Page Action: Imagechoicefor Puppies Are Precious

Iknow That GunImagechoicefor Puppies Are Precious Imagefor Anti Magic
Page Action
Page Action: Imagechoicefor Puppies Are Precious
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+8 (yeas:8 nays:0)
Andrex puppies

For:
  • Image from actual use in media rather than just a photo of cute puppies.
  • Illustrates the trope: Puppies introduced deliberately, specifically to increase the cuteness factor. What other reason is there to connect puppies with toilet paper?

Against:
  • none stated in discussion.
0 (yeas:2 nays:2)
Nose Biter

For:
  • Seriously cute picture of seriously precious puppies.
  • Comes with a caption "Puppies even make domestic abuse cute!"

Against:
  • Not really an illustration of the trope, which is not simply "puppies are cute" or "this work has puppies in it".
-4 (yeas:0 nays:4)
Keep the current page image

For: The puppy is cute.

Against:
  • The picture is blurry
  • The girl is the main focus of the picture, not the dog
  • The dog appears to trying to get away from her
  • The trope isn't simply "This work has a puppy in it"; it's "Puppies were deliberately added because of the cuteness factor."
-4 (yeas:1 nays:5)
Better picture of girl with puppy

For:
  • not blurry
  • more focus on the puppy
  • she's making a cute face to the puppy

Against:
  • seems more like a grown dog than a puppy
Total number: 4. Number shown: 4.

Total number of votes: 22

Iknow That GunImagechoicefor Puppies Are Precious Imagefor Anti Magic
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/ImagechoiceforPuppiesArePrecious?openall=yes