Line #32 Main/TheLivingDead


1	->''"No one in the movies or on television has ever looked convincingly dead, a condition much harder to fake than an orgasm."''
2	-->-- '''Creator/RogerEbert''', ''Ebert's Bigger Little Movie Glossary''
3
4	There are two ways to simulate corpses on TV — get a good dummy or model, or use a live actor.
5
6	The problem with using a live actor is that they're a live actor. Live actors need to breathe. Either they hold their breath, the camera doesn't let you see their chest, or you get this — when you see a corpse visibly breathe on camera. Having the corpse [[CarpetRolledCorpse concealed from view]] immediately after death can often help prevent this.
7
8	Modern special effects have introduced another option, of course; for that reason, this trope rarely appears in more recent movies (big-budget ones, anyway), which tend to have larger budgets and therefore can afford the special effects and editing to ensure that dead characters appear properly dead.
9
10	Related to {{Corpsing}}, which is when an actor breaks into a fit of unscripted (and almost always inappropriate) laughter during a take, whether or not said actor is supposed to be playing dead. The worst time to get a case of the giggles, of course, is when you're playing a corpse, and thus the term stuck.
11
12	Compare PlayingATree for a similarly thankless role.
13
14	See EyeAwaken, RaisedHandOfSurvival, or FingerTwitchingRevival for when the ''character'''s supposed corpse moves to reveal they're [[NotQuiteDead not as dead as previously thought]].
15
16	For the other kind of "living dead", see TheUndead, TropesOfTheLivingDead, or Film/LivingDeadSeries.
17
18	----
19	!!Examples:
20
21	[[foldercontrol]]
22
23	[[folder:In-Universe]]
24	* In ''Series/ThirtyRock'', Jenna Maroney is cast as a corpse in a police procedural, but being a self-obsessed LargeHam goes off book and ad libs being NotQuiteDead, to the point of trying to set up a spinoff for her nameless victim character.
25	* ''Film/{{Center Stage\|1991}}'': Stanley Kwan calls for a second take because Creator/MaggieCheung, playing the corpse of Ryan Lingyu for a scene where they're filming Lingyu's memorial service, took a breath.
26	* In an episode of ''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'', Peter [[CutawayGag reminisces]] about the time he played a corpse on ''Series/LawAndOrder'', "until I got that itch in my crotch."
27	* In ''Series/{{Friends}}'', Joey has done this three times. The first time was when he was hired to play a dying man in a film starring Creator/JeanClaudeVanDamme. After several ruined takes, the script was simply altered to that the guy was dead instead. The second time occurred when Joey was on ''Series/LawAndOrder'' as a murder victim, but the scenes where he was shown alive were cut, so all we see is his body covered with a white sheet being carted out on a gurney. Finally, when he was rehired by ''Series/DaysOfOurLives'' where his character was still in a coma several years after falling down an elevator shaft. It's lampshaded by Susan Sarandon's character who exclaims "That was ''a person''?!".
28	* In ''Film/ItsAVeryMerryMuppetChristmasMovie'', Miss Piggy can't be part of the Muppet Theatre's Christmas show because she has a very important guest role in ''Series/{{Scrubs}}''. She turns out to be a dead patient under a sheet but keeps trying to force in a miraculous recovery, to the annoyance of the ''Scrubs'' cast.
29	* In Creator/MaryRenault's ''The Mask of Apollo'', the narrator Nikeratos tells of his first real acting role at the age of about seven: Astyanax, son of Hector, in Creator/{{Euripides}}'s ''Theatre/TheTrojanWomen''. Near the end of the play he is brought onstage as a corpse, and only has to lie still ... except that at the performance, he is so affected by the speech of the actor playing Hecuba that he has to struggle mightily not to burst into audible weeping.
30	-->'''Kroisos/Hecuba (in an undertone):''' Be quiet, you little bastard, you're dead!
31	* Parodied in a ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' sketch, which had a corpse under a white sheet fart loudly and visibly. This one may be a parody, but it's also TruthInTelevision: bodies can still exhale methane after death. And yes, that includes through farting.
32	* Parodied in the WebVideo/{{Smosh}} video ''If Scary Movies were Real''.
33	-->'''Ian (in a ''Franchise/{{Saw}}'' torture chamber):''' Why is that dead body breathing?\
34	'''Body (punches the floor):''' DAMMIT!
35	* In one episode of ''ComicBook/DeRodeRidder'', Johan sees through the ruse of a mook PlayingPossum by noticing the guy is breathing.
36	-->'''Johan''': Nice try, but those who want to play dead should not be drawing breath.
37	* In its comedic spin-off [[VideoGame/CorpseParty Corpse Party 2U,]] Yoshiki Kishinuma is given the role of a murder victim for a play, and has the choice between playing dead til the end or ad libbing, revealing himself to having faked his death as a ploy to catch the culprit, in order to impress his crush, Ayumi Shinozaki. The latter results in a Wrong End, as she becomes upset at him for ruining the play.
38	* In the ''Manga/MyHeroAcademia'' Special Episode [[Recap/MyHeroAcademiaS3E20SpecialEpisodeSaveTheWorldWithLove "Save the World with Love!"]], All Might plays a dead villain in one of the students' training exercises. Tsuyu tickles his nose with her hair and he stifles a laugh, confirming to her and her classmates that he was alive but supposed to be pretending to be dead. However, [[spoiler:in the end it turns out that All Might was actually pretending to be a living person pretending to be dead. He runs away while the students aren't looking and their teacher, Aizawa, docks points for not noticing that the "villain" was actually alive, even pointing out that All Might gave them a hint when he laughed after Tsuyu tickled his nose. In other words, they mistook his corpsing for bad acting when it was actually meant to be a hint!]]
39	* Alluded to in ''Series/WillAndGrace'' when Jack tried out for a small part on ''Series/SixFeetUnder'':
40	** '''Jack:''' The casting assistant was gorgeous, and as convincing as my performance was for "Male Corpse on Slab", [[RagingStiffie there was one part of me that refused to play dead]].\
41	'''Karen:''' I see. So you would have only been five and a half feet under.
42	[[/folder]]
43
44	[[folder:Real Life]]
45	* Two cases in ''Literature/DalzielAndPascoe'' — one involving a woman who had been dead for over a decade (she'd been embalmed).
46	* In the premiere episode (not the ''Film/{{Casino Royale\|1954}}'' one, as often reported) of ''Climax!'', an anthology of dramatic adaptations performed live, the corpse actually got up and walked away, unaware that the cameras were rolling. See [[http://www.snopes.com/radiotv/tv/deadman.asp this]] ''Website/{{Snopes}}'' link.
47	* On ''TV's Bloopers and Practical Jokes'', a prank involving a visit to a funeral home was foiled when the casketed corpse at the center of the joke couldn't hide his breathing. The fact that a prepared corpse in a funeral home looks nothing like a live person was evidently lost on the proprietors of that joke.
48	* ''Series/DoctorWho'' has had many examples, especially in the Classic series where a combination of NoBudget preventing edits, actors who didn't care and a really high body count often metastises into this. Happens a lot less often in the revival:
49	** Averted in "The Wheel in Space" when Jamie and the Doctor find Gemma's corpse, by cutting still photographs into the frame as closeups. (This also meant the actress didn't have to return to film her role in this episode.)
50	** "Spearhead From Space":
51	*** There is a corpse on display as a waxwork (while the [[ReplicantSnatching waxwork replaces him and works for the Autons]]). The actor does a very good job of holding his breath, but can't resist subtly wobbling on his feet as he maintains his balance.
52	*** When Liz is walking through the hall of famous dummies, a female waxwork in the background blinks.
53	*** A later scene shows Autons mowing down civilians at a bus stop, many of which are visibly moving and twitching an amount that's amazing they got away with.
54	** "The Ark in Space" has people in cryogenic suspension kept in vacuum formed shells around the set. Some can be seen moving in certain scenes.
55	** This trope luckily saved the life of long-running Third and Fourth Doctor companion Benton. Due to the fact that the production team didn't know at the time that "The Android Invasion" would be his last appearance, his [[OffscreenInertia last scene]] ended up being his assault by the androids - for the rest of the story we only see his robot duplicate and [[WhateverHappenedToTheMouse Benton's fate is unknown]]. Fortunately, Creator/JohnLevene's eyeballs can be seen moving about under his lids, meaning at least we know he wasn't killed. The production subtitles on the DVD even point this out.
56	** The Sixth Doctor is supposed to appear to be dead at the midpoint cliffhanger of "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS22E2VengeanceOnVaros Vengeance On Varos]]" during the recording of a government-sponsored SnuffFilm, but Colin Baker is still subtly breathing. Since this ruins the cliffhanger if you notice it, it's most likely this trope rather than an intentional hint he's [[PlotImmunity not really dead]].
57	** Not breathing, but equally revealing; in the episode 'The Unquiet Dead', a character opens a coffin and the corpse's eyes twitch noticeably. But to be fair, "The Unquiet Dead" is ''about'' dead bodies turning into re-animated zombies when they are taken over by the Gelth.
58	* In ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'' Michael Culver (Captain Needa) can be seen moving when his "corpse" is picked up by two troopers after Vader force-chokes him.
59	* In ''Film/FinalDestination3'', Wendy has a premonition of the train she is on derailing and exploding, killing everyone on board, with her trying in vain to prevent the premonition from coming true, and ends up lying on the tracks bleeding out next to many "dead" passengers, whose chests are still visibly moving.
60	* One outtake of ''Series/TheXFiles'' had Scully declaring that a man was dead... just as he sneezed loudly. She continues to deadpan, "He's dead Mulder. He's dead and he's not coming back," as the rest of the production crew cracks up.
61	* Narrowly averted in Hitchcock's ''Film/{{Psycho}}'', in which Janet Leigh could be seen swallowing while her character was meant to be dead. Hitchcock's wife Alma caught the error during screening and Hitchcock corrected it prior to the film's release, replacing the shot with a still image so that there was no possibility of his "dead" actress moving.
62	* In ''Film/MommieDearest'', Creator/JoanCrawford (Creator/FayeDunaway) can be seen breathing while lying in her casket. Her eyelid also twitches when her daughter Christina touches her face.
63	* [[LongRunner Long-running]] Dutch PoliceProcedural ''Series/{{Baantjer}}'' had actors hired to play dead bodies and actual Dutch celebs would feature as stiff of the week.
64	* ''Series/{{CSI}}'' used both dummies and living actors to play their corpses, and almost invariably during the scenes in which one of the investigators consulted the coroners, the "corpse" could be seen breathing if you kept an eye out for it. In one episode, the corpse even opened its eyes... then quickly closed them again.
65	* Seen in ''Film/SantaSangre'' with the corpse of the Tattooed Woman, who's been stabbed absolutely full of holes but whose stomach is still very obviously moving with breath when Alma finds her.
66	* Brazilian play ''Duas Mulheres e um Cadáver'' (Two Women and a Corpse) revolves around the wife and the lover of a murdered psychoanalyst meeting at his office after the death. In the original production, not only was the corpse a big man, (abusing the actress who had to carry the actor all around) but his eyes remained [[DiesWideOpen open.]] The actor had to teach himself not to blink to be more convincing.
67	* Creator/UweBoll's [[Film/AloneInTheDark2005 adaptation]] of ''VideoGame/AloneInTheDark'' has a character get killed, and as the heroes were leaving her body the actress starts getting up a split second too early.
68	* In ''Film/ThorTheDarkWorld'', as [[spoiler: Thor cradles Frigga's body after she was slain by Algrim]], you can see [[spoiler: her breathing (accentuated by her belt pouches moving up and down)]].
69	* In ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'', the actors who play Sam and Dean also act as their corpses. This is especially noticeable in the season 2 finale, "All Hell Breaks Loose pt. II". If you pay attention to Sam's body, you can see his chest rising and falling slightly. According to their actors, Jared had to struggle to not cry while Dean was delivering his monologue.
70	* ''Series/MechX4'': In "Let's Get Some Air", the reveal that the team makes it out alive thanks to the oxygen coming back online in time is spoiled by paying close attention to Mark before the reveal. His actor is noticeably breathing.
71	* In ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'', after Marcus Aurelius has died and Lucilla greets Commodus as new emperor, with the dead body in the foreground, Richard Harris is visibly breathing.
72	* In ''VideoGame/MassEffect3'', after [[spoiler: Thane Krios]] succumbs to his wounds, he visibly keeps breathing and blinking, even after Shepard [[DiesWideOpen closes his eyes]]. Seen [[https://youtu.be/mDbWOz8ReI4?t=388 here]].
73	* ''Series/BlueBloods'': "In & Out", a shooting victim noticeably readjusts his arm position during an overhead shot of the crime scene.
74	* ''Series/{{Angel}}''. In "Harm's Way", the eyelids of a corpse on Fred's autopsy table give a noticeable twitch. Then again, he ''had'' [[RiseFromYourGrave been bitten by a vampire...]]
75	* In the HD version of ''Film/ManosTheHandsOfFate'', one of the Master's comatose wives can be seen smirking at Torgo's antics.
76	* Strikingly {{averted}} in ''Film/TheAutopsyOfJaneDoe'': model Olwen Kelly plays Jane's corpse very convincingly, completely nude at that, and is never seen breathing or flinching. She practiced yoga and meditation to control her movements. Then again, [[spoiler:it's hinted that Jane may not exactly be dead]].
77	* Extreme example in ''Film/TheLordOfTheRingsTheFellowshipOfTheRing'' where after the final battle one of the supposedly dead Uruk-Hai actually ''starts to get up off the ground'' before the camera cuts away.
78	* Former Florida Governor and Senator Bob Graham was known for a practice of taking one day a month and doing random jobs such as, for example, plucking chickens. Where this fits is the fact that, during Creator/{{NBC}}'s 1978 midterm election coverage when Graham, then a state legislator, was first elected Governor it's mentioned in passing that Graham at one point played a corpse during a college play.
79	* In ''Theatre/TooManyCooks'', Micky is scripted to get up at the end of the first act before the lights go down, which seems like a case of this trope. However, this happens because he isn't actually dead.
80	* In one episode of ''Series/DiagnosisMurder'', a hospital nurse is murdered during a practice drill for a major disaster. One can clearly see the victim's necklace rise and fall with her breathing.
81
82	[[/folder]]

Context Main / TheLivingDead