Page Action: Necessary Drawback

Narrative Non Sequitur 2Necessary Drawback Needs More Love
Page Action
Page Action: Necessary Drawback
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
The specialized character tropes have problems evidenced by wick checks stretching back to over three years ago. The problem, it is always agreed, is a shifting definition.

What is misuse in one year is correct use the next, and often TRS threads are unresolved or end with a redefinition that does nothing to solve the issue. The mixed definitions have appeared in the definitions of other tropes, making it almost impossible to tell what any one trope should be defined as anymore. Everyone has their own opinions, of course.

The question that is always missing from crowners, however, is "How many specific tropes do we need?". So, the options below are listing NONE of the current trope names. Instead, we are voting on definitions we need to keep.
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+8 (yeas:9 nays:1)
Good in three areas, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed, Endurance, and Power
+4 (yeas:7 nays:3)
Good in one area, Bad in two areas, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Power (Good) Speed and Endurance (Bad)
  • Endurance (Good) Speed and Power (Bad)
  • Speed (Good) Endurance and Power (Bad)
+2 (yeas:5 nays:3)
Good in two areas, Bad in one area, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed and Endurance (Good) Power (Bad)
  • Speed and Power (Good) Endurance (Bad)
  • Endurance and Power (Good) Speed (Bad)
+1 (yeas:5 nays:4)
Good in one area, Bad in one area, lacking a definition in any other:
  • Speed (Good) Endurance (Bad)
  • Speed (Good) Power (Bad)
  • Endurance (Good) Power (Bad)
  • Endurance (Good) Speed (Bad)
  • Power (Good) Speed (Bad)
  • Power (Good) Endurance (Bad)
0 (yeas:4 nays:4)
Bad in three areas, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed, Endurance, and Power
-1 (yeas:3 nays:4)
Good in two areas, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed and Endurance
  • Speed and Power
  • Endurance and Power
-6 (yeas:1 nays:7)
Bad in two areas, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed and Endurance
  • Speed and Power
  • Endurance and Power
-8 (yeas:0 nays:8)
Good in one area, lacking a definition in any other area:
  • Speed
  • Endurance
  • Power
-8 (yeas:0 nays:8)
Bad in one area, lacking a definition in any other:
  • Speed
  • Endurance
  • Power
Total number: 9. Number shown: 9.

Total number of votes: 76

Narrative Non Sequitur 2Necessary Drawback Needs More Love
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/NecessaryDrawback?openall=yes