Do We Have This
? Should We Have This?
used when someone, usually The Captain
, has to make a Sadistic Choice
. He either has to let millions die or thousands die, there is no third option
and the cavalry
isn't coming. The only option is to sacrifice your own men or let the enemy kill everyone in the area.
Almost always includes There Is No Kill Like Overkill
and is often combined with Pyrrhic Victory
, Earth-Shattering Kaboom
and Taking You with Me
. Almost never leads to a Was It Really Worth It?
as the stakes are usually so absurdly high that it's generally acknowledged that the action taken was worth it. Usually turns one into a Hurting Hero
and is nearly guaranteed to give the person making the decision Flashback Nightmares
Alternatively, it can be used when the Heroes have just grasped the consequences of the Big Bad
succeeding in completing his master plan. Also, highly likely to include There Is No Kill Like Overkill
and Earth-Shattering Kaboom
or Take Over the World
. Difference in this case is that there is less likelihood for there to be a Last Stand
or Pyrrhic Victory
, not to say that it can't happen. It can also be used in reference to realizing that some horrible catastrophe is about to occur unless someone stops it.
- World in Conflict: One mission has the player defending Fort Teller from a massive Soviet assault. The Soviets believe the Fort had the American's anti-nuke program but the Americans know it's a bust. They have to stop the Soviets from taking the Fort and realizing this thus leading to millions of deaths from Nuclear strikes on major cities. The player is ultimately overwhelmed with an overwhelming force of Soviet tanks on the way. Colonel Sawyer is given authorization to nuke the area to stop the Soviets but Bannon points out that if everyone retreats the Russians will know something is up. Bannon stays behind to hold the Soviets off and the player orders the strike. After doing so Sawyer utters this phrase knowing full well the necessity of it.
Horrified Realization Examples:
- The Albino Code:
Captain Fascist: Officer Howard. We are dealing with an Albeeno, which means: He has red eyes, evil in his heart, and create a storm the likes of which the human race has never seen. God help us all.
- Deep Space Nine:
Captain Sisko: If we do nothing, the Dominion could sit behind that perimeter for the next five years rearming themselves. And when they're ready to come out, God help us all.
- Buffy the Vampire Slayer:
Rupert Giles: There's a reference here to the journal of Desmond Kane, pastor of a town called Sharpsville. "May 26, 1723. Tomorrow is the Ascension. God help us all."
Giles: It was the last anyone heard.
Wesley: Of Kane?
Giles: Of Sharpsville.
- LOST Season 4's first episode's teaser ended with Pierre Chang saying, "God help us all" if the energy of the Orchid were released. The episode "The Lie" ended with Eloise Hawking saying, "God help us all," if Ben couldn't get the Oceanic 6 back to the island.
- Futurama: "The Day the Earth Stood Stupid" has Nibbler ending a log like this, which is most likely intended as a parody.
Nibbler: ...and when that happens then may god help us all!
Leela: Time for a diaper change!
Nibbler: End transmission.