* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Archaon's brief appearance in episode 12.
* CargoShip: Aovnick and Ramirez.
* HoYay: [[ThoseTwoGuys Bro and Mastermind]].
-->'''Mastermind:''' Yeah, me and Bro are, like, back here just being gay.\\
'''Bro:''' Yeah, I'm trying to find a place.\\
'''Mastermind:''' ...[[SubvertedTrope And by gay]] [[HaveAGayOldTime I mean happy]].
* ReplacementScrappy: [=TicTac=]. Even lampshaded when he is told that he's "the worst guest star ever".
** ''Profound Moments in Everything'' also has the line "[=TicTac=], don't say words on the Internet."
** Some said it got worse with the release of Episode 10, where both [=PuppySky=] and Archaon were replaced by new players, Bro (Coach) and Mastermind (Ellis). Aovnick was still there and {{screaming|Warrior}}, to the fans' delight.
*** Bro turned out fine. Mastermind on the other hand...
*** Even more jarring in Season 4 where while [=PuppySky=] is back, Bro and Mastermind are still there. As a result, fan-favorite Aovnick was nowhere to be seen.
** And then Abby in season 5, at least to the other players. [=PuppySky=] even refers to him twice as "[=TicTac=] part 2".
----