[[caption-width-right:350:Magnum and his girls.]]

Britta is throwing a Halloween pre-party party before the study group goes to the actual party. Abed and Troy show up as [[JustForFun/InspectorSpacetime the Inspector and the Constable]] and Jeff shows up as one of those [[Film/TheFastAndTheFurious Fast and Furious guys]]. When he goes to leave, however, Britta stops him and reveals the truth.

Remember those [[Recap/CommunityS3E03CompetitiveEcology psychological evaluations]] Britta made everyone do? Well, she ran the numbers, and it turns out ''someone'' in the study group has homicidal tendencies. She claims that it's her directive as a psychology student to figure out this person and get them the treatment they need. The problem is that the tests were anonymous, so Britta devises a way to figure out the sociopath: tell scary stories, and see how everyone reacts.

'''Britta's story''' starts off with Britta and Jeff making out in a car when they are [[http://www.snopes.com/horrors/madmen/hook.asp informed by the radio that an escaped mental patient with a hook thingy for a hand (you know what I mean)]] [[DepartmentOfRedundancyDepartment has escaped and is on the loose and stuff]]. Jeff gets out the car and the escaped mental patient kills him. Back at the study group, Abed complains that [[EightDeadlyWords he didn't care for the characters]], as they were stupid and didn't act like people actually would. So he tells his version of the story.

'''Abed's story''' starts with the newlyweds Abed and Britta going to a cabin in the woods and sharing a kiss. Abed turns on the radio and listens to a song (because having the broadcast start immediately isn't realistic) before they are informed of the escaped mental patient. Abed calls the police with his fully charged cell phone and then they both stand in the middle of the cabin back-to-back holding knives. When the other members of the study group ask if the characters will get killed, Abed says yes, when it's ''earned''. Annie gets annoyed that these aren't really scary stories so decides to tell her own.

'''Annie's story''' starts with the fair maiden Annie getting rescued by the dashing Jeff. However, Jeff has a secret: he's actually a vampire with a thirst for blood (and a blood-deprived Britta in his closet) and... ''he can't read!'' Annie teaches him how to read, but then Jeff reveals that he will always be a monster... before Annie reveals that she's ''also'' a monster, a werewolf that preys on pretentious, self-obsessed vampires. Annie describes [[{{Gorn}} in vivid detail]] how the werewolf then eats Jeff, eating his eyeball while still attached to his optic nerve so he can see his own flesh being digested. And then she flossed her teeth with his entrails. Not wanting to be outdone, Troy decides to tell a "real, legit scary" story.

'''Troy's story''' starts with Troy and Abed as ''Film/TopGun'' fighter pilots who crashed in the woods and found a cabin populated by Pierce as a mad doctor. Doctor Pierce knocks them out and when they wake up, they are sewn together. They figure out that this gives them psychic powers, so they knock out Doctor Pierce and then eat a sandwich. When Doctor Pierce wakes up, they show that they put his butt on his chest and switched his feet and hands, giving him breasts that he can never play with due to his foothands. The actual Pierce gets fed up with his treatment in the story, so he tells his own.

'''Pierce's story''' starts with "Magnum" (Pierce with a wig) and his harem of ladies (Annie, Shirley and Britta) who wish for more sex. Gangstas Troy and Abed barge in, but Magnum disarms them and beats them up with his [[GagPenis gigantic penis]]. The real Troy says that this story wasn't even scary. Shirley says that she has an actual scary story from back when stories were about good versus evil.

'''Shirley's story''' starts with a wild party with booze and drugs. Britta pours her carton of "weed" over herself, but then their death metal is interrupted by heavy news on the radio: all the good people have been raptured up, leaving only the "cool" people. Outside, a rain of blood and plague of locusts is going on, but Britta writes it off--she's lived in New York, after all. Finally, the Devil (played by the Dean) shows up and tells them about their schedule of torments... until the spirit of Shirley arrives and blows the Dean Devil away. Shirley says that she's just come back to wish them goodbye and that she forgives them, then disappears. The Dean Devil comes back and real Shirley says that he then chainsawed them, sewed them back up, and then chainsawed them again... ''forever''.

Everyone gets fed up and decides to leave for the party when Britta tells them about the test results. They still want to leave, but she says that if they do, they could all get brutally murdered (describing the murders in detail), so that now the study group think ''Britta'' may be the mental disturbed one. Violence nearly breaks out until Jeff tries to tell his story.

'''Jeff's story''' starts with the whole group having a good time until the escaped mental patient barges in to kill, but Jeff asks why he kills. The mental patient takes off his paper bag to reveal Chang who says that he kills because he is afraid. They all hug mental patient Chang.

In the study room, the group proclaim that Jeff's story was lame and it doesn't help anything until Jeff reveals that he didn't even look at the questions on the test and just randomly filled in bubbles. They look at the test again and Annie tells Britta that she put the tests into the machine upside-down, so the results are all wrong.

One hour later, Britta has redone all the tests...and all of them except one reveal that the test taker is mentally disturbed. The group decides not to know which one is the sane one so they can all think it is them and leave for the party. Afterwards, it's revealed the sane test belonged to Abed.

This recap has a [[YMMV/CommunityS3E05HorrorFictionInSevenSpookySteps YMMV page]]
!The ''Series/{{Community}}'' episode "Horror Fiction In Seven Spooky Steps" provides examples of:

* AlwaysABiggerFish[=/=]FoodChainOfEvil: Annie's story ends with Vampire!Jeff being eaten alive by Werewolf!Annie.
* AndIMustScream:
** In Annie's story, vampire!Jeff gets eaten and is alive to experience all of it. The entire group is ''horrified''.
** In Shirley's story, the cool hedonists are chainsawed into pieces by Devil-Dean, only for him to put them back together and chainsaw them into pieces again, ''forever''.
* {{Anvilicious}}: In-universe examples. Shirley's story where the bad people are all hurt. Jeff's story has the lesson that killers are just misunderstood people who need a hug.
* ArtShift: Annie's story is shot in Victorian style.
* AuthorTract: Shirley's story is an in-universe example.
-->'''Devil-Dean:''' *Swings around a chainsaw* GAY MARRIAGE!!
* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: Being buried to the neck in scorpions is followed by a lava enema, which is followed by Pilates. Subverted when TheDevil explains that Pilates is the name of the demon who will eat your genitals.
* BackToBackBadasses: Britta and Abed in Abed's story.
* BeastAndBeauty: This is what Annie's story appears to be going for until the twist.
* BigNO: In Troy's story.
* BrainySpecs: Britta wears some while reading [[PunnyName Warren Piece]].
* BrickJoke: Combined with FunnyBackgroundEvent and ShoutOut. As Annie complains that there's nothing on Britta's playlist but Spooky Party, the ''Film/{{Beetlejuice}}'' soundtrack, and Creator/{{NPR}} podcasts, a student dressed as Beetlejuice walks by the window. This is the third time someone has said "Beetlejuice" in the course of the entire ''series.''
* BridalCarry: Occurs in both Annie's and Troy's stories.
* BuffySpeak: Britta's story is filled with it, including the killer having a "hook thingy."
* CallBack:
** Abed and (maybe) Jeff are likely the only two sane people in the group, as noted in [[Recap/CommunityS1E20TheScienceOfIllusion The Science of Illusion.]]
** [[Recap/CommunityS3E03CompetitiveEcology Competitive Ecology]] ends with the group filling in psych profile tests for Britta. This episode focusses on the aftermath of Britta getting the results for those tests back.
** Troy notes that there will be great taco meat at the party. Infected meat confused by the dean with taco meat was the cause of a zombie apocylpse at the previous Halloween party.
* CardboardPrison: Justified in Abed's story. Given the recent economic downturn, the nearby asylum cut corners and a patient escaped.
* TheCasanova: Pierce in his story.
* CaughtUpInTheRapture: Shirley's story.
* CellPhonesAreUseless: {{Defied|Trope}} in Abed's story. He made sure his cell phone was fully charged before heading up to the mountain cabin.
* CoincidentalBroadcast: Played straight in Britta's story, {{defied|trope}} in Abed's story -- much to the annoyance of everyone except Troy (who bops along with the muzak Abed has playing until the broadcast proper).
* ComicallyMissingThePoint:
** When Britta, very concerned, discusses how borderline-sociopathic Annie's story came across, Troy takes it as Britta "pinning ribbons on her" and comes up with a story of his own in an attempt to top Annie's.
** Pierce doesn't even try to make his story scary and instead uses it to [[HerCodenameWasMarySue glorify himself]] and lash out at Troy and Abed over his treatment in Troy's story. He also assumes the cool hedonist leader in Shirley's story (a stand-in for Jeff) to be his own stand-in character, and wonders why Jeff wasn't in the story.
** Britta misunderstands the meaning of "britta-ing" (it's something along the lines of 'fucking up') as "making a small and ''understandable'' mistake."
* ContinuityNod: Troy mentions that the Dean got [[Recap/CommunityS2E06Epidemiology taco meat from the army for the Halloween party.]]
* CoolAndUnusualPunishment: The fate that befalls MadScientist!Pierce in Troy's story.
* CreatorBreakdown: InUniverse, each narrator's story is more than a little informed by their personal issues and relationships to the rest of the group:
** Britta's has her and Jeff's FriendsWithBenefits relationship from the previous season as a subtext, as well as her StrawFeminist tendencies, with her being "smart" and staying in the car and Jeff getting out and dying (after Britta badgered him), all while she screams that "she told him so".
** Abed's demonstrates his difficulty connecting with people in general and the other members of the group specifically, as represented by Britta; he's more interested in the practical details of the story and shuts down any attempt her character makes to try and bond with him, romantically or otherwise. His story also fails to engage the other members of the group [[HeterosexualLifePartners other than Troy.]]
** Annie's reveals both [[ShipTease her desire to change Jeff for the better]] coupled with a bit of insecurity over how reliable a potential partner he may be and [[GreenEyedMonster a hint of jealousy over Britta and Jeff's hookups]] masked as disdain for Britta's character.
** Troy's is about his and Abed's ability to overcome Pierce's attempts to drive a wedge between them out of jealousy in the previous episode, along with the suggestion that Troy might be more than a little codependent in his friendship with Abed.
** Pierce is not-so-subtly lashing out at Troy and Abed over the previous story, coupled with his [[DirtyOldMan leching over the female members of the group]].
** Shirley is basically a polemic of her religious beliefs coupled with a bit of insecurity / vengeance over what she sees as the ways the other members of the group exclude her.
** Jeff basically wants to resolve the conflicts that have arisen between the other members of the group without actually putting the work required in to resolve them.
* CriticalResearchFailure:
** InUniverse; Shirley seems to think that you can snort marijuana. Also, that NPR is a music station that partying kids would be listening to Death Metal on. Also, Britta seems to think that ''Literature/WarAndPeace'' is actually called Warren Piece.
* [[DeathBySex Death By Hedonism]]: The younger members of the group suffer this in Shirley's story.
* DeathBySex: [[DefiedTrope Defied]] in Abed's story. Britta's attempt to kindle romance is quickly shushed to avoid dropping their guard.
* {{Deconstruction}} of GenreSavvy and RationalFiction as the characters in-verse point out how Abed's story is just boring and lack suspense in this regard.
* DecoyDamsel: Annie in her story.
* DepartmentOfRedundancyDepartment: In Britta's narration:
-->'''Radio announcer:''' ... an escaped convict from the asylum has escaped...
* DiggingYourselfDeeper: In attempting to persuade everyone that there could be a psychopathic individual in the study group, Britta's graphic description of what could happen if they were allowed to go unidentified and untreated only serves to freak everyone out and convince them -- and herself -- that ''she's'' the psychopath in question.
* DontGoInTheWoods: Played straight in Britta's story, [[JustifiedTrope justified]] in Abed's story. It's no longer the '50s, so it makes sense to rent a cabin rather than park at a make-out point.
* DramaticThunder
* DumbassHasAPoint: When Britta is revealing her motives for the Halloween stories Pierce points out that if one of them was a murderous psychopath, in over two years of friendship and hanging out they'd have probably picked up on something before now.
* EarWorm: (InUniverse)[[invoked]] "Daybreak" by Michael Haggins, the song from Abed's story. It has received numerous [[CallBack call backs]] being hummed or vocalized by [[Recap/CommunityS3E09FoosballAndNocturnalVigilantism Troy]], [[Recap/CommunityS3E11UrbanMatrimonyAndTheSandwichArts Annie]], and [[Recap/CommunityS3E13DigitalExplorationOfInteriorDesign Abed]]. It was finally referred to by name and played in "[[Recap/CommunityS3E14PillowsAndBlankets Pillows And Blankets]]".
* EightDeadlyWords: InUniverse, Abed's feelings towards the characters in Britta's story, and all TooDumbToLive characters in general. Shot back at Abed when Annie's reaction at his story being a strictly logical defiance of all horror tropes (and absolutely nothing else) is clear disgust and asking Abed whether or not he's actually planning to kill his characters.
* EinsteinHair: Pierce in Troy's story.
* EpicFail:
** The group refers to this as [[PersonAsVerb "Britta."]] It doesn't help that she graded the tests upside down, failed to notice even after double checking, and set the whole episode's plot in motion because of the misunderstanding.
** Troy invokes this after Shirley's AuthorTract story.
-->"You ruined a Britta party. That's like letting poop spoil."
* EvenBetterSequel: In-universe. Troy expresses this opinion for ''SuperMonkeyBall 2'' right before being attacked in Britta's story.
* FlamingDevil: The Dean in Shirley's story.
* {{Foreshadowing}}:
** Troy and Abed reveal that they were already in their Inspector Spacetime and Constable Reggie costumes when Britta called to invite them to her Halloween Party. [[spoiler:Chances are, they were dressed this way because they were playing in the Dreamatorium, which will be revealed in two episodes and which they spend a lot of time over the season [[InsistentTerminology rendering imaginated dreamscapes]].]]
** Annie's story involves her trying to change Jeff for the better (with the [[ShipTease subtext]] of him becoming a more suitable romantic partner for her), only for it all to go south when he reverts to his old ways. [[spoiler:In "Virtual Systems Analysis" later in the season, she ends up admitting to herself and Abed that she keeps trying to push Jeff into fitting various roles he's possibly not suited for because she's "in love with the idea of being loved" and afraid of being lonely.]]
** The murderer in Jeff's story is played by Chang. [[spoiler: "The First Chang Dynasty" has Chang trying to murder the study group.]]
* FramingDevice: The results for the tests Britta had the group fill out a couple episodes ago have come back, and someone is potentially homicidally insane. Britta feels the best way to detect who it could be is to tell scary stories and observe the results.
* FryingPanOfDoom: In Troy's story, he and Abed use one to whack Pierce via telekinesis.
* FunnyBackgroundEvent: This one takes it to a whole [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19FMU3M7Jtk&feature=player_embedded different level.]]
* FurAgainstFang: Annie's story.
* GagPenis: Pierce has one in his story.
* GangstaStyle: Abed and Troy hold their guns this way in Pierce's story.
* GenreBlindness / GenreSavvy: Parodied and deconstructed; Abed objects to the GenreBlindness displayed by the characters in Britta's story, explaining that character's making decisions the audience never would makes us lose sympathy for them. His innate Genre Savviness leads him to construct a perfectly logical horror story where the protagonists [[AvertedTrope avoid every single cliche, mistake and convention]] present in the genre... even the [[NecessaryWeasel ones necessary for telling a story.]] This almost completely robs his story of suspense, tension and horror, and just serves to bore and irritate his audience.
-->'''Annie:''' Ugh! Do these people ever die or what?!\\
'''Abed:''' ''[`Spooky` voice]'' Eventually... once it had been... '''''earrrrrrrrned!!'''''
* GilliganCut: Britta dramatically declares to Jeff that one member of the group has homicidal tendencies. Cut to the other members of the group, goofily dancing to cheesy Halloween music and basically acting as little like deranged murderous psychopaths as is humanly possible.
* {{Glurge}}: Invoked in-universe; Shirley's tale is a perfect, [[ComicBook/ChickTracts Jack Chick-like]] mix of treacly moralizing and horrendous damnation, and most find it annoying rather than scary or uplifting.
* {{Gorn}}: Annie doesn't spare any details about Vampire!Jeff's rather gruesome fate.
* GrievousBottleyHarm: Shirley's ImprovisedWeapon.
* GroupHug: Jeff's story ends with one, even including hook-handed killer Chang.
* HalloweenEpisode
* HeartwarmingMoments: {{Invoked}}, parodied and subverted: Jeff is clearly trying to invoke one of these through his story in his usual style, and clearly expects everyone to react as if it was one, but they instead consider it, in the words of Pierce, "[[TastesLikeDiabetes the gayest crap I've ever heard in my life.]]"
* HeldGaze: The vampire and the schoolteacher is Annie's horror story when he enters carrying her and they're both staring at each other, referencing the "googly eyes" phenonomen between Jeff and Annie in real life.
* HerCodenameWasMarySue: All of the stories play with this to some degree, but Pierce (irresistible sex-stud with a full head of hair capable of beating up Gangbangers!Troy and Abed with his GagPenis) and Shirley ([[MessianicArchetype angelic messiah-figure who nobly forgives her friends their sins]] [[CaughtUpInTheRapture before being raptured into Heaven]]) really go to town with it. Shirley's contains a particularly lame attempt to pretend this isn't the case:
-->'''Britta:''' Thank you for saving us Shirley! I mean, your name's not Shirley, this is a story about strangers!
* HoistByHisOwnPetard: Pierce in Troy's story. His MadScientist self sews Troy and Abed together, but ends up being experimented on himself.
* HypocriticalHumor:
** During the stand-off at the end, Annie can be heard yelling "Stay back, psychos, or I'll slit your throats and bathe in your blood!"
** Jeff doesn't know which of ''Film/TheFastAndTheFurious'' guys he's dressed as because "I don't watch that shallow crap. I just pick a costume girls'll like."
** As Jeff explains that he isn't a sociopath, he actually displays several traits of sociopathy such as remorselessness, egocentricity and amorality. See the [[Fridge/{{Community}} Fridge Brilliance]] page for more details.
** Shirley's self-description of herself (via her perfecter-than-perfect AuthorAvatar) as a human embodiment of forgiveness, compassion and mercy is undercut when she blissfully abandons her friends to get horribly tortured for all eternity, thus hinting at the vindictive streak lurking underneath her self-righteousness.
* IAmAMonster: Jeff in Annie's story.
* IToldYouSo: In Britta's story, "Britta" feels the need to point this out to "Jeff". While he's being ''stabbed to death by a serial killer''.
* IdiotBall: Abed's story is devoted to completely averting this.
* ImprovisedWeapon: Despite being in a college library, most of the study group is able to come up with a weapon at a moments notice. Averted by Britta, who wields a switchblade.
* InadvertentEntranceCue: in Shirley's story.
-->'''Hedonist leader (Jeff)''': Oh man! End of days! Could anything suck harder than this!
-->'''Devil!Dean appears'''
* InstantSedation: in Troy's story.
* JawDrop: The group's collective response to Pierce's story is slack-jawed horrified astonishment.
-->'''Jeff:''' [[PunctuatedForEmphasis What... in the hell... was that.]]
* {{Jerkass}}: Jeff could have averted all the chaos that resulted from the start if he'd bothered to mention to Britta that he filled his test out randomly, and is smugly dismissive and unapologetic towards the others when they call him on it.
* JiveTurkey: Troy and Abed in Pierce's story.
* TheKillerInMe: The ending to Britta's story. Even the ''real'' Britta didn't see it coming.
* MadScientist: Pierce in Troy's story.
* MessianicArchetype: Parodied by Shirley's story, in which Shirley -- "I mean, your name's not Shirley, this is a story about strangers." -- shows up in a heavenly cloud to defeat Satan!Dean Pelton with a single breath before nobly forgiving her friends for "making fun of her Christianity." And then she gets raptured... conveniently leaving her friends there to get tortured by Satan.
* MindOverMatter: In Troy's story, getting sewn together gives you this power.
* MoodWhiplash: In-universe, Annie instantly switches from dramatically describing the death of a vampire in [[{{Gorn}} horrifically precise gory detail]] to innocently chirping "See? There was a twist!"
* MuggingTheMonster: Vampire!Jeff in Annie's story.
* NightmareFetishist. Annie is ''quite'' happy in describing her gory ending, to the entire group's shock.
* NoodleIncident: Judging from Jeff's reaction when Britta comes to him with her problem, apparently Britta dropped her psych tests in a puddle at one point, and presumably called on Jeff to help her fix them up.
* OfCorsetsSexy: Annie in her story.
* OnlySaneMan:
** When Britta runs the test sheets again, apparently only ''one'' member of the group ''isn't'' violently insane, and it's Abed.
** Jeff might be sane, as he randomly filled out the test. But then again, considering the rest of the season as a whole is largely devoted to how screwed up he is, it's unlikely.
* PaperThinDisguise: Of a sort; Britta is trying to secretly psychoanalyze her friends to determine which one of them may be a psychopath, but almost everything she says on the subject sounds like she's quoting it verbatim from a psychology textbook chapter on how to secretly analyse your friends. Probably the only reason they don't suspect what's up is that she tends to over-analyse them anyway.
* PersonAsVerb: Becomes a RunningGag that's taken UpToEleven at the end.
** "You Britta'd"
--->'''Jeff:''' You probably just Britta'd it.\\
'''Britta:''' Are people using my name to mean "make a small mistake"?\\
''[[{{Beat}} long pause]]''\\
'''Jeff:''' [[BlatantLies Yes.]]
** "Pulling an Abed" (to be meta)
--->'''Jeff:''' Wow, you Britta'd Britta'd.\\
'''Abed:''' Yeah, way to pull an Abed.
** "To Pierce" (to not get it)
--->'''Shirley:''' I don't get it.\\
'''Jeff:''' Shirley, don't Pierce.\\
'''Pierce:''' I don't get it!
** "To Shirley" (to protest/ to lecture at)
--->After the gang leaves the study room, Jeff and Shirley start arguing. Most of it is hard to hear, but Jeff distinctly says "Well, now you're Shirleying" at the end.
* PsychicPowers: Apparently Troy thinks that sewing two humans together results in telekinesis and telepathy.
* PunnyName: Warren Piece.
* PurpleProse: Annie's story is ''dripping'' with it.
-->''"Stifle your slackened maw, you drained and tainted bitch dog!"''
* RationalFic: DeconstructedTrope with Abed's story: Defying any and all Tropes that would make a story exciting because of the author's desire to follow rationality instead makes the audience bored and ''even disgusted''. There is a reason why the NecessaryWeasel exists, after all.
* RuleOfCool: In Troy's story, he and Abed gain multiple PsychicPowers after being sewn together. Why? Probably because of this.
* RunningGag: Yet another appearance of the show's own AffectionateParody of [[Series/DoctorWho a certain wildly popular British sci-fi franchise]] occurs in this episode when Abed and Troy show up to the pre-party dressed as JustForFun/InspectorSpacetime and Constable Wigglesworth.
-->'''Britta:''' I told you guys, you didn't have to dress up.\\
'''Troy:''' We know. We were wearing this anyway.\\
'''Abed:''' Yeah, when we're dressed up, you'll know.
* ShapedLikeItself: The radio announcer in Britta's story says that an "escaped mental patient has escaped."
* ShipTease: It would be far easier to list which pairs weren't teased in this episode than go through all the examples.
* ShoutOut:
** Annie and Shirley's stories appear to have been a little influenced by ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'' and ''Literature/LeftBehind'' respectively. Britta's story is a version of the popular [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hook "hookman" urban legend]]. Troy's story is reminiscent of ''Film/TheHumanCentipede''.
** The final story about how the sack-masked anonymous killer would slay the study group references ''Film/{{Triangle}}'', especially with TheReveal.
** When the group turns on each other after the lights go out, Troy has {{Wolverine}} claws made out of pencils.
** In Shirley's story Annie is dressed like Velma from WesternAnimation/ScoobyDoo.
* SpecialEditionTitle: The Halloween version used [[Recap/CommunityS2E06Epidemiology last season]] is back, this time adding in Jim Rash (Dean Pelton) with a drawing of a man in an electric chair.
* StylisticSuck: Each story is deliberately and humorously subpar in a different way depending on who's telling it:
** Britta's first story jumbles details and is told in a rushed, awkward fashion as would be told by someone who isn't really that good at telling stories half-remembering something -- additionally, the scant characterization is influenced by her StrawFeminist-esque views on intergender relationships (the man is [[AllMenArePerverts horny]] and [[TooDumbToLive idiotic]], while the woman is sensible [[CassandraTruth and proven ultimately correct]]);
** Abed's story is overly logical and lacks emotional resonance, more concerned with filling plot-holes and avoiding cliches, unrealistic actions, GenreBlindness and {{Contrived Coincidence}}s than actually telling the story;
** Annie's story is melodramatic and filled with overblown dialogue and PurpleProse;
** Troy's story over-relies on RuleOfCool at the expense of making sense and all the characters -- no matter who they are -- talk like he (and Abed) would;
** Pierce's story is sexist, racist, filled with TotallyRadical attempts to remain relevant and turns Pierce into a MartyStu sex-god, and also completely misses the point of what a Halloween scary story is supposed to be in the first place;
** Shirley's story is a poorly researched [[TheMoralSubstitute bad Christian P.S.A version]] of a horror story which turns Shirley herself into a self-righteous MarySue [[MessianicArchetype Messiah]] figure who saves the day with a DeusExMachina before delivering a poorly-disguised sermon to her friends.
** Jeff's story TastesLikeDiabetes.[[invoked]] He also doesn't bother to construct a narrative and just skips to the end.
* TooDumbToLive: Jeff in Britta's story. Abed calls Britta out on it while telling his own story.
* TotallyRadical: The characters in Shirley's story have a bit of this going on:
-->'''"Annie"''': Yo, Jango! Check it out!
* TropesAreTools: Abed's story demonstrates this; he's so fixated on avoiding bad tropes and plotholes that he doesn't take into account that some of these are actually needed for the story to work, meaning that his story doesn't go anywhere and he just bores his audience.
* TwistEnding: Annie is particularly proud that her story has one.
* WereStillRelevantDammit: What Pierce desperately wants to believe in his story. [[invoked]]
-->'''Gangsta-Troy:''' *Being punched by Magnum* YOU... ARE... STILL... RELEVANT!
* WildTeenParty: In Shirley's story.
* WriteWhoYouKnow: In-universe, perpetrated by ''everyone'' for increasingly petty reasons.
* WolverineClaws: Troy's ImprovisedWeapon, wooden pencils held between his fingers.
* WomanInWhite: Annie in her story; Shirley in hers.
* WomenAreWiser: Parodied; in her story, Britta's AuthorAvatar feels the need to point out that she was right about the situation to Jeff while he's ''being stabbed to death by a psycho with a hook for a hand.''
* YouDoNOTWantToKnow:
** When it's revealed that all but one member of the study group is, according to their psych profiles, completely insane, they collectively decide it's better that they can keep ahold of the comforting delusion that ''any one of them may be sane'' rather than knowing who is or isn't. Turns out it's Abed.
** To be fair, it's ''technically'' possible that Jeff is also sane - he states that he filled in his evaluation randomly, so the results of it are presumably inaccurate. The rest of the series as a whole, however, would seem to suggest that even with this taken into account he's still probably not as sane as he would like to think...