troperville

tools

toys

SubpagesAnalysis
Main
PlayingWith
Quotes

main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
Analysis: A Degree in Useless
There are numerous subtleties to this trope depending on the degree that you're attempting to ridicule; English, Theology, Philosophy, History, purely abstract Mathematics and other Classical intellectual subjects tend to be academically respected and prestigious but financially weak, unless when these courses are do used as a preparation course for a vocational degree (e.g. Philosophy as pre-Law course). Less traditional degrees such as Sociology, Media Studies, Leisure Studies etc are ridiculed for both their uselessness in employability and the lack of intellectual scope in their subject matter. Vocational degrees tend to be the subject of ridicule mostly based on how respected and "realistic/concrete" the profession is; Natural Sciences, Engineering and Architecture graduates are generally off limits, but Journalism, Political Science and Law are fair game.

This stereotype was reinforced by the expensive value of education today. There is an epidemic of victims of student loans that could not be repaid, deterring people from borrowing cash only to spend those for useless degrees. The more the tuition fee hike goes up, the more there is a large drop in the percentage of students going for degrees in the humanities. Statistically speaking, these degrees are a lot less likely to get you a job (especially a good one) than most other ones, but is still is possible. People nowadays view education as a form of capital investment rather than an intellectual venture, hence the rise in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics) Education and Business courses, which are overtaking more and more "unnecessary" subjects. The elite high schools of ancient Athens (such as Plato's Academy) and the Enlightenment used to have Philosophy and Logic, but ever since the Industrial Revolution and rise of public education, STEM Education took precedence and eliminated a lot of "unnecessary" subjects, even though Logic is needed to comprehend Mathematics.

Another variable contributing to the fall of humanities courses is the rise of self-studying and the Internet; one can self-learn Philosophy by searching on the Internet, downloading eBooks or living like Socrates, and one can learn English Literature in a more entertaining form through This Very Wiki. Indeed, discussing the Meaning of Life with your friends over a Sunday cup of tea or studying Hegelian Deconstruction via the media examples provided by TV Tropes may be more satisfying and cost-saving than overspending on a degree. A major in Philosophy is unnecessary to become The Philosopher; after all, Socrates and Jesus were poor and didn't need cash to spread their ideas. As a result, humanities degrees, despite being academically respected and prestigious, have acquired the same public status as Conspicuous Consumption (I have this prestigious Liberal Arts major because I'm an aristocratic emokid rich enough to afford it), and expensive colleges are reserved for more important and pragmatic courses such as Technology and Business.

Sometimes averted in real life, at least for people who get humanities degrees from respected schools. It's not really surprising that world-changing historical figures who spread revolutionary philosophical ideas attend, well, Philosophy. Writers of fiction, however, tend to ignore the fact that such a thing is possible, depicting anybody who didn't choose a highly-profitable and/or Business-related major as a penniless loser, despite how many fiction writers actually had a degree in "useless". Self-Deprecation perhaps?

A few notable real-life aversions:

  This page has not been indexed. Please choose a satisfying and delicious index page to put it on.  



random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
7815
43