* ContestedSequel: ''Transit of Venus'' is either their best album, or them selling out to mainstream pop.
* CriticalDissonance: Like Music/{{Seether}}, they generally garner mixed reviews from music critics. However, among music fans, they're actually one of the more well regarded post-grunge bands in existence.
** ''Transit of Venus'' was hailed by critics as their best album yet, because they expanded their boundaries. [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks Many fans disliked it for that same reason.]]
* EpicRiff: Just about all of their songs, though "Just Like You," "Pain," "Animal I Have Become," and "Break" stand out.
* FaceOfTheBand: Adam, of course, which the label and/or manager seems to be aware of.
** TheBandMinusTheFace: The remaining 3 members plan to avert this fate.
* FanVid: A popular target of them.
* FridgeBrilliance: "Pain" could be taken as either wangsty, vaguely masochistic or [[WordSaladLyrics Word Salad]]. Taken in the context of Adam's painkiller addiction, the lyric "I'd rather feel pain than nothing at all" takes on a new light...
* FriendlyFandoms: With the Music/BreakingBenjamin fanbase, as both have similar styles and are big FanVid bait.
* HarsherInHindsight: The last single "The High Road" is about looking for a way out which was followed by Gontier quitting the band, especially if you think of it as Adam singing it to the other members
* {{Narm}}: The music video for "Animal I Have Become" is full of this, with pathetic CG effects in a failed attempt to make a NightmareFace, but the pinnacle of narm is near the end when a camera slowly pans up to reveal a woman with the same face, only to suddenly zoom in with a bad ScreenShake effect as Adam gives a hilariously overacted scream.
* [[NightmareFuel/MusicVideos Nightmare Fuel: Music Videos]]
* ReplacementScrappy: Brad's brother Matt Walst, singer for My Darkest Days has already received this reaction after it was announced he'd be filling in for vocal duties on the tours following Adam Gontier's resignation from the band. That is if [[http://loudwire.com/adam-gontier-leaves-three-days-grace-replaced-by-my-darkest-days-matt-walst/ the re-recordings with his voice are anything to go by]].
* SignatureSong: Probably "I Hate Everything About You", with "Animal I Have Become" offering a challenge to the title (they even finish some shows with it).
** "Never Too Late" could also be in the running considering it was a big pop hit.
** "Break" did fairly well on rock radio, and seems to be one of their most-liked songs in recent years.
%%* [[TearJerker/RockMusic Tear Jerker]]
* {{Wangst}}: Their early work.