Page Action: YKTTW

yes But What Does Zataproximetacine DoYKTTW YKTTW Rigor
Image PickinPage Action
Page Action: YKTTW
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
Issues with current YKTTW setup:
  • YKTTW is often overly-concerned with example-finding as opposed to description-drafting
  • There is a backlog in the current YKTTW system.
  • There isn't enough quality control over what comes out of YKTTW, leading to more work fixing them later.

These are the solution proposals for YKTTW. Please note that they are not mutually exclusive.
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+53 (yeas:56 nays:3)
Tagging system so that drafts can be tagged as Needs a Better Title, Needs Examples, Is This Tropable?, and so on (proposed list here), with filters to browse by tag
+41 (yeas:44 nays:3)
YKTTW history with diffs and editors
+35 (yeas:37 nays:2)
Allow crowners to be hooked to YKTTW
+34 (yeas:36 nays:2)
Allow hollering from a YKTTW
+32 (yeas:36 nays:4)
Create a YKTTW watchlist
+31 (yeas:35 nays:4)
Create a "Stale YKTTW" list like "Stale Shop" in TRS/IP
+30 (yeas:36 nays:6)
Alternative forum-view
+30 (yeas:33 nays:3)
Use hooked alt-titles crowner on YKTTW
+26 (yeas:29 nays:3)
Allow YKTTWs to be seen sorted by reply date
+23 (yeas:29 nays:6)
Creating an archive for Launched and/or discarded YKTTWs
+21 (yeas:33 nays:12)
Forcing comments on hats/de-hats
+20 (yeas:32 nays:12)
Use laconic as draft title.
+19 (yeas:21 nays:2)
Make permalinks in YKTTW look like a YKTTW in the main list
+17 (yeas:18 nays:1)
Linking your YKTTW history from YKTTW
+16 (yeas:26 nays:10)
"Examples" go in a different comment box than "drafts"
+16 (yeas:20 nays:4)
Tag improper launches in a Launched/Discarded archive
+14 (yeas:27 nays:13)
Preventing public editing of comments
+12 (yeas:30 nays:18)
Three stage creation: Description Refinement; Name Crowner; Examples Round.
+10 (yeas:19 nays:9)
Forcing a post in a YKTTW before launching and/or discarding
+10 (yeas:11 nays:1)
Forcing comments when removing a hat.
+6 (yeas:10 nays:4)
Make the "Needs a Better Description" tag hide several other tags as suggested here
+6 (yeas:8 nays:2)
move hatting / dehatting into the comments so it becomes a single action.
+5 (yeas:16 nays:11)
Pick image by hooked IP crowner
+5 (yeas:18 nays:13)
Use a YKTTW namespace for drafts, and link it from YKTTW
+5 (yeas:10 nays:5)
Make the "Definition Contested" tag hide several other tags as suggested here
+4 (yeas:10 nays:6)
Linking titled YKTTWs to the pages titled.
+3 (yeas:10 nays:7)
Allow sponsors to hook/unhook and close crowners on a YKTTW
+2 (yeas:10 nays:8)
Implement some form of enforced tags with "tag heirarchy", e.g. if tag A is present then tag B isn't displayed because A renders B irrelevant. For example, Needs a Better Description would override No Launching Please because bad YKTTW's shouldn't be launched anyway.
-2 (yeas:14 nays:16)
Change Description to say Description (At Least Three Sentences, No Examples). The OP would be free to supply examples starting with the first comment/reply.
-3 (yeas:17 nays:20)
Remove "sponsor" from the top of the thingie.
-3 (yeas:12 nays:15)
Three stage creation: Description Refinement; Examples Round; Name Crowner.
-9 (yeas:6 nays:15)
Allowing sponsors to clock YKTTWs
-13 (yeas:8 nays:21)
Requiring permission for launching from a "Launch control team"
-14 (yeas:10 nays:24)
Two stage creation: Description Refinement, Name Crowner/Indexing/Examples
-18 (yeas:4 nays:22)
Create a "Trope brainstorming" place separate from YKTTW
-28 (yeas:3 nays:31)
Capping the number of YKTTWs
Total number: 36. Number shown: 36.

Total number of votes: 1112

yes But What Does Zataproximetacine DoYKTTW YKTTW Rigor
Image PickinPage Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/YKTTW?openall=yes