Page Action: Nonstandard Game Over

Non Mammal MammariesNonstandard Game Over Noodle People
Page Action
Page Action: Nonstandard Game Over
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
What is the definition of a Nonstandard Game Over? The current article gets linked in two ways:

  • An unusual, context-sensitive method to trigger a Game Over screen (e.g. something other than loss of HP, lives, time, or NPC). Shmuck Bait would be a subtrope of this.
  • An unusual, context-sensitive screen that declares the Game Over, regardless of whether the method of achieving it was unusual. Have A Nice Death would be a subtrope of this.

The two meanings do overlap, as an unusual method for getting a Game Over often result in a context-sensitive Game Over screen (e.g. eating the Shmuck Bait results in Have A Nice Death).

Also of note that Nonstandard Game Over is typically only one or two context-specific Game Overs, while The Many Deaths Of You is in some ways The Same But More (every Game Over is context-specific); both in the ways of achieving one and the message/screen that results from it.
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+28 (yeas:34 nays:6)
Hard split A:
  • Redefine Non-Standard Game Over as any unusual method for achieving a Game Over (rename optional), regardless of whether or not it uses the game's "standard" Game Over Screen.
  • Move the current article text (presentation of unusual Game Over screens) to a new title.
  • Comb through and clean up the related wicks, making sure that examples of both are linked to both.

  • Game Over is already pre-existing jargon for the condition of having lost a game, while Non-Standard Game Over currently talks about the screen that declares it. The snowclone isn't consistent with its source.
  • Various samples of wicks imply that a majority of links discuss unusual methods for triggering a Gameover, moreso than the screen that results from the trigger. This may or may not strictly be misuse, but it doesn't match article as currently defined.
-2 (yeas:4 nays:6)

  • Create two new articles with new names: One for a non-standard loss condition, the other for a non-standard Game Over screen.
  • The Non-Standard Game Over article becomes a "no examples" Super Trope; all current examples get shuffled into the respective Sub-Trope as needed.

  • Since the two meanings overlap, wicks that ambiguously mention one meaning or the other aren't necessarily misuse.
-3 (yeas:8 nays:11)
Soft split:
  • Mention both definitions (defined at top) in the article, effectively expanding the article to both definitions.

  • The two definitions frequently overlap. Avoiding a hard split means we also avoid duplicating examples where an unusual method triggers an unusual Game Over screen.
  • Only minor cleanup to the article itself is required; no major review or cleanup of wicks is necessary.
-11 (yeas:3 nays:14)
Cleanup only (Hard split B):

  • Preserves the current article/definition.
Total number: 4. Number shown: 4.

Total number of votes: 86

Non Mammal MammariesNonstandard Game Over Noodle People
Page Action