[[WMG: Muffy is a crime-fighting superhero.]]
Why else is crime in Elwood City so low? Why else are her friends able to wander around town without worry? The whole spoiled, selfish, pampered weakling shtick? [[SecretIdentity It's just an act.]] Her family gained their fortune by not-so-honest means, so Muffy needed a way to give back to the city without betraying her family as well. And her valet Bailey, unlike Alfred Pennyworth, seems entirely clueless to her secret double life as well.
* Why Muffy in particular?
* I disagree with your "not-so-honest parents" theory. Her parents are foster parents. She's the Batman. *cue Dark Knight theme.
* No, Muffy is Hit-Girl. And her father is Big-Daddy, and George is Kick-Ass!


[[WMG:None of the main characters are animals.]]
This is just stylistic. They are all human.
* In the episode with Ratburn's MisplacedKindergartenTeacher sister, they had a FlashBack to a substitute teacher who mumbled everything. When Buster asked what she was saying, Arthur replied "your ears are bigger than mine", which would seem imply that Arthur is "aware" of Buster having rabbit ears.
** Maybe he just has big ears.
** Mike Fincke also referred to Buster as a "long-eared kid".
* In the episode in which the class visit a dinosaur fossil site, Mr. Ratburn explains that dinosaurs lived 60 million years before "upright mammals."
** The latest season seem to support the theory that they are actually humans. For example a rabbit child has an aardvark mother, references to animals, a rabbit character drawing a regular rabbit and pictures that appear to be the outline of humans.
*** Buster's parents are rabbits, not aardvarks.
* Don't buy it. In the episode where Buster comes back from vacation and The Singing Moose (Garfunkel) is referred to by Arthur. "Mom, there's a singing moose outside!"
** Also the fact that Arthur, at least in the book series, is repeatedly referred to as an aardvark.
* To all the above: MediumAwareness.
** I guess this would explain away the one you all missed "I'm made of fur, not money!", spoken by Buster after Muffy asks him for club dues.
* I seem to recall one episode where George offends Buster and Arthur by insulting aardvarks and rabbits.
* There was an episode of Disney's Doug that pointed out that he was friends with Arthur and Buster. It even animated them looking human (though their skin colors were blue and green due to the style of that show.)

[[WMG: Ratburn is an EldritchAbomination bent on causing his class eternal grief.]]
He is similar to Tigger.
* He's the only one of the teachers in the school who doesn't confuse the 3rd grade curriculum with that of the preschool/kindergarten set. Knowledge is power, and power corrupts, so he is clearly up to something.
** Yeah, it's pretty clear all Ratburn is doing is challenging his students. There's an episode when there's an academic decathlon or somesuch between the schools third grade classes, and Ratburn's ''thrashes'' the others.
*** Actually, Ratburn's old teacher shows up and thrashes Ratburn's class...
**** Ratburn's old teacher was shown to be cruel and vindictive, as was his class. Besides, it was ''Arthur'' who figured out how to pull the sword out of the stone. Ratburn is teaching his students to be more than intelligent.

[[WMG: DW is the EldritchAbomination feeding off Arthur]]
* Thats pretty much self explanatory.

[[WMG:They will make an episode of Arthur about sexuality.]]
* They've done a bunch of other tough topics, from cancer to cursing.
** Yeah, but for a show where the cast is ''eight''?
* There's a good chance it will only air once.
* [=TiVo=] it, kids. [[MemeticMutation Never forgets.]]
* Wasn't there some episode where Arthur started to have feelings towards Francine, but then shrugs it off? It involves a square-dance event.
** There was also a sequence (in the lice episode) where she successfully passes as a boy when hanging out in the boys' restroom after getting a haircut. I think it would be far too much to expect anything to come of [[QueerAsTropes those]] [[GenderAndSexualityTropes situations]] [[AttractiveBentGender in]] [[SweetOnPollyOliver tandem]], though, and considering it will be two to four years before any of them even start puberty, they might simply never bring up sexual attraction beyond "the opposite sex might not be totally icky" no matter how progressive society is by the time ''Arthur'' ends. Now, this subject is getting somewhat disturbing, so I'll be over at the BrainBleach Cafe.
* Arthur does episodes that the average 7-year old can relate to. A seven year old can relate to bullying, having hard teachers, knowing people with diseases (asthma, allergies, cancer), etc. No seven year old is going to be having sex! Therefore Arthur isn't going to go there!!!
** Don't underestimate seven year olds. I remember back in elementary two 4th graders were caught having sex in a bathroom. Also, on ''sexuality''. Either relating to the LGBT somehow (an gay character appears?), sex ed, related to sexuality in a vague way, one of the characters has a crush on the same gender, etc. Plus a majority of seven year olds do have an avid interest in sex. Just go to an elementary school and hear the little bugs talk. There was a study using Google and sex, even porn, related searches were in the top five for that age group.
** Exactly what it sounded like. You guys must not remember elementary well enough. Also, like I said, an episode vaguely based on something sexual related would be plausible. Something innocent enough to get past the radar and that a lot of kids his age experience. Maybe something about sex ed, the LGBT issues, or new feelings.
*** This troper remembers elementary pretty well and most certainly does NOT recall any classmates having something beyond the dimmest idea of what sex is. Talked a lot about kissing, sure, but sex? Hell no. Sex among students was unheard of until middle school. So yeah, rough school district maybe?
*** This troper had sex ed in elementary school, but it was near the end of the school year in fifth grade. Most of the class was ''eleven''; a lot of the girls had started their growth spurts even. Arthur and his class are mostly eight. Huge difference. Just because some 7-year-olds type "porn" on Google doesn't mean sex is an appropriate topic for a kids' show depicting third-graders.
*** I just want to point out that This Troper went to two different schools growing up, one in the suburbs and one downtown. I went to the suburban one for grade 1-5, and there, everything was very happy and innocent. Topics like sex were hidden until you were almost graduated, sexuality was almost non-existent, and swearing was highly uncommon. Halfway into grade 5 I transferred schools to the one downtown and went there for grades 5-8. A harsh reality kinda crashed around me: there was swearing every three seconds from all grades, little kids talking about porn and sex, and sex scandals among the higher grades. I thought the idea of being "gay" was a joke until I went there. What I'm trying to say is that your mileage may vary depending on how your grew up, and that things can differ insanely depending on area or school (just ending the "what kids are like" debate). I don't think they'll do an episode on sexuality though, since kids' TV still doesn't want to admit that girl/girl and boy/boy relationships exist.
*** I kind of had an idea of what sex was (which turned out to be right) when I was seven, and I started swearing then too. I also had crushes on members of the opposite sex, and thought about the bodies of both sexes then. We had learned about stranger danger already, and I had some pretty sick thoughts. But I knew that I was a bit messed up, and I knew nobody like the seven-year-olds the OP (?) described.
*** What if instead of sex, there was a kid that was transgender? It would cover the LGBTQ spectrum yet for the most part be kept innocent enough (not to mention educational). They can even have a background character given a day in the limelight for this.
* There's a simple reason why this won't happen, Parental groups would kill it. Look what happened to the episode of Buster's spinoff series about gay parenting.
** The episode wasn't even about gay parenting. It was about making syrup in Vermont. One of the characters just happened to have "two moms", it was only mentioned once, but people still went crazy and most stations won't air the episode. So yeah, unlikely that there will be a full-on episode about it, seeing as how the mere MENTION of gay people existing in a children's show is enough to piss people off.

For once, could we get an episode from Catherine's Point-of View, or Molly's? We have had views from the main cast (Arthur, Fraince, Binky, Brain, Muffy, Sue Ellen), we've had episodes from D.W.'s, Kate and Pal's point of views, and from a Pen Pal of Arthur's point of view. So why not have an episode= from the "older" side? Eight-year-olds aren't the only one who watch it; older kids watch it too (besides, we could at least get a glimpse of the high school).

[[WMG: All the named characters are being perpetually held back in school.]]
* If you look at the background characters from one season to another, they change. Obviously the reason they can have so many end of the year episodes is that Arthur and his friends keep getting held back. The rest of the background characters, however, are intelligent enough to pass Ratburn's class.
** If this is true, then why don't any of the kids age?
** And why does Brain keep getting held back if he gets straight A's, and the best grades in the class?
*** Canonically he's been held back.

[[WMG: Doug Funnie was once a resident of Elwood City]]
An episode of ''WesternAnimation/{{Doug}}'' pretty much names his friends as Arthur and Buster (although they were blue and green skinned people instead of animals on that show).

[[WMG: Arthur's pen pal, Adil, is a [[UsefulNotes/{{Islam}} Muslim]], but the episode didn't show it explicitly.]]
The hints are that he's from Turkey, and that there were rugs in his house (which is one of the things you need to do the five-time prayer). Also Adil's father is seen with a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taqiyah_%28cap%29 taqiyah]].
* Confirmed, he mentions fasting for Ramadan in the episode where Francine is attempting her first Yom Kippur fast.
* Isn't >90% of Turkey's population Muslim[[note]]Though according to TheOtherWiki only a little over half of the population of Turkey actually follow Islamic traditions[[/note]]?

[[WMG: Thora paid the crossing guard to scare Arthur.]] D. W. was upset because was Arthur was scaring her by telling her that there were monsters under her bed and sweaters are alive. Thora decided that Arthur needed his comeuppance so she paid Ted the crossing guard to scare Arthur by telling him he had goons and that he had cameras everywhere. Thora did seem to know him pretty well. It just happened to be unfortunate that Brain was with Arthur and got scared by what Ted said as well.
** Completely plausible. Grandma and D.W. seem to be very close, perhaps because of the *IdenticalGrandson trope used in "Clarissa is Cracked." It's possible that Thora, who grew up with three older brothers, was a victim of the same kind of lies Arthur tells D.W., and would've paid off an old friend to show him how that felt. It's even more possible when one considers that she's a senior citizen and thus probably wouldn't buy as much into the theory of raising/educating children that says, "Everything negative will scar them for life."

[[WMG:Arthur takes place after TheSingularity]]
Sometime in the past humanity left earth/uploaded into the matrix, and have left behind the "people" we see in the show, who are genetically engineered to be very similar to humans, and so have similar customs and societies. They didn't do this to ''all'' animals, so there are still birds, dogs and wild animals, etc. A splinter group of humans are attempting to escape the matrix for whatever reason, and are beaming thoughts out into Buster's brain, which he interprets as aliens.

[[WMG:The entire series is being told by an UnreliableNarrator]]
Who? Arthur himself.

Many years from now, he has written an autobiography detailing his childhood and his friends. All of the episodes were infact at different points in their lives, before and after the year of third grade (when the series seems to take place). Most of the stories are told from his perspective. Hence D.W being more bratty in some episodes or Mr.Ratburn giving homework that normally be a part of the high school curriculum. Why be unreliable? It would be dull to write what actually happened, so he embellishs it, or maybe he doesn't remember everything.
* ''Cousin Catastrophe'' seems to support this. He warps Molly into a bully as a child, when she was simply playing around.
* I think that the show was set up like that to connect more with the target audience. I mean, when you were a kid, there was no way in hell that you would say that you were getting, "just the right amount" of homework. In your mind, your younger siblings were always a pain in the butt, you were always given a mountain of homework, and just about everything was over exaggerated/a big deal in your mind. It's just simply telling it from a kid's perspective.

[[WMG: Francine is not Jewish in the books]]
She's made quite a few references to Santa, and has sat on Santa's lap before. Either that or she likes Santa a lot. [[strike:Who can blame her?]]
* Alternatively, she could just live in North America. My mother works in a daycare, owned by a Hindi woman, where most of the kids are the children of immigrants and about a quarter of the kids are Muslim or from Muslim families. And yet there's an annual Christmas party with a dude dressed up as Santa to give presents to everyone and sit the kids on his lap for a photo. A lot of kids in North America know who Santa is or have sat on his lap, whether or not they are Christian.
* I'm going to say it's probably her not being Jewish. She's never stated to be Jewish in the books, not even hinted, and the cartoon added this years later.
* Some Jews celebrate Christmas.

[[WMG:All the episodes are placed randomly in the span of about one year.]]
Outside the two 2nd grade episodes in Season 1, all of the episodes in the show are shown in the span of roughly one year. Depending on the setting of the episode, they would either take place during the summer between 2nd grade-3rd grade, during the 3rd grade, and during the summer between 3rd grade-4th grade. Heck, one episode "The Short Quick Summer" is shown to begin with Mr. Ratburn letting them out of the last day of school, and ending on the last day of summer.

Of course this does tend to be problematic when once considers [[LongRunnerTechMarchesOn how technology seems to have advanced...]]

[[WMG:Ceberus is Arthur.]]
However he forgets his true identity. Arthur's Big Hit is his original personality breaking through.


[[WMG:The two rabbit kids in Arthur's class ARE named Alex and Maria.]]
Anyone longtime viewer of the show will instantly recognize the two rabbit kids that have been part of Arthur's class, and Season 13's MacFrensky episode seems to reveal their identities. This is supported by the fact that in said episode, all classroom scenes showcase those two being the only other kids outside of the established characters.
* Confirmed at New York Comic Con 2013, along with the possibility of them becoming more developed characters.

[[WMG: Arthur is TheUnfavorite compared to D.W.]]
This is the only explanation.
[[WMG: All the humans are extinct]]
The series takes place in an alternative future to where all the homo sapiens are deceased, probably from a nuclear war, and the animals that had managed to survive, were mutated in the waste, and later became super intelligent creatures. They later went to rebuild civilization. The bodies of the humans were [[FridgeHorror later consumed by the evolved animals.]]

[[WMG: Fern is actually smarter than Alan.]]
She's pretty subtle and quiet about it, though.
* She's shown to be pretty intelligent, such as when she shows her deductive skills in one of the few episodes that features her. She's just really shy and quiet.

[[WMG: A future episode will bring back the show's Harry Potter analogy]]
Ever since Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows came out, the show stopped having Prunella/Marina episodes focusing on their relationship linked by the HP analogy, Henry Screever. However, with the movies now done, and Pottermore on the Internet, the writers might bring it back.

[[WMG: Nadine is like Hanyuu from ''HigurashiNoNakuKoroNi'']]
She's only seen by one character in the entire show (DW), is invisible most of the time and 'hides' whenever someone else comes along, and DW acts like she's there most of the time. She checks up on other people, maybe Nadine's responsible for most of the strange events whenever DW was there with Arthur...
** So Nadine is a ghost? ...Sweet.

[[WMG: Francine, Muffy, and the other anthropomorphic apes in ''Arthur'' are like the apes in ''PlanetOfTheApes'']]
They both walk upright on two legs and have humanoid body shapes.

[[WMG: Fern's family is suppose to represent a interracial family]]
Fern's parents are the only parents in the show to be two completely different types of dog with two different color coats.
** D.W.'s friend Emily's family maybe as well. Her dad's an ape, her mom's a rabbit, and she has characteristics of both

[[WMG: W.D. is an intersexual, they just weren't allowed to say that out loud on the programme.]]
Look at it this way: The only reason that W.D. was referred to as a "she" was because it gets old/complicated trying to refer to xir without pronouns, and most adults don't know what Spivak pronouns are, much less children. Xie was referred to as female a total of 4 times throughout the episode, where they never hesitate to refer to any other character with a gender.

Canonically, xir parents wanted a girl, so they're raising xir as a girl. However, xie wants to be a boy, and does boy things. Xir parents, holding the IdiotBall, just treat xir as a tomboy. D.W. is just as much of a tomboy as W.D. (just in different areas), yet D.W. is always referred to as "she" and always has been. W.D's parents only THINK they're letting xir be xirself, when actually, they're holding xir back quite a bit by referring to xir as a girl. In xir teen years, this will lead to a massive power/sexual struggle between W.D. and xir parents when xie finally realizes xie wants to be a real boy. If W.D. doesn't already know that xie's intersexual, it will just make it that much more difficult in xir later years.

[[FairlyOddParents Or I want a banana. I could be paraphrasing.]]

* OR she's just a tomboy.
* But then it wouldn't be a ''wild'' guess, would it? ;) -OP
** Ahh, I see your point, then.

[[WMG: Molly's an anime fan.]]
It's hinted at in "Agent of Change"; not only is the ActionGirl spy she drew rather {{Animesque}} in art style but if you look closely you'll see that she has a ([[LawyerFriendlyCameo green]]) {{Domo}} plushie in her bedroom!

[[WMG: Arthur is an alternate version of CloneHigh.]]
How can you explain all of the celebrities appearing in this small town and the ridiculous plots!
* [[MemeticMutation Say WHAAAAAT?]]

[[WMG: The show takes place in Canada]]
The show hints this as Ratburn in one episode assigns the class something about the beaver in Canadian history. Emily's babysitter maybe a Francophone Québécoise. Also during a cold opening David saw that his weight was 185, that almost 400lb!. All of the fact point out that the show takes place there!
* I seem to recall it being indicated more than once that Washington D.C. is the capital stated to be the capital of the country where the characters live within the show's universe. There is a visit to Washington D.C. and it's within easy driving distance, suggesting the below guess is closer to the mark. ... In fact, firmly {{Jossed}}. In one installment, Arthur's address is specifically given as 562 Main Street, Elwood City, USA.
* And they do use milk bags in a few episodes. But then, they also use cartons of milk.
* It's not that the show is ''set'' in Canada, it's that the show is ''animated'' in Canada. So chances are if you see anything Canada-esque (like milk in bags), that's why.
* TheOtherWiki states that it is a Canadian/American TV show. Animated in Canada? Probably. Set in Canada? Probably not: Washington, D.C. is listed as the capital, and they take a bus ride to Amish country. While there are Amish in Canada, they are far more prevalent in the USA.

[[WMG: The show takes place in New England]]
Remember that episode when Arthur was digging in his front yard? During the ImagineSpot, the Reads were eating hot-dogs like [[http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/thumblarge_357/1232573543cES6Lh.jpg this]]. Also Elwood has a baseball team that were copies of the 2004 Red Sox. All of the fact point out that the show takes place there!
** There's also the fact that one of the class field trips was to Amish country. Leaving aside the implausibility of this (the Amish do NOT just let outsiders show up and poke around randomly, even if they are kids), there are Amish communities in Pennsylvania, Maine, and other New England states. The show would have to take place in New England for the class to be able to reach an Amish community on a bus (though some field trips can have 2-4 hour travel times).
*** Creator Marc Brown was born in Pennsylvania as well, which might've been an influence on the locales in the series.

[[WMG: The reason Buster lives with his father for three seasons is because it is believed his mother molested him]]
His father has no permanent residence, so they obviously would not let his father have sole custody for such a long period, unless his mother was deemed unfit. It is shown at various points in the main show that his mother loves him more than any other man. Can you say {{Squick}}?

[[WMG: Arthur gained an unhealthy obsession with cosmetic surgery at some point]]
In the first book (from 1976) he actually looked like an aardvark, but disliked his long nose and wanted to have surgery to change it. In the end he decided he should like the way he is (a normal Aesop in children's stories). But then why did his aardvark-like nose slowly get smaller over time (to the point that when the cartoon debuted 20 years later he looks more like a hamster)? After the book he realized he really did hate his nose and got it made smaller. But it was still too big, so he had it made even smaller until, one day, he didn't have a nose at all.

[[WMG: Bi-species characters can have a mix of traits from their parents]]
Look at Emily's nose and compare it to Buster's. She has a monkey nose, not a rabbit nose. Her father is a monkey.
** Prunella is apparently a rat, but has poodle-like hair and ears. I think her mom and sister do too. They could also be bi-species.

[[WMG: Carl grows up to be [[TheBigBangTheory Sheldon Cooper]]]]
Sheldon is most likely autistic, has an interest in trains, is bright, has a loving mother, etc.

[[WMG:"Crazy Bus" is about a literal crazy bus]]
As in the route 25 to the loony bin. "Don't make a fuss, just come with us"? Yeah. Uncooperative prospective mental patients will be sedated and get "high" as a plane or balloonie (Arthur was right; spellchecker does seem to indicate it's not an actual word). Alternatively, all the above applies, but it's a kid being taken away to the "crazy bus", with the mental workers telling him it'll be a fun ride with a clown and stuff. Or that's just how the kid's warped mind perceives it. Oh, and for a meta twist... that kid is YOU after being forced to listen to the song for 24 hours straight.

[[WMG: Arthur and his friends live in a post-apocalyptic world where animals have risen up to replace humans.]]
In "D.W. Goes to Washington," while at the Lincoln Memorial, Lincoln is shown to be ''human.'' In the same episode, the Clinton {{Expy}} is shown to be an aardvark, like the Reads. This means, that at some point between 1865 and the present, the ''entirety'' of the animal kingdom has risen up to overthrow mankind.
** Francine's great great grandfather was a barber to Lincoln and is a monkey. We see people from the past like ancient Romans, Lewis and Clark, and they're animals too. Either this is {{Jossed}} or they coexisted with people.

[[WMG: D.W. is a Time Lord]]
Because I say so.
* You don't need to: D.W. -- '''D'''octor '''W'''ho!
* This would certainly explain the fact that everybody has been the same age for 18 years. It could be that D.W. has some sort of omniscient powers that allow her to be fully cognizant of everything happening, even in episodes that are not in her point of view. Of course, this can be frustrating for her because due to the time loop/warp, she and the other cast members don't get any older. She even asks if she's trapped in a time warp in "Arthur's New Year's Eve." Is she just a frustrated little kid? Is her memory erased each time she makes a loop? Or, did she just ask that to cover her Time Lord status? HMMMMMM.....

[[WMG: Mr. Toad is a con artist]]
Always thought it was weird that they had an episode dedicated to D.W. bonding with a Toad, only for him to disappear. Then I realized, Mr. Toad never wanted to be D.W.'s pet. He just wanted access to her socks so he could steal them and use them in the sock market. He knew Spanky had died and wanted to catch D.W. on the rebound. He probably does this to kids all over the neighborhood.
* The problem with this theory is that Mr. Toad isn't the one who became DW's pet, his girlfriend is.
[[WMG: Arthur and his family are actual practicing Christians.]]
Not much evidence exists, but since Arthur's Perfect Christmas explicitly mentions Jesus and church, it's a possibility. Also, it's a stretch, but many Christian parents do not like for their children to watch shows such as Power Rangers, of which the violent cartoon the Tibble twins like is an Expy. Jane Read's response to them wanting to watch it at her house could be because of this. Then again, Arthur does read and enjoy Henry Skreever, so make of that what you will.

[[WMG: D.W., and perhaps the Brain, have Asperger's Syndrome.]]

Many fans of the show complain about D.W.'s seeming lack of empathy toward Arthur, citing episodes like "Arthur's Big Hit" as examples. It could be that D.W. has more going on than the average tantrum-throwing four-year-old in terms of her emotions. Also, her interests seem pretty specialized and limited--the biggest one we see is an interest in unicorns. Third, she's obsessed with "Mary Moo Cow" to the point of dragging her mom away from errands if D.W. thinks it's time for the show to be on. (Some kids with Asperger's may do this type of thing because they're very dependent on routine). As for Brain, he mentions having an uncle with Asperger's; though the condition is not strictly hereditary, Brain could've picked up some Asperger's traits from the parent whom the uncle is related to. More evidence exists in the form of episodes like "Bugged," where Brain is an InsufferableGenius.
** Further supported by a scene in "Best Enemies," where D.W. invites W.D. (her tomboy counterpart) to play a board game that is meant for kids six or older. It can be inferred that D.W. is smart enough to play.

[[WMG: Rattles Ciccone's name is actually a nickname.]]

In "What's in a Name," we find out that [[spoiler: Binky's real name is Shelley. He was called that until age two, when he became very attached to his pacifier, to the point that his parents nicknamed him Binky.]] It's possible that Binky's parents are or were friends with Rattles' parents, and that Rattles also acquired his nickname from a baby toy--a rattle.
----
<<|WildMassGuessing|>>