Page Action: Jack Of All Stats

Jack AttackJack Of All Stats Japan Takes Over The World
Page Action
Page Action: Jack Of All Stats
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
We have a number of issues being presented for the problems encountered by the broad use of "the trifecta" of speed, strength, and defense. In the current TRS thread, we have come up with some ideas for fixing some of the problems. Our last crowner determined that trope under Stone Wall must be renamed, due to the problems with the trope and interactions with other tropes.

Here are three options that the thread is in support of:

  • 21:6 (the option was contingent upon the four tropes getting redefined)
  • 15:9 the four specialty tropes redefined to one great, one poor attribute.
  • (negative) redefine Lightning Bruiser to great attributes, but comes with an additional flaw.
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+15 (yeas:21 nays:6)
Do we make two additional tropes to cover the missing +Attribute and -Attribute pairing? (This option is contingent on the redefinition of the four tropes)
+6 (yeas:15 nays:9)
Do we redefine the four established tropes (Stone Wall, Fragile Speedster, Glass Cannon, Mighty Glacier) to one good Attribute, and one bad Attribute?
-10 (yeas:5 nays:15)
Do we redefine Lightning Bruiser to having the three Attributes, but a flaw that prevents them from being above average in every respect?
Total number: 3. Number shown: 3.

Total number of votes: 71

Jack AttackJack Of All Stats Japan Takes Over The World
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/JackOfAllStats?openall=yes