Troperville

Tools


This is discussion contributing to SlidingScaleOfGenderInequality.
Sliding Scale Of Sexsism
(permanent link) added: 2009-11-02 04:05:22 by Primo Victoria (last reply: 2009-11-04 14:48:41)
Needs A Better Description

Works of fiction can potray male's and females. Writers have different views of terms like sexuality, feminism, sexism or gender equality - all of this strongly Depends On The Writer. First attempt to sort works of fiction ( sci-fi, horror and fantasy literature in that case) by scale of women potrayal was so-called Martin Scale, created by Diana Martin, redactor of fanzin Aurora. Hoever, it was a scale of how much feminist a books is while the highest levels were things that could been consider as feminist only by feminazis. Scale you can see here was inspired by it, but it's more balanced and describes the levels of sexism in any work of fiction, where one end are works with strong "sexism agains females", and second with strong "sexims agains males".

Level 1: There are no women.

There are no female characters in the story. Or it's said there are few of them, but they are nothim more than a backgorung for bunch of males, and dosn't do anything at all. None of them is more than statist, and see any female protagonist/antagonist is impossible.

Level 2: Whores, Whores, Whores....

In this kind of fiction all female characters are either complete sluts that will screw around with anything that moves or helpless sex-slaves whose sole purpose of existence is beign raped by male characters. Of course they enjoy the rape.

Level 3: Male Superiority

Women are useless and most of the time don't do anything at all. If they are in trouble, they can only wait to be rescured. Also, they are never in control of anything - males are always patriarchal leaders and their actions can be questioned only be other males. Most purest and straightest (wich mean - those that will never change) examples of The Chick and Distressed Damsel are here.
  • Andre Norton's Witch World series.
  • Most of the classic Fairy Tales about prince saving the princess.
  • Most Mario games, with Peach as an perfect Distressed Damsel. Hoever, her own games are an inversion.

Level 4: Males are more equal.

At this level it looks like both characters are equal. Or Do They?. Then why only males have all cool powers and equipment, while their female teammates does things like providing first aid, beign Mission Control, working in the labolatory and you would be damned if you will ever seen any of them in actual fight. And even if the go into a fight, they ended up either beign easily defeated, their fights will be unimportant, or end up fighting another girl. Every unlucky Action Girl that lives in world set at this level will suffer from Chickificationn and turn into Faux Action Girl. Also, males will have more dangerous and offensive powers. Men and women are equal, but some things are still a man's job.
  • Yu-Gi-Oh! - Most of the times a girl win in Duel Monsters it's unimportant duel that we see only in a cut-scenes, and those on wich plot is focused ahd have been won by girls can be count on one hand's fingers.
    • Similiar in GX where Asuka is consider among seven best duelist in Duel Academy, but we see her having a victory in fully respected by plot duel only one time. And against guy with Villain Decay

Level 5: Almost Perfect Equality.

Things that potrays both grenders as an equal or are at last trying to balance The Chick and Distressed Damsel with Action Girl or subvert/justify them fith here. Also, females can be protagonists. It's almsot impossible to make a completly, perfect balance of both genders, especially in story aimed for one specific audience (like Shonen or Shoujo). That's while many of examples here are works that, while is still impossible to tell they potray both grenders as an completly equal, are still just more balanced than level 4 or 6.
  • Bleach does it - in both cases of Distressed Damsel we have justification why the girls dosn't do anything to save themselves. And don't forget about Yoruichi, Soi-Fon and Hailbel - three women that can easily give a hard time most of male cast.
    • Also, Vizard's power is determined by how much they can stay with their masks on (they can possibly stay longer with each use). Mashiro was able to have her mask on 15 hours without a single break at first time. For contrast, Ichigo could do it only for 3 minutes at first.
  • in Naruto there are many powerfull female ninja, at last one in each team, and fifth leader in the history of the Konoha village is a woman. Hoever, except for few, they are mostly much weaker than male characters.
  • JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 6 wich breaks series tradition of male protagonists with Joelyne.

Lever 6: Women are better than men.

In this trope women oftenly proves their superiority and are always a protagonists. Men, while they mostly still are competent, are only supporters.
  • Most of Magical Girl seriers fits here. Boys cannot be chosen ones, or fight evil with magical powers (except if they will get Gender Bender). Hoever, they can still be helpfull by beign themselves and provide source of "something to fight for" for protagonits.
    • Most prominent example of this is Sailor Moon, with Mammoru helping by just saying Usagi to never give up, and three boys that helps Sailor Senshi via turning into magical girls themselves.
  • In Sparkling Generation Valkyrie Yuki main protagonist can become a Valkyrie, but it permamently turns him into a girl.
  • Book Frostlover and Thorn by Phyllis Ann Karr.
  • Tomoe Gozen by Jessica Amanda Salmonson.
  • Theanu by Ursula K. Le Ghuin
  • Morgaine by C.J. Cherrych

Level 7: It's hard to live with men but it's hard to live without them too.

Men are jerks and there's nothing good in living with them, bacause they only think about sex and how to put a partner under their thumbs. Hoever, living without them is hard to - there are problems that should not be concern of women, or simply requires a brute strenght to do them. Also, there's one thing that makes males necessary - procreation. Simply, you need a man if you want to have kids.
  • Many of the love stories.

Level 8: All men are dumb and needs to be controled.

Goverments are ruled by women, wars are fought by women and all important functions in the society are in their hands. Men are useless and there's no single thing that women couldn't acomplish without them. Except for one - that goddamnend procreation. That's the only reason men weren't slaughtered alredy. But they are still reduced to second-class citizens at best, and to sex-slaves at worse. In other words, this is just completly inversion of level 2.
  • In Incredible Hercules Artume almost turned Earth into that kind of place, with women in charge since the beginign of time, most males as second-class citizens and few mainly men that survived, including Hercules, labelled as terorists.

Level 9: Full gender separation.

Men and women lives in seperation. All men and women. There are two divided communities, with members of only one gender. There are only homosexual relationships and both grenders dosn't need each other, even for procreation. Women are either more advanced and lives in state close to Utopia, or both genders are at war.
  • Marvel Comics character Thundra comes from future where men and women areat the state of war, and use genetic to procreation. Her daughter, Lyra, (born via in vitro with use of Hulk's cells]] get a little Ret Con of this - her world is set After The End, where women created an advanced society while men degenerated into buch of wild tribals that are worshipping old superheroes as gods.

Level 10: Men? What men?

Women rule the world, men are all eitheir castrated slaves or extnict. Women lives in Feminist Utopia with the most superior technology ever, and happy lesbian community. Genetics takes care of procreation. Of course, there's no evil, because source of all evil where males.

  • Goodmother Night by Rachel Pollack.
  • Amazons from Wonder Woman comics lives on a separate island, without any men.
    • In Planetary their [[Expy Expies] has also a technology thousand years more advanced than rest of the world and were planning to send an emmisarry that would introduce whole mankind into new golden age. Hoever, they still were slaughtered by The Four.
  • This level was parodied in polish movie Sexmisja (trans.: Sexmission), where two male protagonists wakes up from hibarnation in the world where all males were killed by pandemy and nuclear war and women lives in the undreground and thier community denies existence of males. Hoever their leader is in fact transvestite who somehow managed to survive the end of the male race, and the movie ends with our heroes manipulating cloning machine to create new male breed. Keep in mind, that this move was directed in the times of communism and was one big Getting Crap Past The Radar about live in land under the control of communist party.
replies: 50