'''As a Moments subpage, [[Administrivia/SpoilersOff all spoilers are unmarked.]] Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.'''

!From ''A Very Potter Musical''
* "Missing You". Harry's sense of loss over Dumbledore's death and Quirrel's longing for Voldemort are both pretty gut-wrenching, even when the lyrics are humorous.
-->'''Harry:''' ''♫ You gave me hope when my spells weren't right. ♫''\\
'''Quirrell:''' ''♫ You gave me someone to hold every night... ♫''
* Ron, Hermione, and Ginny's reactions to Harry announcing that he is going to sacrifice himself and Harry's good-bye.

!From ''A Very Potter Sequel''
* Strangely, Dumbledore's rejection of Umbridge and her subsequent breakdown is quite depressing... at least, until Umbridge subsequently crosses the MoralEventHorizon.
* Draco's letter to his father. The ParentalNeglect from Lucius is rather sad.
* "Guys Like Potter" will make you want to hug Snape, no question.
* Soon after "Those Voices," Snape looks into the Mirror of Erised and sees Lily. He looks at her for a second, and then silently exits the stage in order to protect Harry and the others. Lily is left alone, and the lights fade to black...
* "To Have a Home", which resonates with anyone who's ever been rejected then found a place where they truly belong, and Guys Like Potter, which, despite its last line, deals with the always-tearjerking Snape/Lily ship in a way comparable to the Prince's Tale chapter.

!From ''A Very Potter Senior Year''
* "I Was" is quite depressing, capturing both Harry and Tom Riddle's sadness regarding being unwanted and Harry's nostalgia for his old adventures.
* "Everything Ends". The title alone kind of explains why.
* "It's all that I loved, and all that you'll see..."
* "OK is wonderful."
* "Things come and go. Nothing lasts forever, kid." and "You know, there's two things in this world I love. One of them's you." Fucking ''hell''.
* Quirell and Voldemort's speech about Harry Potter, how it's brought them joy, family and love but sometimes you need to let things go.
* "Harry, Hermione's Petrified, and I can't do anything to help her!" Joey Richter's delivery is incredible.
* Several of the actors are visibly tearing up during the last couple scenes. Several people have stated Lauren Lopez in particular got them crying too.
* All of the other characters lining up to hug Harry goodbye, especially as most of the actors are genuinely crying. Special mention goes to Neville's goodbye--while the other farewells are softened by the overall [[LargeHam ridiculousness]] of each character, Neville just gives a quiet, understated, "Goodbye, Mr. Potter," and presses his face into Harry's shoulder during their hug. The whole thing is clearly just as emotional for the actors as it is for the characters.