* ''Theatre/{{Cats}}'': Mr. Mistoffelees, though usually paired with Rum Tum Tugger, has been placed with every single male and female character in the show.
* Eponine from ''Theatre/LesMiserables'' has been paired with Marius, Enjolras, Cosette, Montparnasse, Javert, Valjean and every member of Les Amis ABC.
* [[Theatre/{{Hamilton}} Alexander Hamilton]] gets paired by the fandom with literally everyone else from the musical; most notably [[OfficialCouple Eliza]], [[ShipTease Angelica]], Laurens, Burr and Jefferson. Helped by the fact that the [[WordOfGod show creator has confirmed that in his mind, Hamilton is]] [[BiTheWay bisexual]]. He's even been paired with [[Series/DoctorWho the Doctor]], thanks to an offhand remark made about him in one episode that aired well before ''Hamilton'' was even written.