As opposed to Costume Copycat or Legendary Impostor, Secret Identity Theft involves a character losing his super identity against his will, and another guy taking up the mask. May be a temporary problem of the day if the guy is a baddie, or the start of a Legacy Character if the guy wants to help out. Examples:
- Robin from Teen Titans has his Red X persona for when he needs to get his hands dirty, but the costume gets stolen from him and Red X becomes his own villain.
- John Henry Irons's niece, Natasha, becomes the new Steel after her uncle gave her the Never Be a Hero speech. Obviously it didn't take, but John set his equipment up to respond to her commands, so he had this in mind.
- In the new run of Ultimate Spiderman, Peter Parker was killed in a jailbreak of the Sinister Six, and Miles Morales happened to be the only kid with spider powers around to take up the mantle.
Hello, Unknown Troper. You'll need to get known to lend a hand here.
Three days must pass before this YKTTW is Launchworthy or Discardable