Troperville

Tools


This is discussion contributing to PrejudicedForPecs.
Prejudiced For Pecs
(permanent link) added: 2009-11-05 13:44:48 by Superhal (last reply: 2009-11-05 13:44:48)
Molly Brown: Hey, uh, who thought of the name Titanic? Was it you, Bruce?
J. Bruce Ismay: Yes, actually. I want to convey sheer size; and size means stability, luxury and, above all, strength.
Frank the Pug: You humans! When will you learn size doesn't matter?

Who do you think will win?

As part of a Willing Suspension Of Disbelief, audiences tend to have a list of expectations. One of the most prevalent stereotypes is that characters with big muscles must be strong. In most media, this almost forces creators to make large characters seem strong (or at least stronger than smaller characters,) and small characters seem less strong, or risk forcing the audience out of the story.

The Trope Codifier is probably Superman, who, as part of his Secret Identity of Clark Kent, would slouch as part of the identity, assuming that if he was a little shorter, he wouldn't be associated with the taller and stronger Superman, but even cave paintings suggest a certain awe of larger creatures (like wooly mammoths and horses,) making this trope Older Than Dirt.

Often, this carries the opposite meaning as well: small characters are usually elusive, quiet, agile, stealthy and quick, while large characters trying to do so will not be believable.

Subverted in anime, as the smallest character is often the strongest (Sailor Moon, Yugi/Atem from Yugioh, Pokemon, Conan Itagawa, etc.), but in live action, the trope is often supported as in super-sentai/giant robot shows, or Ultraman.

Lampshaded and subverted in Men In Black when Frank the Pug states that "you humans" are always concerned with size, but something very small can be very powerful.

In comedies, a smaller person, usually a midget, dwarf, or martial arts chick, beating up a bigger person is used for humor or comedy relief, as in Elf or Austin Powers 3.

In Professional Wrestling, this is taken to extremes, as few fans will accept a smaller wrestler beating a larger wrestler except through cheating or DQ, and small or average sized wrestlers usually take years of development before becoming believable vs larger opponents (Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Rey Misterio, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, etc.)

Related to Bishonen Line.


Examples:

[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder:Comic Books]]
  • This trope is almost the entire plot for the Hulk, as any character's superpower can be easily identified by which body part is the largest (The Leader, the Abomination, etc.)
    • For a while, the Hulk himself would also get larger as he got angrier/stronger.
  • This is also prevalent in many Rogue's Galleries.
    • For Spiderman, the "strong" villains were always large and muscular (e.g. the Rhino) while the villains who had other powers were slimmer (e.g. the Chameleon.)
      • Venom and Carnage, the "evil" Spidermen, were always larger to indicate they were stronger than Spiderman.
    • Batman had Bane, Clayface, Solomon Grundy, and other "melee" villains who were larger than Batman.
    • Superman's villains who fought with him were drawn larger (e.g. Doomsday.)
      • However, the villains that outsmarted him were drawn smaller, e.g. Mr. Mxyzptlk, Luthor, etc.
  • Batman is an especially obvious example of this trope. In comics where he had to fight, he was drawn larger than average (The Dark Knight Returns.) In comics where he used his detective skills, he was drawn slimmer and less muscular (Brave And The Bold.)
    • In films, Batman traditionally wore a padded Bat-suit, but appeared slim as Bruce Wayne.

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Professional Wrestling ]]
  • In Professional Wrestling, "large" wrestlers (275 lbs or more) are usually given Squash Match es and power Finishing Move s. Smaller (200 lbs or less) are usually in matches that demon
replies: 19