Line #37 Creator/BertoltBrecht


1	[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/f63a2a4a845274e783702c330c56cf25.jpg]]
2	[[caption-width-right:300:''"In me you behold a man upon whom absolutely you can't rely"'']]
3
4	-> ''"What keeps mankind alive?\
5	The fact that millions are daily stifled,\
6	tortured, punished, silenced and oppressed.\
7	Mankind can keep alive thanks to its brilliance\
8	-- by keeping its humanity repressed. \
9	For once, you must not try to shirk the facts:\
10	mankind is kept alive by bestial acts."''
11	-->-- '''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DSiD5CQ_Uk "What Keeps Mankind Alive"]]''', ''Theatre/TheThreepennyOpera''
12
13	Bertolt [[note]]He was born as Eugen Berthold Friedrich, but he adopted "Bertolt", or "Bert" for short, as the one name he actually used; he thought "Berthold" sounded too soft.[[/note]] Brecht (10 February 1898 – 14 August 1956) was a [[UsefulNotes/DichterAndDenker German poet, playwright, novelist and director]]. He was possibly the most influential force in early 20th century political art, with a strong focus on communism and anti-fascism -- and probably most famous for ''Theatre/TheThreepennyOpera''. He was a major figure in the art scene of the UsefulNotes/WeimarRepublic and post-war Germany. Like many German artists, he fled Germany during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. When he returned to communist [[UsefulNotes/EastGermany East]] UsefulNotes/{{Berlin}}, he was granted his own theatre, where the current ensemble still performs his plays daily.
14
15	Brecht was initially part of the post-World War I expressionist school, putting in dark and edgy plays like ''Baal'' about people on the margins of society complaining that life sucks and descending into nihilism and despair. These plays were often done in a naturalistic style with some stylization. Brecht's introduction to Marx however changed his attitude completely and he created a unique approach to 20th Century dramaturgy, one that was non-Aristotlian that is no longer bound by the rules laid down in ''Poetics'', that a tragedy didn't have to provide catharsis or release, and that audiences should not immediately identify with heroic figures against villains, and of course that rather than a cast of small people and a short time frame, there should be numerous characters and action that covered several days. Thus was born "Epic Theatre".
16
17	One of his most important principles is of course, ''Verfremdungseffekt'', or "effect of alienation". This was a method which discouraged immersion and escapism, and encouraged critical reception. This was often subject to {{Flanderization}} in pseudo-Brechtian productions but in Brecht's works alienation was against immersion and identification with characters but heightened immersion and attention to the social interactions, drama and context of character's choices and actions, this was part of the Marxist ideology of showing society, economics and politics at work in human relations. This made Brecht an early precursor to what we would call PostModernism, the use of such effects, most directly in BreakingTheFourthWall and talking to the audiences is often called in film classes as a 'Brechtian Device'. His stories were not meant as escapist fiction, but as scathing caricatures of what was wrong in society. For this reason, he developed certain tricks to prevent escapism: he encouraged his audiences to smoke while watching each play, discouraged method acting in his ensemble (he preferred using the classic, basic characters of the CommediaDellArte), used off-key instruments, and made his props out of flimsy cardboard.
18
19	Very few of his works have an explicit moral, in the conventional sense. His plays relied heavily on {{Applicability}}, on foregrounding the social/economic and political factors of the narrative, shifting away from identifying solely with the main character's victory or defeat. His characters typically don't learn a thing, and end up perpetuating social repression and/or dying miserably. If a moral is stated at all, it's usually blatantly wrong. This way, Brecht encouraged his audience to think about the conditions of their characters, to identify with their social and political positions which make his characters too trapped to merit catharsis. This way, the audience, in theory, could use his plays to make their own reality better than that of the characters, by learning what the characters either refuse to learn or are incapable of learning. Brecht's emphasis on epic theatre, heavy unrealism and his use of period settings rather than contemporary setting departed heavily from the emerging SocialistRealism aesthetic. Brecht felt that by using period and fantastic settings, audiences can get a broader perspective on the events and characters than one from contemporary life while Orthodox Marxists criticized Brecht for indulging in over-aestheticization. This is one reason why Brecht's works tended to have relatively little influence behind the iron curtain and has had far more influence in the West, which suited Brecht perfectly fine since he always felt his plays were for a pre-revolutionary audience.
20
21	Typical features of his work include proud prostitutes, dead sailors, corrupt businessmen on the verge of bankruptcy, headstrong young women who are ''too'' headstrong to actually become independent in society, hopeful young soldiers who keep themselves blind to the real horrors of war, and what has been described as a genre of "water corpse poetry" (''[[Music/PirateJenny Wasserleichenpoesie]]''). Considering himself a true communist, he stated that ''all'' art should belong to the people, to be constantly rewritten and re-interpreted as the political circumstances demanded. In practice, this meant that he refused to spend time even thinking about copyright, often drawing accusations of plagiarism. The reality of it was that he considered the circumstances in which a work of art was created more important than the source, and he actively encouraged others to adapt his works into new performances, without wanting credit for it. Ironically, after his death, Brecht's estate would be fierce in enforcing Brecht's copyright.
22
23	Brecht's very dry sense of humour isn't always apparent to casual observers, although it's all over his poetry and many of his plays. His most famous moment of [[DeadpanSnarker snark]] came from his criticism of the government of UsefulNotes/EastGermany, when in 1953 it put down demonstrations against poor living standards and "Sovietization" policies. The Secretary of the Writers' Union published a leaflet in which he stated that the people had forfeited the confidence of the government. Brecht wrote a poem in which he suggested "Would it not in that case / Be simpler for the government / To dissolve the people / And elect another?"
24
25	Brecht eventually passed away after suffering a heart attack in August 1956, at the age of 58.
26
27	He collaborated often with Creator/FritzLang, Music/KurtWeill, Walter Benjamin, Ernst Busch, Creator/PeterLorre, G. W. Pabst, and Creator/LotteLenya.
28
29	Brecht had a wide influence on various mediums of Theatre, Literature, Film and especially popular music. Several of the songs from his plays, and the style of his songwriting itself, has influenced many popular musicians. His songs with Weill have been frequently covered by the likes of Music/BobbyDarin, Music/FrankSinatra, Music/TheDoors, Music/DavidBowie, Music/AmandaPalmer, Music/MarianneFaithfull, Music/TomWaits and Music/NinaSimone, among many many others. His works have in turn influenced artists such as Music/BobDylan, Creator/DouglasSirk, Creator/JeanLucGodard, Creator/PierPaoloPasolini, Creator/RainerWernerFassbinder, Creator/AlanMoore and [[Film/{{Dogville}} Lars von Trier]].
30
31	Wrote a lot of plays.
32
33	!!Notable works include:
34	[[index]]
35	* ''Theatre/{{Baal}}'' (play, 1918)
36	* ''Theatre/TheThreepennyOpera'' (musical, 1928)
37	** "Music/PirateJenny" (a song used in the musical, 1924)
38	** ''Literature/TheThreepennyNovel'' (novel, 1934)
39	* ''Happy End'' (musical, 1930)
40	* ''Theatre/TheRiseAndFallOfTheCityOfMahagonny'' (opera, 1930)
41	* ''Saint Joan of the Stockyards'' (play, 1931)
42	* ''Theatre/TheSevenDeadlySins'' (ballet, 1933)
43	* ''Life of Galileo'' (play, 1937)
44	* ''Fear and Misery of the Third Reich'', a.k.a. ''The Private Life of the Master Race'' (play, 1938)
45	* ''Theatre/MotherCourageAndHerChildren'' (play, 1939)
46	* ''Me-Ti: The Book Of Changes'' (book, 1939)
47	* ''Theatre/MrPuntilaAndHisManMatti'' (play, 1940)
48	* ''Theatre/TheResistibleRiseOfArturoUi'' (play, 1941)
49	* ''Film/HangmenAlsoDie'' (1943, a film by Creator/FritzLang, Brecht wrote the screenplay).
50	* ''Theatre/TheGoodPersonOfSzechwan'' (play, 1943)
51	* ''Theatre/TheCaucasianChalkCircle'' (play, 1944)
52	* ''Stories Of Mr. Keuner'' (collection of short stories, first published 1948 with 39 stories, most recently published with 121 collected stories)
53	* Many, many poems. Brecht was a poet before he was a dramatist, and is widely regarded as one of the greatest poets of the 20th century, even by people who don't love his plays.
54	[[/index]]
55	----
56	!! Tropes frequently used in the work of Bertolt Brecht:
57
58	* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: [[invoked]]It is the fate of Brecht's plays that (at least, substantial parts of) audiences often see characters in a different way than Brecht intended them. Though this is mostly because most productions tend to tone down the harshness in the original. For example:
59	** Some think that [[Theatre/TheThreepennyOpera Mack the Knife]] is a LovableRogue. Brecht thought he was scum. Though this is partly because most productions and famous film adaptations downplay that Mack is an amoral pimp, human trafficker and child murderer, basing their image on the watered down Bobby Darrin song. Most audiences who see it closer to how Brecht wrote the character don't see him as a glamorous rogue at all but as a VillainProtagonist.
60	** Mother Courage to many is an ingenious, if unlucky character who doesn't give up in the face of adversity. To Brecht she was, though not without sympathetic qualities, ultimately a bad person.
61	** Some feel that [[Theatre/MrPuntilaAndHisManMatti Puntila]] is a JerkWithAHeartOfGold. To Brecht he was a JerkWithAHeartOfJerk.
62	** Brecht's ''Galileo'' controversially portrayed the famous scientist not as a martyr for science but as a cowardly sell-out who cares more about the posthumous fame of his contributions rather than the social changes he could have made by standing against the Church.
63	* AlternateShowInterpretation: Modern performances of his plays almost demand this trope, to keep the audience alienized, as Brecht wanted it. Common tactics include the use of words projected onto a screen (one of Brecht's favourite tactics), having the actors protest their stage directions, having the actors switch roles halfway through, using minimalist sets, and name-checking Brecht. One memorable Berlin performance of "St. Joan" (in the Deutsches Theater) started out with four actors fighting over who got to play which character, all reading from cheap paperback copies of the play. Once they finally all managed to get a private part in the play, they found themselves stuck in the middle of a tragic plot, and desperately tried to stop being these characters again (with varying levels of success). Meanwhile, the actors and a miniature cardboard cityscape were filmed on live and projected onto a screen, with the SFX crew clearly visible, and as the plot got more dramatic, the floor disappeared from under the actors, slowly forcing them back towards the screen. On which a counter was displayed showing how many people had died of poverty and hunger worldwide during the performance of the play alone. Oh, and? It didn't change or add a single word from Brecht's original script.
64	* BeigeProse: Actually, Beige Poetry; Brecht's early poetry tends to be lush, a bit surrealist and very sensual, but his mature poetry is very clear and direct in its language. Lampshaded in one of the last poems he ever wrote, where he characteristically questions whether or not that was effective:
65	-->And I always thought the very simplest words
66	-->Would be enough. If I say what is
67	-->Every heart will surely be lacerated.
68	-->That you'll go down, if you don't fight back.
69	-->Surely you see that.
70	* AsceticAesthetic: Brecht wanted his plays to be enjoyed intellectually, not sensually and therefore avoided lavish costumes, scenery and decorations, and everything else that would allow the audience to wallow in sensual pleasure. As protest against grandiose "bourgeois" theatre, Brecht's own productions strove for this trope instead, avoiding the pageantry and spectacle of his contemporaries. People who saw his own production of his plays, especially when he had his own theatre after World War Two, actually found that the costumes and scenery had their own austere beauty.
71	* BreakingTheFourthWall: Happened frequently in productions he staged, and is a standard in his own plays. Brecht disliked what he called "theatre of illusion", by which he meant theatre that took pains to be as naturalistic as possible, and accordingly took precautions to carefully shatter the illusion. This is probably the most influential thing about his work, given that it's now cinema, not theatre, which likes to present the illusion of reality.
72	* CapitalismIsBad: A major theme in all of his work, as he believed that art was best used to expose the flaws in capitalist society.
73	* {{Doorstopper}}: Any edition of his collected poems will run to well over 1000 pages. The 2018 Norton edition in English translation has 1286.
74	* ForegoneConclusion: Brecht wanted his audience to focus on how an outcome came about, not on what the outcome was. To achieve this, his plays routinely and deliberately give future events and outcomes away. Often there are spoken verses before the beginning of a new scene or episode that bluntly tell the audience what is going to happen. This was part of his self-imposed principle he called "epic theatre".
75	* HoldingOutForAHero: The main critique Brecht directed towards Aristoleian and conventional naturalist drama was the emphasis on special individuals whose tragedy invited audiences towards catharsis and thereby annul their own heroic initiative.
76	** Brecht frequently challenged and questioned audiences looking for heroes by emphasizing amoral, villainous and indifferent individuals as his protagonists or in his play ''Saint Joan of the Stockyards'' showing how a heroic modern day Joan of Arc figure is manipulated/exploited by capitalists.
77	** His play ''Galileo'' was an ironic {{Deconstruction}} of the Galileo case, informed by the horrors of the Atomic Age, with Galileo seen not as a persecuted scientist but a cowardly intellectual who refused to become a martyr out of self-interest and self-preservation.
78	--> '''Andrea''': ''"Unhappy is the land that breeds no hero."''
79	--> '''Galileo''': ''"No. Unhappy is the land that needs a hero."''
80	* ProductionPosse: Brecht was a highly collaborative artist, who worked in a highly collaborative fashion. This includes Music/KurtWeill and Hans Eisler, art director and designer Lion Feuchtwanger, actors Ernst Busch, Creator/PeterLorre, Carola Neher and Helene Weigel (who he later married). He also had "co-writers" Elisabeth Hauptmann, Margarethe Steffin and Ruth Berlau, who actually located source material of earlier dramas and made translations which he either modified or fully sampled. This has led some commentators to regard Brecht as a plagiarist who took credit for other people's work. Eric Bentley has however noted that this was part of the exigency of theatre production more than anything else. Some Brecht productions such as ''Happy End'' were largely authored by Hauptmann (though Brecht did ''write'' Surabaya Johnny, the famous song from the play).
81	* TheRevolutionWillNotBeCivilized: Brecht being a Marxist explored the concept of revolutionary violence in many of his plays.
82	** His most controversial was his Lehrstücke ("Teaching Plays"), one of which is ''The Measures Taken'', the plot consists of a Revolutionary cell executing one of their own when the latter becomes a liability. The victim himself realizes that his death is necessary for the greater good and accepts it with stoicism. This was so controversial that at his [=HUAC=] hearing, Brecht was interrogated specifically about it.
83	** His play ''Theatre/TheGoodPersonOfSzechwan'' has a protagonist Shen Te invent a violent alter ego Shui Ta to protect herself from exploitation and harm. Shen Te is normally pacifist and meek, Shui Ta is not. Shui Ta finally says, in typically pithy Brecht-style:
84	--> ''"You can only help one of your luckless brothers/By trampling down a dozen others."''
85	* SurvivorGuilt: Brecht spent most of his working life in exile from Nazi Germany, and quite a few of his friends and collaborators did not survive the war. As a result, this trope is a major theme in his poetry.
86	* TooBleakStoppedCaring: Invoked. Brecht used the bleakness of the setting to prevent the audience from attempting to indulge in escapism by investing emotionally in the characters, and encourage them to remain detached and examine the characters' actions and the motivations and pressures underlying them.
87	* TroublingUnchildlikeBehavior: The protagonist of the poem "Apfelböck or the lily of the field", an adolescent boy, kills his parents and shuts their bodies in a cupboard, then goes on living in the same house and explains away the smell of their decaying corpses as either the washing, or the veal in the cupboard going off. When the bodies are discovered and they ask him why he did it, he replies only that he didn't know. This was based on a real case.
88	* ViewersAreGeniuses: [[invoked]] The main purpose of Brecht's plays was to appeal to the audience's reason, to make them think about the characters rather than simply relate to their emotional condition and participate in their outcome and CharacterDevelopment. His insistence on stylistic experimentation made him controversial among orthodox Marxists and advocates of Socialist Realism who wanted simplistic anti-capitalist propaganda.
89
90	!! Adaptations of his works:
91	* ''The Threepenny Opera'' (1931 film by G. W. Pabst with a screenplay written by Brecht himself)[[note]]Brecht got into a dispute with the movie's producers and disowned the adaptation, though years later, as per Lotte Lenya on Creator/TheCriterionCollection dvd, he came around ot it and liked the film. Since it has most of the opera's original cast, its considered to be a highly faithful film if only being "traditional" in staging, rather than Brechtian[[/note]]
92	* ''Galileo'' (1975 film by Creator/JosephLosey, starring Creator/{{Topol}} as Galileo).
93	* ''Baal'' (1982 TV film by Alan Clarke starring Music/DavidBowie).
94	* ''ComicBook/TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen'' by Creator/AlanMoore. The third part of the comic adapts ''Theatre/TheThreepennyOpera''.
95

Context Creator / BertoltBrecht