Biggest Complaint: How I Met Your Mother

HomestuckHow I Met Your Mother I Carly
Best EpisodeBiggest Complaint
Biggest Complaint: How I Met Your Mother
Here's the place to let the world know about something that doesn't work about this show, trope, or author. As the votes roll in, you'll be able to see if it is also a problem for other folks.
At issue:
+31 (yeas:42 nays:11)
Barney and Robin breaking up after just 7 episodes, for quite literally no reason at all. And, to add insult to injury, Barney wearing a cartoonish fat suit for their emotional break-up scene. It made a mockery of the relationship and pointlessly threw away something they'd been building towards for at least two seasons.
  • They said Robin and Barney were a bad idea for a couple since the start. This is why they started the plot at the end of season 3. But it is just silly of them to have a season long build-up and a few episodes of actual relationship and then having it end with nothing gained because... Barney is getting fat? Did they want to say he wouldnīt be funny anymore because his characters only trait is the objectification of women? Well, thatīs right but that reason should have been told straight forward and not cryptic.
+30 (yeas:52 nays:22)
Laugh. Track.
+16 (yeas:16 nays:0)
+15 (yeas:18 nays:3)
Don. 'Nuff said.
+9 (yeas:26 nays:17)
Lily, especially in seasons 5 and 6 turning into a Mary Sue who is always right about everything and everyone. Forget Mary Sue, woman's a Hypocrite, Karma Houdini, and Bitch in Sheep's Clothing at once.
+1 (yeas:8 nays:7)
The series is supposed to be about how Ted met The Mother...and yet Ted has become the most uninteresting character on the show and isn't featured as prominently as the other 4 main cast members.
+1 (yeas:6 nays:5)
Ted being uninteresting, condescending, and just being a protagonist that doesn't make you care as to whether or not he finds love.
-1 (yeas:8 nays:9)
Kal Penn. Please, PLEASE get him off this show.
-1 (yeas:3 nays:4)
Robin's huge change of character that was necessary to make it believable that she would date Barney given all that she knows about him.
-1 (yeas:0 nays:1)
I love Robin, don't get me wrong. As a character, she is funny, entertaining, and unique. However, some episodes have her written as a satellite character for Ted, and she just spontaneously disagrees with him or snaps at him for no good reason, sometimes to the point where she is completely stepping out of character.
-2 (yeas:3 nays:5)
Ted's passionate hate of New Jersey.
-2 (yeas:0 nays:2)
The Ship Tease in the early half of the show. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD WE KNOW ROBIN ISN'T THE MOTHER AND SHE AND TED ARE TOTALLY WRONG FOR EACH OTHER ANYWAY. Yet the show pushed it pretty forcibly (apparently for Ted's Character Development, but he could have found that in more interesting, less cliche ways) and keeps bringing it up every now and then as a plot point or just to prolong the season.
Total number: 19. Number shown: 12.

Total number of votes: 403

HomestuckHow I Met Your Mother I Carly
Best EpisodeBiggest Complaint