Jimmy Olsen is having a bad week. Lois is sidelining him in favor of a new intern. Tina, the girl he likes, won't give him the time of day. He's having an all-around crisis of confidence. Then Jimmy gets a thank-you from the Man of Steel himself for his help in rescuing civilians on a breaking bridge, and everything changes. When Angela Chen can't get an interview from Superman on his latest rescue, she resorts to creating a story about Jimmy Olsen's relationship to the Man of Steel. Unfortunately, she blows the whole thing out of proportion. Although initially embarrassed, Jimmy comes to enjoy the perks of his new celebrity, until the downsides start rolling in -- criminals threaten him and people hound him for favors he can't give. Then the worst happens -- Jimmy finds himself kidnapped by Metallo as bait for Superman. Can a photographer save a superhero?
!!This episode contains examples of:
* AllGirlsWantBadBoys: You don't get much more this way than dating a supervillain.
* BigBrotherMentor: Superman/Clark Kent to Jimmy.
* BitchInSheepsClothing: Tina. At the office, she looks like a pretty, [[TheDitz ditzy]] teenage girl. She's actually a hard-hitting manipulator who even Metallo calls cold.
* BreatherEpisode: It's much lighter than the "Darkseid arc" episodes which surround it.
* CarFu: Superman to Metallo. The android is unimpressed.
* CallBack: Twice.
** Angela Chen mentions the events of "Feeding Time", "Solar Power", and "Little Girl Lost" during her televised 'interview' - but she doesn't get all of it correct.
** Superman is also presumably referencing the events of "Feeding Time" when he credits Jimmy with "sav[ing his] life again."
* DeadlyDodging: Jimmy moves a chair so that Metallo's assistant kicks it instead of hitting him again.
* DistressedDude -> DefiantCaptive: After failing to escape, Jimmy doesn't do much until Superman shows up to rescue him and Metallo tries to kill him. Then he breaks out of the car compactor and grabs Metallo with the car magnet.
* DidNotGetTheGirl: But given that she's a frigid supervillain fan girl, Jimmy didn't appear too disappointed.
* DidntSeeThatComing: Metallo's plan was thwarted because he didn't consider if the hostage might try to help his intended victim.
* FriendshipMoment: between Superman and Jimmy at the end of the episode. [[Heartwarming/SupermanTheAnimatedSeries The hero reassures his young colleague that he's done well and gives him the famous signal watch in case he's ever in trouble.]]
* GroupieBrigade: "Superman's Pal" has to outrun a mob of lovestruck teenage girls.
* HandBehindHead: Jimmy does the "uncomfortable" variant when Angela Chen pumps him for information about his relationship with Superman.
* HeroicBystander: in the beginning of the episode, Jimmy drags an unconscious man out of a crashed helicopter. At the end, he saves the Man of Steel himself.
* HopelessSuitor: Jimmy to Tina, until the news report airs.
* IJustWantToBeSpecial: Jimmy, if his conversation with Clark is any indication. He calls himself "just a nobody".
* ImprovisedWeapon: The Man of Steel uses cars; Jimmy uses a battery leaking acid.
* LoveInterestTraitor: Tina.
* LuredIntoATrap: Superman, who arrives to rescue Jimmy and Tina, only to find Metallo waiting for him.
* ManipulativeEditing: When Angela interviews Jimmy, his side of the conversation goes like this: "I don't think I'd be real comfortable with [giving an interview]...It's not like I'd call us pals or anything." When it airs, however, it's been [[QuoteMine edited]] to "Real comfortable, I'd call us pals."
* {{Montage}}: Everyone asking Jimmy for favors from Superman.
* MythologyGag:
** At the end of the episode, Superman gives Jimmy a signal watch which he can use to contact him if he's ever in trouble and needs help. Jimmy's signal watch was a major part of the comics. His joke "Just don't wear it out" could also count because of Jimmy sometimes calling Superman for trivial things.
** The title itself references the SilverAge comic book ''Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen.''
* NeverSayDie:
** Played straight when the lead thug tells Jimmy he's going to "put [him] in the morgue."
** Averted later with one of Jimmy's lines: "How could you help him? He's killing Superman!"
* NowLetMeCarryYou: ZigZagged. Superman and Jimmy protect each other during the fight, but ultimately Jimmy takes out Metallo to save Superman, reversing the usual situation.
* ObfuscatingStupidity: Tina.
* RecycledSoundtrack: This was one of the complaints about the episode.
* RescueReversal: Superman flies into Metallo's trap trying to rescue Jimmy and Jimmy winds up having to save him.
* TheReveal: Tina is Metallo's girlfriend and she only pretended to like Jimmy so that she could trap him as bait for the Man of Steel. Originally, Metallo sent her to get Lois but that didn't work out.
* RevengeByProxy: The leader of a group of thugs gloats that he's going to [[DisproportionateRetribution kill Superman's pal in revenge for Superman sending his to prison.]] Turns out, he was part of a test on Tina's part to make sure that Jimmy would make an effective hostage.
* ShootingSuperman: When Superman turns up to save Jimmy from getting mauled by a gang of thugs, [[WhatAnIdiot one of them]] tries to hit him with a metal bar. Superman {{lampshades}} this:
-->"You're kidding, right?"
* SittingOnTheRoof: Jimmy stands on the ''Planet's'' roof kicking himself over his part in the episode's conflict until Superman shows up to give a YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre speech.
* WaifFu: In spite of her slenderer build, Tina lands some pretty good hits on Jimmy before he turns the tables.
* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: We never find out what happened to Tina after Jimmy locked her in the closet.
* YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre: Our hero says this to Jimmy in both identities.