Bleak Abyss Retirement Home YKTTW Discussion
|Bleak Abyss Retirement Home|
The fate of grandma, her ungrateful children never visiting, the patronizing staff treating her like a five-year oldUp For Grabs
When the elderly can't take care of themselves, often the most practical solution is a nursing home or assisted living facility. The kids and relatives, if any, have their own lives and can't devote themselves to full time care. Staying in home with a private nursing staff is out of reach for all but the wealthiest. A dedicated facility catering to the needs of the elderly is the pragmatic solution. But that doesn't make it easy. When it's time to "put mom in a home," expect a great deal of angst over the decision, quite possibly dividing siblings over the appropriate course of action. Moving to a new place inevitably means abandoning a house filled with personal affects and memories that are irreplaceable. After arrival, it gets worse: the promised once a week visits from the kids become more like once a month, or once a year. The staff is at best patronizingly helpful, perhaps talking like kindergarten teachers to the residents, paying heed to the elder's physical needs but not to any need for dignity. At worst, they could be neglectful or abusive. Expect the food to be bland and possibly pureed. The home could be run-down and dingy, but even if it isn't, it will often be clinical, antiseptic, and dehumanizing. Attempts at warmth with arts-and-crafts project on the walls will be about as effective as motivational posters at a corporate office. On the other hand, if the kids have some unresolved issues with their parents, then they might see putting them in sub-par nursing homes and never coming back as kicking the father-of-a-bitch. No Real Life examples, please.
ExamplesAnime and Manga
- Japan, Inc.. had a chapter in which the main characters visit a nursing home (one of them has an elderly parent who may need such a facility and the others use this as an excuse to investigate a possible investment.) The place is decent enough, but very depressing, and the characters decide to recommend investing in ways for senior citizens to continue living with family.
- In Bubba Ho Tep, Elvis Presley and John F. Kennedy lived in a run down rest home.
- In The Invention of Lying, there is a nursing home called "A Sad Place for Hopeless Old People."
- In The Real Macaw, this is played with: the plot revolves around preventing the main character's grandfather from getting put in a retirement home, but it's because of the grandfather's enormous debt. They had to sell his house to pay it off.
- In Up, no examples are shown, but the idea is there. The elderly in the Pixar Short George and AJ are so repulsed by the idea of entering a retirement home that they happily follow Carl's example and uproot their houses for destinations unknown. Eventually the denizens of Shady Oaks itself follow suit.
- In Water for Elephants, this is the framing story.
- In Win Win, much of the plot revolves around a well-off elderly man unwillingly consigned to an assisted living facility, and who bears responsibility for this. The facility is apparently decent, but the man is still unhappy about leaving his home.
- Happy Gilmore: the cheerful orderly who runs the place is running an horrific sweat shop.
- In Carl Reiner's dark farce Where's Papa, the lead character tours a Dickensian nursing home he's considering putting his senile mother in.
- In She Devil, Ruth accepts a job in an expensive but dehumanizing retirement home, where she quickly proceeds to bring some color into the lives of both staff and retirees, such as a soccer match that proves to be a hit with the old ladies.
- Gran Torino: One of Walt's sons tries to convince him to move into a retirement home but not at all out of genuine concern for his bitter, elderly, and recently-widowed father, oh no. He just wanted the house, some of the stuff and hoped he'd get the titular Cool Car out of the deal too. One can only presume that this trope would have followed. Walt tells him to go to Hell.
- In Lois Lowry's Anastasia Krupnik, the heroine's grandmother lives and dies at such a facility.
- In Barbara Brooks Wallace's Peppermints in the Parlor, Sugar Hill Hall as seen through the eyes of the orphan girl working there.
- In Red Dragon, the villain grew up in his grandmother's house modified into a retirement home.
- Water for Elephants
- Tricky Business has a downplayed version: while the staff isn't too rude or insulting (except for one guy who threatens to put Phil and Arnold in the Assisted Living wing, aka the loony bin), they're not used to having their patients being very active (in fact, large quantities of drugs are distributed to keep them quiet). Phil and Arnold bribe an orderly by giving him their allotted drugs, which he then sells at parties.
- In The Twelve Chairs, Ostap Bender visits a retirement home of this kind in search of the MacGuffin. Bleak, antiseptic and run by a very stingy and embezzling administrator (and a bunch of the administrator's relatives chowing on old ladies' rations).
- In House of Anubis, Sarah thinks of her retirement home as this.
- The Golden Girls
- Has a Running Gag that Dorothy had put Sophia in Shady Pines, a retirement home so bleak that simply mentioning sending her back would humble her. She was there for five years before the place burned down.
- In a later episode, Sophia's friend Lillian was in a retirement home that Sophia makes clear is the only home worse than Shady Pines. She then concocts a plan to break her friend out.
- Inverted in The Sopranos. Tony's mother Livia constantly refers to her retirement home as if its a hell-hole, but on the whole it's shown to be a relatively pleasant place to live
- Waiting for God: Bayview Retirement Village is portrayed as one of these.
- Law & Order: Special Victims Unit featured an extreme version of this trope in an episode that dealt with elder abuse. The detectives initially suspected one of its orderlies of abusing an old woman who'd broken out, but later discovered that the manager herself was also abusing her charges, deliberately giving them drugs to induce heart attacks so that she could "rescue" them and thus look like a hero (and presumably pump their grateful relatives for more money.)
- Moby's "Natural Blues" music video takes this to Nightmare Fuel levels.
- Implied Trope in Simon & Garfunkel's Mrs Robinson, which deals with a family consigning their mother/grandmother to a nursing home.
- Ann Sheppard from Heavy Rain lives in one. It's implied that Madison is the first visitor she's had in some time.
- In Mother 3, Alec and Wess are thrown into a retirement home built on the site of Wess's old house.
- On Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends, Madame Foster believes retirement homes are a sort of prison where the elderly are brainwashed into compliance with tapioca pudding.
- The Futurama episode "A Clone of My Own" features a virtual reality to this effect.
Farnsworth: It was as though I were living in a facility in Florida with hundreds of other old people. All day long we'd play bingo, eat oatmeal and wait for our children to call.
- The Retirement Castle in The Simpsons is a perfect example of this. The orderlies even go out of their way to make life miserable for the elderly.
- An episode of Rugrats revolved around a retirement home where the old people were kept out of all the fun activities. Somehow this turned into a riot.
- Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy from Spongebob Squarepants live in a retirement home, but Mermaid Man's senility keeps him from caring about the bleakness.