!! '''For the band:'''
* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: "The Unearthly Ones", "The Greatest Show Unearthed", "The House of Myth", "Such Horrible Things".
* CompleteMonster: The [[NoNameGiven unnamed]] VillainProtagonist from "Such Horrible Things" talks of all the things he's done while stating outright that he should be killed gruesomely for having done it all. It starts off with him being just a violent JerkAss kid who [[KidsAreCruel pranks people in cruel ways]]. His first known crime is causing one of his friends to vanish in the woods, never to be found. He then burned down his own house [[EvilIsPetty because he hated its color]]. [[EnfantTerrible At twelve]], he tossed his sister down a well to her seeming doom. When recounting what happened when he was 14, he says that nothing happened, but then he remembers "that one time" and chuckles. Cue a series of screams and about 50 seconds without any narration. His reign of terror ended when he tried to [[BuriedAlive bury his brother alive]]. The brother just barely survived, but got the narrator locked in an asylum for the rest of his life.
* EarWorm: "WE ARE COMING FOR YOU. WE ARE COMING FOR YOU."
** "ONE BY ONE WE BITE THE DUST! KICK THE BUCKET, BEGIN TO RUST! GIVE UP THE GHOST WHEN YOUR NUMBER'S UP! WE ALL FALL DOWN!"
* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: The NoodleIncident in ''Such Horrible Things''. "When I was fourteen... nothing much happened. ''({{Beat}})'' Well... ''there was that one time''!"
* NightmareFuel: Several examples. For instance, the deaths described in "A Gorey Demise" are all pretty gruesome sounding, especially this one:
-->L is for Larry, who '''[[OverdrawnAtTheBloodBank bled and bled]]'''
* PainfulRhyme[=/=]LyricalShoehorn[=/=]AcCENTUpontheWrongSylLABle
* SignatureSong: "The Greatest Show Unearthed", or "A Gorey Demise". "Bad Blood", "Buried Alive,", and "Such Horrible Things" are also candindates.

!! '''For the comic series based off of the band:'''
* HeartwarmingMoments: Curtis TakingTheBullet for Erik in "A Corpse in My Bed".
* NightmareFuel: In "The Meek Shall Inherit the Earth", Curt's dog is pretty damn freaky.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: According to WordOfGod, "A Corpse in My Bed" was going to have a DownerEnding, but it was scrapped after it ignored a previously established plot point and [[ExecutiveMeddling after being advised against by the publisher.]]