Directed by Creator/JoshBecker

Written by Creator/RJStewart & Creator/StevenLSears

Xena goes in search of a legendary lost treasure which includes Ambrosia, the sustenance of the gods, in an effort to keep the precious food from falling into the wrong hands.

!Tropes
* TheCharmer: Petracles. He won over Xena's heart and he was doing the same to Gabrielle despite Xena's warnings.
* EatTheEvidence: Xena eats her clue so that no one else will know it.
* HoistByHisOwnPetard: Xena ends up killing Thersites using his own hidden projectile against him.
* IfYouEverDoAnythingToHurtHer: After she sees Gabrielle being friendly towards Petracles, she quietly tells him she will rip out his throat if he does anything to hurt her.
* ImmortalityInducer: Ambrosia makes its first appearance in the series. Xena hopes to find it first before the others discover the means to find it.
* KillTheLights: Thersites kills the lights to make off with the key to Ambrosia and Gabrielle and escape the others.
* NothingUpMySleeve: Thersites reveals he has a knife that can shot out and stab his victims.
* RedemptionEqualsDeath: Petracles saves Gabrielle from the hostage situation, but at the cost of his own life.
* RopeBridge: The four have to cross one to escape a continuous volley of arrows courtesy of the Peis people.
* RainOfArrows: Shot by the Peis people.
* ShoutOut: The title is a reference to Film/AFistfulOfDollars.
* TeethClenchedTeamwork: Neither Xena, Petracles nor Thersites trust each other, but they needed each others' clues to get to the gold.
* VictoryIsBoring: The reason Petracles abandoned Xena. He won her heart and she was ready to marry him, but he lost interest afterwards and decided to leave her.
* WomanScorned: Xena is still more than a bit peeved at Petracles for dumping her.
-----
->'''Disclaimer:''' ''[[NoAnimalsWereHarmed No Ambrosia was Spilled, Spoiled or in any way harmed during the production of this motion picture. (Thanks to the indefinite shelf life of marshmallows.)]]''