[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/rsz_persona_2_nightmare_4010.png]]

* Both Jokers. ''Innocent Sin's'' Joker sports a cruel smile that makes your skin crawl, and it's especially unsettling that this Joker is really [[spoiler: an emotionally and mentally tortured Jun Kurosu, who is in turn being controlled by the real ManBehindTheMan, who has taken the form of Jun's dead father.]] [[http://megamitensei.wikia.com/wiki/JOKER And ''Eternal Punishment's'' serial-killer JOKER wears a bloody paper bag over his head]] with drawn-on features (including a hole where another eye should be) and a huge wicked smile that is NightmareFuel all by itself.
* [[EldritchAbomination Nyarlathotep]] as [[http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20080619210642/megamitensei/images/5/54/JokerNyarla.jpg Jun's Persona]]. Y'know, the fella gets extra fear points for a reason: [[ClapYourHandsIfYouBelieve we made]] [[FridgeHorror him]]. Every single tiny act of evil you've ever experienced or acted upon... [[MadeOfEvil it just makes him bigger]]. ''We'' made him. [[ParanoiaFuel And he lives inside of us]]. Funny thing... didja know he was the one who arranged the events of ''VideoGame/{{Persona}}'', too? Just to give us a chance to destroy all of reality? A mass of unrepentant madness and evil, hating everything and everyone... is it any wonder he wants it all to die? And even funnier... [[spoiler: didja know [[TheBadGuyWins he wins?]] ]]
* [[HumanoidAbomination Great Father]] [[EldritchAbomination Nyarlathotep]]. All of the party's fathers fused by [[BodyHorror Nyarlathotep's]] tentacles [[http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20090904095447/megamitensei/images/d/da/Nyarlathotepfatherfusion.jpg into a single entity]].
* The [[http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110817012820/megamitensei/images/4/46/1545605-13.jpg Moon Howler]].And the Crawling Chaos form is ''worse''. An entity of [[MadeOfEvil pure fear, hate and despair]] ''and'' a LivingShadow... [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20090609083034/megamitensei/images/e/ea/Nyarlathotep.jpg with hundreds of screaming faces]]?
* The [[spoiler: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWZPmW43Tz8 Grand Cross (here from 3:11-3:44)]]]]. '''''[[spoiler: [[ApocalypseWow Oh God,]] [[DepopulationBomb the]] [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt Grand]] [[MayanDoomsday Cross!]]]]''''' The cutscene has to be seen to be believed...
** Even worse, [[spoiler: it's based on a real-life simulation of what would happen if the Earth suddenly stopped moving (which an NPC mentions what would happen should the prophecy is fufilled.) Inertia would literally blow everything apart on the Earth's surface; buildings would collapse, vehicles and people would be suddenly be flung at violent speeds, pretty much killing off most of humanity and society.]]
* ''Eternal Punishment's'' JOKER-possessed victims aren't exactly a walk in the park either. They end up with a white-face with no features except for that wide, creepy smile, and speak in a sing-song high-pitch voice. Add to the fact if they cast Old Maid, your own party will temporarily turned Joker and kill everyone if you're not careful.
** Let's not forget how Jun's dad was said to have died in ''Innocent Sin'': [[spoiler: crushed to death in the gears of a clock tower. Or when he appears before the party - crucified alongside Jun's mother (as [[QuirkyMinibossSquad Queen Aquarius]]) - before one of the final boss battles.]] One starts to think that Jun's entire life has been one NightmareFuel moment after another.
* ''Eternal Punishment'' had a scene in which the Manager ends up melting into a puddle of [[BodyHorror concentrated black hatred goo]].
* The very idea your life ''could completely change'' because of a careless rumor. Picture that for a moment.
* The Joker's curse. To stand in place, devoid of dreams or hope, as everyone you cared for forgets you existed at all.
* Tatsuya Sudou's life. His father decided to hide the poor guy away in a failing sanitarium, though he clearly needed medical attention, and tried to actively kill him! It's suggested that his father's men followed him to the Aviation Museum (part of the reason the blimp blew up instead of just crashing). His moments of clarity are far more frightening than his psychotic rage. Even worse, it's implied he's just as much a victim, as he ''was'' targeted by many rumors in his childhood...
* The slow degeneration of Dark Joker in ''Eternal Punishment''. First seen [[http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110817020534/megamitensei/images/c/c8/1545602-10.jpg here]]. and from there on... [[http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110817020613/megamitensei/images/9/90/1545603-11.jpg it goes to this]], [[http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110817020643/megamitensei/images/2/24/1545604-12.jpg to this]], [[http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110817020709/megamitensei/images/4/45/1545607-15.jpg and finally this]]. VillainousBreakdown rarely is so literal.
* [[EvilOldFolks Tatsuzou Sudou]], father of the above-mentioned Tatsuya, got an underling to join him by promising him [[ImmortalityImmorality immortality]]. Y'know what he ''didn't'' promise him? [[FateWorseThanDeath Immortality]] [[AndIMustScream as a]] ''[[BodyHorror human]]''.
* Hey! The Spear of Longinus is real! AllMythsAreTrue! [[WoundThatWillNotHeal Even the part of what happens when it cuts you!]]
* There is a legend explained during ''Eternal Punishment''-the story of Kiyotada Sumaru, the tyrant ruling over the area of Sumaru City in the Period of Warring States. He was so bad, his servant Tatsunoshin Suou, and Suou's retainer Junnosuke Kuroda and his lover Maihime Amano, teamed up and killed him, but not before Sumaru managed to gore Amano with a spear, leaving Suou broken as he told Kuroda to burn down Sumaru Castle. Interesting story, huh? After scattering the rumors of the spirits, you find the mummies in the ruins of Sumaru Castle and gain the ability to summon them as Personae. The problem? It's ''very'' heavily implied the history is entirely false... [[FridgeHorror and you've altered history by scattering the rumors]].
* During the final segments of ''Eternal Punishment'', as the Torifune is in the collective consciousness, you can see the people utterly terrified at their current situation. Especially the ones who have been brainwashed by the Kegare removals. Their brainwashing can't even protect them from the horrors they are facing. One NPC in particular tries to be optimistic that it will all work out; that or else he'll take everybody down with him.