[[WMG:David is Adam's twin brother, and a Jigsaw apprentice]]

Okay, so David, the protagonist from the short film, is played by Leigh Whannel. So is Adam. Obviously, they're twins, or else the Saw universe involves clones, which seems unlikely considering it's a realistic fiction series. Now, in a deleted scene from Saw, Adam says that he has a family, supporting the idea that he has a brother at all. Adam also says that he doesn't see his family much. Interesting... Think about it. Every other person who has been in the reverse bear trap helped Jigsaw. Why would David be an exception? In conclusion, Adam met his demise at the hands of his brother that he was so disconnected from that he didn't know the story of the man who tried to kill him. And that's why...

[[WMG: The next movie will have [[spoiler:Dr. Gordon and the survivors as antagonists.]]]]
[[spoiler: If you notice towards the end of Saw VII, there are two other people in pig masks with Dr. Gordon, and it is safe to assume they are other survivors, taking over the Jigsaw title to judge people with traps, and continue the series.]]
* Nah, the series has ended. [[spoiler: Those two people are the two guys from the start of the movie. They did nothing but finally end the jigsaw killings. Gordon agreed with John, but both Amanda and Hoffman were simply psychopaths with no attempt to justify their behavior and so Gordon has no reason to continue the games]]
** Actually, they had plans to [[spoiler: have the entire survivor group be accomplices, but the idea was scrapped when the last two movies were shoved together and significant plot was forced to be cut.]]
[[WMG:Dr. Gordon is still alive.]]

Okay, when we last saw him he was bleeding to death, and Jigsaw was sure to catch up with him anyway. But we didn't see him die -- and this series ''loves'' to show the victims' deaths, even if it's a couple of movies later. Besides, they keep making little references to him. Nah, Lawrence is still alive, and they'll bring him back for ''Saw VI'' to bring the series full circle. (His absence since the first film is easy to explain: he's been in hospital recovering from his massive injuries.)
* Full circle? You mean he'll become the next Jigsaw?
** No, I just mean he was in the first and he'll be in the (supposedly) last.
*** Well, the tagline for ''Saw VI'' '''is''' "The Game Comes Full Circle"...
Update: Okay, I'm busted on the ''Saw VI'' part -- Lawrence wasn't back. But they did throw in yet another mention of him, and remember that package Jill dropped off at the hospital? Sure looked like his name on the door. Stay tuned.
* This troper is afraid to say that Gordon's fate being left up in the air is probably a case of RealLifeWritesThePlot. Elwes sued the producers when he felt he wasn't given his agreed-upon percentage. That whole matter was settled out of court, but he's not likely to want to return (and they're not likely to want him back).
** [[spoiler: Actually, according to the [[http://www.toronto.ca/tfto/pdf/currentlist.pdf Toronto Film & Television Office]], Cary Elwes was in the cast for the shooting of Saw VII. It's not guaranteed that he'll be alive, yet, since he could just be back to give a flashback of his death, but this troper is hoping that's not the case!]]
[[spoiler: The very first scene of Saw 3D (formerly Saw VII) is Dr. Gordon cauterizing his stump, so yes, he survived Saw I.]]
* [[spoiler:And I'd just like to add that I ''nailed'' the package thing. I was definitely not expecting Lawrence to go bad, though...]]

[[WMG:Jill Tuck will be the final Jigsaw.]]

You're trying to tell me that she had NO idea that her husband was Jigsaw? '''Bull. Shit.''' She's going to be the one to end Hoffman's life and take up the Jigsaw role...if she hasn't already been acting in concert with her husband already.
* Confirmed, to a degree: [[spoiler: Yes, she knows, and yes, she's in on the plan, and yes, she even does attempt to kill Hoffman, in the end. Whether or not she'll take her husband's place is left a mystery, though, as it's revealed he had arranged to prevent any sort of suspicion be leveled on her.]]
** [[spoiler: We know that "a battle is going to rage over Jigsaw's legacy," [[http://www.bloody-disgusting.com/news/19954/ source]], and Wikipedia has interpreted that to mean that the battle will be between Jill and Hoffman, but there is no indication in either of the two interviews cited that that battle will be between the two of them. We do know that Saw VII will reveal that a new character named Bobby Dagen has "dark secrets of his own," so perhaps he will be a part of this battle. It's also possible that Jill had a change of heart and wants to carry on John's work, so perhaps she will forgo whatever plans he had to prevent suspicion against her and will instead carry on his work.]]
* Patrick Melton confirmed that she will not be the new Jigsaw. [[http://www.demonfm.co.uk/?q=node/596 source]]

[[WMG: ''Jigsaw'' will be the final Jigsaw.]]
Because you can never say a horror franchise is 100% dead until the main villain is [[BackFromTheDead revived]].
** His body was ''cut open,'' though. And there was no mention in either IV, V, or VI of the body unexpectedly going missing, so either [[AssPull Jigsaw is now capable of incorporeally possessing people,]] [[AssPull or he had a twin brother we never heard about.]]

[[WMG: A Jigsaw puzzle will be the final Jigsaw.]]
Because that makes sense.
** Made of the pieces Jigsaw was cutting out of the skin of the people he captured. Stick them to a spiky mannequin, or something, and if you get too much blood on it before revealing the message, you starve to death in some dismal underground room. Figure out how to do it without causing yourself harm (or at least without getting blood on the pieces), and you find the key (...not necessarily a ''[[ContinuityNod literal]]'' key, though). Would be good for someone with physically self-destructive tendencies, like Amanda (I haven't seen the later films, so don't know what happens there). They would have to find the path of least self-harm, or kill him- or herself once and for all (either way, making the human race slightly more appreciative of life on average). Would be an interesting twist, considering all the previous puzzles tend to revolve around getting blood out of a person's body, one way or another, to survive.

[[WMG: Jigsaw was testing himself in Saw 3.]]
Think about it. At this point, it was already at least hinted that Jigsaw was starting to realize that the few people who did survive the tests didn't learn anything, so he was probably starting to wonder if he was actually doing any good, or if he was just a sick psycho who tortures people because he can't cope with his disease. Besides, he may also have realized that spending the short time he has left doing that isn't exactly the best way to show his respect for life either.

So he decided to create a game in which someone would be put to the test, but so would he. His test was to convince Jeff to forget his grief and to forgive to those who he feel wronged him (note the parallel between Jeff not coping with his son's death and Jigsaw not coping with his cancer). If he managed to do so, it would mean his games do serve their purpose and make people appreciate life. If he failed, it would mean his works were meaningless and only made people who already hit rock-bottom suffer even more, making him even more disrespectful of life than the people he tested, and he knew Jeff's anger would be so great that he would kill him (that also explains why he kidnapped Jeff's daughter and put his wife into a deadly trap, to make sure he would hate Jigsaw enough to kill him).

And last but not least, Jigsaw tested both of his apprentices, so it's not a stretch to believe that he would test himself as well, and being killed by a person he tested fit his theme of {{Karmic Death}}s perfectly.

* Concerning your last point, Jigsaw ''did'' drive his car off of a cliff and survive; ''Saw IV'' shows him pulling a part of the car out of his abdomen. He could certainly seen that as his "test"; after all, that's when he changed from John Kramer into Jigsaw.
** Good point, but he did put former victims into a second trap when he thought they still didn't respect life enough, so maybe he considered that him turning into Jigsaw just made him go from disrespecting his life to disrespecting other people's lives.

[[WMG:Jigsaw is just a crazed sadist.]]
''Ostensibly'', Jigsaw's philosophy is that those who do not appreciate life do not deserve it. Practically speaking, this becomes "If you aren't prepared to suffer to survive then you don't deserve life." However, his actions are extremely inconsistent with this.

First of all, look at his first two victims. Their "tests" were obviously ''not'' just a matter of "If you're willing to suffer then you get to live"; they both tried as hard as they could to escape and yet they died anyway. They didn't lack the will to survive; their tests were just too friggin' hard. Then we have Amanda, who has to ''kill an innocent'' in order to survive. So now suddenly it's "If you're willing to commit murder then you get to live," even though he supposedly abhors murder and only does what he does to get people to value their lives. And of course, we learn at the end that Adam basically never had a hope in hell of surviving.

Michael's test in the second movie is the only one that actually conforms to Jigsaw's "true" modus operandi; he ''could'' have survived if he'd been willing to endure the loss of his eye, but he wasn't, so he died. Fine. It's all downhill from there, however; first he uses blatant SchmuckBait to trick a guy into shooting himself, then he sets a test for Xavier that he can easily ''avoid'' just by making someone else do it. Not to mention that razor box, which was just a flat-out ''trap''. Nobody whose brain's been addled by a lethal airborne toxin could reasonably be expected to avoid that. Also, Jigsaw now seems to be be promoting a [[ThePowerOfFriendship Power of Friendship]] message on top of everything else, because the victims would have fared a ''lot'' better without all the infighting. So now we have "You must kill to survive" being followed by "You must work together!"

Then of course we have Detective Matthews, who just gets screwed every which way. Not only demonstrate the will to survive by escaping almost immediately, he's ''smart'' about it; he breaks his ankle rather than sawing his foot off. And then he gets captured again and dies in the next movie through no fault of his own. Grand.

Also, Jigsaw's now trying to teach the value of mercy and forgiveness, apparently. This after forcing someone to commit murder and dragging numerous innocent bystanders into his "tests", ''including a little girl''. Oh, and the final message of the movie is just great. "You didn't instantly forgive me for all the horrible, ''horrible'' trials I put you through, so now I'm going to make your wife's head asplode."

It's possible that this tangled mess is all justifiable somehow, but it's also possible that Jigsaw is just nuts. I know which one I'm going for.

* The Razor Box trap had a way out: at the top of the box was a padlock ''with the key inside it'', if the victim had spotted it, it just needed to be unlocked and then there wouldn't have been the bloody mess that ensued. (See [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2Q3wptGW2E here.]])
* And as for Matthews, he failed his actual test (to talk to Jigsaw for a couple of hours without marching off like a hero). You could see this as justification for his subsequent death (at least, justified by Jigsaw's logic). Or, there's the other view, supported by the films: it's Amanda's fault, not Jigsaw's. Amanda is skeptical of Jigsaw's methods (understandable), believing that they leave survivors [[FateWorseThanDeath worse off than dying]]. So she takes it upon herself to lock Matthews in the bathroom as an execution. He's too clever, escapes, and so she decides to finish him off for his own good.

[[WMG: Hoffman wins...everything]]
As far as I can tell, his "test" was just supposed to be him dying (I don't think Jigsaw meant for him to have an out, since there was no way to get a key). That would make him the only person in the entire franchise John actually UNDERESTIMATED. If this is the case, then his sheer will to live means he deserves to live more than anyone else.
* I'd guess that his test wasn't supposed to have a key because that would be too easy. Think of all of the experience Hoffman has with Jigsaw's traps; he knows the way they work, and a key would be too simple for a man like him. With all of his experience, a proper test would need to force him to get creative to escape, and he certainly passed in that regard.
** Look closer: Hoffman's Reverse Beartrap is NOT a replica of Amanda's. Specifically, the mouthpiece he used to break his hand is reinforced and STUDDED. This troper's impression was that Hoffman OVERTHOUGHT the trap, once his hand was shattered (and, ostensibly literally and metaphorically, his ability to hurt others), all he had to do was flip the switch on the side to turn it off. He let himself panic, missed the obvious out, and ended up with an unforeseen out and a particularly gruesome Glasgow Grin.
*** [[http://www.demonfm.co.uk/?q=node/596 An interview with Patrick Melton]] confirmed that there was supposed to be a key for the back of Hoffman's [=RBT2=], but Jill took it with her, meaning she left him for dead. Whether this is what John wanted or not is unknown, but we do know that she wanted him dead, so he didn't over think the trap.

[[WMG: Jigsaw is really Kevin [=McCallister=] from Film/HomeAlone]]
* Kevin was quite adept at dishing out vigilante justice with a variety of gruesome traps, particularly for an 8-year-old. It takes a twisted mind to permanently brand someone with a doorknob. His neglectful parents apparently never bothered getting Kevin therapy after two felons threatened to torture and murder him, since he deliberately runs away from a second family vacation, and his traps are noticeably more brutal in New York. Imagine what a kid like that would grow up to be.
** This has been taken to its [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOSuWfJeNO8 logical conclusion]]

[[WMG:William didn't have to kill a single person in his game in ''Saw VI'']]

This is a theory that has been floating around in [[Tropers/GamerAmI my]] head for a while, and it has been in there long enough that I think I may have sufficient proof for it. Basically, I don't think William had to choose between killing anyone during his game in Saw VI; I think there was a way for everyone involved in the traps to live.

First of all, look at Saw V: the people in the sewer trap thought they had to fight each other and that the trap was Survival of the Fittest, but it turned out in the end that they were supposed to work together. I don't think it's inconceivable for that kind of aesop change to happen in Saw VI, as well; William thinks he is being taught a lesson about the flaws in his perception about the relative worth of people's lives (for example, a healthy loner is not worth more than a sick grandmother), but it turns out he's really being encouraged to just drop those perceptions completely (rather than just correct them), and to give everyone a chance at life; in other words, to not try to assign life a value. After all, Jigsaw basically told William that his formula for deciding whether someone got coverage was BS because it didn't take into account the human will to live. If William was just being encouraged to rethink his perceptions on the relative worth of human life, then that would just mean modifying his formula, but I think Jigsaw would want him to just forget about his formula.

Now, I think there was a way for William to go about each each trap without killing anyone. I suspect that the Breathing Mask Trap was designed so that it wouldn't actually kill William. After all, without him, none of the other traps can go as planned, and thus Hoffman wouldn't have been able to carry Jigsaw's final will, and why make an innocent janitor go through everything that William had to go through? Thus, perhaps the trap would release them both if William were to simply breath enough to supposedly kill himself. This would have taught him that, though Hank was less healthy than him, that didn't mean Hank deserved to die.

With the Barbed-Wire Nooses, I think the responsibility was more on Allen's shoulder, but he could have survived. Watch the scene: his hands are released well before the noose tightened, meaning he could have grabbed the noose so that it wouldn't cut his neck when he fell. It certainly would have been painful, but considering the alternative (death), it's preferable. And why else would the director have included a scene of his hands have been released? He could have very well said, "Fuck you!" without his hands being released, so it couldn't have just been for storytelling purposes

The Steam Room is simpler to explain. Debbie could have just used to band-saw to cut the device off of herself. The x-rays were probably placed there to make her think she had to maim William to get the key (like the faux Survival of the Fittest theme in Saw V), even though she didn't.

Finally, in the Carousel Trap, what if there was no limit on the number of times William could have pushed the buttons to raise the shotgun? I can't think of any evidence to support this, but if it were the case, it would have sent the message that the limits on how many people should be allowed to live (a parallel to the idea that some people shouldn't be given insurance coverage) are all an illusion created by the higher-ups (in the case of the trap, the higher-up is Jigsaw; in the case of health insurance, it's William). I know it's a ConverseError to assume that since this moral makes sense, then the possibility that lead to it must be true, but I thought I'd bring it up anyways.

Most importantly, though, remember that Jigsaw said to William, "You think it is the living who will have ultimate judgment over you because the dead will have no claim to your soul, but you may be mistaken." However, at the end of the movie, it ''is'' the living (Brent and Tara) who have ultimate judgment over him. Thus, the only way this quote can be relevant is if it is the people who died in the traps (i.e. whom William killed) that are the dead that have a claim to his soul. In other words, had he not killed anyone, there would be no dead to claim his soul, and thus perhaps he would have been saved.

On a side note, since Jigsaw could predict human behavior, perhaps he designed the tape that played at the end of the film specifically to encourage Tara or Brent to kill William. If that's the case, he could have had two tapes ready to play when William made it to the end: one which he knew would cause Brent or Tara to pull the level, and one which would have encouraged them to spare him, or perhaps told William to not stand on the platform that activated the switch, and that one would have played if he had pressed the button in the Carousel trap more than twice, and/or Hank had survived, etc. In other words, maybe William's real test was to find a way to let everyone live, to give up his insurance-based view that some people must die for others to keep living, and he failed that test miserably, and thus his punishment was to die by Brent's hand.

* I really like this theory -- in fact, it improves ''VI'' quite a bit for me. Pity no one in the film figures it out.
* I like this theory as well and to add to it, not just the sewer trap but the entire setup of Saw V could have been fixed through teamwork instead of one person dying. Trap 1: The same key opens all collars. get the key and just pass it down. Trap 2: The explosion-safe spots can fit more than one person in them. Trap 3: All of them hold the cables. Trap 4: All of them should have been alive at that point, so 10 pints between 5 people isn't so horrible.
** When I said "the sewer trap", I ''was'' referring to all four of those traps collectively, since they all take place in a sewer.
* Just as an additional quirk of this theory: if William had acted in ways that ensured his co-workers' survival, then he'd have had the janitor and Debbie tagging along with him after those rooms. He could have had one of ''them'' stick around at the Carousel Trap, punching the button over and over, while he continued onward to find his sister.

[[WMG: If there is a Saw VIII, then Gordon, Hoffman, and Dagen will square off.]]
First off, I don't buy that [[spoiler: Hoffman dies, Jill left him in a much more desperate situation and he found an out]]. The reason I pick these three character is because each of them represents Jigsaw's failure. In the case of Hoffman and Gordon, both of them were underestimated. They found the will to live, even after a "Game Over!" Now, both of them want to be the new Jigsaw, and they will fight for that right. Bobby, however, is their opposite. Rather than pulling victory from the jaws of defeat, he lost the game because the trap failed. John was wrong, his pecks ripped, and his wife died even though he had, by any reasonable standard, won. So, where the games represent a way of rewarding strength to Hoffman and Gordon, to Dagen they are nothing but sadistic mind-fucks. For that reason, he will be determined to stop both of them at all costs, and become a counter jigsaw-killer, finding ways to fuck with the games from outside (one possibility is he finds a way to communicate the nature of a trap to a victim, so that they don't have to listen to the tape recorder, and thus can work without a timer), helping the victims, and eventually killing both Gordon and Hoffman.
* Ah, but you missed the cruel point of Dagen's final test. Jigsaw knew ''damn well'' that the pectorals weren't strong enough to support a grown man's weight for that long. He was punishing Dagen not just for lying about being in a trap, but for making him look sloppy by screwing up the details. So did his wife have a chance? I think so -- but Dagen had to think for himself and not just trust the tape (see IV and V, as well as the VI theory above). There are places he could've put the hooks that might have worked. By trusting in his lie, he doomed Joyce.
** I didn't miss it, I considered and rejected it. First off, it makes John petty and dishonest, traits he's never shown before. Secondly, the fact that Dagen got so close to winning proves that it WASN'T impossible. There's no way John could have known for certain the exact instant at which his pectorals would rip, and had they done it a second later he would have won. So, either John screwed up on his trap intending it to work, or he ALMOST screwed up on a trap he intended NOT to work. I think the former works far better.
*** Well, you've made yourself clearer now... but I've gotta say I disagree with you on every point. \\
- Jigsaw is ''very'' petty. Many of his victims were people he felt had wronged him, not people who needed to appreciate their lives more. By ''Saw VI'', he was reminding me of the guy in ''Anime/HellGirl'' who damns someone for spilling coffee on him. And the ultimate proof is Dagen himself. He's out there on TV ''spreading Jigsaw's message'', giving him exactly the PR he wants -- but Jigsaw destroys that asset because he can't abide a fake victim. That's petty.\\
- Never dishonest? Maybe not in person, but in his traps, he lies all the time. Usually it's just deception, leading the victim to think of the wrong solution (like Rigg's quest in ''IV'' or the group in ''V''), but he's perfectly willing to flat-out lie too (Amanda's trap -- "dead cellmate" my ass).\\
- And as for Jigsaw not being able to know for sure when Dagen would fall... well, one option is that the pecs really were a possible victory condition, but only if he dug the hooks deep enough that they would actually hold out. Maybe that would be enough pain to earn a pass, and Dagen fell just short. But I can also get behind the idea that Jigsaw ''did'' know exactly when Dagen would fall, because that's the particular category where ''Saw'' asks us to suspend our disbelief (no pun intended). We don't have to accept aliens or time travel; what we have to accept is that Jigsaw is ''that damn good'' at predicting everything that can happen in his traps. He doesn't always know if his victims will pass -- but if they do, it'll be on his terms.

[[WMG: [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory Jigsaw is trying to create an elaborate form of Purgatory]]]]
Note: This theory does not necessarily imply the existence of God and an afterlife, but rather Jigsaw's games of life or death look too suspiciously similar to the doctrine of "suffer and have eternal life or give up and have eternal death".

Throughout the series, the philosophy of Jigsaw is that those who do not appreciate life do not deserve it. Endure some pain and survive or suffer eternal death. Remember that John tried to commit suicide, yet failed and thus became enlightened? Because of that incident he realized that the human race have grown sinful, living just because life contains pleasure, and because of that realization, he decided to "purge" humanity of their sin. After that, he created contraptions which purpose is to rehabilitate people by imposing IronicHell upon them, let them choose on their own free will to either endure and lose the things that made them sin, or to give up and choose death, and if they do survive, make them appreciate life as something in itself. Taken from a more biblical perspective, Jigsaw want them to purge them of sin and rehabilitate them in a way that they can see life as something to be glorified and appreciated in itself, not just because life contains sins and vices and pleasures and obsessions. He was imposing judgement on those who deserve eternal life in Jigsaw and those who deserve eternal death. He was trying to create a Purgatory, one person at a time. After all, Jesus did say "If your right eye causes you to sin (which the wage for is death), gouge it and throw it away" (which reminds this troper of the game in Saw IV where the guy was forced to either blind himself for being a rapist or be ripped apart).

[[WMG: Saw VIII will mark the return of Amanda.]]

If Hoffman can survive [[spoiler: being stabbed in the neck with a pen and the RBT 2.0 and most likely the bathroom]] and [[spoiler: Dr. Gordon can survive cutting off his foot and gets to be a Jigsaw accomplice despite FAILING his test]] then there's no reason to believe the writers (who actually really like Amanda) can't bring her back. After Saw 3D all logic can pretty much be thrown out the window anyway.

[[WMG: The end of Saw 3D is the end of the beginning for the Jigsaw movement, not the beginning of the end.]]

Afterwards, the Jigsaw philosophy slowly gains recruits, eventually being a considerable cult and even taking over small villages. After a century, it's one of the most powerful forces in America and has outlets in other countries. A little while later, and soon there are Jigsaws EVERYWHERE (deverywhere, deverywhere). Every household in America gets tested (gets tested, gets tested). It becomes bigger than hula hoops (hula hoops, hula hoops). Eventually it is the leading cause of death in the world and not a single person goes through their life without undergoing a Jigsaw trap. Of course some would prefer being DrivenToSuicide than to endure the traps. Quality of life declines and people forget what they knew, as slowly the Jigsaw become a seperate, more powerful class than the Non-Jigsaw. They're worshipped as gods, and scientific knowledge shifts to being exclusively the domain of the Jigsaw, as the Jigsaw do research into new traps and execute the Non-Jigsaw scientists for stupid reasons. Eventually the Jigsaw create AM from Literature/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream, who kills the Jigsaw and most of the Non-Jigsaw, but still tries to perform his function...
* Alternatively, The Jigsaw and their ideology of rehabilitation ends up in the hands of The Party from ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour''. The Party successfully uses the Jigsaw rehabilitation methods and John Kramer's spying / surveillance abilities (well, after all, how can you have an IronicHell without a knowledge of people's personalities)? to design the Ministry of Love, and the purpose is twisted so that the purpose of the traps are not to make people appreciate life, but to make people appreciate Big Brother.

[[WMG: Lawrence was ''always'' a Jigsaw Apprentice]]
[[spoiler:Dr. Gordon]] was a follower of John's from the very beginning. Before Amanda converted, before Hoffman was blackmailed, he was there. His Test was intended to accomplish two main goals. His final Apprentice Exam, just like Amanda and Hoffman were intended to be given; and to cast him from the list of suspects. He'd been suspected already, and as things continued there was no guarantee they'd take a second look at him later. So he was put into a Test. If he died, Game Over. If he survived, he could either be a publicly traumatized survivor, or [[spoiler:as happened]], he could disappear as Missing Presumed Dead.

[[WMG: John was fully aware of Amanda's role in his son's death.]]
In ''Saw V'', we learn that Hoffman threatened Amanda with the knowledge that she was there when John's son died, one of the events that led him to become Jigsaw in the first place. Because of this, Amanda was forced to blow her last test and kill Lynn Denlon instead of following Jigsaw's direction to release her. The tragic irony of this all is that John was already perfectly aware of this fact, but had never brought it up because Amanda had rehabilitated herself in his tests. In fact, ''this'' was the irony of Amanda's reverse bear trap test, though she did not recognize it as such. She had previously killed by proxy and now, to survive, she had to kill willfully. That's the reason her "cellmate" was still alive.
* Confirmed implicitly: In the video game Saw II: Flesh & Blood, Cecil Adams' journal entries are scattered around and it mentions Amanda's role in the death of Gideon. The entries had been obtained by Detective Tapp after Cecil's death. Hoffman could have gotten ahold of them and then shown them to John. It may have been John who told Hoffman to "blackmail" Amanda into killing Lynn Denlon. After all, he told Amanda that there was something in the drawer for her in Saw III. He may have wanted to see if Amanda would remain a killer or if she would succeed her test and tell him the truth.

[[WMG: Bobby Dagen's traps were not devised by either John or Hoffman]]
I haven't gotten up to ''Saw The Final Chapter'' yet, so I acknowledge that there may be something within the movie itself that contradicts this. However, I think that Bobby's traps were not created by John (who was implied to have finished his last traps in ''Saw VI''), nor by Hoffman (who was otherwise preoccupied with a RoaringRampageOfRevenge). They are, in fact, the creation of [[spoiler:Dr. Gordon]]. The logic behind this surrounds the lesson he himself learned: Empathy. Bobby was a charismatic self-help guru, but he was only using Jigsaw survivors to make himself some cash. He wasn't tested ''just'' because he was posing as a fake victim, he was tested because he was posing as a fake ''healer'' on top of it. By running Bobby through his tests, he experienced exactly what any Jigsaw victim would, leaving him to better empathize with the people he was claiming to want to help. To take this even further, the ultimate goal of making Bobby a true victim is to make him better able to stabilize other survivors, help them realize Jigsaw's message, and become more appreciative of their life after the trauma of a trap. This could also improve the recruiting potential for bringing survivors in the Jigsaw world, as they're less likely to have been pushed as far as Amanda or Hoffman were with proper counseling.

[[WMG:When he first created the franchise, Leigh Whannell was inspired by the first 7 volumes of the ''Manga/YuGiOh'' manga.]]
Think about it. Both Jisaw and Atem like to play ''games'' with their victims in order to show them the error of their ways. If the victim loses, they get a KarmicDeath (or karmic punishment in ''Manga/YuGiOh'''s case). The only real difference is that Atem is an AntiHero while Jisaw is an actual villain...well that and Atem has supernatural powers.

[[WMG:Jigsaw's psychosis had a valid medical cause.]]
As the series unfolds, we discover that John Kramer had cancer in his brain, specifically in the frontal lobes. It is widely believed that the frontal lobes are responsible for one's moral compass, and damage to that area can cause drastic changes in personality, turning a perfectly decent man into a complete JerkAss (look up Phineas Gage for an example). So, while his master plan for reforming humanity one ungrateful bastard at a time did have noble roots (albeit those triggered by anger), as the cancer progressed it started affecting his personality and morality, turning a WellIntentionedExtremist into a KnightTemplar.

[[WMG: Jigsaw is an AlternateUniverse version of Music/DoctorSteel.]]
Both started out as toymakers, but then a tragedy occurred, turning them away from their child-friendly origins into more nefarious avenues via morally-ambiguous engineering projects. However, while Dr. Steel may have started off a bit further [[MadScientist off-kilter]], Jigsaw had the brain tumor (see above) that wrecked his moral compass, turning him evil. Meaning Jigsaw is the ''evil'' version of Dr. Steel, who was a MadScientist. Jigsaw turned to deathtraps, Dr. Steel turned to music and world conquest.

[[WMG: Simone becomes an anti-Jigsaw]]
Traumatized by her experience and angry at all the survivors saying they learned from their experience, Simone starts abducting good people and putting them in death traps, or maybe just using her job to actively and deliberately ruin people's lives, as a why of defying Jigsaw's message and belief system.

[[WMG: Jigsaw is a filmmaker who made the movies as a warning to the audience.]]
He has abducted people from the movie theaters whom he believes need to be tested. People do not notice because they are focused on the movie. Additionally, he abducts people in real life and tests their will to live.

[[WMG: ''Saw'' is in the same universe as ''Dead Silence, Death Sentence,'' and ''Insidious.'']]
Billy appears as a puppet in ''Dead Silence,'' spray-paint in ''Death Sentence,'' and a chalk drawing in ''Insidious.'' Someone must be a big fan of Jigsaw's work.

[[WMG: The video games were designed by Amanda Young.]]
Thus explaining why they are so difficult and seemingly impossible to live through.

[[WMG: The ''Saw'' universe's calendars are different.]]
The 2005 calendar in ''Saw II: Flesh & Blood'' resembles the 2002 calendar. In the ''Saw'' universe, the Year of the Pig falls on 2004.

[[WMG: Jigsaw kept Gordon and Tapp captive for nearly a year.]]
The first Saw movie took place November 2004. "Full Diclosure Report: Piecing Together Jigsaw" takes place the year after. In that in-universe documentary, it is stated that Lawrence Gordon and David Tapp were still missing. In the first ''Saw'' video game, Tapp returns home after being tested by Jigsaw in October 2005. The public knew at that time that Tapp was no longer missing since he freed Jigsaw's other test subjects from the asylum, which was mentioned in newspapers. Maybe Dr. Gordon was the one who put the key in Tapp's heart. He was, after all, initially intended to appear in the game. This could have been the test that set him free. He may have been reluctant to accept John's philosophy right after the events of the first film, but maybe he grew to accept them as he was kept alive by John for eleven months, possibly due to Stockholm Syndrome. Helping John with the tests in the video game proved that John could trust him, and Lawrence agreed to help him with subsequent tests.

[[WMG: A future film will show Lawrence's family's reaction to him being Jigsaw's apprentice.]]
It would make a great dramatic plot point and revelation to his wife and daughter.

[[WMG: ''Saw'' is in the same universe as ''The Collector'' and ''The Collection.'']]
The Collector was inspired by Jigsaw's traps.

[[WMG: Identity of Pighead from the first ''Saw'' video game.]]
* Ray Watkins, head custodian.
* Francis Merkin, head custodian who replaced Ray.
* A custodian who wrote letters to someone named Marie Whitehurst Asylum. Could possibly be either Ray or Francis.
* Emma, a patient who reminds a custodian of Marie. Perhaps they had an affair?
* Daniel Whitehurst IV, M.D., owner of the asylum who said that the government grants do not cover patient needs.
* Dr. Holstein, mentioned in a memo to nursing staff.
* Nurse Cleaver, who believed that patients would get worse and riot despite medication.
* Dr. Timothy Early, a doctor who might have supported LSD research.

[[WMG: Dr. Holstein or Dr. Early wrote the medical notes in the first video game.]]
No other doctors are named.

[[WMG: The medical notes were on John Kramer.]]
The notes mention a wife pregnant with a child, and the behavior described matches John Kramer. Even though it is written that he is 34 in 1998, the doctor could have made a typographical error when he meant to write 44. According to ''Saw IV,'' John Kramer was 52 when he died in 2006, so the math adds up if it's a typo. It is also mentioned that the patient fractured his arm from what he described as an accidental fall, possibly alluding to John Kramer's suicide attempt when he drove his car off a cliff.

[[WMG: Conversely, the medical notes were on Lawrence Gordon.]]
Lawrence also had a wife, and his daughter was 5-6 years old during the first film according to the script. If it takes place in 2004, then Diana being born in 1998 fits perfectly. The notes say that the patient has medical knowledge and comments that "Doctors make the worst patients."

[[WMG: The medical notes are on the person who became Pighead.]]
The notes mention that the patient sees people as objects or pawns. It is also mentioned that he has violent tendencies. This does not seem to fit with either John or Lawrence's personalities.

[[WMG: Hoffman was the one who kidnapped Gordon.]]
It was established in ''Saw III'' that Amanda was the one who kidnapped Adam. By the time she got to the bathroom, John was applying his make-up and Lawrence was lying on the floor. Hoffman could have contributed to the test by bringing Lawrence while John prepared in the bathroom.

[[WMG: Amanda or Hoffman electrocuted Lawrence and/or Adam.]]
Zep seemed busy when he was being chased by Tapp.

[[WMG: Lawrence's other possible contributions to Jigsaw's games.]]
* Placing the key in David Tapp's heart in the video game.
* Luring Carla Song to test her in ''Saw II: Flesh & Blood.''
* He could have used his medical expertise to figure out where to impale Morgan and Rex from ''Saw IV.''

[[WMG: The hooded Jigsaw in the first film was Hoffman disguising his voice.]]
Pretty much the only way to account for Jigsaw directly using a weapon on someone.

[[WMG: John Kramer wasn't originally an engineer: he was ThePhilosopher.]]
He was obviously a polymath, but if he only took up a course in engineering then why did he possess such a comprehensive knowledge about the human condition, human psychology and the survival instinct, which he used to carry out his legacy long after his death? Perhaps being a civil engineer responsible for designing most of the city's infrastructure was not his original passion. Instead, John Kramer's original passion was Philosophy, especially the philosophy behind finding a reason on why a human individual should live despite the circumstances he suffered e.g. the death of his son with Jill. It is entirely plausible that Kramer was a reader of Schopenhauer (who believed that the will to live was the source of all suffering) and Creator/FriedrichNietzsche (where he learned the concept of the Will to Power as fundamental in life) but adopted their philosophies into his own, that for one to survive, they must have the Will to Power in enduring pain to survive. However, in Real Life, [[ADegreeInUseless Philiosophy is known to be an unprofitable venture]], which is why, due to the recognition by others of his skills in engineering, he was forced to enter into becoming one of the most important civil engineers in the city (kinda like Adolf Hitler being forced into architecture even if his original passion was fine arts), and eventually marrying Jill, who as a rehabilitation doctor obviously had an experience in psychology. However, his cancer combined with Amanda's idiocy in aborting his child, convincing him that he has no longer a reason to live,resulted in his suicide attempt, which failed... and reawakened his Philosophical passion in questioning: What does it mean for a human being to survive? This was where Kramer, despite being not a philosophy graduate, decided to use his acquired skills in engineering to express to his subjects what his philosophy of life is.