[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/3a6e9bcc_0777_4d55_9d4b_326341067511.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''[[NightmareSequence Daddy...]]'']]
----
* Realistic and disturbing, "That's My Dog" is an entire episode of a terrifying carjacking. David picks up a "cute" hitchhiker who forces David at gunpoint to take out all his money at an ATM, beats and punches him, forces him to smoke crack, makes him suck the barrel of a gun, threatens to set him on fire after pouring gasoline on him, steals his van, and leaves him in the middle of nowhere, beaten half to death.
%% * His frequent hallucinations afterwards are horrifying in many different ways.
* Lisa's decaying, partially shark-eaten corpse. Shown just for a brief moment, but it's a disturbing reminder of what happens to human bodies after death.
* Many gruesome deaths that are depicted on screen:
** A baker gets hacked into pieces by a huge dough machine.
** One opening teaser scene featured a first person perspective of a three week-old infant lying in a crib. As the adoring parents leave the baby to sleep, the camera (serving as the baby's perspective) looks up at the roof into a rather creepy black and white baby's mobile. As the camera blurs and zooms, the shot [[FadeToWhite fades to white.]]
--->DILLON MICHAEL COOPER\\
2001 - 2001
** One man gets [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe torn apart]] by an elevator.
** One woman loses the top half of her head when she collides with a cherry picker after deciding she wanted to stick her head through the sunroof of the limo she was riding.
** One woman bleeds to death through the nose.
** A woman falls into a metal hand-iron which [[EyeScream impales her eye]].
** A woman is taking a bubble bath and gets electrocuted by a hairdryer her cat accidentally knocks into the tub.
* Keith suggests that Claire donate her eggs so he and David can have a child which is genetically related to both of them. Immediately afterwards, David has a nightmare in which an [[UnintentionalUncannyValley extremely creepy female puppet]] with red hair hands him a basket, then runs off with Keith. As pictured above, the basket contains a grotesque baby puppet, which has Claire's features (red hair, fair skin, and [[PatchworkKids one blue eye]]) on one half, and Keith's features (bald head, dark skin, and one brown eye) on the other. The "baby" blinks and croaks, "Daddy!", whereupon David wakes with a start.
----