Lack of internal consistency. In one review he decries the lack of innovation, in another he complains about mucking with what works. In his Brawl review he claims that fighting games require no skill, and (in the same review) if you play enough your superior skill will cause you to cream everyone else. He likes Silent Hill 2 and Prince of Persia because of their characterization and story, but in other cases states he wishes they would hurry up and get to the action in games. It's a "heads I win tails you lose" situation with his reviews.

Just because other people like the Wii but you don't doesn't mean that they are wrong and you are right. The constant Wii bashing is annoying and too Fan Hater :ish.

Dude, what is it with Yahtzee and Nintendo, anyway? You'd think Nintendo personally burned his house, stole his car and stepped on his blue suede shoes! Every time he reviews a Nintendo, all professialism seems to trickle off, while the pettyness levels crash through the roof and poke a hole on a cloud...

When you see, say, James Rolfe outside his Angry Video Game Nerd persona you can clearly see that the Nerd is just a character. There are little hints all over his videos that there isn't really a Yahtzee character or persona and Ben Croshaw really is the cynical, joyless prick he usually plays for laughs. It's unnerving.

Now that he's resting on his laurels as a web celebrity, Yahtzee's probably never going to go back to what he's much better at - writing excellent games.

His review of Super Smash Brothers Brawl's fans and fandom, which was advertised as a review for the game itself, followed by a video response that failed to make any point other than "You are wrong. Fuck off."

My biggest problem with ZP is that anything on the Wii is just automatically bad. at the end of his madworld review he blatantly states that his biggest problem is that it's on the wii. most of his wii reviews are just complaining about the wii in general and there's about 30 seconds in there for the actual game.

He seams to hate multi-player games, purely on his admitted lack of friends to play with.

Has the misogyny increased lately? It seems like every other review has some kind of take that aimed at women.