Page Action: Added Alliterative Appeal

A Day In The SlimelightAdded Alliterative Appeal Ad Nauseam
Page Action
Page Action: Added Alliterative Appeal
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
This article contains:
  • A discussion of alliteration as a trope.
  • A Just For Fun index of alliterative trope titles.
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+9 (yeas:15 nays:6)

Trope route

  • Added Alliterative Appeal becomes a trope about the use of alliteration in general (or at least in fiction).
  • The index of alliterative trope titles gets split elsewhere.

  • Pro: It's cited as a trope in a good share (est. 50%) of its wikilinks. It's also a popular target for troper-inserted alliterations.
  • Con: Tropability and example guidelines to be determined.
-3 (yeas:9 nays:12)

Take no action

  • Leave the page as-is, an index that is also a trope.
-10 (yeas:2 nays:12)

Index route

  • Added Alliterative Appeal becomes an index of alliterative trope titles.
  • Alliteration in general is split to a separate page.

  • Pro: ____________
  • Con: It's not an index of related trope concepts, but Just for Fun.
Total number: 3. Number shown: 3.

Total number of votes: 56

A Day In The SlimelightAdded Alliterative Appeal Ad Nauseam
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/AddedAlliterativeAppeal?openall=yes