Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Valiona's Stalker Diary of The Stalking Zuko Series
Valiona2014-07-25 22:40:39

Go To


SZ Chapter 1: The Observations Begin

Stalking Zuko

"You might have everyone else buying your... "transformation", but you and I both know you've struggled with doing the right thing in the past. So let me tell you something right now. You make one step backward, one slip up, give me one reason to think you might hurt Aang, and you won't have to worry about your destiny anymore. Because I'll make sure your destiny ends, Right then and there."
Katara

The first installment of the fic, Stalking Zuko, begins a few days after Avatar: The Last Airbender "The Western Air Temple", in which Zuko has been accepted into the Gaang, save for Katara.

Katara begins stalking and writing a diary on Zuko in order to see if she can catch him doing anything suspicious and learn his weaknesses. She calls him "Subject" to keep it confidential(although he'd know in a moment if he found her diary) distance herself from him, saying that "Subject will not endear himself to me again!" In any case, for the sake of clarity, and because I don't do things Katara's way, he and all other characters will be called by their proper names.

Katara then writes about Zuko's mother Ursa (whose name Katara doesn't know), conceding that she's missing and might be dead, but Katara thinks she got tired of Zuko's whining and ran off, which, even considering she admits it's "bitchy", is a low blow. It's also somewhat Harsher in Hindsight considering that in The Search, it turns out that Ursa abandoned the memories of a children for a new life, believing that she would never see them again, although I am actually more sympathetic toward Ursa than most.

Katara then notices that Zuko wakes up early, gets along well with Toph, and trains Aang in spite of the fact that Aang isn't the most diligent student and Zuko's own firebending is off. These details are nice touches, and appropriate considering this is about Katara's observations of Zuko. Katara is about to engage in some schadenfreude regarding Zuko's inability to firebend, but notices that he never smiles, an interestingly somber moment at the end of the observations.

In the next scene, apparently the next day, Katara is stuck doing the dishes, when Zuko comes in to help, over Katara's objections, and after some exchanged barbs, with Katara noting Zuko's betrayal at Ba Sing Se in their diary (it's perhaps a misnomer, as it can be argued that it was a case of Zuko choosing to keep opposing the Gaang, rather than choosing to help and going back on his word), Katara reluctantly accepts his help.

A word about the dialogue. Much of it, at least so far, appears to be Katara telling us about the conversations she's had, rather than showing them herself, not unlike what I'm doing in this liveblog, albeit with a different voice. This can be something of a cop-out for writers, but it can also be good at showing the dialogue from characters' perspective, as well as certain things about it from their point of view- their reactions, what they consider important, how they interpret the others' words and actions, and so forth.

Katara notes that Zuko feels bad about what happened, and again denies warming up to Zuko, denying that he will do so no matter how much he washes the dishes. After a few awkward attempts and an apparent Accidental Innuendo, Zuko asks for a truce, promising to help the Gaang if Katara doesn't hate him so much. Katara decides to think about it.

Katara notes that Zuko's firebending is useful for everyday tasks, and the many ways he is Adorkable, which is starting to turn her on.

Some would be skeptical about how Zuko and Katara could ever be friends, much less a couple, at this point. To that, I say that stories like telling of how people overcame the impossible, and much like how an underdog sports team defeats the champion, or how La RĂ©sistance overthrows The Empire, people overcoming a strong dislike of each other to fall in love is a popular story. It certainly makes for good drama, but like other dramatic techniques, it can sometimes strain belief. Why would Katara get together with Zuko after everything he's done? And what will happen with her burgeoning relationship with Aang? Only time will tell for this fic.

What I liked:

  • Good attention to detail
  • Katara's perspective is an interesting touch.

What I didn't like

  • Katara sometimes taking low blows at Zuko (saying his mother left him because she was annoyed with him, and enjoying his lack of firebending)

Comments

romancechina88 Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 20th 2014 at 4:47:43 AM
This chapter for me was mixed as well (started reading again since I might as well finish it), especially on Aang, while I still hate the bashing he gets in the fic, some of the points do to some degree touch what I have mixed feelings for at times with the show when it comes to some of the events around Aang.

Mostly the finale with the energy bending. Since while I never expected Aang to kill Ozai, I feel the finale didn't do a very good job of structuring aang's dilemma of killing him, since it feels his discussion with the other avatars are mainly him wanting someone to tell him he doesn't have to consider killing Ozai, since he didn't seem to have any plan or idea of what he was going to do to not kill him.

Which Yangchen called him out on to an extent, also the way he met the lion turtle afterwards and what to me (not sure to other people) felt like Aang got given a solution (given since Aang didn't find it or learn it I feel) to his problem and didn't have to put his own needs aside. Again the idea of Aang not killing Ozai and the energybending in general isn't what annoyed me, just the execution and structure and pacing of it wasn't done well I thought. It just made Aang look selfish to some people and he got away with it.

It didn't help that overall the Aang and Ozai fight was the weakest bit of the finale, since the two I feel were the weakest and least interesting characters on their side (Aang isn't a bad character, just not as interesting as Zuko and others to me) Ozai being somewhat of a genericdoomsdayvillain when compared to other villains (expect unaloq and Vaatu from Korra season two who were worse). Which helped in my somewhat less than positive opinion of their fight. I felt it was boring as well and not a lot of tension despite it being built up throughout the series.

The ocean beast thing, that one overall is something I'm just not sure what to think of, it seemed for the most part to be the ocean sprit, but since Aang seemed to accept bonding with it beforehand, you have to wonder if he had any idea of what the sprit would do. Plus the way it was done in the finale was very quick and came out of nowhere for the most part. So I'm neutral on that event.

But that's still no reason to bash Aang the way this fic does at times.

The energybending not being built up very much (or in a way that I felt it should have been, I am a person with opinionated views) didn't help either.

interesting bit on the mooks, reminds me of the Clerks scene where Randall and Dante argue about contractors on the second death star and the roofer comes in how he avoided death by passing on a mob house job, and the guy says in a lot of ways the mooks on the second death star knew the risks and it's the own fault they got killed, which in some ways is fair, since while doing jobs like that for your family etc. is sympathetic to a degree, knowing the risks and high chance of death make them somewhat responsible for their own death.

As for Zuko's crew stuff. I did wonder what happened to them, though I never felt Zuko was close to them really, yeah he put them first at times, but he was distant from them and some like lee didn't like him because of Zuko's somewhat stubborn and emo attitude during season one, and the show always kept that in mind wit zuko during it. Reminding us why yes Zuko's circumstance is sad and tragic, he brings some of it on himself.

I never got why some take different view of Zhao not taking Zuko's hand, I always felt it was clear Zhao did it out of pride and spite, since the guy had no real redeeming traits at all, and really not much character to him for most of season one, so it makes it a little difficult for me to believe he didn't take Zuko's hand for any reason but his own selfish ones (though I felt Jason Issac did a fab job voicing him, but that's because I'm fond of him in general). But again that's just me and my views.

Katara stuff was something that caught my attention as well... katara has become one of those characters of avatar I have become very mixed on each time I watch the show, I think she is a good character for the most part, there are times I felt the show let her get away with some pretty mean comments like saying Sokka didn't love their mother as much as she did, some of the vents of the painted lady (though that episode in general is something of an issue for some anyway,) as well as some of the writing for her at times that can get on some peoples nerves (her feud with paaku, while yes the guy is a jerk and sexist, the way it got written and turned out felt soapbox saddie and anivllous to me, but ymmv on that), along with how some of her power up was a little bit too advanced at times considering her water bending at the start of the show. But her character development throughout the show (especially in southern raider and the runaway) and as well being well rounded and depth character is what I liked watching about her.

Great review again as always. Some interesting and smart points made, I look forward to reading future chapter blogs.
Valiona Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 20th 2014 at 9:11:39 AM
romancechina88,

Regarding Aang's struggling with the question of whether to kill Ozai, I think he was searching for a solution that enabled him to defeat Ozai without killing him. But in the end, he found a new solution that none of his predecessors had considered, which fits ATLA's message more than the author's intention of having the rest of the cast berate Aang for his decision.

I do agree that Ozai is a somewhat less interesting villain than some of the others. My favorite is probably Amon from the first season of Legend of Korra.

Clerks has an interesting perspective on mooks, and it's nice that it doesn't gloss over their being responsible for their actions.

I agree that Zuko wasn't that close to his crew. In the end, though, "The Storm", in both its past and present segments, shows that Zuko, in Season 1 and 2, is bitter and jaded, but he does care for others. He'd probably be sad to hear that they died, but not feel such an overwhelming desire to be able to properly mourn them.

As for my personal opinion on Zhao, I think it was a combination of not wanting to live with the shame of his failure and not wanting to be saved by the kid he hated so much.

That's a good point about Katara, which is why I liked that the fic had her regret what she said to Sokka.
romancechina88 Since: Dec, 1969
Sep 20th 2014 at 1:23:16 PM
fair points on Aang, though in always going to feel it the exaction of it was very flawed and undermined his victory over Ozai, but not going to dwell on it.

Yeah Amon for me has been the best villain they have done so far (so much I was planning in my code geass fic to do a character influenced by him, Steve Blum I felt did a brilliant as Amon, one of the best in the business I feel the man is). Though Zaheer in season three was done well I thought.

Yeah I agree on your point on Zhao, that's generally what I feel his decision on that issue was.
Top