Page Action: The Dragon 2

The DragonThe Dragon 2 The Eternal Churchill
Page Action
Page Action: The Dragon 2
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
This is one of the Tropes Of Legend, with 13,901 wicks and 40,922 inbounds.
+18 (yeas:29 nays:11)

Option B

Make a Trope Transplant: move the genuine examples and the definition of "penultimate challenge for the hero" to a new trope that has a more intuitive name via Trope Launch Pad, and leave the examples of "the Big Bad's right-hand man" at The Dragon, along with a description change that makes clear its current meaning in this wiki. The Dragon would thus become a villainous Sub-Trope of Number Two.

Pros

  • It's the option that requires the least wick migration
  • The vast majority of TV Tropes already thinks The Dragon is the Big Bad's right-hand man

Cons

  • The Dragon is a pre-existing term; this would result in our having a trope named after a pre-existing term but meaning something different
  • The original term of the meaning "penultimate challenge for the hero" would be lost
-9 (yeas:9 nays:18)

Option A

Revise the definition for The Dragon to make it clear that it's NOT the Big Bad's right-hand man, move the examples of Number Two to that trope, and remove or replace the current image on The Dragon for being misleading.

Pros

Cons

The thread in Trope Repair Shop was mostly against this option due to the major cons.
-14 (yeas:4 nays:18)

Option C

Move the definition "The Hero's penultimate challenge'' to a new trope with an intuitive name via Trope Launch Pad, and move the examples of "the Big Bad's right-hand man" to Number Two.

Pros

  • "The penultimate challenge for the hero" would get a better name and the examples of Big Bad's right-hand man would be in the correct trope

Cons

Total number: 3. Number shown: 3.

Total number of votes: 89

The DragonThe Dragon 2 The Eternal Churchill
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/TheDragon2?openall=yes