Linkara: This was not what I was expecting.
Steven the Wizard:
What the hell do you want? It's 2012. There aren't a load of people living in gloomy castles, standing over crystal balls and crap like that.
In a fantasy setting, the Robe and Wizard Hat
is a great outfit for a great sorcerer. In Urban Fantasy
or Magic Realism
(or any other post-medieval setting), however, it can look silly and clash with the more grounded aspects of the the setting. By giving the magic users clothes that wouldn't stick out like a sore thumb in the middle of a crowded street, the realistic look of the world is preserved. And don't expect them to dwell in a mysterious lair, either.
This can also give an air of mystery to the wizards, as it hides the strength of their powers and also implies that anyone
could be a wizard.
The image of a magician in top hat and tails is the basis of this trope. Prior to the Victorian Era, most stage magicians dressed like Merlin. Then, a few entertainers decided magic would look more amazing if done by someone in (at the time) contemporary evening dress. Penn and Teller update the tradition by dressing in ordinary suits and ties.
Compare Not Wearing Tights
Please only note examples where this is brought up or becomes relevant to the story. Otherwise, it's just an incidental detail.
- (Does this use the trope or just include it?) In the Young Wizards series, anyone and anything can be a wizard. Combine this with the modern setting and of course all the wizards wander around inconspicuously.
- Played for laughs in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, where the wizards gathering for the Quiddich World Cup are ordered to dress like muggles so as not to create any suspicion.
...a pair of men who were having a heated argument. One of them was a very old wizard who was wearing a long flowery nightgown. The other was clearly a Ministry wizard; he was holding out a pair of pin-striped trousers and almost crying with exasperation. "Just put them on, Archie, there's a good chap. You can't walk around like that, the Muggle at the gate's already getting suspicious—" "I bought this in a Muggle shop," said the old wizard stubbornly. "Muggles wear them." "Muggle women wear them, Archie, not the men, they wear these," said the ministry wizard, and he brandished the pinstriped trousers. "I'm not putting them on," said old Archie in indignation. "I like a healthy breeze 'round my privates, thanks."
- Several books by Mercedes Lackey apply. Three are three books about Diana Tregarde, a detective and practicing witch. Bedlams bard, a half dozen or so books about a bard, aided by witches and elves. Also there are the SERR Ated Edge books, mainly about elves and their allies driving race cars and helping people. Most of them have some manner of fancy clothes, for casting and/or fighting, though they don't wearer them around town.
- In The Dresden Files, Harry Dresden openly plies his trade as a wizard-for-hire, but dresses, monologues and conducts business like (and pretty much has a life as crappy as) a Private Eye. Since most other wizards keep themselves hidden nobody really believes him unless they're already aware of the supernatural side of things, though.
- The Bartimaeus Trilogy both plays this straight and averts this. Powerful magicians tend to look like accountants; weak magicians look like wizards are expected to — beards, robes, etc, etc.
- Most magic-users in the Iron Druid Chronicles tend to look inconspicuous like this. Atticus, for instance, deliberately looks like some New Age hippie doofus, an impression only heightened by the occult bookstore he runs.
When people see my red curly hair, fair skin and long goatee, they suspect I play soccer and drink lots of Guinness. If I'm going sleeveless and they see the tattoos
all up and down my right arm, they assume I'm in a rock band and smoke lots of weed. It never enters their mind for a moment that I could be an ancient
Druid—which is exactly why I like this look. If I grew a white beard and got myself a pointy hat, oozed dignity and sagacity and glowed with beatitude, people might get the wrong—or right—idea.
- Linkara openly practices magic to turn his toys into weapons, but he still wears a brown jacket and a fedora all the time. Similarly, the Great Wizard Steven (once known as Alpos) who provides the above quote wears a plain shirt and lives in a detached bungalow.