->''"WE'RE THE GOOD GUYS!!!"''
-->--'''Parker'''


Paul, a school teacher who recently got suspended for stealing a truck, thanks the Leverage team for bailing him out. It turns out that Paul has bought his truck at Duke Penzer's auto shop and was a victim of Penzer's car cloning scheme. Paul was unfortunate to get caught when entering New Hampshire where his truck was originally cloned. Parker adds that Penzer's a distributor and he gets the cars from a car-theft ring, since Parker was formerly a car thief herself. So using Art's Auto Sales (by sending the real owners to a vacation in UsefulNotes/{{Hawaii}}), they decide to sell Penzer's racing car (which they get by cheating) at their supposed auto shop and make it look like they too are running the same scheme as Penzer does.

Meanwhile, after doing some research on who's supplying the hot cars to Penzer, Parker and Hardison meet up with Lefty's crew and pretend to work for them (after passing Lefty's test). Penzer, on the other hand, figures out that Nate is working with the Salvadorans to get his hot cars. He then calls Lefty regarding it and decides to screw Nate's shipment so he would get killed by them. The crew's plan goes well as Parker and Hardison steals cars, until Parker tells a young car-jacker, Josie, of the plans to protect her. Unsure if Parker's a cop or not, she tells Lefty (who tells Penzer) what Parker told her.

Eliot, with a truck full of stolen cars is stopped by Lefty and his men. They try to kill him, but Eliot manages to dive into the water. As Hardison and Parker meet up at the docks, realizing that Eliot's comm is dead, Eliot warns Nate and Sophie that the con's blown but Penzer manages to capture Sophie (and later Nate) at gunpoint. While Lefty's men try to kill Hardison and Parker, suddenly Eliot appears and takes out most of Lefty's men. Josie appears with the car, and Parker takes the wheel as they drive off back to Penzer's shop.

As soon as Lefty appears, telling the good news that there's no signal on the stolen cars, both Nate and Sophie stall for time when Penzer takes a look at the stolen cars. Suddenly, all the stolen cars' alarms start to buzz as Penzer quickly turns them off; he instructs Lefty to take both Nate and Sophie inside. To make matters worse, the police arrives, telling him that the cars are stolen based on the massive number of alarm tracking system signals.

Before Eliot was heading to the rendezvous point, he used Hardison's EMP gun to shut off all the car alarms for 30 minutes. Shocked, Penzer tries to shift the blame at Nate. Unfortunately, the moment they enter back into his office, Lefty is seen lying unconsciously on the table, with Nate and Sophie nowhere to be seen, as Eliot managed to save them from the back door. Dumbfounded, the police arrest both Penzer and Lefty.

Turns out that the reason why the police arrived so quickly was that Parker and Hardison actually stole the cars from the police who were having a golfing event. Art's Auto Sales is going to be full of customers the moment the real owners return, and the team hands Paul Penzer's race car, having gotten all charges against Paul (and possibly Penzer's other victims) dropped. They even introduce Josie to help him with his landscaping business.
----
!!Tropes:
* BigDamnHeroes: Eliot twice shows up for last-minute rescues, accounting for Parker and Hardison in one and Nate and Sophie in the other.
* GroinAttack: As part of their stalling for time when Duke is looking to dispose of them, Sophie knees Nate where it hurts.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Parker warns Jodie to keep her out of trouble, but Jodie informs Lefty and Duke, putting the rest of them in peril.