Pædo Hunt: Marcus from "In the Dark" is strongly hinted to be a pedophile. This is one vampire you do not want to be impervious to sunlight.
Paint the Town Red: Holland predicts L.A. will be reduced to this by the time Darla & Drusilla are finished.
Pals with Jesus: All of Angel Investigations' members are reduced to Jasmine's lackeys. One by one they manage to break free; Connor, however, elects to stay chummy with She Who Walks Among Us.
Papa Wolf: Angel towards Connor. It took nearly an entire episode before anybody was allowed to even approach him. In fact, do not even think about possibly touching a hair on Connor's head — you will be a bloody pulp before you can get within a block of him.
Parental Incest: Heavily implied with Bethany. Wesley concludes that her father's abuse is what triggered her telekinesis.
Perfect Poison: Justified (or maybe Hand Waved) by Dr. Meltzer injecting Angel with a paralytic intended for large animals. When used on a human, it induces heart failure. (Good thing he doesn't have one.)
Perpetual Poverty: Running your detective business out of a moldy vintage hotel isn't as lucrative as one would think. This stops in the last season, where they get all the nigh unlimited wealth and resources of Wolfram & Hart's LA branch
Persona Non Grata: Buffy is subjected to this after she tries to kill Faith. In the episode that it happens she is very much treated as the villain, as Angel wants to help people reform when Buffy just wants to kill them, especially Faith, and Angel thinks Buffy is Jumping Off the Slippery Slope.
Pietà Plagiarism: The Teaser for "Orpheus" picks up after Faith's final bout with Angelus; Wesley carries Faith's bloodied body into the Hyperion Hotel in slow motion.
Pin-Pulling Teeth: Wolfram & Harts' black ops unit tries to kill Angel, but are wiped out by Vampire Hunter Holtz, who ties Angel to a pillar to be tortured and murdered. Angel kicks a grenade (lying in the hand of a dead W&H mook) into the air so he can grab the pin with his teeth, then shakes his head violently to free the pin.
The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything: Angel claims to be a private detective/in private security. When actual detective work is required, he has at least once hired a real private detective to do it for him! He just tells people he's a detective because it's easier to explain than "I go around protecting people from hellspawn."
Kate Lockley:(holds Angel at gunpoint) You're telling me you're an investigator?
Rieff: I thought all Brachen demons had a good sense of direction.
Doyle: Yeah, we're all pretty good at basketball, too.
When Harrie calls out Richard's family for attempting to cannibalize Doyle's brain, his siblings indignantly shout "Racist!" She then calls them out on the hypocrisy of picking and choosing the 'sacred rituals' they want to keep doing and then acting pious when called on it.
"Sense & Sensitivity" is a giant lampooning of this trope. An Emotion Bomb affects Kate's co-workers so deeply that they start letting crooks go free, decrying the justice system for brutalizing the poor prisoners.
When Lilah mistakingly uses the phrase "handshake deal" when bartering with a demon assassin, Linday quickly jumps in to emphasize that she meant metaphorical hands. ("Sanctuary")
A less arc-heavy example is the unclear nature of the visions from the Powers That Be. In the season two opener, Angel ended up killing a protector demon because neither he nor it knew the other was fighting for good.
Popular Is Dumb: Cordelia in Season One, though she eventually grows out of it. Played straight with Harmony, though.
The Power of Acting: Although Cordelia's skill is usually Bad Bad Acting, it does help her bluff Angelus when the chips are down. Cordelia is fairly consistently shown to be pretty good at improv acting, but horrible at following a script.
Also, when Wesley impersonates Angel he fools a wizard/businessman/mobster and his thugs.
Also, Angel when impersonating both Jay-Don and Herb Sanders
Spike turns out to be just as eligible for the Shanshu Prophecy as Angel. Or so it seems...
The half-demon clan of "Hero" tell of a prophecy which foretold a "Chosen One" who would save them from The Scourge. The obvious assumption is it's Angel. At the episode's conclusion, though, it's Doyle who sacrifices his life to save them all.
In the first season finale, Wes translates a prophecy to say that Angel will die. In the end it is revealed that Wes mistranslated it, and the real prophecy said that he would "live and die" (the language of the prophecy uses the same word for both); in other words, become human. Of course, the prophecy only said "the vampire with a soul," so in the fifth season, a conflict is introduced that it could have been Spike they were talking about. At the time the prophecy was translated, Angel was not only the only vampire with a soul, but the only one that had ever existed, nobody had even considered the idea that it could refer to someone else.
Psychic-Assisted Suicide: The demon-possessed Ryan 'sleepwalks' into the middle of traffic, almost getting killed before Angel tackles him out of a car's path. The demon later confesses that he would have also died had the car struck. By leaping into a body of a remorseless child, the Ethros had unwittingly trapped itself forever, with death as the only escape.
Psychic Link: Vampires and their sires share these, though only when they are in close proximity. Angel goes absolutely off the rails whenever his 'family' is nearby.
The Haxil demon of "Expecting" impregnates human women, then controls them via some sort of psychic umbilical.
Psychic Radar: Wolfram & Hart uses psychics specifically to scan if a vampire has entered their building.
Psycho Rangers: Holtz's "groupies" (™ Sahjhan). They're vampire hunters, too; only in this case, they're beefing up to take out Angel's entourage: Wes, Fred, Cordelia and Gunn.
The Jasmaniacs could be considered this, seeing as they succeeded where Angel Investigations failed: exiling all of the demons underground forever, blowing Wolfram & Hart to smithereens, and bringing about world peace.
Punch a Wall: In the aftermath of Faith's first duel with Angelus (which Faith lost), the next episode opens with her taking a shower in Wesley's bathroom. Her body is battered, bruised and covered with blood. Without warning, Faith explodes into violence, repeatedly punching the shower tiles until her fists have driven through the wall. Needless to say, this is not played for Fanservice.
Puppeteer Parasite: Talamour, a "Burrower" demon preying on the regulars at a singles bar.
Puppet Permutation: Happens to Angel in "Smile Time." Within the episode, he fights other, demonic puppets. It also contains the line "You're a wee little puppet man!" from Spike. May or may not be a hint that Angel is being turned into a metaphorical puppet.
Spike and Lorne later get the same treatment in the comic Spike: Shadow Puppets when they travel to Japan where Smile Time is still popular.
Purple Eyes: Princess Jhiera, along with the rest of the Oden Tal.
Putting on the Reich: The Scourge is an army of pure-blood demons bent on the extermination of all "half-breeds". They all dress up in faux-S.S. uniforms, making this a not-so-subtle allegory; Their leader even delivers a Hitler-style, genocidal speech to an audience of mooks.
For bonus points, from what we know of demons in general, the Scourge are about as pure-blood as Germans are Aryan.
Now proven In the comics, the Scourge get involved with one of Illyria's former pets named Baticus, who is also an Old One. Baticus incinerates the Scourge but the same attack doesn't scratch Illyira.
Written-In Infirmity: David Boreanaz directed "Soul Purpose", in which Angel is rendered immobile for the majority of its running time. Boreanaz suffered a severe knee injury prior to filming, which necessitated a story in which he doesn't move very much.
Real Men Get Shot: And thrown from rooftops, and stabbed in the neck with their own stakes.
Real Women Have Curves: In "Double or Nothing" when Gunn is fake breaking up with Fred she asks if there's another woman, and asks her name, to which he cruely respons "Her name is 'I'm-a-real-woman-not-a-stick-figure' get the picture?
Reality Ensues: From "Over the Rainbow" when Team Angel was facing down a whole village.
Wesley: I think we're winning! (cut to Team Angel tied up)
Recap By Audit: In Angel, Doyle asks Angel to snoop around his ex-wife's new fiancée, leading to an awkward scene where Angel spots the beau with a knife and tackles him through a plate-glass window. The next morning, Angel grouses that Richard belongs to a family of a harmless restauranteurs "with some pretty expensive windows."
Marcus Hamilton reading off a list of damages caused by Angel's flunky during a rescue mission.
Red Herring: "Lonely Hearts" goes out of its way to mislead viewers as to which character the Burrower demon has BodySurfed into. The opening half of "I've Got You Under My Skin" uses a similar trick to make Angel suspect the wrong man of being possessed, a demon that actually possessed a child and forced it to horrible things. In the end the demon reveals that the child was born with no soul, and the demon had been the boy's prisoner while he did the horrible things.
Redemption Equals Death: Used straight and played with in a few instances. Angel refused to fight Faith when she wanted to be killed, Connor was "killed" and given a new life. Played completely straight when Doyle died, elevating himself from "weasel" to hero.
Redemption in the Rain: Faith's complete breakdown at the end of "Five by Five". Also, Darla staking herself in the episode "Lullaby" to allow Connor to be born.
Red Oni, Blue Oni: Spike is the Red Oni by being... Spike. Where as Angel is known for his brooding thus qualifying him as a Blue Oni. One could argue that this dated back to their days with Darla and Drusilla.
Reformed, but Rejected: Faith's supposed reformation doesn't track with Buffy, who arrives in town with the sole purpose of killing her. Angel think she's acting like a spoiled brat, causing the former lovers to part on bad terms.
Regularly Scheduled Evil: The undead warrior Tezcatcatl is damned to return every 50 years. In this case, however, it's a bonus; the curse grants him unlimited chances to find his talisman, which would render him invincible.
Rewarded as a Traitor Deserves: The first mate on the ship ferrying the Brachen clan out of the country decides to rat them all out for money. The Scourge repay his help by testing their human-disintegrating Beacon on him.
Revenge Before Reason: Despite hating demons and knowing they couldn't be trusted, Holtz jumps at the chance to travel over 200 years into the future to kill Angelus and Darla despite knowing he's making a deal with a demon who isn't sharing his own motives for wanting Angel and Darla dead.
Ripple-Effect-Proof Memory: Used twice with Angel: First, erasing Buffy's memories of their time together ("I Will Remember You"), and again when signing a deal with Wolfram & Hart, giving Connor a brand new family ("Home").
Rooftop Confrontation: Buffy's face-off with Faith on the roof of Angel's building. The throwdown gets postponed when the rifle-toting Watcher's Special Ops Team arrives in helicopters and tries to pick off both Slayers at once.
The entire team facing off against The Beast in a sky lounge.
Room Full of Crazy: Lampshaded in "Somnambulist": Angel deflates one of Penn's evil rants by accurately describing the layout of his "killer shrine" wall, right down to the news clippings and candles — without ever having seen it with his own eyes. "Oh, you are so prosaic."
Angel's suite temporarily turns into one of these in "Darla": Wesley appears in the doorway and expresses his concern that Angel isn't exactly well. Angel, who is busily sketching Darla in various poses, brushes him off. Wesley steps inside, revealing pages upon pages of drawings blanketing the entire floor.
While imprisoned in Pylea, Fred wrote on the walls of her cave to stay sane. It didn't take. Once back in L.A., she immediately starts scribbling on the walls of her room in the Hyperion.
Even after her supposed 'rehabilitation' later in the series, Fred continues to cope with trauma or stress by writing on walls. Wesley and Gunn lampshade it in the fifth season.
Wesley:(at Fred writing on the windows)That's never good.
Fred: What? Oh, no, I— I just ran out of white board. I'm not crazy. Again.
Wesley's office after Illyria's arrival becomes one of these due to his obsession with learning everything he can about her. Lampshaded by Lorne when Gunn mentions having gone in there.
"Oh, God! Don't go in there! That's where he keeps his full-strength crazy!"
Likewise with Spike in "Why We Fight." He becomes so taken with a Nazi captain's leather trenchcoat, he kills him for it.
Sand In My Eyes: Wesley tearfully blots his eyes after officially being hired at Angel Investigations, complaining of "allergies". Invoked again at the end of "Expecting".
Same Story, Different Names: In Buffy's "Becoming", the heroine had to run a sword through Angel before he opened a portal and destroyed the world. In "Inside Out", Angel raises his sword to slay a loved one before she can bring forth a demon to enslave the world. (Interestingly, he fails.)
Scary Black Man: Griff, the debt collector ("Rm v/a Vu"). Technically a Scary Black Demon but you get the idea.
Screw the Rules, I Have Connections!: Wes and Cordy pose as a police detectives in order to intimidate a wealthy couple outside the XXI fight club. The man counters by dropping the name of their "boss", the police chief - and a close personal friend of his. Cordy swoops in and improvises by pretending they're about to raid the club, and are giving the rich couple an opportunity to scram. They do.
Sealed Cast in a Multipack: Subverted; Illyria was a Sealed Evil in a Can, and had an army waiting for her in some kind of pocket dimension. But when she found her way to this pocket dimension, she found that the army had died while waiting in its "can," and she despaired that she was all alone, the last of her kind with no chance of reviving her army or finding any other Old Ones living on Earth.
Selective Condemnation: When a villain hands out fates worse than death, it's seen as awful. When Angel makes a guy immortal, but locked in a room, unable to move or look at something else or speak because he normally takes people to hell but got resurrected (ok, so the guy was evil in life and was only doing the hell thing to stay out of hell, but remember, he was doing it on Wolfram & Hart's property, so most people he did it to probably asked for it), it's never mentioned again.
Plus, Willow mind wiping Tara on Buffy was supposed to be awful, but Angel removing everyone's memories of Conner only is brought up again when Wes finds out, and is quickly dropped again afterwards.
To be fair, the terrible part about Willow's mind wipe was that it was violation of the worst kind; Willow was effectively forcing Tara to remain in a sexual relationship that Tara didn't want to continue, making her actions date rape at best. Angel, on the other hand, wanted to remove horribly traumatic memories from his friends' minds not for his benefit but for their own; wiping away Wesley's tragic betrayal, Connor's insanity, etc.
Self-Defeating Prophecy: The visions sent to Angel's sidekicks are often of a monster killing a human, which Angel is then able to prevent.
Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: Sahjan's action after hearing only "the son would kill Sahjan" part led him to causing Conner to be in the exact position to do just that.
Self-Deprecation: A meta example in Fredless: Trish Burkle comments on how her husband likes "all those disgusting Alien movies... he just can't get enough of them. Except for the last one they made, I think he dozed off." Joss Whedon wrote the last movie in the Alien series, and is not proud of it.
Self-Made Man: One of Angel's richest clients, David Nabbit, made his millions by inventing software which allows blind people surf the internet.
Self Restraint: Faith's prison breakout in the fourth season makes it clear she could have escaped any time she wanted. Alluded to in "Five by Five" and "Sanctuary" where it becomes clear that Angel is helping Faith come round to the idea of wanting to turn herself in because the only way a human prison could ever hold a slayer would be if the slayer 'wanted to be held.
As dismissive, threatening and moderately destructive as Illyria is around the office, that's her being restrained. She kills everyone in about ten seconds flat when she actually decides to fight them in a possible future.
Serial Killer: Penn is nicknamed "The Pope" by the L.A. press, due to his habit of carving crosses onto the faces of his victims (a quirk he adopted from Angel).
Sequel Episode: Billy Blim, the freed prisoner from "That Vision Thing", turns up again to bring mayhem in "Billy."
Sheep in Sheep's Clothing: Fred's parents, in a cast full of Abusive Parents, despite their frightening whispering and how Fred runs away when she sees them... are proved to be generous and balanced people who are just very suspicious and worried for their daughter and thus, difficult to meet after five years of separation.
Spike suggests that a hollow tree, if it's not the entrance to the Deeper Well, could be the entrance to Christmas Land. Angel doesn't get it.
A drunk Wesley calls Illyria a smurf. She doesn't understand the reference but does realise it's an attempt to insult or disrespect her so she's offended all the same.
It's been said that the scene with Connor saying his name is Stephen was a shout-out to or inspired by a somewhat well known made-for-TV movie called I Know My First Name is Stephen
Shut Up, Hannibal!: The object of Dr. Meltzer's desire, Melissa Burns, delivers a stinging one when Meltzer comes for her in "I Fall To Pieces". Melissa reaffirms her refusal to be afriad, having been convinced by Angel that she has survived everything Meltzer has done to her so far. This causes Meltzer to (literally) fall apart at the seams.
Kate tracks her father's killers to an auto repair shop, dusting one of them like a pro. Her Roaring Rampage is interrupted by el jefe: a humongous, steroid-injected demon who lectures Kate on how she cannot comprehend the world she's entered into. Enter Angel:
"A big ugly drug-running demon who thinks he's a lot scarier than really he is, maybe? Yeah, she knows."
Angelus tries to get under Cordelia's skin by ridiculing her total lack of acting ability. Cordy gets the last laugh when she bluffs Angelus into believing her thermos is full of holy water, resulting in his defeat.
Signs of the End Times: In "Apocalypse Nowish" there are birds crashing into buildings, snakes coming out of plumbing, rats everywhere, and eventually, all the phone calls they get about these things make an ancient symbol of destruction.
Single Tear: David Boreanaz squeezes one out during his 'date rape' at the hands of Rebecca ("Eternity").
Sixth Ranger: The cast rotates these out after the core five of Angel, Cordy, Wesley, Gunn, and Fred are clearly established. Some examples include Darla, Connor, Lorne, Faith, or whomever is making a cameo from Sunnydale that week.
Skyward Scream: Angel lets one loose after feeding on a murder victim during the 1970s.
Sleep Cute: Angel and Cordy cuddled up with Baby Connor.
Slippery Skid: Angel squeezes a bag of whole coffee beans to test Cordelia's theory that he can effectively grind the coffee with his "vampire strength." The bag bursts, of course, scattering coffee beans everywhere just as Cordelia and Wesley come in the door; Wesley immediately slips and falls.
Slipping a Mickey: In an effort to make Angel lose his soul and turn her into a vampire, Rebecca Lowell drugs his champagne with a bliss-inducing prescription drug.
Slow Motion Drop: Wesley's slo-mo knife drop at the end of "Five By Five". In the next episode, Faith breaks a glass upon seeing a TV news report declaring her to be a wanted fugitive. Played for Laughs when Spike drops the Cup of Perpetual Torment with a stunned expression after drinking from it because it contains soft drink.
Slut Shaming: As with Buffy, Angel has a tendency to punish sexual promiscuity. In this case, Cordelia ends up with demonic pregnancies. One client of Angel Investigations displays internalized shame with the question, "Does it surprise you? That I'm a giant slut?" after attempting to seduce Angel.
Soaperizing: In interviews before the show's premiere, Joss Whedon said the spin-off Angel would be a "case of the week"-type show, and not a soap opera like Buffy. It ended up becoming a bigger soap opera, with multiple love triangles, Shot Reverse Shots of people standing around in rooms and rehashing old plot points, Angel's son going from a baby to teenager and sleeping with Cordelia, etc.
Fred: Who's Darla? Gunn: Angel's old flame from way back. Fred Not the one who died? Gunn: Yeah. —No, not that one, the other one that died and came back to life. She's a vampire. Fred: (confused)Do y'all have a chart or somethin'? Gunn: In the files, I'll get it for you later.
Lampshaded by Cordy herself: "Tell me we're not living in a soap opera."
Lampshaded by Gunn as well in "Players": "Listen, I spent most of this year trapped in what I can only describe as a turgid supernatural soap-opera."
Softspoken Sadist: Marcus ("In the Dark"). He sounds like the guy who sells you Chakra stones.
Somewhere, a Mammalogist Is Crying: "Through the Looking Glass". Had Wesley simply used the term "hart" or "stag" in the layman fashion (to refer to any male red deer regardless of its age), it might not have been accurate but it wouldn't have been comment-worthy. Unfortunately, he goes into detail saying a hart is "a male red deer or staggard" indicating the script-writers may have attempted to research the proper naming convention that exists for male red deer (that or they thought a "stag" and "staggard" meant the same thing). A staggard is a male red deer in its fourth year of life. A stag is a male red deer in its fifth year of life. A hart is a male red deer over five years old (i.e., in its sixth year of life). The picture itself shows a 10-point deer (5 tines on each antler) which is a "great hart" (a stag over six years old, i.e., seven years old or older with 10-16 tines). By using generalised layman terms, it all could have been handwaved as an ordinary conversation or at least the "hart" being a contraction of "great hart" where the picture itself was concerned. The attempt to be clever by referring to "staggard" simply emphasised the writers had failed to do their research.
A throwaway line in the episode "Sanctuary" revealed that Angel tried to turn Faith on to the "healing power of the Manilow", and that while Manilow seriously wasn't Faith's thing, she had to admit she felt better sometimes after listening to "Weekend in New England"
Soul Jar: Angel's soul is imprisoned in one in the fourth season, in order to temporarily release Angelus.
The "Ethros Box".
Justine traps her boss' boss, Sahjan, in a jar.
Sound-Only Death: When the youngest runt in XXI is pitted against Trepkos in the next match, Cribb remarks, "That's not a fight, it's an execution." Trepkos ignores Angel's imploring him not to kill the kid, instead promises to "kill him quick." Indeed, the fight has barely begun before Angel hears a telltale Neck Snap sound.
Soundtrack Dissonance: Angel's flashback to a donut shop robbery, in which he witnessed the clerk get fatally shot. Angel drinks the corpse's blood as "Mandy" plays on a jukebox.
Fred manages to get one line into "You make me happy", a classic target for this trope, before coughing up blood and collapsing.
Spikes of Doom: Angel gets to experience the full extent of Gunn's vampire-proofing in "War Zone". Upon chasing Angel into Gunn's own building, Gunn rams the wall with his spiked truck, narrowly missing Angel's head. Disoriented, Angel stumbles over a tripwire, triggering a hurricane of arrows as well as a falling spike trap.
Spoiler Opening: Averted. One episode features Alyson Hannigan as a surprise guest star. The actor's name was removed from the opening credits to hide the surprise; instead they get top billing in the end credits. The same was done to hide Faith's first appearance.
James Marsters is in the opening credits of the first episode of Season 5, though he doesn't turn up 'til the last scene of said episode.
Another sort of aversion: Amy Acker's credit sequence for season five includes shots of Illyria ... but only after Fred dies.
Squee: Cordy keeps giggling like a madwoman after being invited out shopping with TV actress Rebecca Lowell.
Step into the Blinding Fight: Inverted in an episode where a blind assassin can sense motion including heartbeats and breath-falls. Angel, being a vampire lacks both a pulse and the necessity to inhale or exhale, so when he stands completely still, the assassin is incapable of seeing him.
Stripperific: Cordelia's outfit when she's made a "princess."
Sugar Apocalypse: What happens when Angel pulls the plug on Jasmine's enchantment over Los Angeles. It's a tough argument for free will when cars are exploding around you during your speech.
Sue Donym: As a reward for rescuing their son from walking into oncoming traffic, Mrs. Anderson invites Angel in for some coffee. When probed about his name, Angel replies "Angel— Jones. Angel Jones."
At the hospital where Connor was brought after birth, he is officially registered as "Connor Angel," as Fred gave his father the alias "Geraldo Angel."
He's a pet psychiatrist with a small practice in Pacoima.
Type 2: Angel, Spike and other vampires, Groo, Gwen Raiden, Connor, Sajhan
Type 3: The Beast, Jasmine, Marcus Hamilton, Illyria
Type 4: The Senior Partners, The Powers That Be, Illyria in her true form, Cordelia after Ascending.
Supervillain Lair: In an inversion of this trope, Jasmine takes over the Hyperion Hotel, and Wolfram & Hart becomes Angel's base.
Surprise Witness: Angel unexpectedly drops in on a courtroom proceeding with an eyewitness in tow — the same kid who was thought to have been intimidated by Lindsey into silence. His testimony effectively torpedoes Lindsey's murder case ("Five By Five").
Suspect Is Hatless: When interviewing witnesses to a demon assault on the subway, the best Kate can glean from them is suspect is of 'average' height, 'average' build, and 'average' weight. Well, that was helpful.
For such a high-security building, the roof is oddly unguarded.
Sword Fight: Between Angel and Lindsey in the last season.
Sword over Head: Pressed by Gunn's oncoming gang, Angel ends up violently disarming one of his attackers and almost stabs him with his own stake. He stops when he realizes that his prey is a mere kid.
Untwisted in the Season Four finale ("Home"). Angel finds himself raising a knife over Connor's neck, fulfilling Wesley's prophecy from long ago. Against all expectation, however, Angel brings the knife down with full force.
In the related "Spike: After The Fall", after L.A. goes literally to Hell, someone comments, 'No new movies have come out for months, the internet is down, the televisions only play that awful show about the witch sisters.'—-"Charmed" is considered highly derivative of "Buffy" and "Angel", and the show followed "Angel" in reruns for at least three years.
Take a Third Option: In "The Ring", Angel implores the other fighters at XXI not to cooperate in the matches. Cribb eventually releases the prisoners, who mob the entire ring and bring the club to a halt.
Taking the Bullet: Doyle sacrfices himself in order to shut down The Scourge's beacon in order to prevent Angel from doing it.
Tattooed Crook: In "Five By Five", Angel mentors a street hoodlum in his own distinctive style. Cordelia snarkily vocalizes her doubt that "a guy with that many tattoos" can be reformed.
Teach Him Anger: While the pair is hunting for Angelus, Wesley devises a number of tests to determine whether Faith has gotten too soft. He goads Faith with memories of how she tortured him, then mocks her apparent reformation, calling her a rabid animal who should have been put down long ago. As expected, Faith lunges for the limey's throat.
Wesley: There, that wasn't so hard was it? ''It's what you'll need to beat him.”
Technobabble: Fred's technobabble always comes off as kind of cute.
Fred has made homicidal rage look cute. Technobabble is as nothing.
Tempting Fate: Cordelia and Doyle commiserate over drinks, wondering if they're out of a job now that Angel's human ("I Will Remember You"). Doyle figures that if Angel's no longer working for the Powers That Be, that must mean he's off the hook, too. Cue another vision, causing poor Doyle's head to slam into the bar top. ..Guess not.
Before departing L.A., Buffy makes a passing laceration at Angel by comparing to her new boyfriend (Riley), whom she "knows" and "trusts" ("Sanctuary"). As we later find out on Buffy, she doesn't know the real Riley very well at all.
10-Minute Retirement: Angel quits the hero business in Season Two (though it lasts considerably longer than ten minutes), firing his team and devoting all his energies toward crushing Wolfram & Hart. Once he finds that the Senior Partners don't exist to be beaten, only fought, he comes to his senses and reunites the team.
Thanatos Gambit: Holtz giving Angel a note to give to Angel's human son Connor. It explains that the two of them should be together. He also tells Angel the same thing, seemingly having finally made peace with Angel for Connor's sake. Then he has his accomplice stab him twice in the neck so it looks like Angel killed Holtz out of spite. This pretty much destroyed the relationship between Angel and his son forever, especially given the vicious cycle that resulted.
In After the Fall, this is how Angel gets L.A. out of Hell.
Theme Initials: A disproportionate number of Wolfram & Hart lawyers have the initials L.M - Lindsay McDonald, Lilah Morgan, Lee Mercer and Linwood Morrow.
Initially justified; Lindsay McDonald's, Lilah Morgan's, and Lee Mercer's first appearances were all written to be the same person.
Invoked on a mammoth scale in Season Four, when Skip reveals the accidents that brought Team Angel together were no accidents.
There Are No Therapists: The following people did not receive therapy: Gunn, who spent much of his life on the streets fighting for his life, and had to kill his sister. Wesley, whose father was verbally abusive and used to lock him under the stairs. Fred spent five years living feral in a dimension where humans were enslaved, and came back babbling and hiding in her room for weeks. And Connor, who was brought up in a hell dimension by a fanatical vampire hunter from the 18th century who taught Connor that his father was pure evil. The one time Angel went to a guru to talk about his problems, the guy turned out to be an impostor. It might have worth tracking down a psychiatrist who catered to the supernatural, particularly for the last two.
There Was a Door: Gunn isn't too receptive to the idea of a noble vampire at first. When Angel suggests an alliance, Gunn expresses his skepticism by locking him in a meat locker. Angel spends the next few minutes trying to punch his way out, only for Cordelia and Wesley to unlock the door.
Faith goes a little nuts after slaying a demon assassin in Angel's basement. With what she's gone through, the last thing Faith needed to see was her hand holding a bloody knife.
This Is Gonna Suck: After Faith drugs Angelus he is forced to relive the good acts he's done. He actually freaks out to Faith when he realizes what's coming.
The Thing That Would Not Leave: Cordelia in "Rm w/a Vu". Within a few hours, Angel's basement is covered wall-to-wall with Cordelia's trophies, there's peanut butter on his bed, his leather chair is ruined, and Cordelia is busily cutting up his linoleum floor to examine the hardwood.
This Means War!: Kate Lockely in "To Shanshu in L.A". Subverted in that Kate can't quite make up her mind about this; she and Angel share quite a few "This Means War" moments in Season 2, but always manage to bury the hatchet some way or another.
After what Angelus did to his family, the only hatchet Holtz wants to bury is the one he can plant inside Angel's head.
Three-Way Sex: In addition to reportedly having a herculean physique, the Immortal has the stamina of a racehorse, as Darla and Drusilla can attest. (To Spike and Angel's vast annoyance.)
Throwing the Distraction: Inverted against the heroes in "War Zone". Gunn issues the evacuation order when vampires firebomb his base. Gunn realizes only too late that it's a distraction, and that he's just sent his little sister outdoors to get chowed down on.
Thou Shalt Not Kill Muggles: Further deconstructed with each passing year. So, butchering hundreds of demons is okay, but a professor who feeds his students to wormholes = the angels weep?
Subverted by Angel leaving a whole pack of Wolfram & Hart lawyers to be fed on by Darla and Dru.
Same goes for Jasmine's pod people. Angel dutifully reminds the viewers at home that these people are under a spell, but it comes down to us vs. them... Gun injects, "Believe me, I'm there."
An interesting footnote to Season Five: Nina winds up deeply disturbed by the lives she took while a werewolf, regardless of how depraved those people were. Angel? He's cool with it. This highlights the differences between them, as well the gradual darkening of Angel's team.
Too Happy to Live: A textbook example with Wesley and Fred, who get to spend approximately ten minutes of one episode as a happy couple after seasons of Will They or Won't They? before Fred is slowly and painfully killed so her body can host Illyria.
Lilah too. It's easy to forget in the later seasons that she was a largely ineffective Smug Snake for the first two and half years of the show, ultimately getting a promotion only because Lindsey turned it down. It's only from season 3 on that she emerges as a genuinely dangerous and capable figure.
Gunn as well via a mental upgrade became the go to guy in court. Able to speak multiple demon languages and knowledgable in Demon diplomacy, while still able to take multiple vampires hand to hand. Cordelia from cheerleader to Katana wielding Seer and Fred from crazy Survivor slave to flame thrower wielding bad ass scientist. Angel Investigations, you didn't need to be a badass to work there, but it helped.
Took a Level in Kindness: When Faith first appeared on the show she thought if she did enough damage she'd get someone to kill her. When she failed to get even Buffy to put her out of her misery Faith goes to prison for murder, where she could have easily broken out but chose to stay to get her head together. When we next see her she's a much calmer, civil chosen one, even going as far as to send Conner home rather than have him try and kill Angelus.
Torture Technician: Marcus the vampire is alleged to have "invented some of the classics", but he's closed-mouthed about which. ("In the Dark")
Faith has a cute system for separating torture into five groups (àla the Food Pyramid), which Wesley gets to experience firsthand ("Five By Five").
Angelus was pretty handy with torture devices in his day. By and large, Angel gave that habit up. In "Forgiving", though, he comes very close to torturing a captive Linwood with stuff he finds lying around the office. (This is a special case, as Angel is desperate to recover his son.)
To Serve Man: All part of a balanced breakfast for Jasmine. Gunn lampshades this word-for-word.
Trade Snark: As Wesley is reading aloud from the owner's manual for Cordy's new security system, he actually recites the "TM" at the end.
Trailers Always Spoil: The themesong montages have a habit of spoiling that someone will be promoted to main cast, most notably Spike in the season 5 opener when he doesn't appear until the end of the episode.
Transplant: Cordelia originally. Later to be followed by Wesley, whose arc had concluded in Buffy Season 3. Spike, who 'died' in that show's finale, promptly reappeared on Angel in its final season. (Can't keep a good Fonzie down!)
Traumatic Superpower Awakening: "Untouched": Bethany, the girl with telekenesis, had it awakened when she was abused physically and sexually by her father. It also flared up when someone threatened her in an alley early in the ep.
Trash the Set: Angel's Season 1 office gets dynamited, Caritas in season 3 and the Wolfram & Hart offices in seasons 4 and 5.
True Love Is Boring: Outright stated in regards to Fred and Gunn. Possibly the case for Angel himself.
Trying to Catch Me Fighting Dirty: After tracking the Mohra demon to a salt refinery silo, a (now-human) Angel tosses salt in the demon's eyes while Buffy goes for the kill. Justified in that Angel didn't have his typical vampire strength and combat ability to rely on.
Twerp Sweating: Angel giving the third degree to Pierce, a day trader and Cordelia's date ("Bachelor Party").
Cordy refuses to bring her next date to meet Angel, convinced he'll act like a forbidding father. But she didn't count on Phantom Dennis! When Cordy brings Wilson over to her apartment, Dennis kills the mood by slamming the front door, brightening the lights she dims, and adjusting the radio dial to blast jaunty polka ("Expecting").
A flashback to the 18th century shows Darla introducing her beau (Angelus) to the Master. Darla tries impressing him with her boyfriend's killing record, but Angelus doesn't warm to his new father-in-law ("Darla").
During the S2 Darla arc, Angel tries to redeem Darla out of a misplaced sense of filial loyalty. Eventually, even Lorne warns Angel that he's about to jump the track.
Angel is offered a choice between preventing Darla and Drusilla from killing a roomful of Wolfram & Hart employees, or simply walking away. Angel decides the lawyers made their own bed and leaves them.
Ultimate Evil: The Wolf, Ram and Hart (AKA the "Senior Partners").
Undercover When Alone: Knox acts puzzled when a large sarcophagus gets delivered to his lab. Turns out he not only knew it was coming, he ordered it, for it contained the essence of his god.
Unusually Uninteresting Sight: Ryan Anderson's reaction to Angel shoving him out of the path of a speeding car. Noticing the bloody scrape on Angel's shoulder, Ryan, who seems completely unfazed by his brush with death, asks Angel if he's going to cry. This is an early sign that this kid belongs in a padded room.
Van Helsing Hate Crimes: Most prominently seen in "The Old Gang of Mine", in which Gunn's old vampire-hunting crew begins hunting anything non-human.
Villainous Demotivator: The head vampire in "War Zone", Knox, claps his buddy Ty on the shoulder and says its not his fault for getting ambushed by Gunn's crew. Right before he stakes him.
Virgin Sacrifice: Magnus Bryce has this in mind for his daughter, Virginia. It didn't work because he didn't watch her closely enough—she'd lost her "purity" a long time ago.
Connor crosses his Moral Event Horizon when he agrees to slaughter a female virgin, furthering Evil Cordy's goals.
Viva Las Vegas: "The House Always Wins" from Season 4, filmed on location in Sin City.
Voice Changeling: The Ethros demon possessing Ryan displays this ability. It taunts Wesley in a voice identical to his own, reminding him of his unceremonious sacking from the Watcher's Council; then it strikes out at Angel by channeling Doyle's voice, playing on Angel's guilt. And also makes him angry.
Walk In Chime In: When Angel warns his buddies about how Buffy would react if she found out he'd been stalking her in Sunnydale, Buffy pops into his office to finish his thought. "A little upset." Oh boy.
Happens quite a lot in Season 4, when the main arc requires the cast to reunite and spout exposition quickly.
Pretty much a Running Gag with Angel throughout the series.
Wall of Weapons: Angel's basement in Season 1. After he joins agrees to run Wolfram & Hart, Angel's office comes furnished with one.
Was Once a Man: The end of season five episode, Damage; after Dana the insane slayer has been carted off, Angel and Spike have a sombre discussion in the latter's hospital room about the nature of evil:
Spike: The tingling in my forearms tells me she's too far gone to help. She's one of us now. She's a monster.
"Well Done, Son!" Guy: Trevor Lockley was always cold to Kate, having shut down all emotion following his wife's death. Despite this, Kate is deeply distraught at the murder of her father. In response to Trevor's death, she begins to hate all paranormal creatures (especially vampires) and turns openly-hostile towards Angel.
"The Prodigal" is interspersed with flashbacks to Angel's upbringing in Ireland, revealing a not-dissimilar relationship with his own father.
Roger Wyndam-Pryce manages to wear down his son's spirit every time he opens his mouth.
WHAM Episode: For starters, "Reunion", "Reprise", "Sleep Tight"/"Forgiving", "Home", A Hole In The World".
Whammy Bid: Played with: The item for sale: Cordelia's visions, or more specifically, her eyeballs. To stall for time, Cordelia incites a bidding war by claiming to be able to see the locations of buried treasure. This escalates until one of the two highest bidders kills the other one. Finally, a female attorney for Wolfram & Hart closes the auction with a ridiculous low Whammy Bid of $30,000.
What Happened to the Mouse?: It's never clarified as to whether the whole Universe-going-all-whackadoo-due-to-two-vampire-champions-with-a-soul-existing thing was a legitimate calamity, or just some hoodoo that Lindsey pulled off to put on a show. Then there's also the part where the Senior Partners were only able to stabilize the effects "temporarily". It's never mentioned again.
What the Hell, Hero?: The rest of Angel Investigations calls Angel out after he lets Darla and Drusilla massacre a lot of Wolfram and Hart lawyers.
Where Does He Get All Those Wonderful Toys?: Have fun waiting around for an explanation, because there isn't one. Angel ditches most of his cool accessories in the second season, though a few random ones still pop up now and again.
Gunn's original street crew included one guy who's armed with a flamethrower. Where did they get that?
Wesley's collapsible wrist-swords came from an Arms Dealer who specialized in esoteric weaponry (seen in "Lineage"). Presumably Angel ordered from the same guy.
Wicked Cultured: Most of the high-class baddies on this series are fond of classical music — even Lindsey. In their first scene together, he and Darla shoot the breeze about Frédéric Chopin.
Marcus the vampire plays a Broken Record of Mozart's Symphony #41 to interrogate Angel.
Wife-Basher Basher: The Cold Open for "In the Dark" follows Angel saving a woman from her drug addict boyfriend, who Angel proceeds to pound unconscious. Ouch.
Wilhelm Scream: Heard at the beginning of "The Cautionary Tale of Numero Cinco", when the redshirt is tossed into the air.
Willfully Weak: It's established that Angel is stronger in Game Face, and that he sometimes holds back rather than scare off the people he's trying to save. Occasionally, a character will punch him repeatedly in order to make him vamp out. This happened once with Buffy (in "Graduation Day"), and again with adult Connor.
"Guise Will Be Guise" hints at Angel's inner fear. In a stick-fighting match with a hermit, Angel repeatedly gets beatenback while his opponent asks him why he's holding back. "Because if I let it, it'll kill you."
The Season Two finale puts Angel on Pylea, an alternate dimension where his Game Face manifests as a crazed, spiked monster. He accidentally switches over while trying to protect Fred, and doesn't revert back until he catches his reflection in a pool of water. The sight of it traumatizes Angel so much that he has a nervous breakdown, and refuses to fight anyone else.
Doyle has much the same problem: He's ashamed of his demon half and will even allow himself to be beaten to a pulp rather than transform. This despite Doyle being practically invulnerable in demon form.
Wire Fu: One of the things that made the fights in this show more distinct from Buffy
Worf Had the Flu: Faith's big fight with Angelus in season four. Angel finally wins a fight with a Slayer... who's previously injured and high on magic heroin.
Wins? Try lost. As Faith said, "Kicked his ass."
Somewhat brilliantly applied in-universe by Hamilton. Hamilton completely avoids Illyria until she (partly at Hamilton's instruction) gets zapped with a depowering weapon. He then mocks and unloads on a extremely depressed, Crash Bandicoot-playing "big scary Old One" and chalks it up. Notable here because the last time Illyria was around, she was at least two tiers higher in power, was presumably feeling a hell of a lot better, and would have eaten the Senior Partners themselves.
Year Inside, Hour Outside: After coming back from the Oracle's realm, Doyle assumes the incantation never worked as Angel only appeared gone for a moment.
You Are in Command Now: Lawson is briefly put in charge of a captured German submarine following the murder of his captain by Spike. Once aboard, Angel assumes control of the sub thanks to the command codes provided for him by the U.S. military.
The same thing happens to Angel again in "The Prodigal": Realizing Kate's father is in danger, Angel rushes over to his apartment, but is unable to convince Trevor to invite him in. Angel is then forced to watch as Trevor is killed by his vampire associates, who were invited inside a mere minute earlier.
The good guys seem to be constantly running late in Season Four. Angel and co. fail to catch The Beast before he blots out the sun, prevent the deaths of the Ra-Tet (one of whom is massacred right under their noses), or stop Cordelia from birthing Jasmine. In the case of the latter, Angel makes it in time to stop Cordelia and raises his sword to kill her, but hesitates for a crucial moment.
You Are What You Hate: In the end, Holtz was engaging in actions that were the reason he hated Angelus and Darla in the first place.
You Can Keep Her: Jack McNamara steps a bit too close to the red line in "The Ring", giving Angel an opportunity to grab him without disintegrating. When Jack's brother (Darin) shows up, Angel demands to be set free or he'll break Jack's neck. Darin casually pulls a gun and shoots his brother, and Angel is knocked out by a barrage of cattle prods.
You Killed My Father: Adopted father in this case, but Holtz kills himself to deliberately set Connor against Angel because of this reasoning.
You Know I'm Black, Right?: Cordelia calls up Willow (from Buffy) to inquire about Harmony's weird behavior... before learning that Harmony's been turned into a vampire during her absence. Along with some other developments.
Cordelia:(on the phone) Oh! Harmony's a vampire! All this time I thought she'd become a great big lesbo! (beat) Oh. Really? ...well, that's great! Good for you!
You Look Familiar: Harriet Doyle's rebound boyfriend, Richard Straley, is played by Carlos Jacott. He previously played Ken, another (seemingly) milquetoast villain on Season 3 of Buffy ("Anne") and would later appear in the first two episodes of Firefly as Lawrence Dobson.
The guy who played Knox previously played Holden in Buffy ("Conversations With Dead People") and Kal Penn played an obnoxious college student in "Beer Bad" before appearing in Angel as a guy with an exposed brain.
The "Mustard" guy (executive producer David Fury) from "Once More With Feeling" reappears on "Smile Time" as the human puppet.
Weatherby, of the Watchers' Council's Special Ops members, later played a similarly ruthless agent as one of the "Hands of Blue" in Firefly.
You Remind Me of X: Penn selects his victims based on their physical resemblance to his family members. Like Angel says, he's "been getting back at (his) father for over 200 years."
Holland delivers this spiel to Lindsey in "Blind Date", implying that he once had an Ignored Epiphany of his own.
Faith's journey is an obvious parallel to Angel's, even moreso when she becomes The Atoner. Angel's rehabilitation of her is a Call Back to his earlier (thwarted) attempt to do so in the third season of Buffy.
You Said You Would Let Them Go: Wesley's reaction to the Watcher Council's Ops Team after they go back on their word to protect Angel from harm. Ha ha....no. ("Sanctuary")
You Will Be Assimilated: Despite his non-threatening appearance, Barney is an auctioneer of stolen body parts from demons and other empowered beings.
You Taste Delicious: Lorne, after he's obliged to swill down some of Sebassis' favorite beverage.
Your Magic's No Good Here: When the gang goes to Pylea, Angel is surprised to find out he can be under the sun without bursting into flames. Less good is that putting on his vampiric "game-face" is replaced by a uncontrollable berserker monster, thus his combat potential is actually a bit lower than on Earth (unless he risks hurting innocents).
Your Princess Is in Another Castle: This is the gist of Season Four. By episode 16, Angel and co. have bested Wolfram & Hart, the demon hordes, the Beast, and Angelus, and it's looking like the job is finally sewn up. — O hai Preggo Cordy.
As Angel later learns, the heroes didn't really accomplish anything. Jasmine was busy snuffing out every supervillain in L.A., because she wants to be the only game in town.
After Angel confesses to being a vampire, Rebecca reacts in true Hollywood fashion: by listing off famous actors who have played vampires (Bela Lugosi and Gary Oldman). Angel remarks under his breath that "Frank Langella was the only performance I believed..."