Line #30 WMG/Maskerade


1	{{WMG}}s for Literature/{{Discworld}} / Literature/{{Maskerade}}. Warning: Potential unmarked spoilers.
2
3	[[WMG: At the end of ''Maskerade'', Walter Plinge drove Agnes away from the Opera on purpose.]]
4	At the end of ''Maskerade'', the "new and improved" Walter Plinge seems to coldly reject the talented, smart, but fat and insecure Agnes Nitt in favor of the vapid, tone-deaf but beautiful and slender Christine because the latter has "star quality". While Plinge and his "Phantom" persona do seem to be different people, it always frustrated me to see the once-kindly Walter do that sort of thing. But [[FridgeBrilliance in retrospect]], it's possible that [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation maybe Walter was well aware,]] or at least realized after his "transformation", that Agnes wasn't really enjoying her life at the Opera, being the OnlySaneMan and therefore frequently confused and/or outraged by the behavior of her fellow performers. Therefore, it seems likely that Walter is discouraging Agnes because he knows that she'd be miserable in a DysfunctionJunction like the Ankh-Morpork Opera House. Sort of a platonic version of IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy.
5	* On the other hand, it's also true that the Ghost chose Christine over Agnes in the first place, on the grounds that "I can teach you to sing like her, but I cannot teach her to look like you" (but Christine swapped rooms with Agnes after she heard the voice, and Agnes did her best Christine impression to get the lessons). The Ghost, unlike Walter, really is a bit of a git. On the ''third'' hand, if the "new" Walter is an amalgamation of his two personalities, it's possible he had both motivations at once.
6	* Or, as in real life, Plinge knew a female artist would suffer for an unattractive appearance, and wanted Agnes out of harm's way before the men of Ankh-Morpork could go to town with their opinions of her.
7	* It could also be considered that Walter was something of a realist. He's right about Christine's looks compared to Agnes, and at least he has the decency to say it to her face, if not in so many words. Salzella, on the other hand, is friendly to Agnes' face and mocks her size behind her back incessantly. He could have been being CruelToBeKind and giving Agnes the push she needed to move on to a life where she'd be appreciated. Or, at least, not in the background all the time, with the credit for her work being given to another. Indeed, he might even have noticed that the witches had followed Agnes all the way from Lancre and drawn his own conclusions, being a perpetual background figure.
8	[[WMG: The late Mr. Plinge was the Opera House Phantom.]]
9	'''Spoilers''': He was the one to whom Mrs. Plinge referred by "he said he wanted ''someone'' to watch the opera" (emphasis Nigel Planer's, if it wasn;t in the hardcopy). This likely started back when the Opera House was comparatively new, likely around the time The Disk was built, and "singing-plays based on Dwarfish theater" would be even more of a risk of customer unavailability than the commoner plays. He always stayed in Box 8, even when the Opera House became popular amongst the rich of Ankh-Morpork. He wore the disguise so that the members of the Opera would feel better having a Mystery Patron than just the janitor watching them. [[spoiler: Once Walter was old enough to be away from his mum and keep quiet for a few hours, he brought him along, and started teaching him the words to the Opera. Walter sang along without thinking thanks to being an operatic virtuoso, and eventually, once Mr. Plinge died, sang to himself (hence why the music "came from the walls")]].
10
11	[[WMG: Mr. Pounder the ratcatcher was reincarnated as Darktan from ''Literature/TheAmazingMauriceAndHisEducatedRodents''.]]
12
13	Mr. Pounder's new rodent incarnation would've been born in Ankh-Morpork, close enough to the University to scavenge its refuse (thus aquiring intelligence and a longer lifespan) just a few years before the Educated Rodents met Maurice and left town. Darktan's exceptional talents for identifying and disarming traps are appropriate for someone who, in his previous life, had won the Golden Mallet for the most rats caught for five years running. Having killed so many rats as a human, yet always respected them as worthy opponents, it's only fair for him to spend his rodent life teaching inexperienced young Trap Disposal Squad members how to elude ratcatchers' devices. And by helping to foil the pair of ''corrupt'' ratcatchers in Bad Blintz, he not only avenged their abuses of ''keekees'' and Changelings, but he also got to punish them for being a disgrace to his former profession.
14
15	[[WMG: Walter was named after [[AlanSmithee the proverbial Walter Plinge]].]]
16	Since his parents (or at least father) had been such fans of the opera, that is, making the joke and the name a sort of ZigZaggingTrope.
17
18	[[WMG: Walter wrote the Disk's version of ''Literature/ThePhantomOfTheOpera'' out of remorse.]]
19	When Nanny Ogg found the original version, her description gave off a HerCodeNameWasMarySue vibe. But the Phantom in the novel and play, is, if anything, more messed up than Walter. This is probably because after Walter had gotten used to his new identity, he felt like a bastard for letting the best voice he'd ever heard get away from him. So he digs out that silly old SelfInsertFic and rewrites so that the dashing Ghost is a mentally unstable WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds and the most significant beauty of the heroine is her incredible voice.
20	* That's adorable. I'm totally keeping this one as personal canon.
21
22	[[WMG: Christine is actually a WrongGenreSavvy BitchInSheepsClothing.]]
23	Agnes notes at one point that Christine is "remarkably clever in some specialized ways", and Christine is awfully short with Agnes after she blurts out her suspicions that Walter Plinge is the Phantom. So, what if she's just [[ObfuscatingStupidity not as dumb as she lets on]]? In Christine's case, she [[GenreSavvy knows she's in a story]] like that of ''Literature/ThePhantomOfTheOpera'', but like Malicia from ''Literature/TheAmazingMauriceAndHisEducatedRodents'' she thinks she's the main character. All those times she was "accidentally" insulting Agnes and [[YankTheDogsChain yanking the dogs' chain]]? All an act to mess with Agnes, of whose talent she's jealous, in yet another reversal of Christine and Carlotta from ''Phantom of the Opera''!
24
25	As for the whole "can't sing a note" thing, she either [[GiftedlyBad has an exaggerated opinion of her ability to sing]], or is just ''pretending'' to be dreadful so she can "miraculously" become a great singer (once she's frustrated her more musically gifted rival Agnes into quitting the opera, that is); it's been noted in other Discworld books that sometimes you have to be really good to appear to be really bad. This also means she was pretending not to notice that Agnes was "ghosting" her during the opera.
26
27	It could be that TP was also alluding to one Narcissa Florence Foster Jenkins, a truly extraordinary opera singer, who was blissfully unaware her singing voice was that of an out-of-tune strangled cat but who used inherited money and a forceful personality to self-promote her performances. The USA fell in with the joke and treated the homely-looking Florence, at least to her face, as a star diva and her performances were usually sell-outs. Christine is perhaps a Florence Foster Jenkins blessed with star quality and captivating beauty: because she looked the part and had Agnes to provide a voice, the illusion carried itself off sucessfully.
28
29	As for why she hid from the voice of the Phantom behind the mirror, she just didn't want to get involved in any dangerously tragic romances with a deformed stranger, which is what she assumed would happen if she got involved with the Phantom because, again, she's WrongGenreSavvy. Though this makes it look like Christine is throwing Agnes to the metaphorical wolves by letting ''her'' get involved with the Phantom instead...
30
31	[[WMG: Christine has [[Literature/LordsAndLadies elvish blood in her]].]]
32	She's beautiful, and seems to capture the love and attention of everyone around her except Agnes, who ends up jealous of her good looks and annoyed with her self-centered vapidity; since Agnes is a witch, albeit a reluctant one, she's resistant to Christine's low-level glamour. And much like the Fair Folk, Christine has no musical talent whatsoever.
33	* Discworld elves can ''sing'' well; it's ''playing'' music that they suck at.
34	* Actually, what they do is described more fully in ''The Science of the Discworld''- their singing is not exactly music as humans would recognise it, but a hypnotic ultrasonic call. YMMV whether this describes the sound Christine produces or not!
35	* In ''Lords and Ladies,'' Granny Weatherwax does point out that half-elves (or their descendents) tend to giggle a lot and burn easily in sunshine. Doesn't Christine giggle all the tiem?
36	* Note that the one ''other'' [[Literature/SoulMusic Discworld character we know of]] who "looks elvish" was a ''very'' good singer.
37
38	[[WMG: Greebo's ability to switch from cat to human form has some unmentioned consequences]]
39	As a big horny tomcat, Greebo has certainly fathered a good number of kittens throughout Lancre. What if his offspring inherits his unconscious shapeshifting ability? The Ramtops might well have a burgeoning tribe of feline shapeshifters in the space of a few cat-generations.
40
41	[[WMG: The opera about [[Theatre/LesMiserables a guy named Les who is really miserable]] is set during [[Literature/NightWatchDiscworld the Ankh-Morpork Civil War]]]]
42	But it played around with history by having the unstoppable policeman being the villain and the fugitive from justice being the good guy.
43	----
44

Context WMG / Maskerade