* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: Both games involve a large cast of characters, all of which are nasty egotistical stereotypes. The main goal is to spy on all of them to learn their little secrets, such as who is blackmailing who and who has had an affair and such. And then they all die like mayflies, slaughtered one by one by a serial killer, which you cannot prevent. So why exactly should you care about any of these characters?
* FridgeLogic: In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
** FridgeHorror: If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
* NightmareFuel: The murderer strangling Laura in the attic.
** The alligators in the swamp.
** Lillian becoming more and more unhinged as the night goes on.
** The ghost in the graveyard, who does nothing but point at you before disappearing.
*** Even worse, if you tell Laura to look at the ghost, she'll dismiss it by claiming "It's just a wisp of mist from the bayou", which makes you wonder if ''you'', the player, [[ParanoiaFuel are the one seeing things.]]
* PlayTheGameSkipTheStory: A rare in-game example... it's possible to completely skip the story. However, if you do this, you get punished with a low rating.
** In fact, it's entirely possible to not have witnessed any events at all!