* PlayingAgainstType:
** Most fans know Toby for playing comedic characters on other web shows, but they got an unexpected surprise when Toby appeared on the Black Box TV episode [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKmLvXajI1I "This Is For You Baby!"]] as [[spoiler: a vengeful boyfriend whose girlfriend is cheating on him with his best friend. Yikes!]] They state in the commentary that they picked Toby for the role precisely because people were used to him being comical.
** Toby stars in DeadIsland: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbrKIDv9wZ4 "No Retreat"]] as a HandicappedBadass of a husband trying to protect his wife from not only zombies but raiders she stole medical supplies from. [[spoiler: they both die, but not after dispatching of a ton of zombies and all the raiders. In a silent DyingDeclarationofLove, he rips the wedding ring he's been hiding on a chain to keep her safe and puts it back on.]] Film shows that not only can Toby play a serious role, but he can play action and be a romantic lead.
** Toby appears in the Stranger Things episode [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__ZGjjjvOVQ "Sacred Cow"]] as Father Micheal Hutchsons, a serious priest and a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who has come to investigate a fellow priest and his adopted DitzyGenius son over a video of prayers turning into energy caught on tape, but [[spoiler:it turns out Father Micheal is an ex-communicated priest and a SerialKiller who is part of a cult that worships {{Sufficiently Advanced Alien}}s that have been feeding off of the energy of human prayers]].
** This will likely be averted with Toby's cameo appearance in the upcoming slasher flick ''[[http://smileymovie.com/ Smiley]]'', as he revealed in one of his Vlogs that he will play the role of a ClassClown[=/=]{{Jerkass}} in said film.
** In an episode of One of those Faces, [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwT7xR1Tev8 Stranger Things]], Toby plays the role of a Guardian Angel sort of figure. It's a far more serious role then what most fans would expect from him.