QuarrelingSong Quarreling Song YKTTW Discussion

Quarreling Song
(permanent link) added: 2012-03-10 08:29:46 sponsor: CaveCat (last reply: 2012-03-18 19:45:13)

Add Tag:
Exactly What It Says on the Tin, two characters get into an argument, which then leads into a song that describes what they're arguing about. This may even overlap with Feud Episode or Isolation Despondency. Sometimes the song will be a Counterpoint Duet.

Needs More Examples, Do We Have This One??


  • "Duel Duet" from Shock Treatment, in which Frank and Farley argue that the other one is worthless, giving reasons why.
  • There was also a song called "Confrontation" in Jekyll & Hyde where Jekyll and Hyde argue over who should be in control of the body. An interesting scene to watch, as Jekyll and Hyde are played by the same actor.
  • "Ah Still Suits Me", from the 1936 Showboat Movie. In it, Hattie is nagging her husband Joe about his persistant laziness, while he laughs it off. link

  • "Anything You Can Do, I Can Do Better" from Annie Get Your Gun where Annie and Frank argue about many, many things such as drinking liquor, shooting better, and singing higher.
    • "Old-Fashioned Wedding", a Counterpoint Duet where Frank wants to have a quiet simple wedding and Annie wants it at the Waldorf with all kinds of fancy stuff.
  • "A Boy Like That / I Have a Love" from West Side Story - Anita warns Maria that white boys are no good, but Maria has a love.
  • "All Or Nothing" from Oklahoma!, Will and Ado Annie argue about her being a Good Bad Girl.
  • "Confrontation" from Les MisÚrables. Javert has come to take Valjean to prison but Valjean has to find Cosette.
  • In Lestat, The Musical of Interview with the Vampire and The Vampire Lestat, "Embrace It" is an argument song between Louis and Lestat about giving in to vampirism.
  • "Fugue for Tinhorns" from Guys and Dolls is three guys arguing about the different tips they have on horse racing.
  • "Another Day" from RENT. Mimi wants to go out and party with Roger and some heroin, but he wants to stay home and brood with his guitar. Also "Take Me Or Leave Me". Maureen is slutty and her girlfriend Joanne is controlling.
  • Jesus Christ Superstar has "Everything's Alright", which has Mary Magdalene telling Jesus to relax, Judas saying that they should be helping the poor instead of relaxing, and Jesus saying they should all concentrate on the future.
  • Evita has a lot: "Eva, Beware of the City": Eva wants to go to the Big City, Magaldi says she's too young. "A New Argentina": Eva thinks her husband should be politically ambitious, he's less sure. "The Actress Hasn't Learned the Lines (You'd Like to Hear)": Aristocrats don't approve of the lower-class Eva. "Waltz for Eva and Che" has Eva arguing with her narrator about whether the ends justify the means.
  • Song And Dance has several, including the oft-reprised "Take That Look Off Your Face", though this is a one-woman show and all the responses to her arguments are unheard by the audience.
  • Aspects of Love has a few; the show is through-sung, so a lot of the arguments are not proper songs but more recitative: One that stands out as a full song is "She'd Be Far Better off with You", George and Alex fighting over Rose.
  • Wicked has "Loathing": Glinda and Elphaba, who really dislike each other, have just learned they're going to be roommates at campus.
  • "Piddle, Twiddle, and Resolve", from 1776, towards the end of which John Adams quarrels with his wife Abigail as they correspond through letters. John wants Abigail to organize the local ladies to make saltpeter for the war, while Abigail wants John to do something about the local pin shortage.

  • "The Boy is Mine" by Monica and Brandy
  • Also "The Girl is Mine" by Paul Mc Cartney and Michael Jackson.
Replies: 13