A hero who is a dropout, result of a failed experiment (in SciFi), or maybe just [[ParentalAbandonment abandoned]]/[[DarkAndTroubledPast abused as a child]]. Nonetheless, this character is [[ThePollyanna amazingly cheerful and optimistic]], and [[NiceGuy nice]] to even [[AllOfTheOtherReindeer the people who don't appreciate them]]. May be introduced as a BigEater, [[TheDitz a ditz]], or some other [[{{Cloudcuckoolander}} harmless personality]]. They may even [[SelfDeprecation make some ostensibly humorous jabs at themself]].

Their BackStory is usually learned in flashbacks sometime later in a show, sometimes without warning. This can shock the other characters, especially TheRival AntiHero, and earns them respect.

A BetaTestBaddie and a Broken Hero often have a complicated relationship of sympathy tied with dislike, until the former finally loses patience with the latter.




[[folder:Anime & Manga]]
* Orihime Inoue, a girl with long orange hair and a very cheerful attitude, from ''Manga/{{Bleach}}'' fits this trope pretty well, losing all her family members to accidents and having to see her dead brother turn into a horrific spiritual monster, who then tries to eat her.
* Oz Vessalius from ''Manga/PandoraHearts'' pretty much ''embodies'' this trope. He's a CheerfulChild StepfordSmiler who was completely shunned by his father at a young age, despite wanting desperately to impress him. His pride/confidence pretty much gets ''crushed'' after failing to save a girl from [[spoiler: her own death--illegal contractor]] and a little boy [[spoiler:who ends up losing his father and his own soul to chains.]] Nonetheless, he ''tries'' to act like he's fine and '''smiles to everyone'''. As of Retrace LXX, already pretty shaken up, he realizes that he is actually a freaking [[spoiler: stuffed bunny, the chain B-Rabbit who, one hundred years ago, was forced to murder countless innocent people.]] By the end of Retrace LXXIV, he is [[BreakTheCutie almost completely mentally and emotionally broken]] thanks to his memories resurfacing as well as [[BreakThemByTalking interference by]] [[spoiler: [[MagnificentBastard Jack]].]]
* While he may not necessarily be the main hero of the story, Momiji Sohma of ''Manga/FruitsBasket'' is impeccably cheerful and caring despite having his mother rejecting him and eventually going insane due to Momiji's curse (turns into a rabbit when hugged by the opposite sex or very stressed like when sick).
** Tohru, who is the main character, lost her father at a very young age, her mother in her teens, and ended up living in a tent. Nevertheless, she is cheerful and bright -- so much that other characters who want to help and provide moral support have to figure out on their own that she's in need of it.
* Allen Walker of ''Manga/DGrayMan''. He's [[NiceGuy nice]], [[ThePollyanna cheerful]], [[WideEyedIdealist idealistic]], and [[{{Bishonen}} really]], ''[[BadassAdorable really]]'' cute, but his life has been kind of traumatic. By which we mean that his parents abandoned him, [[spoiler: he was beaten by ''clowns'' until he got adopted]], his foster father died, his mentor abused him, and he has to watch tormented Akuma souls screaming in pain.
** And (in the anime) the very first Akuma he killed (besides Mana) was his best (and only) childhood friend.
* ''Manga/MahouSenseiNegima'': Negi is one of these despite only being ten. No parents, no family except a cousin that was away most of the year and then that whole bit where ''demons invaded his village and turned everyone to stone''. Everyone was horrified to see his memories of said event, which worked exactly opposite to how it was supposed to.
* Sousuke Sagara from ''LightNovel/FullMetalPanic'' is a borderline example -- he is normally TheStoic, but is a mentally well-adjusted and good-hearted person under it all, if [[NoSocialSkills somewhat socially awkward]]. For someone who has been a Mujahideen ChildSoldier since the age of seven before moving on to work for a mercenary army and has literally never known normal civilian life, that's rather impressive. The sympathy this engenders for him from the school staff may explain in part [[SociopathicHero why he always seems to get away with bringing guns to and detonating parts of the school building on a regular basis.]]
** It also helps that Mithril [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney bribed the hell out of his school]] when he first enrolled.
* Vash the Stampede from ''Manga/{{Trigun}}''.
* Pretty much EVERYBODY in ''Manga/GetBackers''.
* Sanosuke Sagara from ''Manga/RurouniKenshin'', a happy-go-lucky brawler and gambler who never met a jug of sake he didn't like; also estranged from his biological family and had his father figure executed on false charges by the very government they helped to bring into power. Kenshin himself qualifies as well.
* ''Manga/{{Naruto}}'':
** Naruto, who was [[AllOfTheOtherReindeer shunned by nearly his entire hometown]] because of the demon sealed inside him. He is nevertheless cheerfully nice and compassionate to anyone he meets, especially to those [[BecauseYouWereNiceToMe who were always nice to him]]. His {{Foil}}, [[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds Gaara]], is basically what Naruto would be if he was never acknowledged by (in chronological order, as [[WordOfGod Kishimoto]] confirmed) [[LivingEmotionalCrutch Hinata]], the [[BigGood Third Hokage]], [[BigBrotherMentor Iruka]], and [[TrueCompanions Team 7]].
** [[TheDragon Nagato]] served as [[EvilCounterpart the example]] of [[FallenHero the alternate outcome]], should Naruto have chosen to give in to his anger instead.
** Obito was also this, considering that he was basically the Uchiha version of Naruto and lived a life similar to his. [[spoiler: Then he became Tobi.]]
* In ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWing'', Duo Maxwell's seemingly self-congratulatory "God of Death" (Shinigami) nickname takes on a new light when it's revealed that he took it on given the fact that [[DoomMagnet anyone he cares about tends to die if they hang around him]].
** Done again with Sanders in ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamThe08thMSTeam''; he picked up the nickname given the unfortunate tendency of almost every unit he joined getting wiped out on their third mission together, except for Sanders himself.
* Gon Freecs from ''Manga/HunterXHunter'' lost his mother, his father is missing, and he has a knack for making enemies who want to gut him, but is still eternally cheerful. He's the BrokenHero and TheDitz rolled up in one.
* Judai Yuki from ''Anime/YuGiOhGX'' turns out to be one of these by season three.
* Tsuzuki of ''Manga/DescendantsOfDarkness''. He's a BigEater, BadassAdorable Shinigami, who everyone seems to make jokes about, including himself. Until the [[BreakTheCutie Kyoto arc]], that is.
* [[HandsomeLech Miroku]] from ''Manga/{{Inuyasha}}'' is an easygoing, carefree and cheerful guy who likes to joke and tease, even though he will die very young being consumed by the [[{{curse}} Wind Tunnel]] in his right hand.
* Mami Tomoe from ''Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagica'', who smiles as she gives advice to Madoka and Sayaka and fights the Witches... but confesses that she cries a lot when alone and says her smiles are all false.
* Krista Renz from ''Manga/AttackOnTitan''. She's a sweet, beautiful girl adored by everyone because of her kindness and considered the "Goddess" of the 104th Trainees Squad. However, it turns out that she's [[spoiler:a HeroicBastard disowned by her noble family, with massive issues concerning her self-worth. She's a DeathSeeker so desperate to die in a way that will get her praised that she was willing to risk the life of an injured comrade, and joins the [[RedShirtArmy Recon Corps]] while crying]]. [[BadassGay Ymir]] calls her on it numerous times, and she's begun to improve as a result.
* [[CuteMute Shirayuki]] from ''Manga/SnowWhiteAndSevenDwarfs'' is an irresistibly adorable CheerfulChild, whose life has been miserable since literally the day she was born and involves [[spoiler:a severe case of AbusiveParents, having CompleteImmortality forced on her, repeatedly having her heart gouged out, being forced to bring about an apocalypse, among others.]]
* ''LightNovel/HighSchoolDXD'': Kiba Yuuto is a calm, confident and skillful Knight. His [[StepfordSmiler perpetual smile]] and collected demeanor hide the fact that he is [[spoiler:the only survivor of the Church's Excalibur experiments, who were so brutal that left him traumatized and killed all his friends when he was a mere child]] and to top it off, he [[spoiler:is an artificial human without sense of self-worth; he is so deeply loyal to Rias simply because he has nothing else to hold on, something that Rias knows but is unable to fix]]. He even admits to it in the Kokabiel arc. Though it gets kinda fixed with Issei and Koneko's friendship (with a healthy dose of Rias' ToughLove to help).

[[folder:Comic Books]]
* Pretty much [[DysfunctionJunction everybody]] in the Franchise/MarvelUniverse. There's ComicBook/CaptainAmerica (grew up poor during the Great Depression, parents died when he was young, dead sidekick and identity issues), [[ComicBook/LukeCageHeroForHire Luke Cage]] (grew up in a bad part of New York, wrongly jailed for drug possession), ComicBook/IronMan (alcoholism, depression, self-worth issues, romantic issues and massive survivor's guilt), {{SelfDemonstrating/Deadpool}} (disfigured, partially reformed murderer, crazy), every single [[ComicBook/XMen X-Man]] (FantasticRacism), the [[ComicBook/FantasticFour Fantastic "I promise I'll make you normal again someday, Ben!" Four]], a certain Dr. [[Comicbook/IncredibleHulk Bruce Banner]], Rick "the Hulk is my fault and I'm often trapped in the Negative Zone" Jones, the seething mass of neurosis that is {{Franchise/Spider Man}}, everything that's wrong with [[ComicBook/AntMan Henry Pym]], and... yeah, pretty much everybody else.
** The [[Comicbook/TheAvengers Initiative]] in the Marvel Universe is a government subsidized effort to train the next generation of superheroes, which includes some old characters and new ones. Those that weren't ''already'' broken when they went into the program...are quickly and ''brutally'' broken down by the events in the Initiative series.
** Then you have ComicBook/TheSentry, who makes the rest combined look well adjusted. And that's on his better days.
* The [[Creator/DCComics DC]] universe has its fair share of hard luck heroes, e.g. Franchise/{{Batman}} (his parents were killed by some mugger in a dark alley), [[ComicBook/{{Shazam}} Billy Batson]] (an orphaned boy whose evil uncle stole his inheritance and was left on the streets on his own), [[Franchise/GreenLantern Hal Jordan]] (his home city was destroyed and was possessed by Parallax).

[[folder: Fan Works]]

* ''Fanfic/ACrownOfStars'': Shinji and Asuka were severely traumatized due to deep childhood trauma and being children fighting a war they did not understand. They tried to save the world but at the end they were so broken that Shinji let it die. Their lives got worse during the next years while they tried survive in a devastated world ruled by warlords, but after getting help and an improved and more optimistic outlook they are again fighting to save their world.
* Harry in Fanfic/TheWizardInTheShadows. All the trauma of the Wizarding War, plus four years of constant and brutal warfare in Middle Earth with no prospect of return. It's implied to have driven him a little mad, if only in the {{Cloudcuckoolander}} sense.
* ''Fanfic/GhostsOfEvangelion'': Shinji and Asuka try to get over their issues and improve their lives after the War.
* ''Fanfic/ThousandShinji'': Shinji, Asuka and Rei were abused children. When they convert to ''[[TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}} Chaos]]'', though, they focus on the positive aspects of their dark gods, and although neither of them is nice, Shinji becomes optimistic and hopeful, Rei happy and mirthful, and Asuka courageous and passionate.
* In spite of everything what they endured in ''Fanfic/ChildrenOfAnElderGod'', the main characters -Shinji, Asuka, Rei and Touji- tried to remain optimistic and positive during and after the War.
* When Shinji and Asuka got together and befriended Rei in ''Fanfic/AdviceAndTrust'', the Children became a bit happier due to their stronger emotional bonds. They're still traumatized teenagers, but they smile more often and they're actually hopeful about their future. And they've become better warriors, too.
* ''Fanfic/TheSecondTry'': [[AfterTheEnd After Third Impact]], [[ChildSoldiers Shinji and Asuka]] managed to overcome their many psychological issues and insecurities and became a little happier and more upbeat.
* In ''Fanfic/LastChildOfKrypton'', Shinji is the more powerful hero in the planet, and he tries to be nice and upbeat despite of having abandonment and loneliness issues.
* ''Fanfic/OnceMoreWithFeeling'': Shinji has suffered terribly, he has lost his mother and his family, and he has seen literally everyone dying… but he tries to be optimistic and upbeat when he returns to the past because being sad and depressed the whole time got him precisely nowhere the last time around.



* Neville Longbottom of the ''Literature/HarryPotter'' books eventually evolves into a Broken Hero after the tragic insanity of his parents is revealed to Harry.
** As well as Harry himself - he's nice to people despite being emotionally abused by his aunt, uncle, and cousin.
* ''Literature/LordPeterWimsey'' always appears to be a cheerful RichIdiotWithNoDayJob and a MotorMouth, frequently compared in universe to Bertie Wooster by both the narrator and other characters, however it is revealed that he suffers from severe post-traumatic stress disorder from his time in the War. We get literal flashbacks from him when he relives events of it after a particularly stressful case triggers him and also [[FlashbackNightmare Flashback Nightmares]].
* Rosario Hernandez in the ''Literature/UrbanDragon'' books is an obese homeless woman who managed to tame a dragon, befriend ghouls, and fight monsters
* All the Outcasts of ''Literature/{{Tasakeru}}'' in one way or another.

[[folder:Live Action TV]]
* Chuck in ''Series/PushingDaisies'' is extremely upbeat and [[GenkiGirl enthusiastic]] for someone who has never known her mother, had her father die when she was nine, the moved in with her aunts only to die herself and then be resurrected in such a way that she can't see them again either.
* ''Series/StargateSG1''. All the characters have suffered tragedy to some extent, Jack lost his son, Sam lost her mother, Teal'c lost both parents, etc. But Daniel wins this trope for being more or less cheerful despite losing his parents as a child in an accident, losing his foster parents in another accident, spending most of his professional career having his theories scorned at (most of which, as he points out, turned out to be right) and had just been evicted from his apartment at the start of the movie. As soon as the TV series starts, his wife is [[PeoplePuppets taken]]. He spends [[strike:five]] two and a half series trying to rescue her, [[spoiler: then Teal'c kills her to save Daniel. Once he gets over losing his wife, he runs into an ex-girlfriend, who is promptly made into a host,]] but is ''still'' polite, has faith in common humanity, and ''chides Jack on being so snarky''.
** Actually subverted on nearly all counts. Teal'c only lost his father, not his mother, and while Daniel certainly did lose his biological parents, his foster parents were never mentioned in [[{{Canon}} canon]]. If he did lose them, too, we didn't hear about it. And his backstory was alluded to since the original [[Film/{{Stargate}} Stargate movie]], as was Jack's particular tragedy - Jack O'Neill having made his first appearance trying to commit suicide with a nuclear bomb. Daniel's being 'polite' is often strewn with pithy and/or patronizing comments, and his having faith in humanity could be considered gullibility. Jack's open hostility, sometimes snide cynicism and occasional moral pragmatism disqualify him completely, though in the [[{{DarkAndTroubledPast}} trauma stakes]] he could probably drumpf Daniel. Teal'c has a similar problem to Jack, and Sam was never broken enough to qualify.
* Dr. Gregory House, from ''[[Series/{{House}} House, MD]]''. Minus the "nice" and "cheerful" bits.
* Stefan from ''Series/TheVampireDiaries''. He has endured a lot of pain and tragedy yet still seems to hold it together.
* Glitch, from the ''Series/TinMan'' miniseries, who is awfully upbeat for someone who's had half of his brain removed by the bad guys. Missing half his brain may be ''why'' he's "upbeat". The parts of him that could react appropriately are [[BrainInAJar floating in a jar somewhere]].
* Both Sam and Dean from ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'', due to their crappy childhood and their status as [[{{Cosmic Plaything}} Cosmic Playthings]]. Except that while they're nice guys, you could probably get frustrated with them very easily because of all those issues.
** Castiel fits this trope perfectly, in the great escapist it was revealed that [[spoiler:Castiel repeatedly rebelled for mankind against whatever order he deemed too dangerous for them like the slaughter in Egypt, which lead his superiors to use torture, wiping out his memory and brainwashing to punish him and force him to be obedient again, which never lasted for long as Naomi complained about having to do it too many times]] without counting all the times he was used, given up on by his so called friends [[spoiler:When dean kicked him out of the bunker right after he died to be homless again without any help]] told over and over how useless and expandable he is by everyone, he still finds it in him to help save people and show mercy even to the people who wronged him [[spoiler:like how he decided to let metatron go on Season 11 after he took his grace, destroyed most of it to cause the fall which made him a target to all the angels and hated by them]]
Malcolm Reynolds of ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' qualifies.
* Even though his BackStory is revealed almost immediately in the pilot episode (or would have been if it hadn't been shown last...)
** It should be noted, however, that Fox employed ExecutiveMeddling after viewing the pilot to make him more of a jokester; his portrayal in the PilotMovie was ''somewhat'' more low-key and bitter. But in all versions there's still an element of this depending on the circumstances and Mal's mood.
** Ditto for River Tam; during her more lucid periods she's actually a really nice and cheery girl, but she is about as completely broken as a person can get, without factoring in her madness.
* Jarod Series/ThePretender is this, though we find out the basics of his backstory pretty quickly. He was kidnapped as a child; mentally, emotionally, and physically abused; kept as a slave for most of his life; and as the series progresses it [[TraumaCongaLine gets worse]], but his personality is that of a cheerful, {{Adorkable}}, mischievous, and insatiably curious ManChild (at least until he gets into psycho badass avenger Pretender mode or has the occasional HeroicBSOD).

[[folder:Video Games]]
* Niko Bellic of ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoIV'' once his full backstory is revealed.
* Cloud Strife from ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII'' has more than a few elements of this -- he's a bullied-as-a-child [[PeopleJars People Jar]] escapee. He's got a dorkish, awkward side to his personality as a result.
* Robo from ''VideoGame/ChronoTrigger'', who was abandoned by its creator for sympathizing with the humans. He's also ''literally'' broken when he's introduced, needing GadgeteerGenius Lucca to repair him before he can join the party.
* Marona from ''VideoGame/PhantomBrave''. Her parents died when she was five and the world as a whole, including her HonoraryUncle, seems to hate her for her spirit-seeing power, but she's a AllLovingHero nonetheless. There's quite a bit of terror in realizing that this is a prepubescent child who's only real companions are dead people for the majority of the game. Ash is a dependable guy, but he's not exactly fit to do the bills and the vacuuming, meaning that Marona basically manages an entire island ''by herself.''
* Lucius from ''VideoGame/FireEmblem''. He was brutally tormented in an orphanage after his parents died when he was three, yet he still treats everyone with compassion and fairness, even going so far as to say that he wished that the man that abused him could still live well. He even forgives the man who murdered his father (and by proxy, his mother), and caused his terrible childhood.
* Gulcasa of the [[VideoGame/YggdraUnion Ancardia]] [[VideoGame/BlazeUnion series]] [[VideoGame/YggdraUnison of]] VideoGame/DeptHeaven games. You don't see as much of his normal disposition in ''VideoGame/YggdraUnion'' due to his [[HeroAntagonist fighting for the opposite side]], but in the other two games especially, he's revealed to be the sweetest, most idealistic and {{Adorkable}} [[AntiAntiChrist demonic Christ figure]] you ever did see. His mother abandoned him when he was a toddler, his father brutally abused him all his life, and he grew up in extreme squalor. When his life finally started to turn around at age seventeen when he was a part of LaResistance, his father figure betrayed him, his childhood friend/surrogate mother/possibly first crush died because of it, he had to kill said father figure because of this, he was reunited with his mother only to be forced into a DuelToTheDeath with her, and then [[EtTuBrute his other childhood friend and his mentor backstabbed and deserted him]]. The TraumaCongaLine made him a lot more driven, but didn't put much of a dent in his wholehearted love for and trust in his TrueCompanions or his determination to create a peaceful world.
* Commander Shepard of the ''Franchise/MassEffect'' series can fit this depending on you play Him/Her. Two of the back stories, [[StreetUrchin Earthborn]] and [[DoomedHomeTown Colonist]] has Shepard being an orphan, the former has Shepard being a product of the streets while the latter had Shepard's entire family killed.
** [[IronWoobie Colonist Shepard can even admit to one character that s/he was totally broken for a while after his/her parents were killed and maybe still is.]]
** Regardless of background, by the time of ''VideoGame/MassEffect3'', the [[TheChainsOfCommanding sheer weight of responsibility]] on Shepard's back has [[DeathSeeker pushed him/her to the breaking point]].
* Really? Pick a Creator/BioWare game. ''Any'' Bioware game. If your PlayerCharacter isn't here already, they will be by game's end.
* ''VideoGame/ResonanceOfFate'':
** Leanne . Several times it's remarked how cute and sweet she is, and she is a perpetually upbeat, cheerful, determined and playful little thing. (At one point, a dorky, strange, not physically attractive possibly, uh, 'special' character hires her to go on a date with him as a job. At the end, she refuses the money and flirts honestly with him, saying 'It wouldn't be a date if I took that, now WOULD it?' With a wink and a sweet grin.) She's also totally girly, even when kicking ass and taking names in gun battles. Meanwhile, she's actually the only survivor out of twenty experimental children who were all supposed to die at set dates in an attempt to control the human lifespan. She is very aware of it, and, in fact, attempted to commit suicide immediately before her time was supposed to 'run out', so she would control her own fate. Only one person in her life cared for her, and she's not sure if he's even alive- the last she saw of him, he was being dragged away after setting her free, assuming she had only a year left to live. Perhaps not as tragic as some examples here, but it certainly counts.
** Vashyron. He is often relied on for comic relief and comedic moments in the game, he is rarely very serious for long unless on a job, he seems to get along with pretty much everyone he comes across, he's a womanizer, [[PapaWolf protective]], and a fun loving eccentric. He is another lone survivor, however, after his entire military squad was wiped out. By a lone little girl. Well, okay, so she only looked like a little girl. If you don't count the horns. [[spoiler: or the wings, or the creepy too-old woman's voice and super-ninja powers. Seriously, what IS this chick, any way?]] Two of them originally escaped the carnage, but after a rather heart wrenching sacrifice- only Vashyron was left standing.
* [[TheBigGuy Big loveable goofball Snow]] from ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyXIII'' is an orphan. You never find out about his past, per say, but there are moments where it's demonstrated just how much he really longs for the family he never had, and how devoted he is to his fiancee, slowly endearing him-uh, sort of- to Lightning.
* ''VideoGame/{{Halo 4}}'': Dr Halsey's interrogator accuses ''Franchise/{{Halo}}''[='s=] Master Chief as this, as despite all of his Badass abilities, he is considered an empty shell, and Cortana is the only thing that's keeping him from falling apart.
* ''VideoGame/{{Blazblue}}'': Ragna the Bloodedge was a young man who lived happily with his [[{{Jerkass}} brother Jin]] and his [[IllGirl sister Saya]]. Then a psychotic hipster named Yuuki Terumi burned down his home, killed his adoptive guardian and chopped his arm off. He gets a new arm called the Azure Grimoire from a girl who rescues him, which grants him awesome power but will probably one day kill him horribly. He's a man who has lost almost everything he's ever held dear to him, and it really shows in his attitude towards life. However, he's a source of much of the game's comedy moments, with most of the cast snarking at him and/or kicking his ass.
* ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}'': The dialogue options and reactions of other characters to [[PlayerCharacter the Fallen Child]] in the Neutral and [[GoldenEnding True Pacifist]] endings seem to indicate that our main character is a cheerful goofball and an AllLovingHero...and [[AmbiguousGender they]] also climbed a mountain that no one has ever come back from alive. A few characters are troubled by [[DarkAndTroubledPast what exactly could drive a child to do that.]]
** Thoroughly subverted in the No Mercy path by both the Fallen Child themselves and [[spoiler:the ''true'' Fallen Child, [[DemonicPossession who is possessing poor Frisk's body.]] The true Fallen Child is implied even more heavily to have had a nightmarish past, and in the [[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds No Mercy path has decided to take it out on the entire world.]] [[YouBastard And they couldn't have done it without you...friend.]] ]]

[[folder:Visual Novels]]
* Shirou in ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight''. As his BackStory reveals, he lost his family, his friends, and his old life in the great fire 10 years ago, but is still extremely friendly and helpful towards almost everyone and never seems bothered by the event beyond some bad dreams. As one of the game paths later reveals, Shirou basically lost his entire existence and sense of self from the trauma as well, and his personality was 'rebuilt' around the fact that he was rescued when basically no one else was. Shirou is fundamentally broken on a mental level, in that he is unable to live for his own sake and can only find meaning in life through the act of saving others like he himself was once saved. [[spoiler:Kirei Kotomine is something of an inversion - A Broken ''Villain''. Like Shirou, he has no sense of self and only defines himself through others. The trouble is, while Shirou finds his meaning in helping others, Kotomine finds his in the ''suffering'' of others.]]
** As we learn in the Heaven's Feel route, [[spoiler:Sakura Matou]] is broken to an even greater degree than Shirou is. [[spoiler:Born as Sakura Tohsaka, she was given up for adoption to the Matou family to serve as their heir. Doing so involves tortured daily by her adoptive grandfather, and later on raped by her adoptive brother. By the time of Heaven's Feel, she's endured the former for eleven years, and the latter for three.]]

* ''Webcomic/{{MAG ISA}}'' -- Eman Cruz was abused [[http://mag-isa.thecomicseries.com/comics/pl/119198 by his parents]] and by [[http://mag-isa.thecomicseries.com/comics/pl/119177 bullies]]
* [[spoiler: Eddie]] of ''Webcomic/EmergencyExit''.
* Der Trihs of ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'' gets revealed as one in his DayInTheLimelight arc.
* [[spoiler: Hanna]] of ''Webcomic/HannaIsNotABoysName''. It hasn't been revealed what happened, but it's heavily implied in Tessa's DA sketches that something went wrong.
* Alexander Hamilton in ''Webcomic/TheDreamer'' certainly counts.
* Almost ''all'' the kids from ''Webcomic/{{Homestuck}}''.

[[folder:Web Original]]
* WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic has more than a few aspects of this, being sad and/or pathetic most of the time. But when he's happy, he manages to get excited for a lot of things... even if it does [[YankTheDogsChain usually end up getting crushed.]]

[[folder:Western Animation]]
* Heavily {{deconstructed}} in ''WesternAnimation/BoJackHorseman''. As it turns out, becoming a decent and caring person in spite of the horrid experiences suffered might bring rather dire implications if [[AngstWhatAngst the person doesn't deal directly with his psyche]]; as such, he could resort to becoming TheParagon and hollow himself as the happy façade he puts on becomes thinner and thinner (like [[StepfordSmiler Secretariat]]), he could keep the "helping and comforting" part by doing noble deeds out of selfish motives or a guilty conscience (like [[MightyWhitey Sebastian St. Claire]]) or without being a bad person themselves, he could let the pent-up fury and sadness leak through the surface until becoming outright nastiness (like [[SourOutsideSadInside [=BoJack=]]]). You can be a BrokenHero but without real help or support, ''[[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped it will cost you]]''.
* Beast Boy from ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans''. Especially considering his backstory in the original comics...
* Oddly enough, ''Optimus Prime'' of ''WesternAnimation/TransformersAnimated''. Once a promising recruit at the Autobot Academy, now the captain of a washed-out repair crew.
** To a degree, every member of his crew qualifies, too. [[strike: Except maybe]] Especially Ratchet. If not literally because of the little bit taken off his helmet/head crest thingy, then because of the events that led to him [[spoiler: being put in control of Omega Supreme]]
* Although not the hero, Iroh of ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'' embodies this trope rather well. Introduced as Zuko's happy-go-lucky crazy old uncle, it's later show that he was a badass general before [[spoiler: his father and son were both killed]] and his younger brother [[spoiler: took the throne instead of him.]]