Line #26 Main/NeverGiveTheCaptainAStraightAnswer


1	[[quoteright:350:[[Webcomic/{{Chainsawsuit}} https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/no_straight_answer.jpg]]]]
2
3	->''"I don't like when they encounter something amazing in Engineering or wherever and call up to the bridge and say 'Captain, you'd better get down here.' Explain what it is! THAT IS WHAT PEOPLE DO. I don't call up my friends and say, 'Utahraptor, you'd better get down here.' and he says 'Why?' and I say 'Oh Utahraptor, if only we had descriptive language; if only I could describe something using my words. But you know as well as I that I can only point and say, lookit.'"''
4	-->-- '''T-Rex''' (on why [[PetPeeveTrope this trope]] bugs him), ''Webcomic/DinosaurComics'', [[http://www.qwantz.com/index.php?comic=1270 #1270]]
5
6	A giant bug-eyed monster has just appeared in the engine room, and is asking to borrow a cup of sugar. Someone on the bridge calls down and asks what's going on.
7
8	Now, if this were a real spaceship [[note]]okay, we don't actually have spaceships complex enough to have "bridges" or "captains" yet, but just bear with us here — and the point also applies just as well to the mundane sea-bound ships we ''do'' have[[/note]], your duty would be to give a short, concise description of the problem. To do otherwise would be irresponsible to the point of criminality.
9
10	But this is TV, and we need TheCaptain in this scene. That is why you Never Give the Captain a Straight Answer. Instead, you say something like, "You'd better come see for yourself," or the ubiquitous "Sir, I think you'd better (come) see/take a look at this...", giving the character a reason to enter the scene, with the added bonus of allowing a surprised reaction to the crisis when he arrives.
11
12	Occasionally, [[JustifiedTrope some rationale]] is offered. Perhaps the person who encountered the weirdness is simply too stunned to explain what's going on. Another possibility is that the situation is too sensitive to discuss over a possibly insecure line of communication. Or perhaps the person who encountered the weirdness doesn't ''know'' what's going on, and is calling someone who might be able to figure it out. May also be a case of YouWouldntBelieveMeIfIToldYou. And there are cases where every second matters and it would be a huge waste of precious time to explain something that the person in charge can see for themselves.
13
14	Of course, there's the option of you giving out a description, then the Captain responds "What!? I'm coming down there to see for myself!"
15
16	Variation crops up in most SpaceOpera. Though less common in other genres, it still occasionally shows up as a way to perform the RoomShuffle in response to an unexpected guest or sudden crisis (Often phrased as, "There's {{no time to explain}}, just get here right away!"), or to hold off TheReveal until the moment of maximum [[RuleofDrama drama]]. Can lead to some FridgeLogic that if this ship is the WeirdnessMagnet that it has a reputation for being, why isn't there any training to reflect that?
17
18	Compare FigureItOutYourself. Contrast SealedOrders, when sensitive orders aren't relayed until the last moment to prevent intel leaks.
19	----
20	!!Examples:
21	[[foldercontrol]]
22
23	[[folder:Anime & Manga]]
24	* A too-flustered-to-explain variant occurs in the first season of ''Anime/StrikeWitches'', with Lynette unable to explain to Mio that Yoshika is fondling Shirley. For the most part, though, the show avoids this.
25	[[/folder]]
26
27	[[folder:Comic Books]]
28	* {{Justified\|Trope}} in the 2008 ''ComicStrip/DanDare'' miniseries, as Sergeant-major Wallis doesn't want to announce to the already rather shaken civilians present that a horde of monsters is coming their way.
29	* In ''ComicBook/ExMachina'', Mayor Hundred's chief of staff drags him to the Brooklyn Museum of Art to look at a painting of Abe Lincoln with the word "nigger" across his face, claiming he needed to see it for himself.
30	* ''ComicBook/WonderWoman'' [[ComicBook/WonderWoman1942 Vol 1]]: For whatever reason the communications officer felt the need to call Suprema and every other officer out of the room to hear the broadcast that explained why their earth prisoners were really there and how the Green Geni had broadcast a lying call to help to earth that painted the space police as the villains. By the time they return to the room to apologize and explain the misunderstanding Diana and the Holliday Girls had escaped and gone to the Geni.
31	[[/folder]]
32
33	[[folder:Films -- Animated]]
34	* ''WesternAnimation/HowToTrainYourDragon2'': When Stoick tries to drag Hiccup out of the dragon sanctuary, Gobber, after learning that Valka is alive, just tells Stoick, "You might want to take this one... hooboy..."
35	[[/folder]]
36
37	[[folder:Films -- Live-Action]]
38	* In ''Film/{{Alien}}'', Science Officer Ash does this to Captain Dallas twice. [[spoiler:Possibly justified by Ash having no interest in being helpful.]]
39	** The first time occurs after the alien FaceHugger releases itself from Kane's face and disappears.
40	--->'''Ash:''' I think you should have a look at Kane. Something's happened.\
41	'''Dallas:''' Serious?\
42	'''Ash:''' [[AdmiringTheAbomination Interesting]].
43	** The second is when Kane wakes up. The novelisation has Dallas envisioning all kinds of horrible scenarios as he rushes to Medical, only to find Kane awake and alive, so it wasn't very nice of Ash to do this.
44	--->'''Ash:''' Dallas, I think you should see Kane.\
45	'''Dallas:''' Has his condition changed?\
46	'''Ash:''' It's simpler if you come.
47	** In the novelisation, Dallas assures himself on the first occasion that Ash would have said something different if Kane was dead. On the second, poor Dallas is tormented by nightmarish images of what might have happened to Kane while rushing to the sickbay.
48	* Almost every time the ''Sea Tiger'''s intercom rings in ''Film/OperationPetticoat'', chances are good [[Creator/CaryGrant Lt. Cmdr. Sherman]] will have to deal with this sort of call. One sequence revolves around about half a dozen of them happening in a row, chasing him from one end of his sub to the other and back.
49	* One of the most famous examples actually zig-zags the trope, in ''Film/StarTrekIITheWrathOfKhan''. Without Kirk's knowledge, [[spoiler:Spock]] goes down to Engineering and takes a lethal dose of radiation while saving the ship. Kirk calls down to Engineering.
50	-->'''Kirk:''' Engine Room? Well done, Scotty.\
51	'''[=McCoy=]:''' Jim! I think you'd better get down here.\
52	'''Kirk:''' Bones?\
53	'''[=McCoy=]:''' Better... hurry.
54	** Given that it was the ship's ''doctor'' and not the engineer who answered, and given the very personal nature of the situation, discretion was called for and the trope is justified. Then again, it's still played straight to the hilt: we did just pull the captain off the bridge in a crisis situation, ostensibly with no explanation, after all.
55	** As [=McCoy=] says that last line, Kirk turns to look at [[spoiler:Spock at the science station]], but only sees an empty chair. That, combined with the tone of [=McCoy's=] voice, tells Kirk ''exactly'' what he needs to know, and he immediately charges through the ship to get to Engineering.
56	** And perhaps the most important detail to take into account, Spock had knocked [=McCoy=] out with the Vulcan Neck Pinch. He was likely still groggy when he contacted Kirk and too disoriented to articulate what happened.
57	** Not to mention, this is incredibly emotional for him too. It's entirely plausible that he simply can't bring himself to say the words.
58	* ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness'' also has this. In fact, [[spoiler:it's the exact same setup as ''Wrath of Khan'', down to the lines -- only Kirk is the one dying, Spock is the one being called down, and Scotty is the one doing the calling]].
59	* In ''Film/{{Interstellar}}'', Cooper's father-in-law gives Cooper a call on CB, refusing to explain the situation on his end but instead requests him to come down to the farm and see for himself. Cooper does and sees the harvesting machines acting up, which could have been explained on the CB already. However, Coop is literally the only person on the farm with the technical know-how to actually maintain and fix said machines, so perhaps his dad thought it would be better if he just came in person.
60	* ''Film/{{Predator}}'': PlayedForDrama. Hawkins is the first member of Dutch's team to be taken by the alien, but all Poncho can find is a pile of internal organs rotting on the ground. When he returns to report, Poncho can barely comprehend what he has seen.
61	-->'''Poncho:''' Major...you'd better take a look at this...
62	-->'''Dutch:''' Did you find Hawkins?
63	-->'''Poncho:''' I...I can't tell.
64	-->''(ReactionShot from Dutch)''
65	* In ''Film/{{Predestination}}'', when the Barkeeper offers John to [[TimePolice try his real job]], the latter asks what his job was but the Barkeeper refuses to explain right out, given that John is hardly going to believe him unless shown firsthand.
66	-->'''John:''' What is it?\
67	'''Barkeeper:''' I'll show you. ''[moving towards the backdoor]''\
68	'''John:''' No. Fuck that, no. [[DefiedTrope Stop playing games. Just tell me right now.]]
69	* ''Film/TheMask''. Dorian Tyrell sends his minions to rob a bank. Later on, one of them shows up unexpectedly and is somewhat unresponsive to Tyrell's question. It turns out that another minion is upstairs dying from gunshot wounds.
70	-->'''Tyrell''': Why are you here?
71	-->'''Minion''': There's trouble. You better come upstairs.[[note]]Okay, so in real life criminals ''are'' known for their habit of [[SpySpeak avoiding clarity in communications in case there's someone listening in]], but in this case the evidence linking Dorian to the bank robbery is currently ''bleeding to death in his office'', so there's zero plausible deniability and zero reason not to tell him the facts except for this trope.[[/note]]
72	* ''Film/MarginCall'', Sam gets a call from Will close to midnight to return to the office and Sam offers the logical alternative to have the mysterious problem emailed to his phone. Will replies "I don't think that would be a good idea." This is enough to get him to turn around. Later, Sam's boss Jared leaves the room and makes a call to the CEO at 2am that lasts barely a minute and gets him to come back as well.
73	* ''Film/Sahara2005'': Al follows a stray soccer ball down the street and into a basement room. He runs out and tells Dirk he better come see what's in the room, which we don't see until Dirk does ... [[spoiler:the painting showing the wreck's location]].
74	* In ''Film/JurassicPark'', after seeing the live dinosaurs in the park, Grant asks Hammond how he did this and the only answer he gets is "I'll show you" and the scene cuts to them driving up to the lab.
75	[[/folder]]
76
77	[[folder:Literature]]
78	* Subverted in ''Literature/JonathanStrangeAndMrNorrell'', where the Greystones' servant says he has to show something to Drawlight. He says it can be seen from the edge of the canal... and then he kicks Drawlight into the canal.
79	* In ''Literature/ThePrincessBride'', Buttercup's parents do this to each other just to be jerks. "You look; you know how."
80	* Creator/DeanKoontz's ''Literature/{{Phantoms}}''. In one house Deputy Frank Autry finds a room with bullets (not complete cartridges, just the part that shoots out of the gun) all over the floor. He realizes that they're all of the bullets that have been fired at the mystery monster during the book. He calls his superior Sheriff Bryce Hammond on the radio.
81	-->'''Autry:''' Sheriff?\
82	'''Hammond:''' What is it, Frank?\
83	'''Autry:''' We're still here at the Sheffield house. I think you'd better come over. There's something you ought to see.\
84	'''Hammond:''' More bodies?\
85	'''Autry:''' No, sir. Uh, something sort of weird.\
86	'''Hammond:''' We'll be there.
87	* Inverted in the ''Literature/HoratioHornblower'' series. Hornblower doesn't give his ''crew'' a straight answer--he simply gives them whatever relevant orders re necessary to carry out his plans. He does this for two reasons; one so that success will be more impressive to them, and two because he's mortally afraid of talking about an idea only to have it not work -- a sort of self-imposed UnspokenPlanGuarantee, if you will.
88	* Within three pages, ''[[Literature/{{Temeraire}} His Majesty's Dragon]]'' has Royal Navy Captain William Lawrence being told "there is something queer in the hold" of the French ship his crew just captured. No hints concerning the new bulkhead or [[EggMcGuffin heavily secured crate beyond]] are given.
89	* ''Literature/WarJunkie'' by Creator/JonSteele. "Trust me, words cannot describe what is coming up the road." [[spoiler:In this case, an air-to-surface missile launcher from a helicopter gunship, mounted on the back of a goods truck.]]
90	* Happens in the first ''Literature/ArtemisFowl'', although justified in this case as both people are in the same room: Foaly tells Commander Root to come look at the screen instead of explaining that [[spoiler:Butler is putting on a suit of medieval armor in order to fight a troll.]]
91	[[/folder]]
92
93	[[folder:Live-Action TV]]
94	!!!'''In General:'''
95	* As pointed out later on in [[http://www.qwantz.com/archive/001270.html the comic quoted at the top of this page]], television news frequently follows the FilmAtEleven version of this trope, [[ViewersAreGoldfish so as to keep us hooked]].
96	* This seems to happen to Creator/StephenColbert offscreen. Experienced fans know that "We have some footage -- now, I have not seen this..." is the cue for an immediate fit of rage and/or tears when the clip actually rolls.
97	!!!'''Series:'''
98	* ''Series/AmericanGreed'' In "From Bouncer to Millionaire Fraudster" it is described as happening in real life as when the authorities search Cohen's house for evidence of his fraud, one of the agents tells his supervisor "she has to see this book". When she asks what it is (assuming he's found an incriminating ledger), he insists on her seeing it with her eyes without him describing it. It's a list of his targets for the killing spree he's planning.
99	* ''Series/BabylonFive'': It is ALWAYS "Captain, I think you need to see this" or "you'd better get down here". (They really need to work on adding some security to those links.) The station is ''five miles'' long, so the captain may have to travel a considerable distance to "see this." The lifts and core shuttle help speed up the trip, but they also break down or get sabotaged a lot, typically while the captain is trying to use them.
100	* Fairly JustForFun/{{egregious}} on ''Series/DoctorWho'':
101	** Invoked in ''[[Recap/DoctorWhoS12E1Robot Robot]]''. The Brigadier tries to explain to the Doctor what the situation is like before he leaves, but the Doctor refuses to have any of it for DramaQueen reasons:
102	--->'''Brigadier:''' The thing is, there's been another robbery–\
103	'''The Doctor:''' ''[heading out of the door]'' Tell me on the way, Brigadier, tell me on the way! ''[as if a stage school teacher]'' You must cultivate a sense of urgency!
104	** [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E12TheStolenEarth "The Stolen Earth"]]: Independently and in different countries, Sarah Jane Smith and Martha Jones desperately try to find out what's just happened to the ''entire planet'', only to have whoever's nearby insist that they have to see it for themselves. Sylvia Noble (Donna's mum) and the Torchwood team have similar reactions, but in their case the info is only hidden from the viewers.
105	** Subverted in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E4TheTimeOfAngels "The Time of Angels"]]. Christian and Bob request clarification when told to "Come and see" by a squadmate: "It's not a school trip. Just tell me." [[spoiler:It is, in fact, the Weeping Angel — using their companions' voices. They still come and see, despite being frustrated with their companions' vagueness, and it still kills them.]]
106	%%** It happens all the time on ''Series/{{Torchwood}}'', too.
107	* ''Series/{{Eureka}}'', pilot episode. "That's not all we've found — better come take a look."
108	* ''Series/TheFall2013'': A technician examining Spector's computer interrupts Gibson while she's watching one of the interrogations, telling her there's some videos on it that she'd better see.
109	* Shows up occasionally on ''Series/{{Firefly}}'', usually with Wash calling Mal up to the bridge.
110	* Apparently averted in the fifth season finale of ''Series/GameOfThrones'' when Olly comes to tell Jon that his uncle Benjen has returned to Castle Black. Subverted [[spoiler:when he follows Olly outside and learns, too late, that it's really just a ploy to set up his assassination]].
111	* A rather cruel example comes from the ''Series/InspectorMorse'' episode "In Service of All the Dead", when Morse and Lewis climb a bell tower. Morse is badly winded by the climb and clearly suffers from terrible vertigo (he can't bear to look up or down, or even move around). Lewis, by contrast, is skipping around happily when he sees a corpse far below and tells the elderly Morse that he'd best come see for himself.
112	* Shows up in ''Series/{{Lost}}''.
113	-->'''Jack:''' You wanna tell me where we're going, Sayid?\
114	'''Sayid:''' It's better that you see it for yourself.\
115	'''Jack:''' [[LampshadeHanging No, I'm not so sure it is]].
116	* ''Series/{{NCIS}}'':
117	** Abby has been known to continue this even while Gibbs is ''standing right in front of her''. Abby's excuse for wasting time explaining technical details of her forensics before getting to the useful information also explains this. She works alone in her lab most of the time, and even though [[IWorkAlone she doesn't want an assistant]], she still likes to have company.
118	** Ducky does it as well. Why simply tell Gibbs about the results of his autopsy when he could show him in gory detail?
119	** And [=McGee=] and his {{technobabble}}...
120	--->'''Tony:''' Oh, twenty bucks says [=McGee's=] about to say something nobody understands again.\
121	'''[=McGee=]:''' The GPS coordinates came bundled in a proprietary packet. Since it was a beta, I thought--\
122	'''Gibbs:''' I'm starting to think you can't help yourself, [=McGee=].
123	* A rare example from not only a non-genre series but a comedy, at that: In ''Series/TheOfficeUS'', Kevin calls Michael from a supermarket and tells him he'd better get over there and see... [[spoiler:what turns out to be a pregnant Jan]].
124	* In ''Series/TheOrville'', Talla calls Ed and Kelly to the science lab without explanation. Justified in that Talla needs to report vandalism ("Murderer" painted in red on a wall) directed at Isaac, who is facing angry crewmates demanding retribution for the Union's losses in defending Earth from the Kaylon. Talla's brevity is warranted; she doesn't know where the two are and wants to avoid starting conflict with any irate crew who happen to overhear.
125	* Inverted in ''Series/StargateSG1''. In "[[Recap/StargateSG1S7E1Fallen Fallen]]", SG-3 come across someone who appears to be one of the natives of Vis Uban, but turns out to be an amnesiac Daniel Jackson, [[spoiler:post-descension]]. The next scene involves SG-3 showing up and informing Jack O'Neill that "we found something you might want to see," but rather than making him go anywhere, it turns out that they actually brought Daniel along with them, so he immediately enters the scene. It's not even drawn out for [[TheReveal drama]]; the audience clearly sees that it's Daniel in the same instant that SG-3 recognize him initially.
126	** It's still pretty common for someone to call Sam's lab or Daniel's office to insist they report to the Gate Room immediately.
127	%%* On the ''Stargate'' bandwagon, ''Series/StargateAtlantis'' does this rather rampantly.
128	* ''Franchise/StarTrek'' in its various incarnations is far and away the most common user.
129	** Justified in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekS3E2TheEnterpriseIncident The Enterprise Incident]]", when Dr. [=McCoy=] calls Scotty (currently in command) to sick bay to let him in on a situation (that Kirk's supposed insanity and death were faked as part of a secret mission) that can't be discussed over an open intercom.
130	** In the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS1E22SkinOfEvil Skin of Evil]]", a monster made of sludge rises out of a pool of slime. When Commander Riker is ordered to report on the situation, all he can come up with is, "Trouble."
131	** The most egregious example has to be in "Hide and Q" when Picard asks Data, an android who generally can't stop ''oversharing'', to describe what happened on a planet. Data replies, "You may find it aesthetically displeasing, sir. I could put it in a report."
132	** ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'':
133	*** Major Kira, commanding the ''Defiant'', returns through the wormhole. On the station, Commander Sisko asks the major what she found. Kira, visibly terrified, says, "Trouble!"
134	*** Again in "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS06E21TheReckoning The Reckoning]]" when Odo calls Sisko to the promenade, saying that he'll "let [Sisko] be the judge" of whether or not what's going on is a problem. Somewhat {{justified\|Trope}} in that what's happening is that Kira's been [[DemonicPossession possessed by a Prophet]], and Sisko, who knows them best, really is the best judge on if it's a problem.
135	* ''Series/StrangerThings'': In "Chapter Two: The Weirdo on Maple Street", Police Chief Jim Hopper is called via radio to check out for himself [[spoiler:an apparent suicide at Benny's Diner.]][[note]]Though Benny was a personal friend of Jim's.[[/note]]
136	* In the ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' episode "[[Recap/SupernaturalS02E21AllHellBreaksLoosePartOne All Hell Breaks Loose, Part One]]", Ash insists Dean comes to the Roadhouse to find out what he has learned about the Yellow-Eyed Demon, but this may be {{justified\|Trope}} as he did not feel comfortable discussing his discovery over a phone line.
137	* Happens on an episode of ''Series/{{Vera}}'' when one of Vera's assistants finds blood in the barn near where the murder victim's car was found.
138	[[/folder]]
139
140	[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
141	* ''TabletopGame/StarFleetBattles''. ''Captain's Log'' magazine #47, short story "Into the Eagle's Nest". After a battle with the Romulans, Ensign Caldwell calls up the bridge from the shuttle bay. {{Justified}} because the Ensign was ordered by a superior officer to only tell the Captain what was going on face-to-face for security reasons.
142	-->'''Ensign Caldwell:''' You'd better get down to the shuttle bay as soon as you can. There's something you need to see here.\
143	'''Captain Lester:''' What is it, Ensign?\
144	'''Ensign Caldwell:''' Just come quickly! Please, Sir?
145	[[/folder]]
146
147	[[folder:Video Games]]
148	* Inverted in ''VideoGame/{{Crysis}}'', where it's the "captain" that calls the "crew", and a rationale is offered.
149	-->'''Prophet:''' Nomad. Get to the rendezvous ASAP. There's something here you need to see.\
150	'''[=Nomad=]:''' What have you got, Prophet?\
151	'''Prophet:''' Just get up here. You wouldn't believe me if I told you.
152	[[/folder]]
153
154	[[folder:Webcomics]]
155	%%* Parodied by this ''Webcomic/{{Chainsawsuit}}'' strip.
156	* Simultaneously {{invoked\| Trope}}, {{subverted\| Trope}}, and {{lampshade\| Hanging}}d in a ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'' [[http://www.schlockmercenary.com/2003-07-20 strip]]:
157	-->'''Tagon:''' That ''is'' suspicious.\
158	'''Ennesby:''' See how much time we could have saved if you'd taken my word for it the first time around?
159	[[/folder]]
160
161	[[folder:Web Original]]
162	* ''WebVideo/CinemaSins'' dubs this the "You better come take a look at this" cliché.
163	[[/folder]]
164
165	[[folder:Western Animation]]
166	* In one episode of ''WesternAnimation/BatmanBeyond'' Terry says he can't return to the cave immediately because something has come up. When Bruce asks what, he is told to look out the window as it is something he has to see for himself (in Terry's defence, it is [[spoiler:the BatSignal, so he probably thought Bruce would get a kick out of seeing it above Gotham again]]).
167	* Parodied in (what else?) ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'': In "Lemon of Troy", Nelson bursts into Mrs. Krabappel's class and says, "Everyone come quick! {{No time to explain}}!" All the children start to run across town, but have to stop when Nelson needs a drink of water. Someone asks if it wouldn't be faster just to tell them what happened, and he snaps, "No! I said there was no time to explain and I stand by that!"
168	* "Doc, you'd better come see this!" Doc Saturday of ''WesternAnimation/TheSecretSaturdays'' might have been more prepared for trouble had Drew yelled "Doc, a giant bird is attacking!" This is a case where even just yelling "Help!" would have been more effective.
169	* Justified in ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'' episode "Old Friends Not Forgotten". Yularen has Anakin and Obi-Wan fly ''all the way into orbit'' to receive the transmission instead of beaming it to them because it's their first contact with [[spoiler:Ahsoka since she left the Jedi Order]].
170	[[/folder]]

Context Main / NeverGiveTheCaptainAStraightAnswer