becomes engaged to Janine in order to get access to her employer, Magnussen.
- Married to the Job: Celibacy aside, this is the reason he gives for why dating (or human social interaction in general) isn't "his area". You can count the number of people close to him in any sense on one hand.
- Morality Pet: John, Mrs Hudson and Molly all serve to keep Sherlock grounded.
- Motor Mouth:
- Whenever he goes into a Sherlock Scan. It's entirely possible that Cumberbatch doesn't need to breathe; for example, just listen to his explanation of John's phone or much of "Hounds of Baskerville". And whenever Irene Adler is around he somehow manages to go even faster.
- In one interview, Gatiss comments on the extreme length of the deduction in Baskerville; apparently, on Cumberbatch's script he actually wrote "Sorry, Benedict" next to it.
- Must Have Nicotine:
- It's impossible to sustain a smoking habit in London nowadays, so Sherlock confines himself to patches. It just might end up being "a three-patch problem".
- Goes absolutely haywire in "Hounds of Baskerville" when he's detoxing, turning the entire flat upside down and outright begging John to give him a cigarette.
- Noted in "The Sign of Three" where a patch can be seen under his shirt.
- Not even hiding the fact that he's smoking and doing other drugs as of "His Last Vow."
- The Navigator: Has all the streets of London memorized and can predict a cab's likely path and come up with an intercept course in a matter of seconds.
- Nice Hat:
- Sherlock's stolen security guard hat.
- The deerstalker in "A Scandal in Belgravia", which also doubles as a Mythology Gag.
- Nightmare Fetishist: He appraises things from a purely intellectual level - not an emotional one - and that can lead into this trope. Grotesque crimes are 'interesting', 'ingenious', or 'elegant'.
Sherlock: Four serial suicides and then a note! Oh, it's [like] Christmas!
- Noble Demon: Freely admits - in fact, insists - that he's a 'high-functioning sociopath'.
- No Social Skills:
- Insults his friends, gets on trains covered in pig's blood and holding a harpoon, and visits Buckingham Palace practically naked.
- It wasn't until "The Sign Of Three" that he realized that John actually thought of him as his best friend. And John had to tell him.
- Not So Stoic:
- Whenever John is genuinely threatened or in danger. Stick him in a bonfire, strap a bunch of bombs to him or point a gun at the good doctor's head, and Sherlock's cool mask will evaporate in two seconds flat.
- Also two moments in "The Great Game": When the elderly blind woman begins to talk about the soft voice of the person who kidnapped her, Sherlock frantically warns her against it, knowing that the kidnapper will likely detonate the bomb he has strapped to her as punishment, which he does. Later on, when attempting to solve the riddle of how the painting was faked before the kidnapper blows up a child, he's clearly freaking out. Despite his supposed interest in puzzles over people, the prospect of these two lives being lost deeply disturbs him.
- When Mrs. Hudson is taken hostage, he rescues her, has Watson take her downstairs... and then proceeds to beat the crap out of her attacker and toss him out the window. Repeatedly.
- Is visibly shaken after his "encounter" with the titular creature of ''The Hounds of Baskerville", and even admits his fear to John.
- Odd Friendship: On the face of it, Sherlock and John have absolutely nothing in common. However, their shared Allergic to Routine tendencies end up making them rather inseparable.
- One-Man Army: At the end of "A Scandal in Belgravia", he wipes out an entire terrorist cell single-handedly, armed only with a scimitar.
- Pet the Dog: His apology to Molly for verbally tearing her apart on Christmas, complete with a sincere kiss on the cheek.
Sherlock: Merry Christmas, Molly Hooper.
- Prayer Pose: Sherlock uses this pose frequently, but as a sign of concentration while he's thinking, rather than any form of actual prayer or supplication. The books often describe Sherlock as sitting with his hands steepled below his chin.
- Red Oni, Blue Oni:
- The blue to John's red.
- But the red to Mycroft's blue.
- Sacrificed Basic Skill for Awesome Training: Sherlock's brilliant deductive reasoning comes at the expense of practical knowledge and ability to interact socially.
- Scarf of Asskicking: Sherlock wears a blue scarf.
- Sherlock Scan: Naturally! John first endears himself to Sherlock by being audibly impressed at Sherlock's "trick".
Sherlock (momentarily distracted): You do realize you're saying that out loud.
John: Sorry. I'll stop.
- Shipper on Deck: For John/Mary. He plans their wedding, scares off Mary's ex-boyfriend and breaks out of hospital with a gunshot wound in order to play marriage counselor to them. Though it might be more a case of I Want My Beloved to Be Happy.
- Shoot the Dog: The inevitable result of revealing to a high-functioning sociopath that killing you is the only way to save his best friend's marriage (and his brother's ability to remain unbiased).
- Slasher Smile: Sports an epic◊ one when he's dealing with David in "The Sign of Three".
David: They're right about you. You're a bloody psychopath!
Sherlock: High-functioning sociopath. With your number. *grins*
- The Sociopath: Played with regularly. Sherlock has all the classic signs of a fictional sociopath: a general lack of empathy; self centered behavior; total disregard for laws; regular use of fake charm, lies and manipulation to achieve his goals; he even goes so far as to call himself one. Ultimately subverted however, since when push comes to shove Sherlock really does care about his friends. It's suggested that Sherlock has tried to mold his mind into sociopathic thought patterns in order to function better as a detective.
- The Spock: John even calls him "Spock" in "The Hounds of Baskerville".
- Sticky Fingers: John's laptop, Lestrade's warrant card, an ashtray from Buckingham Palace, and Mycroft's clearance ID.
- The Stoic: Shows little emotion most of the time, especially compared to those around him at crime scenes or during an investigation.
- Sugar and Ice Personality: Ice towards almost everyone, but sugar towards his friends, especially later in the series
- Tall, Dark and Handsome: Since he's played by Benedict Cumberbatch. Molly noticed.
- "The Reason You Suck" Speech: Delivers one to himself in his best man speech at John's wedding, pointing out the sheer number of flaws and personality quirks that make him a terrible person and friend, but which John's patience has helped him to better overcome.
- Too Clever by Half: His need to be challenged gets the better of him sometimes and he ends up doing things any normal person would back the hell away from.
- Took a Level in Jerkass: In Series 2, which comes back to bite him in the finale.
- Took a Level in Kindness: Over the course of the series undergoes this due to John's influence, which he admits and credits him for Series 3, by which he's much nicer than he use to be.
- Trademark Clothing: His coat, he makes a point asking for it in "The Empty Hearse". His blue scarves count as well.
- Tranquil Fury: You'll never realize he's angry until after he's beaten the crap out of you. Or shooting you.
- Troll: Even when he's not bored out of his mind he can occasionally be an ass to get a rise out of people. Best example is him fooling John into thinking that they're both about to die since he can't disarm the bomb and he hasn't called the police just to watch him freak out.
- The Unfettered: Accused of being psychopath by most of Scotland Yard. Also has no problem ignoring 90% of the laws if it'll help him solve a case or help a friend. In order to protect John and Mary in "His Last Vow" he murders Magnussen in front of John, Mycroft, and three armed policemen.
- The Un-Smile: Invoked to scare the hell out of David. To the audience it's equally hilarious and unsettling.
- Undying Loyalty: To the Watsons. In particular John.
- Unkempt Beauty: As Shezza, his underground drug addict persona.
- What the Hell, Hero?: Gets called out a lot when he says or does cruel things to people around him, mostly by John.
- Who Names Their Kid "Dude"?: Averted. Sherlock is his middle name. His first name is William.
- You Wouldn't Like Me When I'm Angry: He gets very irratable when he's high off drugs, best not to piss him off.
Dr. John Hamish Watson
"How— oh, never mind."
An army doctor who was injured in the war, the series starts with him going to therapy and looking for a flatmate. He becomes one of the first people to appreciate Sherlock's incredible analytical skills, and Sherlock in turn realizes that John's therapist is wrong—he's not having trouble being back from the war because of post-traumatic stress, but because he misses the excitement. John becomes an invaluable aid to Sherlock, especially as his conscience.
- Adorkable: Doctor Watson. Martin Freeman's support of Woolly Hat Day.
- Allergic to Routine: As much as he complains about Sherlock's behavior, there's nothing in theory to stop him simply walking away - except, as Mycroft points out, he's nearly as big a danger-junkie himself.
- Anger Born of Worry: He reacts to Sherlock being alive by hitting him multiple times.
- Badass: We know (from a blog comment by Bill Murray, the nurse) that he's the recipient of at least one medal, and Sherlock refers to him as a "war hero" during the taxi drive to Brixton.
- Badass Adorable: Whether it's shooting a guy dead under improbable odds, sassing back criminal masterminds who've kidnapped him or ordering around CIA agents who have a gun to the back of his head, chances are he'll be doing it in a cardigan. Also is strongly implied to be one of those people who start celebrating Christmas in October.
- Badass Bookworm: He's an ex-army doctor.
- Berserk Button: Actually punches out the superintendent of Scotland Yard because he called Sherlock a "weirdo," probably partly so he'll be arrested as well and can stay with Sherlock, but the fact that he chose that way to do it says something.
- Beware the Nice Ones: Though a friendly and laid back man, John is still an ex-soldier. He has no compunction about killing someone if they're putting the people he cares about in immediate danger.
- Big Damn Heroes: In the first episode, certainly.
- Blood Knight: John isn't traumatized by combat so much as he misses it. It's rather downplayed, though, since it's not something John is really proud of.
- Boring Yet Practical: Prefers to use diaries and cameras to record data instead of bizarre memory techniques. Also prefers to call the police using a phone instead of a gun, and would like Mycroft to call him instead of kidnap him.
"You know ... I've got a phone. I mean, very clever and all that. But you could just phone me. On m' phone."
- Brains and Brawn: The Brawn, to Sherlock's Brain.
- The Caretaker: To Sherlock, going so far as to ditch his girlfriend on New Year's Eve just to make sure that Sherlock doesn’t relapse.
- Cloud Cuckoolanders Minder: To the point where he can't hold down a regular job at a hospital or clinic since looking after Sherlock is his full-time job.
- Combat Medic: He is a military doctor, after all.
- The Conscience: To Sherlock, reminding him what is good or at least how to behave in public.
- Curse Cut Short: Almost every episode. Most memorably in "The Great Game", when he opens the fridge in 221B and finds himself staring at a severed head inside.
- As Series 2 goes on, more of John's curses are left in-episode, mostly to demonstrate that the tone has gotten noticeably darker. He has two particularly PG-13 words in Episode 3.
- Deadpan Snarker: Oh so very, very much. He gets the majority of the most delicious lines of snark in the show. From the very first episode:
Mycroft: (About Sherlock, after kidnapping John and bringing him to an abandoned warehouse to simply talk to him) He does so love to be dramatic.
John: Well, thank God you're above all that.
- Distracted by the Sexy: Frequently. At Buckingham Palace, he gets so carried away imagining that he nearly drops the fine china.
- Embarrassing Middle Name: Hamish. He dislikes it so much that Sherlock couldn't goad him into divulging it and only found out by looking at his birth certificate. His middle name becomes a plot point in "The Sign of Three".
- Foil: To Sherlock. Pretty much an obligatory aspect of his character.
- Friendly Sniper / Improbable Aiming Skills: Once shot a guy through two windows, in another building. With a pistol.
- Genre Blind: To an extent, In The Great Game, Sherlock implies that Moriarty is one of the people who reads Watson's blog. This revelation does not stop Watson from maintaining his blog or putting fairly personal information about him and Sherlock on it.
- Giver of Lame Names: Sherlock is consistently unimpressed with the case titles John comes up with.
- Good Is Not Soft: One of the sweetest people in the series, but dauntless in the face of intimidation, capture or imminent death. And not above shooting a sufficiently bad man.
- Handicapped Badass: Even when being affected by the fear drug in "The Hounds of Baskerville", he's still the one to kill the hound.
- Hospital Hottie: Although he's hardly ever in scrubs.
- If It's You, It's Okay: When he tells Irene he's straight, she implies this about him and Sherlock.
- Incompatible Orientation / Married to the Job: He started to catch this from being around Sherlock; none of his girlfriends were able to put up with their adventuring for long. Fortunately, Mary adores Sherlock possibly even more than John does - but it's still unlikely they would have got to the point of marriage had Sherlock not been off the scene for a couple of years.
Jeanette: My friends were wrong, you know. You're a great boyfriend - and Sherlock Holmes is a very lucky man.
- In Harm's Way: When your best friend is a crime solving sociopath, and your wife is a retired professional killer, you really have no excuse.
- Lampshaded in "His Last Vow":
Wiggins: Somebody hit me.
Wiggins: Just some guy. (stares at Watson)
John: Probably just an addict in need of a fix.
Sherlock: Yes, I think in a way, it was.
- Jumped at the Call
Sherlock: You've seen a bit of trouble too, I bet.
John: Of course, yes. Enough for a lifetime, far too much.
Sherlock: ...Want to see some more?
John: Oh, God, yes.
- The Lancer
- Logging On To The Fourth Wall: His blog documenting his and Sherlock's adventures, which is widely read in-universe, can be found here.
- Magnetic Hero: For someone who doesn’t go out of their way to make friends, people seem to quickly take a liking to him. At any rate, he’s a far more likable hero than Sherlock.
- Minored in Asskicking: He's generally known for his equanimity, but if you make him angry, you'll know about it.
- Mistaken for Gay: By Mrs Hudson, Irene Adler, and several of his short-lived girlfriends. At least until he meets Mary.
- Morality Pet: For Sherlock, letting him know whenever he's said or done something "not good".
- Mysterious Middle Initial: In "A Scandal in Belgravia", John H. Watson finally reveals his much-speculated upon middle name: Hamish.
- Which of course lines up with Conan Doyle's canon. For even more speculation, see the pre-season-two debate on DI Lestrade's first name. Conan Doyle only gave an initial (G) which BBC expanded to Greg.
- Nerves of Steel: You'd be amazed by how much he goes through completely terrified and yet keeps his calm no matter what. It's telling that the only time we really see him panic is when Sherlock drugs him with a chemical specifically designed to cause irrational levels of fear, and even then he keeps his head enough to get to the safest place possible and continually report what's going on.
- There's a Freeze-Frame Bonus in The Blind Banker where you can see his resume, which says he's a trauma surgeon. That makes him combat trauma surgeon and people don't get that job without Nerves of Steel on several levels.
- Nice Guy: John Watson is a decent, friendly and moral human being. Just don't piss him off.
- Nothing Exciting Ever Happens Here: A variant; John says "Nothing ever happens to me" to his psychologist's suggestion that he blogs everything that happens to him. And then a couple of scenes later, he meets Sherlock...
- The Not-Love Interest: To Sherlock.
- Not So Above It All: Sherlock's Brutal Honesty has rubbed off on him by the time of Series 3.
- Odd Friendship: With Sherlock. He's a military veteran and Nice Guy, while Sherlock is a high-functioning sociopath (moreso initially).
- Only Friend: To Sherlock, at least for a very long time — and everyone who knows Sherlock is amazed that he's even managed that much. And as Sherlock almost affectionately points out in "The Hounds of Baskerville":
Sherlock: I don’t have friends. I've just got one.
- Only Sane Man: Frequently. Especially when Mycroft and Sherlock are yelling at each other and playing tug-of-war with a bedsheet protecting Sherlock's modesty. In the middle of Buckingham Palace.
- Lampshaded dramatically in "His Last Vow" when Sherlock points out John is attracted to unstable, dangerous people, pointing out himself, Mrs Hudson (who formerly worked for a drug cartel and was an exotic dancer) and his own wife, who was a CIA assassin.
- Pintsized Powerhouse: As seen in "A Scandal in Belgravia", where Sherlock learns it's not a good idea to hit him. John hits back. Hard.
John: (has Sherlock in a headlock) You ought to remember, Sherlock, I was a soldier! I killed people!
Sherlock: You were a doctor!
- Reaction Shot: John's very good at these.
- Red Oni, Blue Oni: The red to Sherlock's blue.
- Screw the Money, I Have Rules!: In the first episode, a mysterious unidentified man offers him a generous stipend just to report Sherlock's movements. He scorns the notion.
- All the more striking because he has recurring money troubles and is far more interested than Sherlock in any honestly earned money that comes their way.
- The Southpaw: Played with. Sherlock identifies him as left-handed in "A Study in Pink", but he consistently shoots and throws punches with his right hand. Possibly cross-dominant.
- Shell-Shocked Veteran: Subverted. He looks like this in the first episode before it's revealed that he's not really haunted by the war, he misses it.
- Stating the Simple Solution: Does this often, either to be refuted by Mycroft or Sherlock or to demonstrate how averse to common sense the latter can be.
- Straight Man: More down to earth than Sherlock is.
- Submissive Badass: May have a higher kill count than Sherlock, but still defers to his intelligence and for the most part, does what Sherlock tells him to.
- Throwing Off the Disability: His limp is psychosomatic, meaning that he can lose it when he forgets about it. In fact, he was actually shot in the shoulder, meaning that his leg is completely fine.
- Undying Loyalty: To Sherlock, shown on several occasions.
- Unfazed Everyman: From who else but himself? He adjusts remarkably quickly to the weirdness that comes with being Sherlock Holmes's sidekick.
John: We've only just met.
Mycroft: And since yesterday you've moved in with him and now you're solving crimes together. Might we expect a happy announcement by the end of the week?
- Vitriolic Best Buds: Him and Sherlock. Hardly a moment passes when they aren’t snarking at each other.
- The Watson: Well, duh. Occasionally Played for Laughs.
"How— oh, never mind".
- Weirdness Magnet: Sherlock implies he's naturally attracted to this, although only unconsciously. Mary agrees.
- What the Hell, Hero?: If Sherlock's getting one of these, chances are good that John will be the one lecturing him, and chances are that he'll be the only one Sherlock will even try to listen to.
- With Friends Like These...: With Sherlock and cranked Up to Eleven in "The Hounds of Baskerville" when Sherlock drugs John and then locks him up in a lab to conduct an experiment that involved scaring the crap out of John, a war veteran who still suffers from nightmares and flashbacks related to the battlefield. It's surprising that John didn’t at least take a swing at him afterwards.
- Wouldn't Hit a Girl: Violence against women seems to bother John. He's notably guilty about Soo Lin's death in "The Blind Banker", becomes noticeably distressed at the crying woman in "The Great Game", and while he had no problem punching the Superintendent of Scotland Yard for calling Sherlock a "weirdo", he ignores Sally Donovan rubbing it in that Sherlock was not to be trusted.
Jeff Hope (Phil Davis)
"It's not chance, Mr. Holmes, it's chess. It's a game of chess."
The killer in "A Study in Pink," who has a sponsor and receives money for his family for every kill.
- Adaptational Villainy: The literary version of him was a Sympathetic Murderer who targeted Asshole Victims for hurting the people he loved. Here he's a Serial Killer whose motivation is much less sympathetic, targets completely innocent people, and is overall much more cold-blooded and cruel.
- Almighty Janitor: His career is rather dull and unimportant, yet he shows himself to be rather intelligent and calculating. He lampshades that someone like him who drives a cab doesn't look all that bright.
- Alone with the Psycho: A variation. Sherlock actually volunteers to be alone with the psycho because aforementioned psycho's promised to tell Sherlock how he's been committing his murders.
- Beneath Notice: As he says, nobody ever thinks about the cabbie. It's like he's just a back of a head. He's able to take advantage of his job to hide in plain sight and be inherently trusted by his victims.
- Cut Lex Luthor a Check: He's very intelligent but working in a low income job, even Sherlock lampshades it:
"Either way you're wasted as a cabbie."
- The Dog Was the Mastermind: There was some subtle foreshadowing about what the character's profession was, but the character himself is never introduced, nor is he ever clearly seen onscreen, until the climax of his episode.
- Driven to Suicide: It looks like this is what he does to his victims. It turns out he's forcing them at gunpoint to choose between two pills, one of which is poisonous.
- Evil Old Folks: His exact age is unknown but he's definitely getting on in years.
- Faux Affably Evil: His tone is certainly friendly and cordial, but the actual content of what he says shows him to be a pretty massive asshole.
- Four Eyes, Zero Soul: His glasses only add to the eerie appearance that he has, although they're more subtle than most cases of this trope.
- Lack of Empathy: He doesn't seem particularly bothered by the fact that he has to kill people in order to secure money for his children. In fact, he seems to like killing and holds most people in contempt.
- Love Makes You Evil: The entire reason behind his killings is because, once he's dead, there'd be no income to provide for his children. Moriarity acts as a "sponsor," paying him loads for each person he kills.
- Manipulative Bastard: He's able to play on Sherlock's constant curiosity and desire for excitement to get Holmes to, not only go alone somewhere with him, but also to play the "game" even when there’s no reason for Sherlock to do so. His game also depends on manipulating people based on what he's deduced about them and what he believes they've deduced about him.
- Never Suicide: The entire plot of his episode really. Though since these are "serial suicides" it's kind of obvious.
- Nice Hat: Sports a nifty flat cap.
- No Name Given: His name is only revealed in the credits, and even then his last name's not given.
- Not Afraid to Die: Whenever he plays his "game" with his victims, there's a good chance he could die too but he just doesn't seem to care. Most likely it's a combination of this trope due to the knowledge he's dying anyway, and confidence that he'll always be able to outsmart his opponents.
- Papa Wolf: The more people he kills, the more money Moriarty gives to his children.
- Poisoned Chalice Switcheroo: His method of killing involves offering his victims a choice between two identical pills, one of them harmless, the other poisoned.
- Serial Killer: He's murdered at least four people and he aims to take a fifth in Sherlock Holmes.
- Smart People Wear Glasses: He may not look it, but he is a genius behind the simplish look.
- Smug Snake: While he is a very clever man, as proven by how he's managed to survive four rounds of his "game," his arrogance, cold-bloodedness and firm belief in the stupidity of everyone around him does little to earn anyone's admiration.
- Starter Villain: He's the villain of the first episode of the series, and, while clever and dangerous enough to arouse Sherlock's interest, he's just the opening act for Moriarity.
- Surrounded by Idiots: At least in his own opinion
" Between you and me sitting here, why can't people think? Don't it make you mad? Why can't people just think?"
- Take a Third Option: If anyone tries to refuse his game, he offers them a bullet from his gun instead. Gun's a fake.
- They Look Just Like Everyone Else: He's a perfectly ordinary-looking man, which aides him in committing his murders.
- Worthy Opponent: While he talks about all his other victims as if they were idiots, he seems to hold Sherlock in some regard. Granted he still thinks Sherlock's not as smart as him, but he's conversational with him and even compliments Sherlock on the ideas Sherlock's put on his website.
- Your Days Are Numbered: He has a life-threatening aneurysm, meaning he lives with the knowledge any breath could be his last.
"Every fairytale needs a good, old-fashioned villain."
Sherlock's biggest fan and his arch-nemesis before Sherlock even knows he exists. He has a vast criminal network that he manages largely as a way to stave off the boredom of a world that poses no challenges for his incredible intellect.
- Always Someone Better: As smart as Sherlock is, Moriarty is just as brilliant and has none of Sherlock's self-imposed constraints.
- Ambiguously Gay: He claims he's not gay, but he delights in flirting with Sherlock regardless. Andrew Scott coming out as of 2013 doesn't help either.
- Arch-Enemy: Sherlock and Moriarty's relationship shows many traits connected with the trope.
- It's Personal between them? Check. Moriarty is obsessed with Sherlock and Sherlock keeps his own version of Moriarty in his Mind Palace.
- The Hero and his Evil Counterpart? Check.
- Worthy Opponent rivalry? Check.
- Not So Different? Check. Moriarty is what Sherlock could become if he'd let his quirks, boredom and anti-social behavior overcome his mind and morality. Lampshaded by their talk on the roof.
- Moriarty is the Big Bad of Seasons 1 and 2, which makes him the most consistent enemy for Sherlock to fight - another trait of the Arch-Enemy which may explain why Moriarty may return in Season 4.
- His Arch-Enemy status is consistent with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's stories.
- Ate His Gun: Puts a gun in his own mouth and blows his brains out in "The Reichenbach Fall", For the Evulz.
- Ax-Crazy: Though more in the way of telling other people to kill people, rather than assaulting them himself.
- Badass Boast: "The man with the key is king, and honey you should see me in a crown."
- "Sorry boys! I'm sooo changeable! It is a weakness with me, but to be fair to myself...it is my ONLY weakness."
- Badass in a Nice Suit: Westwood, to be precise.
- The Bad Guy Wins: Destroys Sherlock's reputation in "The Reichenbach Fall", forcing Sherlock to fake his own death for a full 2 years.
- Beware the Silly Ones: Go ahead, laugh at him. See what painful punishment he comes up with.
- Big Bad: Every major antagonist in Series 1 and 2 either answered to or was advised by him. He's supposedly back from the dead to return as the Big Bad for Series 4.
- Boring Insult: Invoked. According to him, the most heinous insult to someone like him or Sherlock is to be "boring".
Moriarty: I'm disappointed, I'm disappointed in you, ordinary Sherlock.
- Break Them by Talking: Moriarty has developed this to an art form.
- Camp Straight: Keeps up his Camp persona after revealing his identity to Sherlock. Also delights in flirting with him, calling him "sexy" and "honey". As always, it's hard to tell what really motivates him.
- Card-Carrying Villain: Is openly proud of being reprehensibly evil. He even gave Sherlock his card.
- The Chessmaster: In Series One, he's behind every case Sherlock investigates. In Series Two about the only one he wasn't involved in was an actual accident.
- Consummate Liar: To the point where he can claim to be the former host of a children's TV show, and have an astounding amount of evidence to back it up.
- Dangerously Genre Savvy:
- As "Scandal" shows, if it comes down to a choice between baiting Sherlock Holmes and his actual job, he'll pick the job. After all, crime is a heavily trust-based business.
- In "The Reichenbach Fall", he plays — and wins — Gambit Roulette with both Holmes brothers and forces Sherlock to fake his own suicide or risk John, Lestrade, and Mrs. Hudson's deaths. Although in Season 3, Sherlock claims he and Mycroft were playing Moriarty all along.
- Deadpan Snarker: When he's not giggling.
- Death Seeker: Jim's excruciating boredom with the world leads him to try get Sherlock to kill them both at the end of series 1, simply because it'd be fun.
- Diabolical Mastermind: He's a "consulting criminal" behind dozens of illegal schemes.
- Dies Wide Open: Complete with a seriously creepy smile after having supposedly blown his brains out, though his return at the end of "His Last Vow" has thrown the "Dies" part into question.
- Do Not Adjust Your Set: Takes control of every TV set in Britain for his return at the end of "His Last Vow".
- Driven to Suicide: Zig-zagged. Looks suicidal when he realizes that in destroying Sherlock, he's actually won, and now has nobody who will pose a challenge to him anymore. Then changes his mind and says he'll manage. Unfortunately Sherlock then convinces him that as long as Sherlock has Jim alive, Sherlock can also stop Jim's plan. Moriarty promptly shoots himself in the head to make sure Sherlock can't beat him.
- Possibly subverted at the end of "His Last Vow".
- Evil Counterpart: To Sherlock. In this version, he lists his occupation as "Consulting Criminal", and his Insufferable Genius tendencies are played up just as much as Sherlock's. His goal, as it turns out, is to find a perfect counterpart — someone who is him. Sherlock indulges him, in the end, and admits as much. He may well have faked his own suicide, to boot.
- Expy: Aspects of Jim's personality are similar to that of Moriarty expy Professor Ratigan.
- Faux Affably Evil: Makes him even creepier.
- Foe Romance Subtext: Invokes it with Sherlock, every chance he gets.
- Foe Yay Shipping: In-universe, no less, judging by one of the members of Sherlock's fanclub who puts forward the theory that Sherlock and Moriarty faked their deaths to run off into the sunset together!
- For the Evulz: Has no real reason behind his cruel Evil Plan except that he is a psychopath and he "got bored". Remarkably like our hero, in fact.
Sherlock: People have died!
Moriarty: That's what people DO!
- Giggling Villain: His laughter is truly creepy.
- Go Out with a Smile: Grins right before shooting himself in the head in "Reichenbach Fall".
- Karma Houdini: He's Driven to Suicide, but this is only done as a way to ensure Sherlock can't wriggle out of his Evil Plan.
- Knight of Cerebus: The series was never the most lighthearted, but there was plenty of humour. When Moriarty enters as an indirect antagonist, the death toll escalates and the show gets darker. When he appears in person, things get seriously disturbing.
- Large Ham: His high-pitched voice and psychopathic mannerisms make him constantly appear on the edge of psychotic madness. He also changes his tone of voice and his mannerisms about every other line, rapidly going through affected personas and acting styles just to mock Sherlock. He's always hammy, though.
- The Mad Hatter: He's out of his damn mind and proud of it.
- Man of Wealth and Taste
Jim: (Straightens suit) Westwood!
- Manipulative Bastard: He is really good at this.
- Mood-Swinger: Holy shit. He goes from calm and collected to practically screaming in about two sentences. He even acknowledges it.
Jim: Sorry boys! I'm sooo changeable!
- My Death Is Only The Beginning: "His Last Vow" ends with his image appearing on every screen in the United Kingdom, suggesting he had plans in place even in the event of his death, if he even died at all.
- Not So Different: To Sherlock, being basically a true sociopath. It means that people start assuming Sherlock made him very easily.
- Obfuscating Stupidity: Poses as Jim from IT, a seemingly dumb and weak-minded guy.
- Posthumous Character: In Series 3, he appears as a mental vision in Sherlock's mind, tormenting him further. He also appears in a few flashbacks or Imagine Spot moments.
- Post Mortem Comeback: Maybe. He appears at the end of "His Last Vow" via mass broadcast around the UK, but it's unclear if he's dead for real or not.
- Psycho for Hire: He acquired his wealth and connections by working as a "consulting criminal". Once Sherlock gets his attention, he's happy to cut loose several clients as part of the game.
Irene "The Woman" Adler (Lara Pulver)
"Do you know the problem with a disguise, Mr Holmes? However hard you try, it's always a self-portrait."
Played By: Lara PulverThe
Woman, perhaps the only person to ever consistently flummox Sherlock Holmes. She's a dominatrix who first enters the story due to blackmailing the royal family.
- Adaptational Badass: In the original stories, Irene Adler's impressive feat was simply seeing through Holmes' ruse, pulling one in turn, and then having the good sense to skip town while she has the chance. Here, she manages to con him into decoding top-secret, vital information which she then passes along to Moriarty, ruining Mycroft's day. It takes a last-second epiphany for Sherlock to recover himself and make up for his own royal screwup.
- Adaptational Villainy: In the original short-story, Irene just wanted to be left alone.
- Badass Boast: "This is how I want you to remember me...the woman who beat you."
- Big Bad Wannabe: For all of Irene’s cleverness, it’s still clear that she wouldn’t have gotten away with as much without Moriarty’s assistance. This is made more evident after she loses his support, and is captured and almost put to death.
- Bitch in Sheep's Clothing: She may not have been a sweetheart when she was introduced but by the time the episode ends, it’s revealed that she’s complicit in terrorist plots and Moriarty's willing accomplice.
- Bi the Way: She's been in relationships with both men and women prior to meeting Sherlock.
- Brains and Bondage: A dominatrix who caters to the highest echelons of society. One of very few people to get several over on Sherlock Holmes.
- Brainy Brunette: Brown hair and nearly as smart as Sherlock.
- Broken Bird: She's very clever, but also clearly rather damaged; Irene routinely drugs her 'friends', keeps blackmail material on her phone just in case she needs it and her career is sex- it's not fun, it's a job.
- The Cameo: Irene very briefly appears in Sherlock's mind palace in "The Sign of Three", suggesting that Sherlock still thinks about her sometimes. She's completely naked, naturally.
- Catchphrase: She mentions a couple of times she knows somebody, then amends, "Well, I know what he/she likes."
- The Chessmaster: Outplays both Holmes brothers, at one point.
- Dark Action Girl: She can handle herself in a scrap, as seen when she and Sherlock are ambushed in her drawing room, she easily disarms and pistol-whips her attacker.
- Dominatrix: Mycroft specifically describes her as such.
- Easily Forgiven: She was perfectly willing to extort the British government for millions, enlist the skills of a psychopath, aid in a terrorist plot, and manipulate and betray Sherlock, yet she still gets saved by Sherlock in the end and lives without any apparent consequences or moral development.
- Excessive Evil Eye Shadow: Prior to meeting Sherlock, she is seen liberally applying copious pearlescent eye-shadow and blood-red lipstick.
- Faking the Dead: Twice.
- Femme Fatale: A classic example.
- Fetish Fuel Station Attendant: In-universe. It comes with the job.
- Fun with Subtitles: When Sherlock does his trademark scan, a subtitle floating beside the clue says what he's noticed. When he first meets Irene, all his scans get is "???????".
- Jerk with a Heart of Jerk: Let's be honest, whether she has feelings for Sherlock or not, it still doesn't stop her from treating him terribly or excuse her for working with Moriarty. She's made it pretty clear all through that episode that her self-interest comes before anything else.
- Karma Houdini: For all the havoc and damage she caused, she still gets to survive in the end.
- Laser-Guided Karma: She does everything she can to exploit Sherlock’s naivete when it comes to sex and intimacy but in the end her own feelings for him prove to be her downfall. Verges on Dramatic Irony.
- Mata Hari: One of her many tricks for stealing blackmail material.
- Ms. Fanservice: Struts into the drawing room to greet Sherlock stark naked.
- Naked on Arrival: Pulls this on Sherlock to defeat his trademark scan. Can't tell anything from a person's clothes if they're not wearing any, right?
- No Sell: When first meeting Adler, Sherlock's scan can only come up with "??????"
- Not Even Bothering with the Accent: Admittedly, she might not be from New Jersey in this version, but the fact Pulver uses her normal accent is a notable departure from past portrayals of the character.
- Romantic Two-Girl Friendship: With Kate, her lover/assistant.
- Show Some Leg: Calculates that showing some leg would simply be analyzed for what it is by Sherlock. So she takes it Up to Eleven.
- Silk Hiding Steel: Elegant. Ruthless.
- Single-Target Sexuality: Caters to both male and female clients, claims to self-identify as being gay, yet the only man (or indeed anyone) she actually shows any serious interest seems to be Sherlock. Her chosen password is particularly telling.
I Am SHER Locked
- Troll: She loves to troll Sherlock, even leaving her Immodest Orgasm as his ringtone.
- Unusual Euphemism: At one point, her occupation is described as "recreational scolding".
- The Vamp: A dangerous, beautiful woman who uses sex as a tool to get what she wants.
- Villainesses Want Heroes: Very much taken with Sherlock.
- Woman Of Wealth And Taste: The phone everybody was fighting for in "A Scandal in Belgravia" was a Vertu Constellation Quest smart phone, with a price tag of £17,300. There was more than one reason she was fighting tooth and nail to get it back.
- Whip It Good: Introduced holding a riding crop, which features extensively in her website's photos, and uses it for reasons very different from Sherlock's.
Charles Augustus Magnussen
Charles Augustus Magnussen
"Knowing is owning."
Played By: Lars Mikkelsen
A media mogul who owns the majority of Western civilization through very careful application of blackmail.
- Achilles' Heel: Magnussen stores all the information about his victims not on a computer, which would be hackable, but in hard copy form in a vast underground vault underneath his high-security home. Only he has access to it, and he doesn't let anybody in. ...Except that he doesn't. There is no such vault. He just remembers it all. As a result, Sherlock is able to eliminate Magnussen as a threat by shooting him in the head.
- Adaptational Badass: His literary counterpart was content blackmailing England's nobility and gentry, specifically ladies, who were either married or engaged. Here he's blackmailing world governments, and instead of keeping all of his information in a locked safe, he keeps it all in his own head.
- Adaptation Name Change: From Milverton to Magnussen.
- Always Someone Better: Sherlock's hatred of him is exacerbated by the fact that Magnussen is genuinely smart enough to outwit him.
- Asshole Victim: He's so cruel and unlikable, you can't help but cheer Sherlock on when he shoots Magnussen in the head.
- Big Bad: He's the one for Series 3.
- Blackmail: Specializes in extortion.
Sherlock: ...he attacks people who are different and preys on their secrets!
- Boom, Headshot: Sherlock shoots him in the head after he makes it clear that if he dies, his information goes with him.
- The Bully: What he basically is, and the specific reason Sherlock hates him as he picks on people for being different, hinting at a bit of bullying in Sherlock's own past.
- Bullying a Dragon: Seriously, revealing that there are no physical Appledore vaults, that all the information is in his head, and there are no tangible copies of data or backups or contingencies that can be disseminated in the event of his death to cause chaos, and then being utterly unrepentant and physically humiliating the people who hate him and want to stop him. Did Magnussen really not consider someone would be desperate or stupid or self-sacrificing enough to simply kill him where he stood? Because that is the one thing that will easily and definitively eliminate the threat of his blackmail scheme by leaving all that sensitive information completely dead inside his equally dead brain.
- Card-Carrying Villain: To the people he's blackmailing. In public, he presents himself as a simple businessman. Defied at the end, though — he mocks Sherlock and John precisely for treating him like some kind of villain. He seems to honestly believe that he isn't a villain due to some Insane Troll Logic like, for instance, the fact that he technically hasn't killed anyone (even though he has ruined several lives and puts others in mortal danger, both for his own amusement).
- The Chessmaster: His ultimate goal in Series 3 is to get leverage on Mycroft to blackmail and control him. He achieves this by blackmailing Mary, then manipulating Sherlock and John when they react as he expects they will, relying on a series of "pressure points" to control the involved parties. Once Sherlock implicated himself in high treason by trying to sell him Mycroft's laptop full of government information, Magnussen would have the leverage he needs to get to Mycroft.
- Composite Character: Largely based on Charles Augustus Milverton, from the short story of the same title. However, the larger scale of his activities, the "Napoleon" nickname, his appearance and personality, and the events in his brief meetings with Sherlock, make him a more faithful depiction of Moriarty as he originally appeared in the Conan Doyle stories than the Sherlock Jim Moriarty is.
- Corrupt Corporate Executive: In addition to his blackmailing activities, he has no problem printing false information in his papers.
- Dangerously Genre Savvy:
- He keeps all his information in an underground vault in hard copy, because computers are hackable. Taken further when we find out there is no vault. He's able to memorize everything, by having his own version of Sherlock's mind palace. Further, while he has no physical evidence of anything he knows, the people he blackmails don't know that. And besides, he's a media mogul - his newspapers don't need proof to print the stories.
- Deadpan Snarker:
John: I don't understand.
Magnussen: You should put that on a t-shirt.
John: I still don't understand.
Magnussen: And there's the back of the t-shirt.
- Dirty Coward: No problem with begging for his life.
- Dirty Old Man: He can go anywhere from small, simple actions and words that will leave your skin crawling, to licking a woman's face.
- Does This Remind You of Anything?: His interactions with his victims strongly resemble those of a rapist (and in Britain, forcibly licking someone like that counts as sexual assault).
- The Dreaded: Sherlock mentions that Magnussen is the most dangerous threat he's faced up to that point and nobody's ever made his stomach turn quite like Magnussen.
- Evil Counterpart: Another one to Sherlock. Like Sherlock, he's a genius who stores vast amounts of information in his head via the Mind Palace technique. This is the secret of his serial blackmailing. He doesn't need to store the information corporeally or digitally. He's basically Sherlock's logical side, if taken to a cold, logical extreme.
- Like Sherlock, Magnussen specializes in uncovering secrets and solving mysteries, but while Sherlock uses it to put evil away and better society, Magnussen uses it as power to assert his dominance over people and countries.
- He is arguably more the evil counterpart of Mycroft. Both have extensive influence over governments, both have direct yet ethically-questionable access to leaders of Britain, both are more chessmasters than trickster, and both are strongly implied to actually be smarter than Sherlock (and both definitely like reminding him of it). It's strongly implied that Magnussen has clashed with Mycroft before and has found a way to blackmail or control him which may be threats against Sherlock and at one point Sherlock tries and fails to bribe him with Mycroft's laptop, because Magnussen craves the information on it. In the original stories Sherlock muses that if Mycroft had the inclination he could easily become the most successful criminal the world had ever seen- Magnussen could be read as an attempt to see if that is true.
- Evil Cannot Comprehend Good: For all the ways that he managed to outwit Sherlock and take advantage of the fact that John is Sherlock's pressure point, he was apparently unaware of how far Sherlock would go to protect John.
- Also, for all the truly vile and horrible things he does every single day, he scoffs and laughs at the idea that he is actually the bad guy.
- Evil Gloating: Magnussen likes to do this. And in classic villain fashion, this ultimately leads to his downfall: When he thinks that he has beat Sherlock Holmes, he tells him the reason why - this way exposing his own biggest weakness. Namely that the police can't confiscate his blackmail vault because it only exists in his head. Thus the vault will simply cease to exist and stop causing any more trouble with Magnussen's death.
- Evil Is Petty: Mainly because of all the information he has on people, he fully believes he can do whatever to whomever he wants. In fact this seems to be his main motivation.
- Faux Affably Evil: He rarely gets angry, and almost always speaks with the same polite tone of voice. It makes him even creepier and even more disgusting.
- Four Eyes, Zero Soul: A criminal mastermind with a pair of rimless glasses.
- For the Evulz: He's a wealthy newspaper magnate, so he blackmails people because he enjoys the power it gives him, not for the money.
- Hypocrite: He loves threatening people with ruination and does so with the utmost apathy and grace, but as soon as his neck's on the line, he breaks down into a quivering, pleading mess.
- Icy Blue Eyes: Sherlock compares his eyes to the "dead eyed" gaze of a shark.
- Idiot Ball: Magnussen makes two mistakes:
- He decides to blackmail Mary, a recently retired assassin. He presumably knows everything about her, and takes joy in amusing himself with the nature of her assassinations. Except this also means she has no moral or practical issue in just sneaking into his office and shooting him in the hea as soon as she could fit it in her schedule. Which she was seconds away from doing if not for Sherlock and Watson making an appearance and forcing her to improvise to avoid them being suspected in Magnusson's murder.
- The reveal that the Appledore blackmail vault is entirely in Magnusson's head, and he controls no records other than what he remembers, makes him pretty impotent. Perhaps the only reason he hasn't been killed before the episode is that his targets think that Magnusson has some sort of failsafe in case he's killed, such as physical records that would be disseminated if he dies under suspicious circumstances. Magnusson likes the idea of showing up Sherlock by getting the police to search his home and find nothing incriminating. However, he seems ignorant of the fact that this also will reveal to lots of current and future unhappy blackmail victims that it might be better to just kill him instead of pay him. The reveal is intended to demonstrate Magnusson defeating Sherlock's plan to expose him, but it also suggests Magnusson is far and wide the stupidest criminal Sherlock has ever faced, as even after Mary attempting to kill him, he seems unaware that any of his victims might attempt to kill him, and therefore makes no effort to use his extensive blackmail library to protect himself.
- Irony: Sherlock shoots Magnussen in his both his literal and metaphorical computer, (where he stored all his oh so valuable blackmail information) which is directly caused by two separate instances of the dog biting back.
- Kick the Dog: To all of his onscreen victims.
- Kick the Son of a Bitch: What two of his onscreen victims do back.
- Knight of Cerebus: For Series 3. At first, it appeared "The Empty Hearse" would be more lighthearted and funny... then John Watson is nearly burned to death. From there, he only gets worse.
- Lean and Mean: Although his slender build doesn't stand out a whole lot against the likes of Sherlock and Mycroft, Lars Mikkelsen's sharp, angular features◊ help to create the effect.
- No Celebrities Were Harmed: Of Rupert Murdoch. Both are wealthy, powerful foreigners who run controversial news organizations.
- Old Media Are Evil: He's an international newspaper magnate who blackmails people as a sideline.
- Out-Gambitted: For all of his planning and manipulation, he'd never anticipated Sherlock shooting him in the head.
- Psychopathic Manchild: He is arguably the most powerful man in the world, but he acts like a Spoiled Brat or Schoolyard Bully All Grown Up, since he uses said power mainly to bully and humiliate people For the Evulz.
- Sadist: Absolutely revels in the power his information, influence and public standing gives him over other people- to the point of forcefully licking the arm and face of a government minister or pissing in Sherlock's fireplace, just because he can.
- Screw the Rules, I Have Connections!: Even though he's seen blackmailing MP's (and it's implied the Prime Minister) Mycroft wants him left alone for reasons that are unclear.
- Sherlock accuses Mycroft of also being blackmailed by Magnussen. It's implied that he actually got to Mycroft by threatening to use his papers to go after Sherlock.
- Sharp-Dressed Man: Always dresses in suits.
- Shadow Archetype: If Moriarty is the more chaotic, wild counterpart to Sherlock, Magnussen is Sherlock to his absolute coldest depths.
- He is also a more smug, sadistic, and unprincipled version of Mycroft, what the latter could be if he stopped caring about the defence of the realm and instead decided to rub its face in the mud.
- Smug Snake: He considers John and Mrs. Hudson to be "unimportant".
- He tends to underestimate the people he blackmails, some like Lady Smallwood and Mary refuse to put up with it, and try to bring him down.
- All his information is memorized, so there's no hard copy of it. But he tells this all to Sherlock, thinking he got one up on him, which is a rare but severe miscalculation on his part. Sherlock has no problem putting a bullet in his brain when he threatens John and Mary's happiness.
- Soft-Spoken Sadist: Is always soft spoken, even when pleading for his life. Also, torments people he doesn't need to just because he enjoys it.
- Stat-O-Vision: His glasses show information useful for blackmail on anyone he looks at including their porn preference and "pressure points." It turns out that his glasses are completely ordinary and the information he sees is just his "mind palace." It still fits this trope, though.
- Take That / Shout-Out : To another newspaper executive Rupert Murdoch (leading to more accusations of BBC bias from the Daily Mail.)
- Thou Shall Not Kill: Villainous version, and an extremely borderline case. He has no problem arranging for John to be put in a bonfire just to see how Sherlock would react...but says he had a man on-site who would have saved him had Sherlock not made it in time, so it doesn't really count. His final fate is to be on the receiving end of Sherlock defying this trope. Also, at least one of his blackmail victims committed suicide after he threatened them, and he doesn't give a damn.
- Ungrateful Bastard: Mycroft has him under protection, yet Magnussen has no problem stealing data from British Intelligence if it gives him more power. But he's Genre Savvy enough to not get caught doing it.
- White Void Room: His "vault", which helps him in accessing his mind palace.
Detective Inspector Greg Lestrade
""Well, don't let it get to you, I always feel like screaming when you walk into a room. In fact, so do most people."
Played By: Rupert Graves
The Chief Inspector of Scotland Yard, and one of Sherlock's few friends. He is well aware that Sherlock is a stuck-up prick, but unlike the rest of the force, is also willing to admit that he genuinely is better at solving crimes than the police.
- Badass Longcoat: The few times he is badass a long black overcoat is usually involved.
- Big Good: Moriarty of all people, even compares him to King Arthur.
- Busman's Holiday: How he becomes involved in "Hounds".
- Butt Monkey: Is apparently one to the rest of the police force, over his support of the "fraud" detective Sherlock Holmes.
- Deadpan Snarker: Not as often as Sherlock and John, but he definitely gets some good one-liners in.
- Demoted to Extra: In Series 3, the main focus is how John and Mary's marriage has changed they dynamic of the show. Lestrade's still in all the episodes but he doesn't do that much plotwise.
- Distracted by the Sexy: Molly's Christmas dress in "Scandal" causes Lestrade to need to pick his jaw back up off the floor.◊
- Donut Mess with a Cop: When Sally startles Lestrade in his office at the beginning of "Reichenbach", it's to find him with his feet up on his desk, classily stuffing his face with a doughnut and talking with his mouth full.
- Friend on the Force: To Sherlock. The only one. The rest of Scotland Yard is nearly almost comprised of jealous, arrogant, bullying douchebags who would happily do anything to incriminate Holmes if needed.
- Give Me Back My Wallet: He is one of the many people Sherlock steals from to break in somewhere.
- Hero of Another Story: Cast by Moffat and Gatiss specifically because Rupert Graves gave off this trope when he played the role.
- Inspector Lestrade: Played with. The creators comment that Sherlock Holmes is not stupid enough to accept being Surrounded by Idiots, so they present the diligent, methodical Determinator Lestrade of the later Holmes stories, not the Comic Relief Lestrade of A Study in Scarlet. In this series he's Sherlock's Friend on the Force - and the only member of the Yard who doesn't turn on him during the smear job of 'The Reichenbach Fall.'
- Manipulative Bastard: He'll resort to it. "What, this? This is a drugs bust."
- Must Have Nicotine: Shows off his own patch to Sherlock.
- Nice Guy: Very easy to get along with. There's a reason he's the only officer on the force whom Sherlock likes.
- No Name Given: Only has a first initial of "G" , until "The Hounds of Baskerville", when Sherlock mocks him for going undercover to spy on him with a lame alias of "Greg".
: That's his name
: Is it? Lestrade
: Yes! If you ever bothered
to find out!
- Only Sane Employee: The only cop in Scotland Yard willing to put up with Sherlock, because he gets results.
- And the only cop who doesn't immediately jump to the conclusion that Sherlock is a fraud in "The Reichenbach Fall".
- Only Sane Man: Frequently, especially when Sherlock's around.
- Reasonable Authority Figure: Pretty much the only police officer willing to lend Sherlock a hand when not forced to.
- Silver Fox: Gray-haired and quite handsome
- Team Dad: Most notably in Many Happy Returns where he checks in on both Anderson and John with genuine concern. Also often talks to Sherlock like a stern father or authority figure.
- Him being the only person (that we see) to hug Sherlock upon his return reinforces this.
- Undying Loyalty: In "The Sign of Three", leaves an important case that has both plagued and infuriated him for over a year, leaving someone else to get the credit for the bust, simply because Sherlock texted him saying that he needed his help urgently because he was in trouble. Lestrade immediately calls for backup and storms over there... only to find that Sherlock was having trouble writing his best man speech.
- Vitriolic Best Buds: Despite his loyalty to Sherlock, he takes great pleasure in Sherlock's misery - using every opportunity to get an embarrassing photo and refusing to keep his voice down when John and Sherlock are hung over.
Sgt. Sally Donovan
Detective Sergeant Sally Donovan (Vinette Robinson)
"You're still hanging round him? You should get yourself a hobby. Stamps, maybe. Model trains? Safer."
One of the more prominent police officers, Donovan hates Sherlock with a sort of cold apathy. As far as she's concerned, he's going to turn bad eventually, and she is well-prepared for that.
- Bullying a Dragon: Sherlock exposes her affair with Anderson at a crime scene just by taking a whiff of her. Doesn't stop her from calling him 'freak' or encouraging John to leave him.
- By-the-Book Cop: Does not approve of Sherlock's consulting. To her, he's always "Freak".
- Deadpan Snarker: Has her moments.
- The Dog Bites Back: It doesn't pay to have enemies in the police force, Sherlock, no matter how lowly they seem.
- Fair Cop: Unless Sherlock is involved.
- Green-Eyed Monster: She appears more than a little resentful of Sherlock's abilities, especially when the media start painting him a hero.
- Jerkass: Towards Sherlock. Sally rationalises her antagonism towards him as a being a result of Sherlock enjoying his work a little too much.
- The Lancer: To Lestrade.
- The Stoic: Unlike Anderson, she doesn't seem to have any guilt over her role in Sherlock's death.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Jim Moriarty.
- Your Cheating Heart: Sleeping with Anderson, who's married.
Philip Anderson (Jonathan Aris)
"Never mind that, we found the case! According to someone, the murderer has the case, and we found it in the hands of our favourite psychopath."
Another prominent police officer, Anderson is much louder about his hate of Sherlock than Donovan and others. Sherlock responds by constantly belittling him and making him look like a fool (not that he needs much help).
- The Atoner: In "Many Happy Returns", he's come to regret the part he played in Sherlock's downfall, and is obessed with proving Sherlock's still alive to the point where he lost his job because of it.
Anderson: I believe in Sherlock Holmes!
Lestrade: Yeah, well, that's not gonna bring him back, is it?
- Bad Cop/Incompetent Cop: It's unclear if he's actually good at his job or not, since all we hear is Sherlock trashing him. In the original pilot, Lestrade seems to treat him better.
- Implied that he's not completely incompetent, considering Sherlock asks for him specifically in "Reichenbach" (despite reluctance in "A Study in Pink", which he claimed was because "Anderson won't work with me").
- Beard of Sorrow: Has one in the minisode "Many Happy Returns" and in Season 3, due to guilt over the part he played in Sherlock's downfall.
- Bullying a Dragon: Sherlock only has to sniff him to figure out he's having an affair with DS Donovan.
- Butt Monkey: Sherlock can't stand him, and as such, treats him horribly.
"Anderson, don't talk out loud, you lower the IQ of the entire street."
- Cassandra Truth: In "Many Happy Returns," he has tracked Sherlock's movement and come to the conclusion that he is alive and coming back. No one believes him (at least, Lestrade doesn't.)
- Gratuitous German: Apparently knows enough to tell Lestrade and Sherlock that "Rache" is German for revenge.
- Lab Rat: An in-the-field version, as he's a crime scene tech.
- Last Name Basis: It wasn't until Series 3 that we learned his first name.
- My God, What Have I Done?: Implied to have one of these between Series 2 and "Many Happy Returns", over the role he played in Sherlock's downfall. Despite how much he hated him, Sherlock's death has weighed heavily on his conscience.
- "No. Just... No" Reaction: His reaction to a Yaoi Fangirl in his Sherlock fanclub suggesting that Moriarty and Sherlock faked their deaths in order so they could run off into the sunset together.
- Sanity Slippage: Guilt for his part in Sherlock's death apparently lead him to become obsessed with the case, lose his job and concoct increasingly bizarre theories for how Sherlock is alive and how he faked his death. He's right of course, but no-one believes him. Even when Sherlock tells him how he supposedly did it, he immediately begins questioning the explanation and appears to go a little mad from the revelation. He does however get better, and get his old job back.
- Shipper on Deck: Sherlock/Molly, apparently. His theory on Sherlock's survival ends with Sherlock crashing through a window at Bart's and kissing Molly.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Moriarty.
- Your Cheating Heart: Gets his affair with Donovan exposed at a crime scene by Sherlock.
Detective Inspector Dimmock (Paul Chequer)
A one-episode character who fills Lestrade's role in "The Blind Banker."
"All lives end. All hearts are broken. Caring is not an advantage, Sherlock."
Sherlock's older brother, who claims to be a minor government functionary. Sherlock, on the other hand, claims that he is
the British government, and considering the number of pies Mycroft has his fingers in, he seems to be right.
- Aloof Big Brother: To Sherlock.
- Always Someone Better: True to the books, he is smarter than Sherlock. In "The Empty Hearse," they reflect on how they thought Sherlock was stupid because, as children, they had no one to compare him to but Mycroft.
- Ambiguously Gay: If you take Sherlock's "queen" joke at face value. He does have a few of the traits.
John Watson:(wondering what they're doing in Buckingham Palace) Here to see the Queen?
(Mycroft walks in)
Sherlock Holmes: Oh, apparently yes.
(Sherlock and John giggle like children)
- Though this could be more towards the statement of Mycroft being the government.
- Ascended Extra: Originally just a cameo, Mycroft is central to most of the happenings of Series 2.
- Aww, Look! They Really Do Love Each Other: Sherlock is his 'pressure point.'
Mycroft: Also, your loss would break my heart.
Sherlock: What the hell am I supposed to say to that?!
- Badass Bookworm: Even smarter than Sherlock, as he himself acknowledges.
- Badass Bureaucrat: Apparently he is the British government.
- Big Brother Bully: Probably unintentional, but still present. Sherlock thought he was 'the stupid one' and Mycroft apparently did too, Mycroft in Sherlock's mind palace sits above him and judges him in the courtroom, and his stories to Sherlock as a child were about unworthy children being plucked from the earth, of which Sherlock was one. In Sherlock's own words, "He was a rubbish big brother."
- Big Brother Instinct: In a rare tie in with Big Brother Is Watching. Apparently, when you're a shadowy government official, keeping tabs on your little brother involves kidnapping and bribery.
- Big Brother Is Watching: Quite literally, in fact. Mycroft's command of seemingly every surveillance camera in London under the vague name of the "government".
- Big Brother Mentor: Sherlock pictures him in his Mind Palace when he needs help.
- Break the Haughty: Gets this twice throughout the series, due to his arrogance: Driving Sherlock towards Irene results in an anti-terrorist plot being compromised in "A Scandal in Belgravia. In "His Last Vow" he refuses to deal with Magnussen. Also he rather carelessly leaves his laptop out in the open at his parents home, which Sherlock takes in an attempt to bargain with Magnussen. When the deal goes sour, Sherlock ends up killing Magnussen.
- Brilliant but Lazy: Typical for the character, he can even outdo Sherlock when it comes to deductions, but he dislikes legwork.
- Well-Intentioned Extremist: Will do just about anything in the interests of British national security (as well as keeping his little brother safe), up to and including assassinations.
- Averted with Magnussen. Despite how dangerous a threat he is to the British Government, he's content to let him continue his activities even as he's blackmailing MP's, one of who is his own superior.
Played By: Lisa McAllister
Mycroft's personal assistant, almost always seen texting on her phone.
- Commuting on a Bus: Shows up in "A Study in Pink", then doesn't come back until "The Empty Hearse".
- Drop-In Character: Has only a couple lines in the first episode of Season 1 and has an even shorter appearance in the first episode of Season 3 when she hands Sherlock his trademark coat.
- Girl Friday: To Mycroft.
- No Name Given: Her name is never given; she introduces herself to John in "A Study in Pink" as "Anthea", but cheerfully admits that it isn't her real name.
- Phoneaholic Teenager: Though not a teenager, she is almost always seen texting.
- Sexy Secretary: Mycroft's.
- Shout-Out: A bit of an obscure one: this isn't the first show based on Sherlock Holmes to feature a government employee whose fake name is Anthea. Jonathan Creek originated it.
Played By: Lindsay Duncan
A member of the British Parliament who is being blackmailed by Magnussen (just like everyone else). Unlike everyone else, she figures out a way to fight back—by calling Sherlock Holmes.
- Blue Blood: She's an MP who presumably sits in the House of Lords.
- The Chains of Commanding: She's not particurarly thrilled to sign the order for Sherlock's exile, but does so anyway in the interests of "justice."
- Genre Savvy: When Magnussen threatens her with blackmail of her husband to stop a government investigation against him, her solution is to go to Sherlock.
- Wrong Genre Savvy: Sherlock fails, and a freezeframe bonus reveals Lord Smallwood committed SUICIDE.
- Iron Lady: Absolutely refuses to let Magnussen walk over her or her husband.
"You do not own me!"
- MI6: It's implied one of her duties as an MP is to look oversee British Intelligence, meaning she is technically Mycroft's superior.
- The Stoic: Keeps her cool, during her episode with Magnussen.
- Ungrateful Bitch: Signs an order for Sherlock to be sent on suicide mission for MI6, after he kills Magnussen, on Mycroft's behest. Although she notes it is "hardly merciful".
- Unwitting Instigator of Doom: Asking Sherlock to bring down Magnussen sets off a chain of events that lead to Magnussen being murdered by Sherlock, and nearly exiled stopped only by Moriarty's "resurrection".
Played By: David Nellist
An old friend of John's, who is also one of the only people who can stand Sherlock for any length of time. He's the one who sets them up as flatmates.
"I know what that means, looking sad when you think no-one can see you."
Played By: Louise Brealey
A mortician in love with Sherlock, she is an important ally of his, often helping him do odd studies on corpses and letting him use the lab for experiments he can't fit into his flat.
- Adorkable: She just can't help being this.
- All Love Is Unrequited: Is hopelessly in love with Sherlock. In The Empty Hearse she claims to be over him and has a fiancé, but her fiancé turns out to look a lot like Sherlock even to the point of dressing like him. In The Sign of Three she spends most of the wedding looking at Sherlock instead of her boyfriend or John and Mary. The engagement has ended by His Last Vow a month later.
- Anger Born of Worry: Actually slaps Sherlock three times for failing a drug test, then chews him out how he could be so careless and to apologize to his friends.
- Armor-Piercing Slap: Gives Sherlock a doozy when she finds out he's fallen off the wagon. John asks her if Sherlock's clean, Molly merely walks in front of Sherlock, braces herself, and wham... wham... wham!
- Ascended Extra: Originally a minor character in Series One, she became a major character in the following series.
- Beneath Suspicion: It turns out that Sherlock asked her to help him fake his death, knowing that Moriarty wouldn't be keeping an eye or bothering to target her, since he'd dismiss her as being not important enough for Sherlock to care about.
- Berserk Button: In "The Sign of Three", after her fiance Tom jokes that Sherlock is drunk during his awkward speech, she stabs him in the hand with a (plastic) fork.
- She slaps Sherlock across the face when he betrays his friends' trust by falling off the wagon.
- Beware the Nice Ones: Between stabbing her ex-fiance with a fork and slapping Sherlock three times for failing a drug test, Molly Hooper is not to be messed with.
- Butt Monkey: Verging on Chew Toy at times, with the way Sherlock treats her.
- Canon Foreigner: According to Word of God, she was just written in as a one-off character in "A Study in Pink", but they liked the actress and the character so much, she became a central figure in the rest of the series — even though she's one of few in the show who don't have a counterpart in the original canon.
- Closer to Earth: The only one to see Sherlock's suicidal behavior in "The Reichenbach Fall", and ultimately the one he trusts to help fake his death.
- Crazy Cat Lady: She worries about becoming one on her blog.
OMG! I nearly just wrote 'At least Toby will never leave me'. I am becoming a Mad Spinster!
- The Cutie: Easily the nicest character on the show. And just look at her - she's so cute!
- Dogged Nice Girl: To Sherlock. No matter how horribly he treats her, she just can't give up on him.
- Grew a Spine: She's noticeably more assured and less awkward in Series Three, refusing to put up with Sherlock's more mean-spirited antics.
- Has a Type: In The Empty Hearse, Sherlock assures Molly that all the men she falls for can't be psychopaths. After he leaves, she muses to herself that maybe it's just her type.
- Ignored Enamored Underling: To Sherlock, who only returns her affections when he wants something, at least in the first season. Although he doesn't return her romantic feelings, he does see her as a friend, eventually.
- Incompatible Orientation: With "Jim". It's the psychopathy.
- Also has it with Sherlock. She wants his body; he wants her dead bodies.
- Inter Generational Friendship: Has one with Mrs. Hudson.
- Seems quite friendly with Lestrade as well in "Scandal".
- Lab Rat: The coroner at St. Bart's.
- Loving a Shadow: Molly's fiance. Looks quite like Sherlock and wears the same Belstaff coat.
- Morality Pet: To Sherlock:
"And if you watch the scenes with Sherlock and Molly, apart from the very beginning, she always wins. She always wins. She makes him apologize. She humanizes him. She tells him off." - Steven Moffat
- Nice Girl: The things she's been through would cause anyone to become bitter, but she remains sweet and good-natured despite.
- Open Mouth, Insert Foot: An unfortunate habit of hers.
Molly: How's the hip?
Mrs. Hudson: It's atrocious, but thanks for asking.
Molly: I've seen much worse ... but then I do post-mortems.
- Plucky Girl: Despite everything that happens to her.
- Rapunzel Hair: Not to ridiculous lengths, but it's past her chest.
- Replacement Goldfish / Selective Obliviousness: Despite her belief that she's moved on from her unrequited crush on Sherlock, she's completely oblivious to the fact that her new fiance Tom looks and dresses exactly like him. No one has the heart to tell her.
- Averted in "The Empty Hearse", when Sherlock brings her along on the case. Molly thinks she is there to replace John but Sherlock is trying to thank her.
- Sarcasm Mode: Actually capable when pushed: her response to John asking if Sherlock is "clean" of drug use is to vocalize a very bitter-yet-subtle "Clean?".
- Secret Keeper: Moriarty's failure to recognize her as among the people Sherlock cares about lead to her being one of the only people to know he isn't dead.
- She Cleans Up Nicely: In a jaw-dropping black and white dress◊ in "A Scandal in Belgravia". Even Lestrade is Distracted by the Sexy. Really, anytime she takes the effort to dress up, including her bright yellow do◊ during John and Mary's wedding in The Sign of Three
- Shrinking Violet: At first. She starts to grow a spine in Series 2, and by Series 3, she's much more confident.
- Spanner in the Works: As Sherlock explains in The Empty Hearse, the reason her help was so essential in his plan to counter Moriarity was because she was someone Moriarty believed was below Sherlock's notice, even as he used her to get closer to him, and thus Moriarty believed she didn't matter in the grand scheme of their game - a hole in his scheming that Sherlock is ultimately able to exploit. This even shows in Moriarty's plan to hurt Sherlock's loved ones: he sends assassins after Mrs. Hudson, Watson and Lestrade, but ignores Molly completely.
- Throw the Dog a Bone: Her relationship with Tom in Series 3, who aside from being the spitting image of Sherlock is her first love interest who's not a sociopath. And as she cheerfully comments, she's now getting regular sex.
- Sadly it's ended by "His Last Vow", a month later. It might have been because she stabbed him in the hand with a plastic fork.
- Unwitting Pawn: Moriarty uses her to get close to Sherlock.
Martha Louise Hudson née Sissons
"I'm your landlady, not your housekeeper."
Played By: Una Stubbs
The landlady of 221B, she basically treats John and Sherlock as her sons—a relationship they largely reciprocate.
- As You Know: Her screen-name is "Marie Turner" which is her friend's name (Mrs. Turner, next door, with "the married ones"). Becomes a Running Gag on Sherlock's site and John's blog where every time she comments, she immediately double-posts a reminder: "It's Mrs. Hudson, by the way."
- With the exception of the one time Mrs Turner herself actually commented.
- As of Christmas 2011, she now signs under 'Mrs. Hudson'. John and Sherlock got her a computer for Christmas.
- Berserk Button: Harming her is officially Sherlock's, considering he throws her attacker out a window multiple times.
- Being rude to her is another, even stunning Mycroft with how angry he got when Mycroft told her to shut up in irritation.
- Don't lead her on, or let her find out about your marriage from Sherlock.
- Brainless Beauty: Anyone who unknowingly marries a major drug kingpin can't be much in the way of a detective.
- Catch Phrase: "I'm your landlady, dear, not your housekeeper!"
- Cloud Cuckoolander: She's cheerfully oblivious to most of Sherlock's strange living habits. Or she simply doesn't care. Or, given hints in Series 3, she's quite often stoned. That said, she does have a bone to pick with a few of his habits. Upon finding that Sherlock keeps thumbs in the fridge, she reacts with disgust, and she also seems extremely panicked by him shooting holes in the wall- though her reaction to this is just to scold him like a child and add repair costs to his rent.
Mrs. Hudson: I'm putting this on your rent, young man!
- Cool Old Lady: Mrs. Hudson is one of a select few who can tolerate Sherlock for extended periods of time, gave Sherlock a special deal on the apartment (as thanks for helping her out with getting her husband executed), and keeps some kind of "herbal soother" in her apartment that she doesn't want the cops to know about.
- She also pretends to be much more of a fragile old woman than she actually is when captured by the Americans in order to hide the fact that she has the phone they're looking for. When Sherlock throws the guy out the window, her first reaction is simply that her bins are getting dented.
- Dark and Troubled Past: Series 3 later reveals that she's a former exotic dancer, and that whilst she lived in Florida, unbeknownst to her, her husband had gotten involved in and eventually ended up running a local drug cartel, before being eventually caught and executed for double homicide. She actually found this something of a relief and even formed a friendship with the man responsible for securing his conviction, Sherlock. Although she was perhaps more involved than she'd like us to know:
Sherlock: Even your landlady used to run a drugs cartel
Mrs Hudson: It was my husband's cartel, I was just typing.
- Gossipy Hens: In the un-aired Pilot, Sherlock says, with genuine appreciation, that little old ladies are better than security cameras.
- G-Rated Drug: Her "herbal soothers" she doesn't want the drugs bust to find.
- Fridge Brilliance comes into play after the revelation in Series 3 that her husband was involved in running an American drug cartel, since being found in possession of illegal drugs could cast doubt on her being unaware of his activities, causing her to risk accusations of perjury and even extradition by the American authorities.
- Avert in "His Last Vow", when Magnussen's scan of her reveals outright she uses marijuana.
- Informed Deformity: Her notorious hip has come up multiple times, and yet, she's never seen limping or otherwise uncomfortable because of it, and she seems to have no trouble going up and down the stairs in 221B.
- Morality Pet: To Sherlock and John.
- Never Mess with Granny: Played CIA agents, police officers, and even Watson himself in "Scandal" by faking tears and sneaking Irene's phone out in her bra.
- Odd Friendship: With Sherlock, the man responsible for getting her husband executed in America.
- Parental Substitute: She dotes on Sherlock and John like they were her own grandchildren, she even brings Sherlock his morning tea.
- She's one of the few people Sherlock is openingly affectionate to her, and does not take it well if she's threatened.
- Screaming Woman: Twice in Series 3. The first one is played for laughs when Sherlock reveals himself after pretending to be dead. The second time is not played for laughs is when Moriaty comes back from the dead, and Mrs. Hudson is understandly freaked out by the prospect.
- Shipper on Deck: Mrs. Hudson might be pushing eighty, but she's a great, gushing fangirl at heart. She initially assumes that John and Sherlock are a couple, and wouldn't be persuaded otherwise. However, after Season One (especially during the events of "A Scandal in Belgravia") it appears that she doesn't think of them in that way anymore. Or perhaps she's just keeping that to herself now.
- In "The Empty Hearse", she's shocked that John is getting married to a woman, especially so soon after Sherlock. John responds once again insisting that he's not gay and that Sherlock was not his boyfriend.
- Shrine to the Fallen: Left Sherlock and John's flat exactly as it was during the two years Sherlock was "dead", admitting she didn't have the heart to move anything or even dust, since Sherlock always refused to let her clean the flat.
- Team Mom: To Watson and especially Sherlock.
Played By: Zoe Telford
One of John's girlfriends.
- We Hardly Knew Ye: Disappears from the narrative when she and John break up some time after "The Great Game".
Harriet "Harry" Watson
Played By: N/A
John's sister, who he has an abrasive relationship with due to her alcoholism.
- The Alcoholic: Harry's a known alcoholic, but has tried to quit various times according to John's website, with limited success.
- Aloof Big Brother: Inverted. She's very supportive of John, but he's distant because he doesn't like her drinking.
- Big Sister Instinct: Is very protective of John on the forums of his website.
- Divorce Assets Conflict: Solved this by giving her phone, a present from her wife, to John.
- The Ghost: While mentioned in the show, Harry has yet to show up. She is, however, a frequent poster on John's blog.
- Precision F-Strike: Whenever someone insults John, judging by all the deleted comments on his blog.
- Samus is a Girl: Invoked by Sherlock, while deducting who John's phone belongs to, he assumes that Harry is a boy; turns out that it's Harriet, but she does happen to be a lesbian.
- Tomboyish Name: During his investigation of Watson's phone, Sherlock notices the name "Harry" on it. Turns out it's Watson's sister, Harriet.
Played By: Katherine Parkinson
A reporter who is both smarter and stupider than she appears. She affects a "loony fan" persona to get close to Sherlock (which he sees right through), but it turns out she's actually being played by someone far more dangerous than him.
- Intrepid Reporter: Tries to be this but Sherlock calls her out for being a Hot Scoop and a Stalker with a Crush trying too hard to impress people.
- Meaningful Echo / Ironic Echo: "You repel me".
- Shadow Archetype: To Molly. Molly is a Dogged Nice Girl, Kitty is a Stalker with a Crush. And both of them prove to be rather important in "The Reichenbach Fall", as Moriarty sold his "story" to Kitty after Sherlock tore her down, helping to spread the belief that Sherlock is a fraud. Molly, meanwhile, despite being treated badly by Sherlock, still seems to step up to help him behind the scenes of "Reichenbach". Also, they both display admirable loyalty to Sherlock and Moriarty, respectively.
- Smug Snake: She reeks of desperation and uses every tactic in the book to wring a story out of Sherlock. It doesn't work, as he finds her repellent.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Moriarty.
- Wrong Genre Savvy: Clearly thinks she's an Intrepid Reporter who has uncovered the truth that Sherlock is a fraud and responsible for the crimes he's solved, while Moriarty is merely an actor suffering a crisis of conscience. Alas, no.
Mary Morstan/Watson / A.G.R.A.
Played By: Amanda Abbington
John's girlfriend in season 3.
- Adaptational Badass/Adaptational Villainy: This version of Mary is a former assassin and intelligence operative.
- Admiring the Abomination: While most of John's past girlfriends are mentioned to have absolutely hated Sherlock due to his various personality quirks and mildly sociopathic tendencies, her reaction to meeting him is to grin and admit;
Mary: I like him!
- Alliterative Name: A canon carryover. Bonus points for her actress having one, too.
- Amicable Exes: With David though the latter retains feelings for her. Sherlock makes it very clear he thinks those feelings are a little too strong.
- Casting Gag: Watson's fiancee is played by Martin Freeman's real life partner. It makes their chemistry much more natural and believable.
- Composite Character: The traits of the original canon's Mary Morstan have been combined with those of Sebastian Moran.
- Dark Secret: Mary's claim to be an orphan is a lie: she used to be a professional killer, and the reason she has so few friends is that 'Mary Morstan' is an identity she adopted only a few years ago.
- Dead Person Impersonation: The real Mary Morstan was still born.
- Easily Forgiven: John decides to not read her past and keep her as his wife. Granted, it does take months for him to come to terms with her deception.
- Fake Brit: In-Universe. Sherlock suspects that she is not really English.
- Fangirl: Certainly reads John and Sherlock's blog like one. And she pushes them to investigate the Bloody Guardsman case together even though they're both trying to be "responsible" so as not to upset the fragile three-way balance.
- Fluffy Fashion Feathers: Wore a black feather jacket on the date where John proposed to her.
- Guile Hero: Taking into account her background and skill sets, she can qualify as one.
- Hair of Gold, Heart of Gold: Unusually, among John's girlfriends.
- Hello, Nurse!: Works at John's clinic. Also doubles as a Hospital Hottie.
- Improbable Aiming Skills: Able to throw a coin and shoot it in mid-air.
- Kindhearted Cat Lover: One of Sherlock's deductions is that she is a cat lover, and she certainly fits the kindhearted part of the trope.
- Manic Pixie Dream Girl: Aversion. While she helped pull John out of his depression after Sherlock's disappearance, there's more to her than that. She's the only one of John's partners who has understood the importance of his relationship with Sherlock without becoming jealous because of it.
- Nice Girl: She's a genuinely compassionate person but also no pushover. When informed by Sherlock that one of John's cousins secretly hates her, Mary smiles serenely and moves the cousin's seat at the reception from the main table to next to the bathroom.
- One True Threesome: Invoked. Mary seems fine with John's non-sexual bromance with Sherlock in addition to his romantic and sexual relationship with her. Sherlock actually seems to enjoy her company, actively accommodating her wishes instead of simply tolerating her presence. The three of them get along astounding well in "The Empty Hearse" and "The Sign of Three", with the closest he comes to displaying any sort of irritation towards her being when she tagged along to prevent Major Sholto's death, which in fairness occurred at her wedding. Their fragile equilibrium only seems to become unbalanced when Sherlock realises that she's pregnant.
- In "His Last Vow", their dynamic shatters when it's revealed she used to be a professional assassin for the CIA. After some initial shock (and a bullet wound) Sherlock doesn't seem particularly bothered by her former occupation, being more upset she lied to John than anything else. John on the other hand is understandably furious.
- Only Sane Woman: The wedding planning scene, where she can see that both John and Sherlock are itching to go on a case together to reaffirm that they'll stay friends after the wedding, but she has to manipulate them both shamelessly to make it happen.
- Pregnant Badass: Nearly assassinates Magnussen while pregnant.
- Professional Killer: Former intelligence agent and did wet work for the CIA. Bet you didn't see that coming.
- Walking Spoiler: For "His Last Vow".
Played By: Yasmine Akram
Mary's bridesmaid at her wedding, she quickly forms an Odd Friendship
with Sherlock and uses his super-analytical skills to weed out one-night stands she'll regret.
- Foreign People Are Sexy: She's Irish and gorgeous, to the point Sherlock specifically notes her beauty in his wedding toast.
- Nice Girl: From what we see of her she's very pleasant and outgoing.
- The Pawn: A particularly unlucky example. Not only did Sherlock pretend to fall for her to use her to get access to Magnussen, it turns out Mary independently cultivated a close friendship with her for the same reason. Mercifully Janine never found out about that aspect.
- Punch Clock Villain: Only 'villainous' at all in the fact that she works for Magnussen as his PA; there is no indication that she is involved in anything unethical herself or knows the extent of Magnussen's criminality. Magnussen himself mentions he enjoys jabbing her the eye, the implication being that she only worked with him because he had found one of her pressure points.
- Sexy Secretary: To Magnussen, though technically she is a PA. She hates him and only sticks around because of blackmail. It's implied he took sadistic pleasure in abusing her.
- Vitriolic Best Buds: With Sherlock, in "His Last Vow" after she finds out she used him to get to Magnussen.
- What the Hell, Hero?: To Sherlock, in "His Last Vow" after finding out how he used her. She tells him, clearly more hurt than angry, that he needn't have manipulated her and if he'd just trusted her they could have been friends.
- Woman Scorned: Downplayed. While she does sell increasingly outrageous stories to the papers out of anger at Sherlock (and messes around with his morphine drip), she clearly doesn't hold a major grudge and even kisses him on the forehead before leaving. Sherlock conversely acknowledges he deserves it and congratulates her on at least making some cash for her troubles.
Mr. & Mrs. Holmes
Mr. & Mrs. Holmes
Played By: Timothy Carlton & Wanda Ventham
A perfectly ordinary married couple that somehow managed to produce both Mycroft and Sherlock.
- Amazingly Embarrassing Parents: Subverted. Sherlock and Mycroft are both highly embarrassed by them... because they're so ordinary. It's their lack of genius - or madness, either would be acceptable - that makes them 'highly embarrassing' to their child prodigies.
- Bow Ties Are Cool: Mr. Holmes wears one at Christmas.
- Casting Gag: They are played by Benedict Cumberbatch's real parents.
- Family Versus Career: Mrs. Holmes was a career mathematician, even having a published textbook. But she gave it all up for her children.
- Happily Married: To the extent that Sherlock brings the Watsons down to their house when they have a bit of marriage trouble.
- Good Parents: They certainly seem to be. They love their sons despite their....quirks, and take no notice when Sherlock steps onto the couch between them while they are telling him a story and pushes them out the door when John arrives.
- In the Blood: Mrs. Holmes was a mathematician, so it's obvious Mycroft and Sherlock got their intelligence from her.
- Iron Lady: Mrs. Holmes definitely gives off this vibe, even Mycroft is afraid of upsetting her.
- Jerk with a Heart of Gold: Like her sons, Mrs. Holmes seems a bit cool on the exterior, but is a caring mother, going as far as to do Christmas dinner for the whole family, plus the Watsons (and even Billy Wiggins, although she freely admits to him that she's not quite sure why he's there), as Sherlock is suffering from a bullet wound and she wants to make sure he's okay.
- Last Name Basis: Mrs. Holmes math textbook gave her the initials "M.L.," but that's about it, we don't really get a first name for either of them.
- Mama Bear: "Somebody's put a bullet in my boy and if I ever find out who, I shall turn absolutely monstrous."
- Nice Guy: Mr. Holmes is very pleasant and outgoing. He's even concerned about the Watsons marriage.
- Odd Couple: Mrs. Holmes was a mathematician, Mr. Holmes is by his own admission "something of a moron", at least by comparison.
- Opposites Attract: From what we see of them. Mrs. Holmes is a bit temperamental, stubborn, and headstrong, whereas Mr. Holmes is much more laid-back, calm and passive. Many have noted they seem very similar to a time-shifted, partially-gender-flipped Sherlock and John.
- Only Sane Man: Mr. Holmes is the normal one in the family.
Played By: Tom Brooke
A seemingly harmless drug-addict.
- Baker Street Regular: He's a drug addict Sherlock befriends while undercover in a crackhouse. Sherlock then uses him to communicate with Mary.
- Composite Character: His first name, Billy comes from the page boy of 221B who first appeared in William Gillette's play, and than migrated into the stories as a relatively minor character. His last name Wiggins, comes from the leader of the Baker Street Irregulars in Conan Doyle's first two novels, "A Study in Scarlet" and "The Sign of Four".
- Crouching Moron, Hidden Badass / Hidden Depths: Inverted; he's more Crouching Wimp, Hidden Genius - which is why Sherlock takes a shine to him. He's also apparently an excellent chemist, capable of creating non-lethal drugs to knock out people without damaging their bodies.
- Erudite Stoner: He might be a heroin addict but he also has deductive skills similar to Sherlock's.
- Knife Nut: Pulls a knife on John during their first meeting and gets a sprained wrist in return.
- Sherlock Scan: Pulls it on Watson, recognizing his shirt wrinkles imply he folds all his shirts in that manner because it makes them easier to pack, thus he dresses at the office once he's showered there. Holmes is impressed by this, so Billy tries to show off some more but gets it wrong on account of not knowing Watson personally.
- They Call Me Mister Tibbs: Tried to pull it off by claiming to have a codename amongst the druggies as "The Wig." Sherlock doesn't buy it.