DiscardedYKTTW Cavemen and Dinosaurs YKTTW Discussion
|Cavemen and Dinosaurs|
Prehistoric-style man is shown with animals from before his era.Motion To Discard
"There should be cartoon confessionals where we could go and say things like, 'Father, I have sinned -- I have drawn dinosaurs and hominids together in the same cartoon.'"
-- Gary Larson, creator of The Far SideDespite the earth spending over 60 million years downtime between the fall of the dinosaurs and the rise of the cavemen, some works just have to put them together. This is a specific type of Anachronism Stew. Usually presents cavemen from One Million B.C.; showing Homo Erectus / Neanderthal Man as some low-intelligence thug with limited language skills. Some works use modern-era humans, except with the addition of loincloths. One way to play with this trope is to show primates with the dinosaurs, and imply that these primates are human ancestors. Another way is to take place on a different planet. Reasons for Cavemen And Dinosaurs abound. Most commonly, it is used to show the Earth in it's prehistory. Sometimes, however, it may be used for alien planets with different evolutionary paths. Aside from setting, the dinosaurs can also be in a relationship with the humans. Perhaps the dinosaurs are used as technology, instead of, or alongside of, Bamboo Technology. Maybe they just act as a man versus nature conflict. If the perspective is reversed, perhaps the dinosaurs view hominids as a threat. See also One Million B.C. for just cavemen, and Stock Dinosaurs for just dinosaurs. Prehistoria is a videogame trope with similarities. This trope does not include dinosaurs in modern-day times, unless cavemen come, too. This trope is not just for portrayals of prehistoric man as less than human; that belongs in One Million B.C.. Remember that any examples that are supposed to be our Earth in the past means Somewhere, a Paleontologist Is Crying. If a work seriously tries to convince the audience that humans and dinosaurs lived at the same time, they Did Not Do The Research. This includes any primates living with dinosaurs.
- The Flintstones are One Million B.C., with modern-style humans wearing loincloths replacing the unintelligent caricature and using a combination of intelligent dinosaurs and Bamboo Technology to create 1950s conveniences.
- to quote from their theme song, "they're a modern-stoneage family!"
- The Herculoids took place on another planet, with Zandor and his family (humans in loincloths) living with Tundro; a rhino-triceratops-like creature that could shoot burning rocks from its horn.
- Along with several other alien creatures.
- Doubly Subverted in an episode of Batman: The Brave and the Bold. Guy Gardner scolds Ice when they're traveling through time, saying that "Humans and dinosaurs didn't live at the same period, did you ever go to school?". And then a dinosaur attacked them. And then Cave-Batman (Batman as a caveman) saves them.
- No Dungeons & Dragons edition would be complete without at least having Stock Dinosaurs in the Monster Manual. Troglodyte is another common creature.
- The Eberron setting has an entire country of dinosaur-riding tribal halflings. Who are considered very backwards by their city-living cousins.
- ElfQuest, a series taking place on a far-off fantasy world, has a brief glimpse of a dinosaur-like beast in a swamp in the original series, and in the Spin Off anthologies there are references to allosauri roaming around. The rarely seen humans are in a neolithic age.
- The 1960's TV show "It's About Time" was about two U.S. astronauts thrown back in time to the days of the cavemen. Dinosaurs were an occasional threat.
- Subverted in an Animorphs book. The team travels back in time to the late Cretaceous, and Marco wonders if they are going to run into cavemen. Turns out Tobias liked to play with dinosaurs as a kid and tells him humans aren't going to evolve for millions of years, since This Is Reality.
- S.M. Stirling's novel The Sky People is set in an alternate history where aliens terraformed Venus and Mars millions of years ago and have periodically transplanted species from Earth to the other planets. As a result Venus has dinosaurs, prehistoric mammals, Neandertals and Cro-Magnons living side by side.