* AbortedArc: Seemed to be getting a push to win the Divas' championship from Beth Phoenix near the end of 2011. However, a match where Alicia squashed her on Raw saw her botch a move and stiff Beth with a hard somersault leg drop to the face. The fact that Beth took time off to heal the resulting hematoma probably changed a few minds on pushing her.
** FromBadToWorse: After botching all over The Glamazon's face, she then tried to cut a flirty, babyface promo to the crowd, telling them to have a "Foxy holiday". The smarky [[Wrestling/{{ECW}} Philadelphia]] crowd booed her out of the building.
** Her makeover storyline on NXT with JTG was dropped after two weeks with all the rest of the NXT Redemption storylines.
* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: We can only assume that the amount of times she's dyed her hair has affected her brain, resulting in her HeelFaceRevolvingDoor.
* CriticalDissonance: ''Diva Dirt'' writers were awaiting her face turn and praised her performance in the role. However most fans seem to prefer her as a heel.
* EnsembleDarkhorse: Has been something of a favourite among Diva fans since 2009.
* FashionVictimVillain: Her set of outfits that resemble a pinata.
* HilariousInHindsight: Her segment with Dule Hill where she threw a tantrum after losing her match. Fast forward to 2014 where throwing epic ringside tantrums after losing has become her character.
* [[HoYay Les Yay]]: With Melina. They actually kissed on screen.
* NeverLiveItDown: The above mentioned injury to Beth Phoenix. Her detractors would have you think that, along with her title defense against Melina at Summer Slam were only her only matches. Since we're on the topic, her title defense at Summer Slam, where miscommunication between the two lead to Alicia working the wrong limb, even though Melina's return from injury was all hyped up. While not match of the year candidates, every match they had before and after Summer Slam was better.
** For the Melina Summer Slam match, Melina actually tweaked her surgically repaired ACL. For obvious reasons, Alicia couldn't very well go after a legit injured leg. The fault lay with WWE for putting Melina in such a high profile match literally the week she returned to the ring.
* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Her initial entrance theme "Shake Yo' Tail" was an obvious one to Nelly's "Hot In Here".