Alternative Character Interpretation: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
The Mane Six
Twilight Sparkle's difficulty in social situations (most clearly seen at the start of season 1), her love of studying and reading, her knowledge of magic, and her Super OCD all point to her being an aspie or a high-functioning autistic. The WMG page and the Princesses section has more speculation.
Humanized fanart of her tends to depict her as black, Asian, or Indian (mostly following the variouscommonstereotypes). This doubles as a Genius Bonus as well: horses with dark coats in real life actually do have dark skin underneath.
"Lesson Zero" gives more insight into Twilight's personality, specifically, her deepest fears: She's absolutely terrified of failure and the thought of not meeting the expectations of others (a trait further solidified by "The Crystal Empire"). Add her general social awkwardness, the fact that she always wanted to throw a slumber party (even though she and her friends are now adults) and even the lyrics of the theme song ("I used to wonder what friendship could be...") and you get the idea that Twilight's early childhood was a less then pleasant experience (victim of bullying perhaps?). Her obsession with studying and being a good student may have been to avoid the pain of being alone and friendless and to validate her own self-worth. Now that she has real friends, she's completely terrified of losing them and reverting back to the lonely and scared filly she once was.
The events of "The Cutie Mark Chronicles" have lead some to speculate that Twilight's obsessive studying and list-making are all about retaining control of her magic. Basically prior to the day of the test she was studying to be like Celestia, after the test she's studying so she never again turns someone she loves into a potted plant.
On that note, where exactly did Princess Celestia get the egg that Spike hatched from? Did she conjure it up with magic, or find it abandoned somewhere? Or did she literally overpower a dragon mother and steal her soon-to-be child? The fact that "Dragon Quest" gives the set-up to answer this question but never delivers in the end only raises further questions...
Rainbow Dash's tomboyish nature, boyish voice, and rainbow motif have caused some people to come to certain conclusions.
Rainbow Dash is often implied to be a Lazy Bum, yet she has also been shown working her rump off when it's important to her (such as constantly practicing her moves) or to Ponyville (she's a team leader during Winter Wrap-Up). Is she lazy, or is she bored by what she sees as trivial duties and consequently slacks off? Given her preternatural skill in tasks she's interested in, such as being the only pony in recorded history to perform a Sonic Rainboom, she might be Brilliant, but Lazy.
One YouTube commenter had the idea that Rainbow Dash has Winston Churchill complex - she equates affection with achievement and assumes that if she isn't the best at what she's doing, her friends won't love/respect her, which would possibly explain her fear of failing/losing and her increasingly erratic behaviour in "Sonic Rainboom" and "The Mysterious Mare Do-Well." This could also explain why she idolises the Wonderbolts as much as she does.
Pinkie Pie being a Fourth Wall Observer with Medium Awareness who ignores it when it suits her is an ACI so widespread most fans assume it's true. Granted she does interrupt the Iris Out on two separate occasions, and many times she appears to look directly at the audience (Word Of God says these are coincidences... at least they used to be, though sometimes in seasons two and three these fourth wall references seem to be intentional).
After "Party of One" it became very common for fans to depict Pinkie as judging her self-worth entirely by her parties and how much other ponies enjoy them, which is used to explain why she's so eager to be happy and (literally) bouncy all of the time. Less common is the interpretation that she is outright mentally ill, with manic-depression and schizophrenia the usual suspects.
Another point of evidence to the former theory, in her "Smile" song, Pinkie sings "There's one thing that makes me happy and makes my whole life worthwhile / And that's when I talk to my friends and get them to smile."
Another interpretation is that Pinkie Pie is immortal. She grew up on a rock farm because that was an actual job during Discord's reign, and he made her as weird as she is to cause strife within her family. The rainbow blast and rainbow she saw afterwards wasn't from a Sonic Rainboom, it was from Celestia and Luna using the Elements of Harmony to defeat Discord.So that really was how Equestria was made.
Some fans have noticed that Pinkie's abilities (Offscreen Teleportation, obtaining objects from nowhere, ignoring the rules of magic, use of Wrong Context Magic) are very similar to Discord's, leading them to conclude that she is a demi-goddess of chaos like how Discord is a full god of chaos.
Fluttershy's possession of the Smart Ball in "Suited For Success" has led to her exhibiting similar behavior, and that level of knowledge about a number of fields (from writing to gaming to politics), in various fanfics.
Due to an offhand comment in "Over A Barrel", some people think she's obsessed with becoming a tree. (Her disguise in "Hurricane Fluttershy" probably only added fuel to that particular fire.)
Was Fluttershy's actions during "Putting Your Hoof Down" simply her trying to be more assertive, or her letting out her true feelings?
Speaking of "Putting Your Hoof Down", did the entire town of Ponyville just happen to take about twelve levels of jerk-ass or, since this is the only time we've seen Fluttershy interact with them in general, is this how they always treat her? It might explain why she tends to prefer the company of animals.
Because of season one's finale, Fluttershy has been thought of as more than a little unstable due to her rather terrifying outburst.
Additionally, because of the numerous situations in which Fluttershy kicks extreme amounts of flank (making a dragon cry, staring down a cockatrice, giving belly rubs to Cerberus, counter-trolling the spirit of chaos) it's common to depict her as the scariest pony in Equestria, and that those who know her know to be cautious around her.
One popular theory is that Fluttershy witnessed her father being eaten by a dragon, traumatizing her. Her mother then pushed and forced her into all the best flight schools and camps, not noticing (or possibly, not caring) that Fluttershy was a weak flyer, causing her to fall behind...
In "Sweet and Elite", the behavior of the Mane Cast outside of Rarity lends itself to some speculation. For instance, was Twilight genuinely ignorant that Rarity was ditching her and the rest to hobnob with the Canterlot Elite? Or was she feigning ignorance to help Rarity save face? Or was their immediate act to crash and trash the Garden Party them being spiteful and they were feigning niceness? Or were they just drunk (we don't see Spike, so they might have been serving intoxicating beverages).
Apple Bloom's friendship with Twist. Did Apple Bloom abandon Twist for more popular friends? Did Twist abandon Apple Bloom after getting her cutie mark? Or do they hang out off-screen because Twist can't be a Cutie Mark Crusader?
When playing the fan game Story Of The Blanks, CR says Sweetie Belle is Rarity's daughter instead of sister, jokingly. (A Shout Out to Gavalanche's fancomics where Rarity is really Sweetie Belle's abusive mother who prefers to be called her sister.)
Scootaloo is the only member of the Cutie Mark Crusaders who has had no familial connections shown or even hinted at, and is rarely seen apart from her two closest friends. Additionally, she's a pegasus unable to fly for anything but short distances, and is rarely seen without her crude wooden scooter. As such, Scootaloo is often depicted as being stuck in an abusive family, or as a homeless orphan.
Also it's known that pegasi have to learn to fly. So far Scootaloo has not shown any interest in flying. Does she not want to fly? It would be assumed that Pegasi have to learn from birth or would it be just a case of turning old enough?
Season four confirms an episode where Scootaloo is bullied for this, and it is implied she should have learned to fly by her age, so age is likely not her excuse.
Some humanized versions of Scootaloo have her with a prosthetic limb; the implication being that Scootaloo can't fly due to a disability. (Scootaloo being disabled was something thrown around during the series' development, but it may or may not have been abandoned - while she has been shown to slightly hover, it's simply short bursts of flight where her wings rapidly buzz like a hummingbird.)
Another theory gaining some popularity is that Scootaloo is the product of a mixed marriage and for whatever reason-death, divorce, etc.-the Pegasus parent is a missing parent, leaving Scootaloo to be raised by an Earth Pony or Unicorn, neither of which can teach her how to fly.
The only thing that brings this theory into question is Pound Cake, the Pegasus son of the Cakes, two Earth Ponies, who's shown to fly rather well at a month old. Then again, he could be a prodigy. His unicorn sister is certainly implied to be one.
According to this fanfic, Pound Cake would lose his flying ability once he got bigger, because his wings wouldn't be able to carry him. So it wouldn't be too hard to believe that Scootaloo's wings can't carry her full weight yet.
PrincessCelestia's characterization can vary greatly depending on who you ask or what fanfiction or fanart you look at. Canonically she's a wise and loving Big Good, but in the fandom she is very prone to Ron the Death Eater characterizations.
Some see her as a Troll, perhaps as an effect of her immortality and position making her day-to-day life very dull and thus she needs to have fun sometimes. She does demonstrate a more mischievous and fun side sometimes, such as inviting the Mane Six to the Grand Galloping Gala in the hopes they'll liven up the boring tradition for once. While she can still be loving and wise while this way, some fans go for full Jerkass God who toys with her subjects for her own amusement.
There's also the interpretation that she's full evil, ruling a Crapsaccharine World as a vicious tyrant who enforces conformity, segregation and control. These can vary from her being a Knight Templar who sees such control as needed to keep Equestria from falling apart, to Despotism Justifies the Means, focused on keeping her control over the land by any means necessary.
Some fans have noted that devastating, highly important events in Equestrian history are either completely unknown to the general populace (Discord's reign, the disappearance of the Crystal Empire) or only known through inaccurate myths (Nightmare Moon's longest night). They thus speculate that Celestia regularly alters official histories to remove undesirable elements, which in turn has speculations as to whether she does this out of misguided benevolence or a malicious attempt to hide her own mistakes.note One alternative to these alternatives is that she just lets the natural distortion of historical events happen, and everyone usually thinks she's too busy or important to fact check with her. In Nightmare Moon's case, who's going to ask her about the time she banished her own sister and risk reopening old wounds?
The "Molestia" interpretation is so common it comes with its own sub-categories; from a shiftless layabout who has grown bored of her duties and dodges administration to watch porn, to a very open but harmless nympho with a light BDSM fetish (the most popular, thanks to the infamous Ask Princess Molestia blog), to a serial-rapist and pedophile.
Celestia as a Broken Bird is a less common but still prevalent interpretation. The theory goes that fighting against Discord, forced to banish her sister, and spending a thousand years defending Equestria from frequent threats all alone, while everypony else dies of old age, left her bitter and permanently hiding behind The Queenly Mask.
Speculation about Celestia's relationship with Twilight is rampant, with interpretations ranging from polite but distant professionalism, to a close friendship, to Twilight being Celestia's only friend aside from Luna, to outright romance. A common theme in nearly all of them though is Twilight having (or used to have) a crush on Celestia.
Is Nightmare Moon really a Green-Eyed MonsterMad God or was she banished for leading the ponies into an ultimately failed civil war against Celestia's rule? Combined with the aforementioned "Tyrantlestia" interpretation is the theory that Nightmare Moon was the hero and is only the victim of Written by the Winners.
It isn't even clear what Nightmare Moon WAS, given that once the Elements of Harmony were used on her, she reverted to Princess Luna, who is far more mild-mannered. Was she brainwashed by the elements, or was Nightmare Moon some sort of possessing force that Celestia herself could not extricate? The IDW comics seem to indicate that Nightmare Moon was the result of an outside force, given that they possess Rarity and make her their new Nightmare Queen.
Celestia and Luna being Physical Goddesses is itself an ACI; there are numerous hints for it, most significantly their dominion over celestial bodies, the aspects of nature they represent, and their extensive lifespan, but the actual word god/goddess has never been used in the series. Less common is the interpretation that they are "merely" extremely powerful ponies, or two of the few remaining alicorns after their race was nearly rendered extinct.
This is further complicated by the presence of Princess Cadance. Is she also a Physical Goddess? We're told she's the niece of Princess Celestia, but she couldn't be Luna's child since Luna spent the last thousand years in the moon so who are her parents? Is she also immortal and will outlive Shining Armor? Does she even have a blood relation to the Royal Pony Sisters? (It should be noted that Cadance was originally conceived as a unicorn but made an alicorn because of Executive Meddling.)
With the introduction of "Age Spells" in "Magic Duel", spells that can alter the age of the target but can only be cast by the most powerful of casters, Princess Celestia and Princess Luna's immortality may not even be inherent but the product of repeated self-cast Age Spells (which would also explain Luna's difference in appearance between her first and second appearance).
Then Twilight became an alicorn, also making her a princess, bringing another whole host of questions. Do all alicorns "earn" their ascension this way? If so, how did the other three do so? Can it be given as some sort of reward or a Enlightenment Superpower? Is Twilight now immortal? And if she is, is this a way to give Celestia some more company for her eternal life?
Twilight Sparkle And The Crystal Heart Spell expanded on Princess Cadence's backstory and where she came from: It is revealed that Cadence was originally an orphaned pegasus that was adopted by an earth pony village. A Wicked Witch by the name of Prismia attacked the village by draining all their love for each other. Cadence somehow defeated her and was magically transported to the same "Twilight Zone" Twilight went to when she completed Starswirl's unfinished spell. She met Princess Celestia there and was then turned into an alicorn, adopted by Celestia and was made a princess herself. Whether this is canon or not is up in the air right now, but this is the closest thing to a backstory she has so far.
Although this in itself is extremely flimsy because she managed to comparatively do far less then what Twilight did to achieve the same thing. Twilight had to prove that she had the magical capabilities to become Celestia's student and spent years in that position, she defeated no less then four threats to Equestria, two of those were Physical Gods, restored a previously lost part of Equestria and finally completed a spell that was supposed to be her hero's magnum opus. Cadence barely did anything (defeated a single witch who was only threatening a single village) and somehow she ended up being adopted by the ruler of the country and granted goddess-hood.
Did she barely do anything? Or was it, as implied by her Cutie Mark, her destiny to someday help to save and go on to rule the Crystal Empire, and becoming an alicorn merely the optimal method through which she could attain such a position?
Is The Great and PowerfulTRRRIXIIEEE a Jerkass, or insecure? Was Ponyville a lousy stop? Did the Mane Cast have the right to interrupt her show and performance with heckling? There's also a very large part of the fanbase that remains adamant that she is just as powerful, if not more powerful than Twilight, despite "Boast Busters" showing that her special talent is in stage performance.
Others have suggested the exact opposite. One fanfic, The Liar, portrays Trixie as a run-of-the-mill con artist. It suggests that Trixie has NO magical ability, that her powers are all based off of the machines she uses in her act (including powdered poison joke to disrupt attempts to show her up,) and that her special talent is really the ability to tell the perfect lies.) (Fair warning: This fic reads in reverse chronological order.)
A common fanon portrayal of Trixie depicts her Miles Gloriosus streak as a mask over a Dark and Troubled Past with a side order of woobie. (It's quite possible you get bonus points for the degree of cruelty with which you kill off the parent who inspired her to start a magic act.)
Others have suggested that Trixie suffers from an Inferiority Superiority Complex; she didn't make it in magic school because she was a bully whose only real talent was using her telekinesis to pick on others compared to other unicorns that can do much more useful magic. Similar to common fan theories about Applebloom's nemesis Diamond Tiara, this theory holds that Trixie is such a showboating Jerk Ass because her talent is nothing special and she's desperate to convince herself and everypony else otherwise.
Perhaps Diamond Tiara's bullying is her lashing out at others because her special talent is merely wearing jewelry, possibly on the issues of Truth in Television beauty pageant attendees.
Similarly, Silver Spoon may be a stereotypical "queen bee" because she's insecure about being rich and useless, hence her cutie mark.
Despite her rhetoric against Blank Flanks, the only ponies Diamond Tiara is ever seen bullying are Applebloom and those who hang around Applebloom. Maybe she's less a generic bully and hates Applebloom specifically (and by extension, those she's hanging around).
Diamond Tiara is usually thought to be a simple Alpha Bitch (although see the Trixie example for one way some people interpret her more sympathetically), her friend Silver Spoon is sometimes suggested to be a much nicer filly who is mean to Apple Bloom because she's imitating her best friend. Silver Spoon is noted to genuinely care about Diamond Tiara's feelings, seeing how she tried to cheer her up at the end of "Call of the Cutie," and was also the very first in the class to applaud Granny Smith's story about how the Apple Family founded Ponyville despite Diamond Tiara refusing to.
Near nothing is known about Discord, and so speculation about him runs rampant:
Is he the Anthropomorphic Personification of chaos that's just hard-wired to want chaos, just as the ponies are hard-wired to want harmony and peace? If so not only is he unwilling but incapable of maintaining anything resembling a moral compass; even if he could feel empathy for the beings he torments for his own amusement, he wouldn't be able to maintain it long enough for it to make any difference. By this interpretation, he is The Sociopath because he's hard-wired to be incapable of internalizing emotions that could let him live in harmony with others; by his very nature, Discord must consider himself separate from and in conflict with the rest of existence. Keep Calm And Flutter On seems to suggest he can understand and even enjoy friendship, however his selfishness and chaos-mongering tendencies have always prevented him from ever having a real friend.
Is Cheerilee correct when she called him a Draconequus and there is an entire species like him? If so, is he the Last of His Kind?
Do he and Celestia have a more amiable history? Many fans think that the two were close friends or even lovers long ago, and that their falling out has at least something to do with his tyrannical intentions. Their dialog hints at a deeper relationship of some kind that we're only able to speculate about, and the way they brush off each other is very similar to the way Q (who Discord is based off of) would ruffle the feathers of Captain Picard. The fact that Picard and Q had a metric ton of Ho Yay adds fuel.
Were the Windigos evil spirits intentionally causing the ponies suffering and grief, or non-sentient beasts who were merely feeding and their natural way of survival made them a dangerous threat?
The same episode made people claim, as a joke, that Fluttershy was clairvoyant.
Do the Changelings need to feed on love to survive, or is it merely a luxury that they use to become stronger? Are they innocent, non-malicious drones who can't help that their food source is draining the life out of ponies (often combined with the "their queen is a Complete Monster" interpretation for extra Woobie points) or are they as aware as their queen and just don't care?
Fans are somewhat divided over whether or not they managed to survive their fate at the end of the episode (though in the comic series, they do).
Some people have interpreted King Sombra's animalistic behavior as a sign his defeat and long imprisonment have driven him insane. While he was a nasty person before that, this would explain why he acts so feral and inequine.
Celestia outright states he was "turned to shadow" when he was overthrown. The phrase "a shadow of his former self" springs to mind.
Lightning Dust (from "Wonderbolts Academy"): an arrogant, self-absorbed victory hound who only respected Rainbow Dash because she was a Worthy Opponent or an enthusiastic cadet who was told to give her best and went too far unintentionally? Spitfire also could be said to hold some of the blame in Lightning Dust's overzealous attitude as she encouraged her behavior and never stepped in once it started getting out of hand.
Granny Smith. Is her eccentricities just "old people are funny humor" or waaay back in her youth was she the Pinkie Pie of her social circle? The Zap Apple prep stuff she's shown to do in "Family Appreciation Day" support this. Pinkie often knows what she is doing even if it seems strange, and it would explain how Granny discovered things like Zap Apples prefer polka dots; she did Pinkieesque things and kept doing them when they made the jam better. Besides, running off into the most dangerous forest in the world alone at night is not very sensible.
Blueblood's behaviour at the Gala has been interpreted by some as him recognizing Rarity's dream, and was screwing with her because he's met countless other mares with the same vapid dream and he's not willing to play the part.
Fanon has four general depictions of Derpy Hooves (also known as Ditzy Doo or Derpy Doo). She can be an ordinary pony with the same kind of problems as everypony else who's just clumsy and misunderstood because of her eyes (not that popular, but made moreso by Doctor Whooves and Assistant), an airheaded but well-meaning and perfectly functional klutz (this seems to be the most common interpretation, and the one which most closely matches "The Last Roundup"), a kind pony with genuine mental disabilities who speaks in broken and (seemingly) senseless sentences that may or may not make sense in hindsight, or a complete idiot (and everything in between). It really depends on the artist/writer/etc.
Is Shining Armor an effective captain? Sure, he's immensely powerful and a useful asset, but that would make him deserving of being a special operative, not a captain of the guard, as captains of the guard are supposed to lead and train their troops. Despite deploying their troops in a state of readiness, having a professionally trained army, and having some warning as the changelings bashed against the shield, the Royal Guard lost the capital in about 10 minutes.
There's also the possibility of Nepotism. Perhaps he was promoted to captain by Princess Celestia because of his relationship to Twilight Sparkle or Princess Cadance.
The land of Equestria as a whole might be a less-than utopian autocracy where the unicorns stay in power thanks to their control over magic and learning, and the pony population as a whole oppresses and even enslaves the other hoofed races.
The posters in this discussion thread analyze the show and eventually come to the conclusion that Equestria is basically a fascist utopia, rife with rigid caste systems, engineered environments, slavery, class imbalance, all controlled at the beck and call of an all-powerful, godlike being that somehow manages to keep her subjects ignorant of the underlying problems of their society.
Another theory is that Equestria used to be a facist caste system because of the the Hearth's Warming Eve play. It is the only time we see the ponies divided along Earth pony/pegasus/unicorn lines and that is explicitly set in the past, implying that modern Equestria is much more racially balanced. If the unicorns somehow controlled all the learning and knowledge, then why is the most prominent teacher character an Earth pony? Also, if the unicorns oppressed the earth ponies in a 'first and second class citizen' manner, then why is the mayor of Ponyvile an earth pony and the Film Flam Brothers run out of town by angry customers?
Just who exactly is benefiting from the friendship reports that Twilight sends to the Princess? Are they intended solely to help with Twilight's personal growth as she learns more about friendship? Or are they for Princess Celestia as a way to understand the common Ponyvillers and how to interact with them? Or are they for Luna?
"Magical Mystery Cure" heavily implies that all of Twilight's training, Friendship Reports included, were to make her ready to become an alicorn.
In "Sweet And Elite", Twilight says to Rarity that she understands her going to the other party as being work related. However, they immediately afterwards crash the party and make complete asses out of themselves and proudly declare their association with her. Was it merely all in good fun, or were Rarity's friends being spiteful over Rarity lying to them?
The nature of the dragons as a species is widely debated. Common interpretations are that wild dragons tend to be Jerkasses and Spike's a Nice Guy because he was raised by ponies, while others suggest that adult dragons are powerful and dangerous when provoked but also intelligent and non-malicious, in which case they are the antagonists because we keep seeing them at their worst; the purple dragon had suffered a personal crisis, the red dragon was unreasonable because it was exhausted and the Mane Six kept interrupting his nap, the green dragon overreacted because he thought Spike wanted to steal all his food, and the teenage dragons were immature idiots that hadn't learned how to behave.
Are the duplicates from the Mirror Pool mindless constructs, reflections of Pinkie Pie's surface personality, or simply innocent children with adult bodies? The tone of the episode changes greatly depending on which interpretation the viewer uses.
After the brief fallout between them at the end of "A Canterlot Wedding, part 1", much speculation arose as to whether Twilight's friends, brother, and mentor were sincerely remorseful on how they abandoned her in the wedding episode, or whether it was a cover-up. Some people considered the former based on how things are in season 3, but for others who considered that the only person who apologized was Applejack note Although they were in a middle of an invasion., and Celestia's form of apology can look broken, they tend to say they were just saving their own flanks.
How much of what Shining Armor said to Twilight was him being brainwashed, and how much of it was what he really meant?
Did Twilight's friends, mentor, and brother really abandon and shun her after her outburst until her vindication, or did they walk away (possibly for only a few minutes) to give everyone time to cool down, only to later be unable to find her? One of Equestria's most talented unicorns couldn't have been kidnapped, especially not in the middle of a secure castle on high alert, so she must have left on her own. Worrisome, but there's no reason to think she's in danger and they can all have a long talk after the wedding.
When discussing the above event, the excuse people often say to justify them leaving Twilight was that they were thinking she was jealous. Jealous over whom? Her brother.