----
* BrokenBase: Over whether or not Toby should have covered the VideoGame/AssassinsCreedIII E3 Trailer. To be noted is that the people who wanted him to cover it didn't unsubscribe him or anything- it's just that the previous trailers brought many of Toby's fans in, and some people got really excited when the trailer came out.
** And it looks like the same thing is happening with VideoGame/AssassinsCreedUnity. Again, no-one's threatening to un-sub, but they are asking him to do it out of nostalgia.
* SugarWiki/HeReallyCanAct: Many people had this reaction for his appearance in Black Box TV's "This One's For You, Baby", where he plays a [[spoiler: vengeful boyfriend whose girlfriend is cheating on him with his best friend.]]
* HoYay: Played for laughs in his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXBm2hRc-mA New Years Rap (A Couple of Guys in Hawaii).]]
* MemeticMutation: As an Internet personality, he's prone to creating these. The list starts with:
** '''[[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsVSkyrim VOICE AT-TACK!!]]'''
** '''[[{{DistractedByTheSexy}} Hothothothothothothothothothothothot]]'''
* OvershadowedByControversy: In 2016, multiple of Toby's ex-girlfriends accused him of abuse, sexual assault, and inappropriate behavior. While Toby denied the accusations, many were not convinced, in part because [[UnreliableNarrator his story kept changing]]. His reputation was obliterated, he was dropped from multiple projects, and his [=YouTube=] career has never recovered.
** His career has also taken ''another'' downturn with him posting [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfV0Bu76yDw a video of himself hanging out]] with Kyle Rittenhouse, a man who brought an assault rifle to a BLM rally and killed two people and was infamously [[https://www.npr.org/2021/11/19/1057288807/kyle-rittenhouse-acquitted-all-charges-verdict acquitted]] for it.
* TearJerker: His first Minecraft world got corrupted.
** The VideoGame/{{Dead Island}} Literal Trailer.
** Turtbuscusle's death in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Puedev2xNuw HOW TO DROWN]].
** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RPOxSXgS1rY At one point during Toby's run of Minecraft's Eather Mod]], he accidentally kills one of his blue moas, who was recently baptized as [[ItMakesSenseInContext the Murder Bird]], by setting it on fire with the Phoenix Bow. The music that's playing as he frantically tries to find a way to put out the flames on the moa as it burns to death doesn't help...
----