----
* AwesomeMusic
* BrokenBase: Over whether or not Toby should have covered the VideoGame/AssassinsCreedIII E3 Trailer. To be noted is that the people who wanted him to cover it didn't unsubscribe him or anything- it's just that the previous trailers brought many of Toby's fans in, and some people got really excited when the trailer came out.
** And it looks like the same thing is happening with VideoGame/AssassinsCreedUnity. Again, no-one's threatening to un-sub, but they are asking him to do it out of nostalgia.
* EarWorm: His literal trailers and songs are catchy.
** [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mmdc9RIhmOI Nugget, biscuit, nugget in a biscuit, nugget, biscuit, nugget in a biscuit...]]
* HeReallyCanAct: Many people had this reaction for his appearance in Black Box TV's "This One's For You, Baby", where he plays a [[spoiler: vengeful boyfriend whose girlfriend is cheating on him with his best friend.]]
* HoYay: Played for laughs in his [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXBm2hRc-mA New Years Rap (A Couple of Guys in Hawaii).]]
* LoveItOrHateIt: Toby is a polarizing personality; his particular brand of humor is appreciated by some but not by all. There's also some resentment over his inability to finish projects, as well as opposing groups of viewers who variously prefer his gaming channel and his main comedy channel and don't appreciate it when one takes priority over the other. Toby has addressed the "copying from others" complaint in his vlogs, saying that he doesn't keep track of what other [=YouTubers=] are doing; he creates videos for his amusement and those of his fans, but inevitably gets accused of copying when he starts a Let's Play later than someone else.
* MemeticMutation: As an Internet personality, he's prone to creating these. The list starts with:
** '''[[VideoGame/TheElderScrollsVSkyrim VOICE AT-TACK!!]]'''
** '''[[{{DistractedByTheSexy}} Hothothothothothothothothothothothot]]'''
* TearJerker: His first Minecraft world got corrupted.
** The {{Dead Island}} Literal Trailer.
** Turtbuscusle's death in [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Puedev2xNuw HOW TO DROWN]].
** [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RPOxSXgS1rY At one point during Toby's run of Minecraft's Eather Mod]], he accidentally kills one of his blue moas, who was recently baptized as [[ItMakesSenseInContext the Murder Bird]], by setting it on fire with the Phoenix Bow. The music that's playing as he frantically tries to find a way to put out the flames on the moa as it burns to death doesn't help...
----