Created By: yisfidri on March 13, 2013 Last Edited By: yisfidri on May 1, 2013
Troped

Redemption Equals Affliction

Erring character suffers affliction, loss, or crippling while redeeming themselves

Name Space:
Main
Page Type:
Trope
Sometimes, a character who has committed wicked deeds or screwed up enormously manages to redeem themselves, but at a cost. A toned-down cousin of Redemption Equals Death, this trope describes a situation where the redeemer does not die, but is crippled or afflicted somehow or suffers a huge and meaningful loss.

This trope exists, like Redemption Equals Death, for the benefit of the audience, in order to stop the redeemed character from becoming a Karma Houdini who might never pay for the horrible things they did before.

Compare Karma Houdini Warranty, and compare Restrained Revenge and My Fist Forgives You if it's the offender invoking this. Compare also Break the Haughty, which can overlap with this if the person took great pride in whatever they had to lose to earn redemption. See also Being Good Sucks. Contrast Redemption Earns Life.


Examples:

Anime & Manga
  • While on an assassination mission Kenshin Himura recieved a cut to his face from his target's bodygard (whom he immediately dispatched as well). Because the cut refused to heal it was theorized by Kenshin's peers that he had been struck by an innocent man and his wound was pennance. The wound only finally stopped bleeding some months later when the famous cross-shaped-scar was completed by his dying wife whom he had accidentially struck during a battle (and whom it turned had been the fiancee of the man he murdered before) in possibly the most heart-wrenching scene of all time (atleast before the second OVA blew that emotional baseline out of the water). Kenshin holds the belief that the cross-shaped-scar will vanish when he has fully atoned for his sins. He also doesn't believe that is possible, so...
  • In Fullmetal Alchemist Doctor Marchoh has his face disfigured by Scar after regretting everything he did in the Ishbalan war.

Literature
  • Mr Rochester in Jane Eyre treated Jane quite badly, pulling an Operation: Jealousy on her, and then trying to induce her to unknowingly enter into a bigamous marriage with him. When his mad wife burns down his house, not only does he lose it, but he also loses one hand and most of his eyesight trying to save her life. Jane returns to him.
  • A Song of Ice and Fire:
    • In A Storm of Swords, Jaime's Heel–Face Turn comes at the price of his sword hand.
    • As of A Dance with Dragons, Theon seems to be heading in a similar direction after his prolonged Cold-Blooded Torture at the hands of Ramsay Bolton.

Live Action TV
  • The TV series of Rebecca featuring Charles Dance as Maxim de Winter, unlike the Hitchcock film, had Maxim kill his wife as in the original book. Reminiscent of Jane Eyre, Maxim suffers disfigurement in the fire trying to save Mrs Danvers in this version.
  • Londo taking the Drakh Keeper toward the end of Babylon 5. One interpretation of Morella's prophecies regarding Londo ("Point of No Return") would have this be the consequence of "killing the one who is already dead" (which could be read, after a fashion, as Sheridan, Morden, or Refa--but Morden, or possibly rival-to-the-throne Refa, in this case)--although he has much else to redeem himself for--and the total loss of control represented by the Keeper could be read as the "greatest fear" which is then his final chance at redemption. At any rate, he bears the Keeper to avoid the Drakh detonating fusion bombs all over Centauri Prime, potentially killing millions. The Keeper is a living symbiote that can neurally exert control over his actions, as directed by a Drakh controller.
  • In an attempt to atone for his actions in Season 6, Castiel in Supernatural absorbs Sam's mental trauma, and suffers a mental breakdown as a result.

Religion
  • In The Bible, King David had slept with Uriah's wife, Bathsheba, while sending him out to battle, which would led him to be killed. This angers God who had sent the Prophet Nathan to rebuke David for pulling the Uriah Gambit. David sincerely repents, but while God forgave him, He allowed David and Bathsheba's child to die in infancy.

Video Games
  • At the end of Dragon Age: Origins, one of the possible outcomes of the plot is Big Bad Teyrn Loghain being forced into joining the Grey Wardens and helping the party battle the Bigger Bad Archdemon in the Final Battle. Should he survive, he's redeemed himself from almost plunging Ferelden into a civil war but now has to spend the rest of his life with all of the nasty side effects of surviving the Warden joining process. Could also count as Redemption Equals Death, although said death would be decades down the road.

Community Feedback Replies: 13
  • March 13, 2013
    Earnest
  • March 13, 2013
    WeAreAllKosh
    Live-Action TV

    Londo taking the Drakh Keeper toward the end of Babylon 5. One interpretation of Morella's prophecies regarding Londo ("Point of No Return") would have this be the consequence of "killing the one who is already dead" (which could be read, after a fashion, as Sheridan, Morden, or Refa--but Morden, or possibly rival-to-the-throne Refa, in this case)--although he has much else to redeem himself for--and the total loss of control represented by the Keeper could be read as the "greatest fear" which is then his final chance at redemption. At any rate, he bears the Keeper to avoid the Drakh detonating fusion bombs all over Centauri Prime, potentially killing millions. The Keeper is a living symbiote that can neurally exert control over his actions, as directed by a Drakh controller.
  • March 14, 2013
    yisfidri
    Done. Will add more suggested content too when I get time.
  • March 15, 2013
    Guyven
    Kenshin's cross-shaped-scar probably counts as this: Anime and Manga:
    • While on an assassination mission Kenshin Himura recieved a cut to his face from his target's bodygard (whom he immediately dispatched as well). Because the cut refused to heal it was theorized by Kenshin's peers that he had been struck by an innocent man and his wound was pennance. The wound only finally stopped bleeding some months later when the famous cross-shaped-scar was completed by his dying wife whom he had accidentially struck during a battle (and whom it turned had been the fiancee of the man he murdered before) in possibly the most heart-wrenching scene of all time (atleast before the second OVA blew that emotional baseline out of the water). Kenshin holds the belief that the cross-shaped-scar will vanish when he has fully atoned for his sins. He also doesn't believe that is possible, so...
  • March 16, 2013
    MokonaZero
    In Full Metal Alchemist Doctor Marchoh has his face disfigured by Scar after regretting everything he did in the Ishbalan war.
  • March 16, 2013
    313Bluestreak
    Compare Restrained Revenge and My Fist Forgives You if it's the offender invoking this.
  • March 29, 2013
    313Bluestreak
    Religion
    • The Bible: King David had slept with Uriah's wife, Bathsheba, while sending him out to battle, which would led him to be killed. This angers God who had sent the Prophet Nathan to rebuke David for pulling the Uriah Gambit. David sincerely repents, but while God forgave him, He allowed David and Bathsheba's child to die in infancy.
  • April 13, 2013
    WeAreAllKosh
    bump
  • April 14, 2013
    MonaNaito
    Compare Break The Haughty, which can overlap with this if the person took great pride in whatever they had to lose to earn redemption.

    (Also, looking at The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe "temporary" example, I think we need to make a decision as to whether "almost dying, then being saved and suffering no lasting consequences" counts as this trope.)
  • April 15, 2013
    yisfidri
    True. The Lion The Witch and the Wardrobe example does not belong here; instead, it is a subversion of "Redemption Equals Death", so I will move it there.
  • April 17, 2013
    MonaNaito
  • April 29, 2013
    CrankyStalfos1
    In an attempt for his actions in season 6, Castiel in Supernatural absorbs Sam's mental trauma, and suffers a mental breakdown as a result.
  • April 29, 2013
    arbiter099
    Would this count? At the end of Dragon Age Origins, one of the possible outcomes of the plot is Big Bad Teyrn Loghain being forced into joining the Grey Wardens and helping the party battle the Bigger Bad Archdemon in the Final Battle. Should he survive, he's redeemed himself from almost plunging Ferelden into a civil war but now has to spend the rest of his life with all of the nasty side effects of surviving the Warden joining process.

    I mean technically it's Redemption Equals Death since said effects will kill you eventually, but it's decades down the road.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=fabjvlf257dbwngb7a2gzeak&trope=RedemptionEqualsAffliction